Discussion Locked

wich is better

0 helpful
63 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

why do some say that win os's 95/98/nt will be phased out within the next few years and that unix would be the superior os.
frankly i do not see anything special about linux!!!

63 replies

by peaston

The reason why unix is gaining popularity, especially in the business world, is it's stability. The UNIX OS can run for years without problems. Also,it is a more secure OS than Windows, making it tough for hackers to infiltrate the system.
Anyone who hasused Windows for any amount of time will know that it is very problamatic and prone to crashes.

by clewis94

i haven't worked too much with linux/unix, but i know the little bit i have worked with it, it wasn't very hard to come to the conclusion that it's difficult to navigate through. let's say that unix is more secure and more stable...unix at it's present sate could only be a good solution at the server end. as far as clients using this on a day-to-day basis, that would be even more of a tragedy than the problems people have with windows. unix is very unfriendly to the average user in my opinion. it's al about opinions and what you're comfortable working with. my take, i hope unix does gain market share, i hope microsoft continues to hold market share, and that both os's will be prevelant in the business world. they can only compliment one another. ifunix becomes the superior os, then we're at point a again (yes i'm talking about the microsoft controvesy of monopolizing the computer industry). if unix is given the foothold of superiority, it too will do the same practices everyone complains about wit

by dave

One of the most attractive aspects of Linux that I've found is that it's Open Source, meaning it's not controlled by one company, but many people from around the world have contributed to it's source code. One of the benefits to this is that when a bug isfound, it can be corrected quickly. Add to this the fact that even features that work are constantly being "tuned" for better performance. Other's that have responded to your question also hit on good points; it's stable. It's not uncommon for a Linux serer to run for months on end without the need to reboot.

by dklapper

I've only been running linux for about 6 months now. No, a linux system is not the easiest of things to get going if your comming from a windows world. I have had to learn quite alot about how linux/unix works. What I do have though, is a PC that boots an runs faster and is configured the way I want it configured, not the way windows wants to configure it.
There are things to be improved in linux before 'Billy Bob new computer user' can hit the road running like he could if he had a windows system, but the rate that linux is developing, it will not be long before linux is just as easy.
You also do not have to shell out $90 dollars to try and see if you like it or not; linux can be downloaded free. Granted I have paid for mine, but what I would pay forone copy of windows, I have four different varients of linux and now have a preference for a specific distribution that suite me, that I like.

by patric.karlstrom

Either Windows or Linux is the best OS. It all depends on what you are going to use it for and how experienced the user is.
Windows is a suitable OS for "first time" computer owners because it's easy to use and there are lots of programs and other stuff.
Linux (or any other UNIX OS) Is more suitable for more advanced stuff.
Most computers with a UNIX OS running on them is used as servers just because of it's stability and good multitasking. Not for that they are easy to use. Shure many peopleuse Linuxt home, but you need to regard that you dont have any real support for the OS, and how should that be if someone that have never used a computer before sits down at a Linux machine and cant use it just because he dont have access to any support?.
There yu have it, you cant just say that ONE operating system is better than another. One OS is better than another depending on what you are going to use it for.

by htaler

That is the answer: there is nothing special about linux - no blue screens, no general protection errors, restarts after installing anything. Just operating system which _operates_.
Hubert

by skiz

I use linux/ unix/ freebsd... and they just work. I build/ configure/ troubleshoot Win9x/ NT all day long and I do not want that to come home to. The box has not been rebooted / shutdown in 3 months... when I went on vacation and did not trust anyone here to guard me equipment... I am sure I am not the only one that hears "can you show me this cut and paste trick I keep hearing about..." or other user tricks of failure to learn how to boot/ shutdown, run a specific APP, and just a general useof a PC.

by chris

We have been runing Linux (Debian) for the past 4 years .We are an isp in Perth Western Australia we have 20+ servers all runing Linux and we have never been hacked in any way. Most of the servers have got uptimes of over 12 months
But we have two windows box both runing win98 and we are lucky to keep them up longer than 2 days with out some sort of problem .
The only thing windows is good for in my mind is playing games and linux is catching up in the game area as well
Linux Rules!!!!

by pneves

People say that win os's will be phased out within the next few years and that unix would be the superior os because Linux is becoming easier to use. The installation software and the desktop is constantly improving and will very soon be easier to use then windows. It has cleaner multitasking, better online support (you just can't beet the unix man pages), and more flexability. Once linux is properly setup it can be easier to use then windows and with all the same capabilities. This is because there is less chance of linux crashing and some of the new desktop environments for the X windows system even have a built in web browser like windows 98.

by yanzickp

Personally, I don't think that they will be phased out, but less popular instead. Linux and Microsoft OSes all have their good and bad points. It all comes down to what you want to do. Linux is a VERY affordable alternative which runs more stablethanwhat NT would in most cases (heard of Linux systems being up for years without a reboot), but if you are a new administrator for a small company, you will most likely use a Microsoft OS because of the more defined GUI. Linux is catching up withthe userfriendly side of things as well. I use both Linux and NT, and both have advantages and disadvantages, but I prefer Linux.

by torield

The future will provide enough marketshare to Linux, Unix (all flavors) , NT ,MAC and more.
Each system has its pros and cons.
NT stability has been enormously improved and
provides a superb environment if you know how to use it.Below all the appearances
Windows NT has been written by old UNIX programmers who ported most of the features of Unix to a GUI interface.LINUX is also a child spawned out of UNIX.All and all we have
not gone that far away from giving UNIX new
facelifts and namedthem Windows NT and LINUX.
So much for that - These OS'es will mature and respond to the demanding needs of the market equally.Choose the one you feel more
comfortable with depending on what you intend to do.
Keep in mind that LINUX is still the youngest
and does not have all the support that NT enjoys from hardware and software manufacturers but it will eventually catch up.Also keep in mind that NT4 was officially
turned into an Embedded OS for ROM-Chips in use for appliances, medical equipment,phones and s

by edgedyrksec

Opinion, usage, and over all comfort are going to decide which OS is better for the individual. However, Unix is gaining popularity, I think, because businesses are recognizing the stability of the internet (and other such networks) as stable, since Unix is the main internet OS. Linux is gaining popularity because a, it is free, b, it is stable (like its big bro, Unix), and c, because it supports networking very well (also like its bro) and d, can fit onto a "normal" sized HD. Businesses like being cheap so having free OSes helps. Having them stable and equipped for what they like/need is also a plus. Then there is the fact you can change, edit, debug (if needed) and even completely overhaul Linux with a good programmer (or team). That's why I think L/Unix is gonna knock down the "king of the PC". Hope it answers your question!

by nap

I think windows is still better than Linux, Linux has some work to do before it can pass up windows. Linux is not as user friendly as windows yet. People say that Linux is more stable not to crash than NT but I've rarely heard of NT going down all the time anyway But in my opinion you are totaly right about linux there is nothing special at all.

by schweitzer

The main reason is bigotry. There are some people that would like to see Microsoft bite the dust - or who just plain dislike anything that comes from Microsoft.

I am old enough to remember when people said that UNIX would be phased out in 5 years (and that was over 10 years ago).

Linux is an excellent operating system if you know UNIX and do not mind doing a lot of tweaking, although it is getting much easier to install and use. Its main advantages are that it is free and is extremelywell supported. It also has the advantage that it runs on a lot more platforms than Windows and there is a lot of high quality free software (particularly for developers) that comes with it.

by jimkey9

I am an ISP using both Linux and NT servers in a critical environment. I only use NT for some web servers where Front Page extensions are necessary(the Linux FP exts aren't completely stable). For ALL other jobs, Linux is faster, far easier to admin remotely and much more stable. If I had to use only one of the two it would be Linux without question.

by max2

Some are being over optimistic. Linux is a very good, and stable OS. But it has at least 2 years before the average home computer user will be able to realistically use it. Now on the server side it is a different story. Companys are always looking to save money. Well Linux, while not really free like most like to say, is very cheap. Plus once setup will run, and run, and run. The same can not be said for Microsoft OS's.

by arunajv

I've been using Linux (Admn) for the past 2 years.I've also used DOS, WIN3.1/95/98/NT, AIX, HP-Unix, QNX & Sun OS . I strongly suggest to use one from the Unix varients. It's because the MS OSs have crashed many times( and they'll continue to do so). MS has stoped the development of Win9x versions, now the one comming up
Win 2000 is network based. For smooth performance it needs P III processor with 128MB RAM. In the other hand Linux will run smoothly on a 486 (even 386) & on a pentium machine with a good Graphics card, one can have a nice Xserver. Even more Linux is a freeware.

by ice_berg_

Personaly I find linux rather easy to use, but I started playing with UNIX back in 91 before there were a lot of kids and web pages and all. Now days few peopl even know what gopher is or how to use it. I think promoting linux will also promote people to leant how and why their computer works, the National Average intelect in the US is much lower than other equal countries, and it's a shame. Living in the US isnt all it use to be and maybe Linux can make it better (I can dream cant I )

by ram_cv

This is a very very good question. Each OS has its own pros and cons. Certain points that clarify this issue are as follows:

1) The GUI presented by UNIX presently is not match for the ones provided by NT/95/98.
Although people claim KDE for Linux tobe as good as Win95. But the catch phrase is as good as and not better.

2) Unix is much more stable than 95/98/NT. The Legendary Blue Screen Of Death has been seen by more men than the Star Wars Series.

3) Linux is Open Source code which allows people to write custom modifications according to their needs. The catch here is that most of the Development of Linux has been done by Hackers and leisure workers. When it comes face on face with the Industrial requirements it stands to pass the test.

4)95/98/NT support most of the RAD tools that are widely used in the development of applications. I have yet to come across any RAD tools for UNIX or Linux.

5) Another important thing in favour of 95/98/NT is the huge reach of Microsoft and its being eas

by info

stability / customization / reliability / scalabilty / etc etc./

linux is leaps and bounds ahead of NT in those areas. for all of you that are having hard times learning linux stop by my website and read the NHF's and the bbs.

Sensei
http://www.linuxnewbie.org

by malut

From the standpoint of remote support Linux (or unix, or any OS that does not require a GUI to do even the most simple task) is the winner. At 3 AM when you get a page to address an issue on the server, what can an NT admin realy do remotly? With a telnet session into a Linux machine an admin can do just about anything. So you Linux server is back running smoothly, fixed in a few minutes. And your NT server is still down, while the admin has to drive in to address the issue. Sure NT there is terminal server, but that seems to cause more problems than it fixes.

by joshua.pyle

there isnt anything special about linux, atleast not right now. Most users use microsoft products. this wont change for a long time, because everything works with windows, and it works well. every week there is an update to linux, and home, basicusers will not want to recompile the kernel every month. linux has to become more user friendly if they want to over take microsoft, and i dont see it happening. Bill Gates does what he does very well. Ive used Calerda OpenLinux, and Red Hat, and i could get on the internet, and do a few things with it, but its like a Mac. They has little to no software. Macs are good for graphics, linux may appeal to programers, but for most people, windows is the way to go. and there is not much money making a product to just server programers, or graphic artist.

by tainos

IMHO, Linux/FreeBSD already have all abilities to shoot out the windowses from server segment, because they have better perfomance/stability , more customization abilities and much easier in config/control and in future they will work better and better and provide more and more abilities and servises.
As desktop systems Linux/FreeBSD at this time sometimes hard to use, but we already have GNOME and KDE and they are working and grow fast. We have office suites, Star Office and ApplixWare, and they work fine.
And I'll waiting for Inprise Delphi for Linux to port our applications in Linux...

by gzill

OS preference will depend on what you plan to do. I am a webmaster and depend on my machine(s) to deliver web pages 24x7. I have used win and unix/linix machines. Sun and Linux are by far my preference for developing, stability, scalability, and reliability. My 60-year old mother, who writes simple letters and little email is just as happy with a win98 machine. It all depends. But there is a growing midle-ground of users who are a little more sophisticated need more reliability than what any win desktop can provide. I think they are the curious rubber-neckers trying/buying Redhat, for one, and trying it. Man, just check out the IPO! Go penguin, go!

by rasterbunny

first of all, the win oses will all be merged into windows 2000, combining the features of both windows 98 and NT in the same os.

Now, Why would a unix-type os take over? Really it is about what is most supported. Windows-based platforms tookoveron the desktop not because they were better than their competitors like os/2 and others, but rather because Microsoft spent a lot of time and money getting software developers to support their platform. People who wanted to run a cool new game or other piece of software had to get windows to run it.

The very nature of linux as an open-source os promotes the development of cool new applications and features. Until recently it has been little more than a toy for the smartest programmers out there, butnow it's coming into it's own with usability and other features. Every day new apps come out because some smarty 'thought it would be cool to...' And because it's all built on a stable 32-bit multitasking unix foundation, it's typically less buggy.

T

by danf

Perhaps it is time to end the OS wars and recognize that there is a place for each operating system in an integrated network. WindowNT/9x has proven itself to be a secure, scalable environment. The complete range of MS products from OS to desktop apps is a hard combination to beat. Linux has proven itself to be a worthy, stable, secure and scalable server platform. It cost effectiveness has made it available to a wide range of ISP/web hosts who might not otherwise be able to afford the startup costs required with MS products. Even Macintoshes have held their place securely in the DTP and graphic design arena against all comers. What is needed is the ability to integrate these seeming disparate platforms into a seamless environment, bymaximizing thefeatures that each has to offer.

by a.douwes

A classical discussion. It all depends on what you prefer. Some are dead set against Microsoft (MS or M$) and thus they prefere Linux. My personal experience is that Linux is not as stable as others have you believe. Our Email server runs on RedHat Linuxand it crashes too often. I cannot vouw for comercial UNIX versions like HPUX, AIX etc. in terms of stability. The stability of Windows NT as an OS and its flexability when it comes to installing new software, adding computers to the network, adding userbased security and the like is something that I prefere. Under Linux you have to compile the software and hope that your compiler is configured as the author's of the software pakage. If it isn't you will run into compilation problems. SinceMS is working with Intel on a 64 bit version of Windows NT OS called Windows 64 and Intel has the Merced 64 bit CPU, I think Windows NT will still be around for quite some time to come.
It's true that Win95/Win98 are less stable as Windows NT.

Mainframes tend to

by scaleracer

It seems as Windows becomes more stable it is written more like Linux.And as Linux becomes more mainstream it looks and acts more like Windows.For servers systems that need to be reliable how unix addresses harware malkes it a much more stable package.Microsoft does not sit on thier buts though.NT addresses hardware differently than win95-98 and 2000 works.Have been betaing 2000 for a few months and although buggy they are on the right path.By the time we all figure out what Os is better it will have changed anyway.
As to what is best;It depends on what you intend to do with the machine
BeOs if you deal in multimedia
Linux if you want a robust no crash server
Win95/98,If you like games

by frule

My wife who know nothing about computers and had a hard time with Windows now uses Linux with KDE like a pro. It used to be that she would freek whenever I made any changes to OS now whatever we do is kept seperate. My oldest child is 8 yrs old. Allof my kids us Linux as well. Microsoft software is not used at my house and we're happier for it. No worries about viruses or worms. I can easily control access to websites using Squid. Pretty much all the must have software is freely available. Youcan't beat Linux. I am an experienced systems admin and when I came to work for my company they had no Linux machines. Now the Linux machines out number the all the other machines. Linux is no harder to use than Windows and is a much more flexible and able OS.

by zbrain75

As far as 95/98/NT, 2000 being phased out, it probably will not happen. It may evolve, but it will still be around and have a strong market for a long time. Its biggest strike is it's proprietary.
As far as not seing anything special about Linux:
1. It's open source
2. It's stable
3. I don't have to reboot to reconfigure it.
4. I can configure it from anywhere in the world without buying additional software.
5. It's free
6. It comes with a running web server
7. There is free software that lets you run your linux desktop using a web browser.
Its greatest weakness is mail servers and ease of configuration. I expect soon there will be better GUI configuration tools and a better mail server. If the above 7 items don't make it special then I don't know what would.

by justin

First, You will never have a single superior OS. Second Windows 98 and Windows NT do not crash every other day, like any OS you must make sure that you are running compatible hardware and that you don't install all the junk software that is out there for Windows. I am a MCSE and have been working in the Windows enviroment for 4 years. I handle more than 400 Windows PC's and 24 NT 4.0 Server by myself and I am still able to go home at 5:00 everyday and sleep through the night. It comes down toreally knowing what you are doing...not just going through the motions. Third Linux is difficult to use in a deployment of the masses at this time such as 400 users and 24 servers. Fourth...has anyone hear tested the final release of Windows 2000?I think many will be truley suprised.

Just to note even though I am a MCSE I use Novell in certain cases and Linux in certain cases were there strength's can truley be utilized.

Justin Benoit, MCSE

This discussion is closed to new replies.