Discussion Locked

Windows End of Life Support (MS Bandwagon)

0 helpful
333 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

As MS roles out new versions of Windows I have been thinking 'how can these guys sell a new interface, complicate the functionality and require people to double and triple the hardware requirements so they can keep people on board with MS products?' The biggest problem I have is MS forcing people to upgrade by stopping the support for older products. So if you want a secure/stable OS then you need to follow MS with every version of Windows they put out, even when their systems are inherently insecure.

To start this discussion off I would like to briefly describe what I have noticed about different versions of Windows and hope people will add to my list or agree that most new versions of Windows have been useless and superficial.

Windows 9x = Useless and if Linux was where it is now back then we would all be using it today.

Windows 2000 = the entire reason I didn?t jump ship and go Linux all the way. Thank you for Windows 2000.
Pros: Stable-just about eliminated the BSOD. Better organized by implementing a directory structure to distinguish between different user files helped backing up and saving important files.
Cons: Still allows most programs to require admin rights to run.

Windows XP = useless improvements and a new flashy interface that doubled our hardware requirements.
Pros: Better USB support and SP2.
Cons: Still allows most programs to require admin rights to run. Doubled hardware requirements from Win2000. Runs wizards by default for every configuration. No ?Classic Mode? to be rid of flashy interface and configuration wizards.

Windows Vista = useless improvements by its release and didn?t make good on any projected improvements except strict driver signing in 64-bit edition.
Pros: Directory layout improved (shorter directory names too). Got rid of the ?My . . .? naming convention from early Windows daze. Cool but function-less Aero interface. Navigation with the Windows Explorer address bar. Even better USB support and new flashy icons (useless!). Broke most of the programs that require admin rights hence forcing programmers to write better programs that won?t make our OS vulnerable to all sorts of attacks and users who download ?free? software.
Cons: Doubled and tripled the hardware requirements again. Over complicated networking-Pick a zone: Home, Work or Public (Why?? Just firewall the connection like WinXP SP2)? Complicated the network browser even further (Just give us back the Network Neighborhood that worked in Win98) The UAC is not needed for every little thing I do especially if I am logged in as admin. The useless, flashy login page. Windows sidebar is a useless resource hog and shouldn?t be default (how about get rid of useless sidebar and install Telnet by default).

Those are the obvious changes that have been made over the years that I have consistently noticed. Most of the changes have been for no reason other than to impress teenagers. Keep in mind I am operating from a admin prospective and want functional efficiency and would like MS to work on functionality and less on wizard-like processes that are meant to cater to end-users/noobs/lamers.

My main contention is Windows 2000 was a great OS (add msconfig) and XP SP2 was a good improvement but put the benefits of XP SP2 on Windows 2000 because business doesn?t need the jelly icons. It doesn?t make Excel add columns faster.

Making the interface more attractive only appeals to people who don?t understand or concern themselves with efficiency. A similar statement can be made about the gaming industry as well which is why I can?t find a Wii anywhere!

333 replies

by now left tr

Making the interface more attractive only appeals to people who don?t understand or concern themselves with efficiency.

OK so you can work just voltages or with 001010001001001000100010010010010010010010011101001001001001001001001001001001001010010000101001 1001010010010 1010010101010101011001.... can you?

The interface was made more attractive to turn voltages to 00101001001 to something more useful for people to use.

Why do you want a Wii if you have this attitude - guess you don't really understand efficiency after all.

However - on an MS server, why cant I unload the GUI???
I will be able to (so it has been said , somewhere) on the next version of the MS Server.

by toughguy000

Can you just type out the word "Binary" instead of a useless phrase of (?"I$?$?I$?)??*?

Yes, some people can read Binary, and quite quickly. Is it useful? probably not to you, but it was to them in the past.

010000100110100101101110011000010111001001111001

by jackie40d1

There was a programming language think its Cobal used for the CPA programs of long ago ! It was the reason the big worry about 2000 as it did not allow 4 places for the year in the original code only two . . Actually computers talk binary now any way all the time as there are only 2 ways a switch can be is off or on !
Jee that kinda dates me being that old almost like punch cards . .

by countupir

If you think I said the GUI needs to go away you should point out where I said that. I didn't even come close to implying that the GUI concept is useless or I would have focused more on a Linux environment.

The main point that you didn't read was that Windows 2000 is Microsoft's last significant and effective improvement and they have mostly stopped supporting it. If you see a need to go from Window2000 to Windows XP to Vista then talk about what are the functional improvements. If you didn't read what I wrote clearly the first time you might not have much constructive to say and you might just end up getting flamed anyway so be careful.

by 706pbd

This is exactly what I have been saying for a loooooong time. The ONLY reason my firm has migrated workstations to WinXP from W2K was to be able to throw the "3GB switch" for the CAD terminals (need more RAM for all the 3-D assembly models). Non-CAD computers still run W2K, not needing any of the useless BS that comes along with WinXP. And don't get me started on the effing Wireless Zero Configuration Service in WinXP.....

by rkuhn040172

Why just focus on functionality? Although there is more functionality in XP, how about talking about security?

You obviously wrote this post with a biased opinion to start with, we should just ignore you.

by pgm554

they caught up to Netware and *nix.

These OS's have been able to do this for many years,but the point has been to dumb down the UI at the expense of speed ,security and stability.

Vista is a bloated slow ,pig of an OS.

When compared to XP,it boots slower and in roughly 17 out of 24 benchmarks,was up to 25% slower than XP on the same HW platform

by ron.miller2091

The same can be said of just about any OS advance. Before comparing timings and benchmarks, it's reasonable to do that using the hardware for XP that was available when XP was developed and comparing it to Vista running on hardware that's available at this time.
I'm not sure what the OS of 2012 will be like, but I guarantee you that if you compare it to Vista on hardware that's available FIVE years after the release of Vista, that new OS will be a "bloated slow pig of an OS."

That said, I'm keeping my XP installations because the advances in Vista don't come anywhere near justifying the price that MS is charging for it. But it's not because it's a "bloated pig." I remember some old cigarette-smoking twit in a computer store remarking about Windows 3.1 in 1991 -- "Yeah, that's a resource hog, isn't it?"

by samirk

Vista is an improvement that enhances security...but still I think the requiremt of trippled hardware is the point where I feel windows is bad... doing nothing i find near about 600 mb out of my 1.5 gb ram is eaten by vista...MS could have thought of a OS that would require less ram so that we can use it for our own development .

Anyway good article.

by critch

I tell people "The bad guy shot you 20 times last time...this time, he shot you only 10. Isn't that better now?"

M$ makes the most unsecurable products I have ever dealt with (in about 20 years of IT)

by jackie40d1

Hey you might also be running at 2 teraflops per last I read about IBM's new toys to be
Thats in the range of "The Terminator" and then AI will take over and run this side of the computers and forget the GUI's will not need them then . .

by zen37

I am afraid that this discussion will turn out to be another MS vs Linux flame out, but, being optimistic, i will contribute my feelings in regards to this issue.

I personally will not be following the MS bandwagon for Vista this time because i see no reason for it. The problem i have with Microsoft is with their vision of IT. It seems to them that they are IT and what ever they think is good automatically is.

On vacation once, i met two people who worked for MS and i was surprised at how "brainwash" their attitude was towards their employer. They seem to think they could do no wrong and that if you disagree, you simply didn't understand the concept or you did not know what you were talking about.

I once wanted to make a suggestion to MS regarding their Internet Explorer. I contacted customer service and asked them where can i send my suggestion. I was politely but firmly answered "MS does not take suggestions from the public". How can they honestly say to our faces: "Our customers have asked us to..."

Because of that attitude, i don't think MS will change unless they fail as a business at some point. The only way that will happen, is if the customer truly say to MS; "Enough, we are not following you anymore" and truly do not purchase MS products. But that is a risky move that will not bring any capital to companies. Businesses are well known to not take risks unless there is a ROI at the end. Businesses have no morality, just capital.

I agree that there is a lot that Vista and its predecessors have left to be desired. But as long as MS keeps their present attitude, there is nothing that will change.

Now as far as Linux is concerned, they are guilty of some of the same crime, just not as evident though. Linux people don't seem to be able to create a decent GUI to save their lives. Their command structure is based on 1970s geekoid administrators that lived in their own worlds. I cannot say this enough; CHANGE THE COMMANDS TO SOMETHING THAT CAN BE UNDERSTOOD BY THE COMMON MAN. Df just doesn't scream disk drive management to me.

The GUI is important because it bridges the vision of cold, hard, emotionless machine that computers are to something that is softer, warmer, friendlier and that people will want to interact with. Bottom line, "Its the people stupid!" and as long as Linux will not listen to that, they will only be second best.

My next machine will be an Apple. They have their faults too, i know. But they are the only ones offering right now the best of both worlds.

...just my 2? worth.

by countupir

If MS wasn't such a great marketing machine the Windows days might be over with the short-comings in Vista.

This is a naive opinion but a perfect computing environment is OS X on the desktop, Linux servers and Microsoft productivity software. e.g. MS Office Suite. But not Office for Mac. Those floating Windows have to go bye-bye.

Although MS has some good servers they are still built with the same vulnerabilities as the desktop OSes. Good thing users don't actually use them.

by rkuhn040172

Prove the statement about their server software having the same vulnerabilities as their desktop OS's. Specificially, Windows Server 2003...

by danlm

I'm not a Microsoft basher, so you wont see it. I won't follow the vista bandwagon till Microsoft stops supporting XP on the computer I just bought last year. That?s how I switched to XP by the way. They stopped supporting 98se.

With regard to the gui and Linux and apple. Apple's gui is nothing but GNU, or window's x which has been around forever in Linux UNIX. That's all it is. Not a nock, just a fact. kde is liked by a lot of people because it is more often updated and looks more like windows. Justin just posted a blog on PC-BSD which I think shows what I'm trying to say. https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=217451 If you check it out, you will see how userfriendly it has become. There are screen shots in his article. Me, I?m the 1970's geek. Came from a main frame, like command line, keep your gui. I want the raw power that Linux UNIX offers because they don't waist cpu cycles on a pretty interface. But, that is just me and I understand it's not everyone else.

98se to xp, I think the biggest improvement's were user accounts and networking. But, that is because xp was built on 2000. Just my oppinion.

The only thing I really disagreed with here was Zen's post about Linux UNIX gui's. They are there, and there are several flavors that offer user friendly versions of them. So, I disagree respectfully with his comment on that.

Until business?s change their primary desktop, Microsoft has no worries. It's simple. Your normal user learns what he knows from his job with regards to computers. That heavily influence?s his buying for home use.

Dan

by zen37

For being polite in your response. Too many people tend to flame others when they disagree.

I hope you did not take offense at the "Geekoid" stereotype i used. I did not mean anything bad by it.

I would personally love to find a good GUI for Linux that would feel as good as the one from Microsoft or Apple, but so far, they still look more like "machine" interface than "user" interface. I don't know if you get the difference I'm trying to convey.

There is also the fact that the GUI must come with the OS, one cannot be without the other if you want to cater to the general population. Apple may be using GNU, but they made it in a way that is appealing to the user. That makes it attractive to the general public.

Finally, you have to have viable commercial software development for that OS. Without commercial appeal, you won't get software. Without software, you won't get general adoption of the OS.

by w2ktechman

Ok, I get what zen37 is saying. Linux, although the desktop is windows like, it is not as refined and looks a bit rougher. I cannot describe it better than that. The Win desktop looks smoother and more appealing.
The other thing is that trying to figure out what things do. Yes, they are marked in the start menu (or whatever the distro calls it) by category, but to find items you need to interpret the k(name) to what it does. However, many distros are doing a better job of it now.

by jackie40d1

I wish some of the things I have to run were or had drivers in Linux ( any flavor ) I have 3 things which are seen but I can NOT get running yet in LINUX when I do its bye bye windows . .
I ran O/S 2 Warp 4 till IBM decided not to support it and dropped it I was using windows stuff inside it for a while . . But then Windows decided to come out with windows 98 SE and I went to it as the few versions of Linux were nice but did not run everything I needed to run yet still does not . . So I am stuck with Win 2K Pro till I buy a book and make a driver for 3 things in Linux

by pbd

I have to ask how many of you folks that are saying Vista is bad, have actually installed, and tried using it? I've installed Vista about 12 times, experimenting, and just getting to know it. I honestly have to say I think it's great. I'm not on any "bandwagon" so you can stop right there. The thing is, most of us like new things. New car, new iPod, new Digital camera etc. Is any of it "needed"? No. We buy things because they are new, and we like new gadgets. Vista is the same thing to me. I like it because it's new and refreshing. I like the new GUI look because I never cared for XP's "toon town" GUI.
The other reason I ask is, Vista can run fast. All you have to do is turn off all the pretty crap. Yes, it's all on by default, but you DO have the power to change it, so stop complaining. It only requires 3x the hardware to do all the pretty stuff. If you turn it all off, it will run with 512 mb of ram, etc. Another tidbit of advice, turn of Indexing. That speeds things up a bunch.

As far as Linux goes, I like Ubuntu. But I have to agree with what someone else said here. "Make the commands more logical".

by matt peacock

I agree that "Until business?s change their primary desktop, Microsoft has no worries. "

However, as I have learned over the years most businesses want their employees to be at their most productive. They want an employee to start work on a monday without having to go through training and learn new applications (industry specific aside.)

What most comapnies dont want is every employee to go through a two or three day training course on how to use the operating system and slowly get used to it when they can just use 'windows' and get on with their job.

I proposed the possibility of Open Office as an alternative to occasional users to reduce MSOffice licensing - but then the change=training aspect arose and that idea was discarded.

by intrepi

I've evolved from the MS DOS vs IBM era and have supported every version of Windows up to XP. MS has evolved it's OS to Vista which has made some happy, some mad. The fact is all OS's have and will continue to evolve or will be no longer. I have bought full distros of Linux as I'm not looking for a free ride but you know and I know that Linux has never had the support from software or hardware manufacturer's with respect to applications or drivers. If Linux had the same support in these areas as Windows, then Windows wouldn't have as large a following. I agree, they have applied strong arm tactics with OEM preloaded versions as well as others. The only reasons I don't have Vista is I can't agree to it's terms and conditions of it's license but more importantly, I feel it was rushed to market and the fixes have just begun so I'd wait until the SP1 update or wait until the next version of Windows. With regards to Mac, I wouldn't begin to suggest it's another version of Linux as the OS's are too far apart in their differences. The graphical power of Linux vs Mac would be silly to compare as the hardware and software support, drivers are just not there for linux which is why the number of games available for linux are minimal. I'm not against any OS including Linux as I'm running Xandros Business Edition 3.0 as well as the Professional 4.01 which I like but they do have downsides too. I honestly believe and I leave room for being wrong, that the Mac Leopard OSX will be a very serious, no nonsense OS with very powerful graphical tools that may well show some real WOW. I'm leaving myself open to seeing what it has to offer and I'm assuming it won't be a cheap spin off as Windows ME was with little or nothing to offer. I honestly think one needs to look with an open mind to find what they want but try it before you buy it. All OS's with the exception of Mac will allow you to and even with Mac you can always go to a dealer or lease a Mac to try before you buy.

by rkuhn040172

About the over used by many statement about wasted CPU cycles for the GUI.

Probably the most common "problem" nowadays is under use of CPU cycles.

Whether that be a desktop or especially servers, most CPU's sit around waiting for something to do.

It's a fact. CPU's are so fast nowadays, that the vast majority of the time they sit there doing nothing.

Hence the popularity of VM's and trying to get more out of each CPU.

by phalacee

While I see the point you are trying to make (Mac OS X is a Unix, being based on BSD) I do have to make a clarification:

The MAC OS X GUI (known as Aqua) is not GNU, and XFree86, which Mac OS X's implementation of X11 is based on, isn't GNU either.

To be GNU software the software's license must grant you "the freedom to copy and change the software, even to sell copies." (http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html) and I know that Apple does not allow this with their Aqua GUI. It must also be GPL compatible, and if you look at the list of licenses on the GNU site (http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/license-list.html#X11License) you will see that they list XFree86 as GPL-Incompatible.

I do agree however with what you have said about the current state of Linux/UNIX GUI's ... if anyone has used Ubuntu/Kubuntu 6.10 or later, they'd understand that Linux is not just for servers any more.

The fact that its a live-cd allowing you to boot into the OS and then launch the installation from within the GUI is something Microsoft could learn alot from.

Fedora also comes with a nice pre-installed GUI.

Couple a KDE with Beryl (Linux's answer to Apple's Quartz) and you have a Linux installation that rival's Mac OS X for useability, leaves it for dead in terms of pricing, and with the current state of WINE, provides you with almost all the software you've been using on your Windows machine.

And if the GUI wasn't reason enough, both the Fedora and Ubuntu distros come with software update systems that allow you to patch and update all the software installed on the computer (not just the OS as Windows Update does) as well as install any of the applications available.

As far as efficiency goes, I've got an old system that wouldn't run any version of Windows past 98SE, but it runs Ubuntu nicely. Gamers would be happy to know that Windows games running under WINE often run better and slightly faster.

Really, for the home user, there is no reason to swap to Linux now. For the corporate businesses, there may be a few issues they might have to address in order to move over to Linux.

The only groups of people couldn't move to Linux are the Graphic Artists that need Adobe's Creative Suite, Corel Painter, or Adobe's Macromedia Studio, and the Accountants that use MYOB and Quicken and other financial packages.
3D Artists might not be able to move to Linux, depending on whether the applications on Linux match Lightwave, Maya, 3DS Max, Cinema 4D, and Poser.
Note, almost all of these applications are available on Mac OS X, so 3D Artists and Graphic Artists need not stay with Windows.

Thing is, most users stay with Windows because it's what came with their system. They've paid for it already, so they may as well use it.

by underground_in_tn

Come on, Zen. How can you say that to the average computer user "grep" is not as obvious as "find", or that "ls" is not as clear as "dir"? Surely "cp" is easier to recognize and remember than "copy", and "mv" makes more sense to rename a file than "ren", and "ex" and "vi" are certainly more intuitively-named commands than "edit"!

by neon samurai

It's similar but perhaps not exactly the same as the Windows GUI names vs *nix GUI names debate. It all comes down too a name being just a name. Both systems have program names that are blatantly obvious and names that are completely unrelated to function.

I personally like the Unix commands. Their being different after growing up on Dos was part of there charm. They can be cryptic but in general, are shorter commands (switches aside that is) too type. I even had a win32 build of the basic Unix commands so I had my LS and CP for Dos/Windows until a recent drive crash.

by intrepi

MS Windows is produced by a single company as is Mac but Linux has many different companies producing different versions. So when you say they are guilty of the same crimes, it's not quite the same thing. I've been a Windows user since MS DOS and was quite happy about MS being the winner in the IBM / MS Dos era. MS has grown to be a very large corporation which wants to attain as much as it can by whatever means, legally or illegally. Now to emphasize my point, how many times has MS settled in court and out of court ? Let's assume MS want to do something that infringes on another company's patent. They go ahead, use it, distribute it, and make a lot of money. They get sued, go through the motions then either settle out of court or in court. The truth is if you were to do this and be sued, pay a settlement of 10 million, would you do it if you made a profit of 22 million ? Keep in mind you have several billion to play with and lawyers, court actions are tax deductible. It becomes a game, the opposing lawyers probably buy each other lunch and golf together. I've been using Xandros Business Edition 3.0 and Xandros Professional 4.01 which I like as the license is extremely flexible and allows multiple installations.
It does have downsides and I knew what they were before I bought the full versions but the upsides made it one of my Linux choices.
I like Ubuntu but it isn't as complete as it will be later down the line. SuSe, I bought and used but just couldn't get used to it as it wasn't a personal favourite. I continue to use XP when I have to but I no longer download updates as it required me to agree to it's new license and I just wasn't up to it. I'm very interested in the Mac Leopard OSX coming out later this year as I'm keeping my options open by looking beyond Windows.

by tony hopkinson

right?

The UAC is needed for every little thing, due to the way it was implemented. Maybe they'll sort that out.
The network zones is to allow big holes in 'stupid' user's defenses so MS can keep all the client side drivel they've invested in.

by dkteddy

I think it depends on which applications support remote connectivity. For internet devices especially routers, Telnet is great but once again it is a command line. Im sure telnet was meant for something else than a command line, but it never reached that point. : /

by tony hopkinson

on the security front, and given the thrust of the original post, seemed to have done himself up the arse for all to see.

by danlm

I am a believer that each os has it's strength's and weakness?. I use FreeBSD for my file server, and I would never think of using anything else. I also use Windows as my desktop, and right now really wouldn't think of using anything else.

FreeBSD kicked butt and took names when it was running on an old 600 MHz. It now just sits back and spits on you since I?ve upgraded that machine a 1.4 athalon with a gig of memory. No gui, just straight command line. But, it?s a server not a desktop. I flat out don't want a gui on a server. Windows desktop, ehhhhh. That?s back to my original statement of. If businesses were to use something else, the population would follow. I use and have used windows as a desktop at work from the start. I need to be familiar and proficient with it to be good at my job. I don't want to switch to something else and lose that edge. If they switched to a different desktop at work, I would probably follow suit in a matter of time.

;o), have a good one. No offense was taken.

Dan

by fujikid2

Seriously, you could at least try to sound like you knew what you're talking about.

"Windows 9x = Useless and if Linux was where it is now back then we would all be using it today."

ROFL ... Thanks for the laugh I needed it. I still can't get over just how dumb that statement is! A bit like saying if Skoda were where they are now back when Ford released the model T we'd all be driving Skoda's.

As for most of the comments on XP and Vista it's clear you've never been a serious user of either.

As a developer and 10hrs a day user of Windows since 95 I have to say all new versions (OK excluding ME) have been improvements.

Vista is no exception. It's by far the easiest to set up and use of all.(OK excluding the well intended but annoying UAC rights warning messages. :-))

I really don't understand this persistent claim of 2 or 3 time the hardware requirement. On my 4 year old DELL I doubled my memory and bought a cheap budget graphics card(~$150 total) to switch from XPSP2 to Vista Ultimate running smoothly with full Aero.

For once networking is really easy. Either it just works or running the connection problem analyser points you directly to the problem and in most cases can fix it.

On Vista - UAC you know you can turn these warnings off if you want! MS just can't win can they? Everyone cries "insecure" and points to Mac and Linux requiring admin acceptance. So MS listens and adds it and the cry changes to "interference".

On XP - No classic mode? Just how many seconds did you spend looking at XP?

by tonypmartin

As I see it, there is a place for Microsoft and Linux. Neither needs to rule the IT world. It may be more difficult for Microsoft, since they are entirely a profit driven engine. But that doesn't inherently make them bad or wrong. They do a lot of research too.

The debate did however begin by questioning the value of Microsoft upgrades, and this really is worth a meaningful debate. inter alia, the consideration of value for money.

In my view, a progressive development rather than a complete replacement should be favourable, unless there is something fundamental that needs to be replaced such as the file system structure itself etc. I suspect even MS realise in hindsight that Vista could have been XP Update (Surely they could have packaged that and sold it, albeit at lower cost, but who knows the greater take up may have been equally financially rewarding?) and maybe that Vista could then have been the up and coming Vienna.

The danger of replacing the whole OS each time, is the temptation to add unneeded frills to justify the change. MS's two page newspaper spread about the Vista WOW factor, included very little, or nothing on the (sparse) page that isn't already available or possible with XP.

One of the things I dislike with the Microsoft approach is the tendency to change terminology, or invent new terms where adequate ones exist already, seemingly just for the sake of it. And don't reply with 'patents issues'. That cannot explain why bat became cmd for example.

Another effect, would seem to be the constant revision of menu systems, with the inherent need to offer 'classic' views. If there is real improvement to be had then fine, but it seems to me the change is frequently cosmetic rather than practical. To me this is emphasised when some of microsoft's own instructions on their tech support site tell you to switch control panel to classic mode to enable you to access a certain function.

Finally, my pet hate. Wizards! Don't get me wrong, they do have a place for a novice user , or to do certain things quickly, but IMHO, a wizard should always have an equivalent GUI that shows you what precisely you are changing (Maybe they do, but from my experience these are fragmented and not obvious).

As for Linux GUIs, I use Fedora a lot, and I like the desktop. The GUIs are pretty good and continually improving. I would not say they are perfect by any means, but the thing I do like is that if you are not sure what the GUI has done, the configuration file is never far away for inspection. Maybe some folk don't like that approach, but it seems to me that Microsoft's attempt to insulate the average user from the techy bits in the OS have a danger of obscuring the important configuration details from the techy user at the same time. (Or maybe there is a commercial element too in hiding some of the implementation details?).

As Linux may try to ape some of what Microsoft does, there could be a danger that the GUIs start to tend towards becoming Wizards. Personaly I hope not. One thing is for sure, the Open Source aspect of Linux will always have the advantage for technical support, that if you really need to understand what is going on under the bonnet, you can delve as deeply as you wish.

Lets continue to debate the technical issues and try to maintain emotional detachment, it is a human thing to defend what we believe, but if we are right in our thinking then chances are right will prevail eventually - lol.

Best Regards
tonypm

by kw08

I am a software developer doing real applications on Linux and Windows. I have been writing software for 30 years now, and the current situation reminds me of a certain corporation's IT department telling me that Novell would never work - they only new big blue - Unix scared them - they po-pooed PCs as toys. Most people who do not agree that MS is useless are the ones who know now better, never learned anything about real world development, and are scared they will be found out to be as useless as the OS they use. Same as when big blue and their minions had to go.

by jackie40d1

I have 2 Items I would like to get running in Linux . . And then I would leave Windows so far behind me they would not even see my shadow . .
Right now I am getting a book from Linux central on how to make drivers . . I have a Verizon USB720 broadband modem which Linux see's but does not have a driver for it so it just sits there and also got a ADS Tech DVD Express which I use so much it should have wore out by now . .

by intrepi

I'm thinking everyone is entitled to their opinion and I try hard to respect it regardless of intent or lack of constructive input. Windows of whatever version was not useless and that includes Vista. I wouldn't try to belittle anyone here by throwing my profession into the ring to add any weight to the argument as we all know how many things were written and not everything including Windows ME was something to brag on. Now, with respect to Vista, there are machines out there with Vista ready, Vista capable on them but when it comes down to it, Vista may not have been ready for them. Vista is still being updated weekly because it was a rush to market OS that was and still isn't ready. It may not be ready until the SP1 becomes available later this year. This in itself is an assumption as Vista was a year later as it was and still wasn't ready. Vista can be easy to install but it really comes down to what you are installing it on as Vista can and does abort if there is something in the PC it doesn't see as compatible. Your opinion on what's cheap is questionable and may be cheap if you are comparing it to a high end 8800 board but for many $ 150 is not cheap. This can be a lot more when you add all the Antivirus, Adware, OneCare and other software required to secure the already secure OS.
MS could have included OneCare to show good faith by showing they were going to do everything in their power to make Vista the most secure OS ever but they chose to offer it for $ 49/yr additional. Vista does require more memory as it is really doesn't run well on less than 1 gb of memory, this is not a bash, just a fact. Let's not compare Linux and Mac to Vista as there are no serious comparisons, the support factors are too one sided, both in software and hardware. You tend to imply that MS can't win, well they have been winning the market share since MS DOS. There is a place for constructive criticism and you should be more open to it as this is what makes things evolve to be better. There is no perfect OS and I strongly doubt you would be able to suggest there is one but I'm not saying there won't be one someday. Just as a matter of fact, the installation of Xandros Professional 4.01 is easier to install than XP or Vista as it doesn't require you to install additional hardware drivers with a 3rd party CD. I had to install an additional Raid driver as well as mouse driver and others via a cdrom but I never had to do that with the installation of Xandros. Xandros also has very liberal licensing which allows me to install it on as many personal pc's that I own including 1 business machine. It comes with it's own Antivirus, Adware and File Protection software which has free ongoing updates. It comes with a long list of free software so I chose Xandros over Vista. This was not because Xandros was better, it was because I could no longer agree to Vista's terms and conditions in it's license agreement. Since you are a developer, how about you develop a program that would allow MS to validate their software without taking up my time and expense. I can't count how many times I've talked to some guy in India who, at times, I had no idea as to what he was saying. Why, because I had to reactivate Windows via a long 42 digit process which I could well live without. Seriously, why can't MS use an online verification system similar to that used in secure banking to verify and validate their software ? I'm certain some improvising would eliminate this ridiculous procedure. Like it or not, MS has not made Windows a perfect OS yet and it really appears it has a lot to get right before it is.

by rkuhn040172

And I get tired off everyone tell the world how insecure Windows is.

It takes about 3 brain cells to properly secure Windows.

I'd venture to say that the average home user is now more able to secure Windows having a broad choice of consumer grade products available, software and hardware, than say a wholesale switch to Linux or Apple where they'd know nothing about and open gaping holes.

by michael_orton9

The "strict requirement" for driver signing in the 64 bit version will cause trouble for me.
Since that days of DOS I have always used non manufacturers approved drivers. If it works its legal has been my way since STRETCH & Fortran 2 days in the early 60s.
And to make almost any MS software do what I want it to do almost always entrails downloading unapproved s/w. Ie to open/edit .pdf files in Word, extract tables into Excel or OOo spreadhseet needs non approved s/w.
In fact since the days of DOS there have always been non approved software programs, mostly free that have extended MS windows useability and office, specifically forbidden under VISTA eula.
Will I stop using such free goodies, will I heck!
Sent using UBUNTU Linux, using a PC that wouldn't run XP and only ran 98se VERY SLOWLY.

by underground_in_tn

Must be an old version of Ubuntu. 6.06 will not install, much less run, on anything with less than 256MB memory. And since Win98SE ran very well on even an old Pentium 233MHz with 64MB RAM (I did for years), then you must be running a very, VERY old version of Ubuntu to run on less than that.

by neon samurai

It's all the Ubuntu goodness with Xcfe desktop manager so it's nice and light on older hardware. They may also be using a limited install of Ubuntu with only what they need.

Those are my two guesses anyhow.

On a side note, Mandriva with KDE runs nicely on my pent 300mhz with less than 128meg ram. I should really test Xubuntu on it though or either Puppy or Damn Small distrobutions since they're meant for limited resources.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

is idealogical. If I pay 200-300 (or more) for an operating system disk, I think I should be able to use it on each of my computers (it's not like I have hundreds or thousands of them), or at the very least [as with Office] on a desktop and a laptop. And I should be able to reinstall it as often as I need to due to system changes, crashes, whatever. Vista has imposed significnat limits in this regard, though I could see it coming with XP and product activation. WGA and DRM bother me also. As to WGA, I run a lot of freeware and it's not difficult to forsee the day that WGA becomes a tool in the "force the user to buy MS software only" arsenal. As to DRM, I don't appreciate in the least that MS now appears to consider itself a primary enforcer for the entertainment industry. Re: driver signing reqs, if MS moves to require software signing in addition to driver signing (another problem for me) then they have in effect become the "big brother" of the computing world, a position they are already well on the way to acquiring. It is no one's business but mine what software I run on my PC or what hardware I choose to employ in building my PC.

Pumping up the hardware requirements for each new OS release has the potential to widen the divide between those who have and have not, technologically speaking. Widening that divide at some point in some subtle manner widens the divide between those who have and have not at a more rudimentary level. It also serves to keep the hardware manufacturers happy with MS, therefore influencing them in a manner that makes it less likely that they will provide hardware and drivers to lesser markets. Knowing which side their bread is buttered on and all that...

98FE was my first MS OS and it frankly was worse than ME ever thought about being (and yes I have run Me, though not by choice). The SP that was supposed to "fix" it did nothing to improve its performance and reliability. I cannot speak to 98SE. NT4.0 came next and it was sweet in comaparison, being at the least stable. The lack of USB support until SP 4 or 5 was disappointing, but after the nightmare that preceeded it, I hardly cared. Win2K is to this day my preference. It is stable, not particularly resource intensive, well-organized (to my mind anyway) and gives me no trouble ever (with the exception of the standard reload the dang thing every 3 years because it's becoming corrupt). WinMe was a pile of junk, out-junked only by Win98FE, and WinXP strikes me as a slickered up 2K with somewhat steeper hardware requirements. I use both WinXP and Win2K primarily, and am happy with both as re: performance as it suits my needs. However, I have to agree that a lot of so-called improvements in XP are not much more than eye-candy, and childish eye-candy at that.

Vista , at least for me, is not an option. No way will I rebuild my computers just to get that annoying Aero-Glass. And not being particularly visually oriented, it is exactly that - annoying. Classic mode in Vista lacks the menu options that I prefer - again, not being visually oriented I prefer words. The directory re-structuring at first glance is a drag. Another pet peeve re: MS. I do not understand the need to change things that are working just fine as they are. From a personal productvity angle, this at least temporarily lessens my productivity as I devote too much time to relearning an OS I have been comfortable in since Win98. The learning curve for previous OS releases was not as time consuming, or so I think.

As I will not likely ever install Vista due to all the mentions above, I am now exploring Linux and wish I had begun that process several years ago. I frankly don't care too much what the various gui's look like, it is functionality and ease of use that I am interested in. I would prefer to never have to deal with CLI, but unfortunately with Linux this will likely not be the case for some time. As the "bully factor" in Redmond increases exponentially with each new OS release, my preference re: CLI is relevant only to the degree that it influences which distro I eventually settle on.

It is likely that I will maintain a Windows installation for quite awhile - there is a lot to learn with Linux, my job requires Windows, and a secondary job requires the use of software that only runs on Windows at this time (yes, I know about the emulators, more to learn). No biggie. I order SP disks for each of my OS'es and when product support ends, I at least still have the SP's at my disposal. I spent a lot of time learning how to [hopefully, probably!] secure my Windows systems, so I should be good to go for awhile without getting anywhere near Vista.

The introduction of Task Manager is for me one of the highlights of MS OS evolution. Though frankly it could work better at killing hung apps.

by eddie n

...the outrageous price. I can't imagine spending as much on an operating system as I would for a midlevel notebook computer. That's insane!

by rkuhn040172

Ok, so you're running Ubuntu but can't run Win 98SE very fast?

What did you strip out of the install? Running command line only?

You're either lying or not telling the whole story. Please let us know the whole story.

What version of Ubuntu? How much CPU? How much RAM? Please, entertain us.

There is no way in this world that you can run the newest version of Ubuntu and not run Win 98SE fast.

You tweaked Ubuntu to hell and back and probably accepted all the defaults in Win 98.

Give me a break. Stop lying, crawl out of your hole, and get a nose job...you'll need one.

by phalacee

I have a Pentium 166MX with 48 MB of RAM and 4GB+4GB+8GB HDDs running Ubuntu 5.10 (Breezy Badger), I haven't tweaked it all that much, I just compiled the kernel to match the hardware I have, and only installed the software I need.

I used to run Windows 98SE on the same machine, and to be fair, I wasn't able to compile a kernel, but I did install the drivers for the hardware in the machine, and no others. I did tweak the Windows 98SE machine very heavily to improve performance, but I also ran Litestep with a very graphical theme.

All in all, I haven't noticed much of a difference between Windows 98SE and Ubuntu. The only reason I moved was because 98SE is no longer supported.

Oh, and just so you know, I haven't changed the purpose of the machine at all despite the change in OS. It still acts as my email spam filter (running Spambayes), and displays a photo-slideshow on its original CRT monitor.

I very rarely sit infront of the machine to do anything, because the machine is slow (even running DOS or Debian CLI is slow on this machine).

My point is that even on an old machine like this, having Ubuntu running the way I want it to, looking the way I want it to it runs the same as Windows 98SE did and I had that running the way I wanted it to, and looking the way I wanted it to.

If MS still supported 98SE, I'd still be running it.

There is the full story.

by kw08

Microsoft was never any good at OS. All OS versions since DOS 2.22 have been useless. Open office is better than MS Office, MS SQL server has always been crap since version 2. MySQL is so much better than MS SQL Server I doubt MS even uses it. Linux can be a better desktop than Mac. I just hope Microsoft's death throws do not last too long.

by underground_in_tn

No version of DOS better than 2.22? Useless?? Get real. While you've been busy saying your Hail Torvalds deep inside your Linux monastary, the real world has been working with continually improving versions of DOS and Windows. Were they all better? Oh, hell no. WinME stunk big time. And I, for one, will not be moving to Vista for a lot of the same reasons already mentioned in this thread. I'll stick with XP, and a virtual machine running Ubuntu 6.10.

But to say nothing has improved in the DOS and Windows world since 2.22, or that it's all useless, is just to ignore reality in a fit of Linux worship.

by intrepi

I've supported MS since the struggle between IBM and Microsoft MSDOS. I've supported every version of Windows up to XP and I can see your emotional dislike and disrespect shining through but it doesn't solve anything and shows little aside from your bad non constructive commentary. I've bought full versions of Linux in SuSE, Xandros and a Ubuntu live cd but they simply don't have the same support base in either software nor hardware as does Windows. Linux cannot be better than a Mac in the graphical areas as there is just not the same level of available software, hardware or drivers for it. I like Linux but these are points that just can't be ignored as they are facts and liking it has nothing to do with it. Microsoft is unlikely to ever be in any kind of death throw as they have broadened their horizons into other areas aside from the computer business. If you are really as angry as you appear to be, I'd advise you to stop supporting Microsoft by not buying their products and services.
There are choices out there that will work for you, you just have to try them out and decide what works for you in a way that you can live with. Quite frankly, Microsoft is doing more for Linux, Mac and Sun Solaris than anyone else out there. How so ? Well, MS and most other large greedy corporations tend to annoy their supporters until the supporters decide they've had enough and go elsewhere. MS has no legal responsibilities to anyone buying, using or selling legal copies of their OS. They have made the terms and conditions of Vista's OS something you really should read before you open and agree to it as opening it is agreeing to the terms
so try before you buy but read and heed. It might help stop you from coming back to the forums to complain about their software.

by mgonzalez66

Many of the responses here hold very true, often resulting in what many feel that the improvements or benefits of a newer O/S from MS does not justify the need for a forced upgrade due to the lack of support for previous versions. Despite the various opinions from users we must keep one thing in mind: it is a business and the bottom line is money. Sure, I share many of the same feelings the rest of you have. But after spending more than a decade providing desktop support to end-users, I see why MS is often forced to cater so much to them rather than the technically savvy. And as long as end-users are willing to empty their pockets for the "newer, better versions", they will continue to tweak and bloat the O/S beyond recognition. Just add a few new "lame" features, a "cool" accessory or two, smother some "eye candy" all over it, spend millions in advertisements and there you have it: a recipe to make MS even richer. Sad truth. Personally, I only upgrade when I have to (i.e. the software demands a hardware or O/S upgrade).

by critch

US automobiles - still lousy mileage, cupholders, DVD players, air conditioned "map" compartments .....
Way too much like the old jokes "If MS designed an automobile" or should it be "If Detroit Designed an Operating System" ?

by hefairman

As a computer user who goes back to the Tandy Model 1 days, Operating systems updates have been a major thorn in the User world. IBM stuck with Windows 98SE until the Pentium 4 came along for their business clients with 2000 as an alternate. XP offered little new features but required a hardware boost including memory. Windows ME was an absolute was of money as it often fails to shut down properly unless you have a OEM version custom tailored for a given machine. For example, my Thinkpad 600 and T-22 run fine with 98SE, but choke often with ME. My main system with XP SP-2 failed due to a hard drive problem, and I lost all of my documents, Outlook address book and emails when I re-installed it. Not so with 98SE, and XP requires a re-install if you change the MB unlike 98SE.

I have refurbished over 1,000 IBM, Dell, and Gateway computers for a church group over the last 5 years, and those with 98SE are still running with no problems. Not so with ME or XP. Many of these computers are still running in places like Kenya, the Ukraine, and El Salvador who have little or no technical support. The two computer labs that I sent to Kenya in 2002 were up and running in less than a day (Peer-to-Peer)and still function perfectly.

Not so with my 3 XP systems at home with a wireless network which takes over an hour to setup each time I change the hardware. But my old oldtop with 98SE just chugs along.

by jhecht

As a freelance tech, I've installed five Vista 'puters so far. Four of the five had serious problems CAUSED by Vista!

One could not read a 4 gig flash card the EU owned - Vista has a 2 gig limit bug. One (a HP) could not strike recovery CD's from the restore partition - HP said this was also a Vista bug. Two more broke in other ways. As Kurt Vonnegut said, "So it goes."

Overall, I've found Vista to be sluggish even on fast hardware - and the best incentive I've gotten recently to work more with Linux.

Puppy OS (www.puppyos.com) is blindingly fast, works on hardware that Vista wouldn't even load on, and was basically written by ONE person. It also comes with a ton more USEFUL apps than Vista - and it's FREE, not $400 for a full-function version.

I hope there is a massive user revolt that forces Micro$loth to turn away from creating ever more bloated & dysfunctional OS's, & makes them take note of how lean and fast an OS can really be...

by jackie40d1

I have heard and read more problems about "Vista" and its inabilities to do things like it was supposed to do ! One of the many reasons I told all the people I have made computers for ( all of them would have made the conversion ) NOT to change it to "VISTA" wait for a few years till the dust settled and the patches were almost done ! And maybe they would make the choice to go to Linux like the last 2 people did that I made the computers for . .

by jsehlmeyer

I've also installed Vista on a few machines.. Few being 10 and have minimal to no problems. The only problems I've had came from using beta/RC versions. Build 5600 seemed to be the best until 6000.

I've installed 6000 on a average machine and it runs quite well. Granted not as well as XP pro, but it still runs well.

I like the look of Vista over the crayola look of XP which is why I told myself once I started with Vista, I'd keep with it through the thick and thin. Now that other software companies are FINALLY coming out with the tools I need to do my job the road is much less rocky. Thank you Symantec for finally releasing a beta of PCanywhere that works with Vista.

As far as the original post, if you really want to run Vista on your 500mhz Celeron, go ahead. It won't be fun and you'll be sitting around waiting quite a bit, but you can do it. Microsoft isn't saying you HAVE to upgrade your equipment, it's just recommended. I don't care how you slice it, Linux also has hardware requirements and the newer versions require much more than the previous versions, so are they forcing you to upgrade too? Given the cost of components today anyone who has a machine that is older than 5 years needs to upgrade.

Even if you purchased a new machine when XP first came out, you wouldn't be happy with it 6 months ago before Vista was released.

Maybe you should point some fingers at all of the PC Game manufacturers for allowing so much sloppy code we HAVE to upgrade our equipment for better experience. Funny how in order to play the newest video game you have to run out and purchase 2 of the newest nvidia cards at $350 each. Vista Media Center works well on my $40 6800GT.

by pbd

You are correct. I've had about the same experience with Vista. The only problems I've had with Vista were with my own crappy failing hardware.

by rkuhn040172

Probably 5 crappy machines, generic hardware, taped together with duck tape and super glue.

As for me, since we're in this "I've tested 5 whole machines" now mode, my dad bought a new PC with Vista about 3 months ago.

I've gotten less questions from him in the last 3 months than I've had in the last 2 years running anything else.

He even figured out on his own how to setup dual monitors. And from a guy who barely knows how to turn the thing on too.

by neon samurai

MS makes the dominant OS in the market primarily sold to businesses and computer resellers. When MS peaks out the profit on one version, they simply release the next version from the workshop with prettier graphics and whatever minimal improvements they have to include under the hood. The rest of the improvements remain in cold storage to bring the next version up to minimum standards.

Third party developers complain but they're still getting a new version of there software sold to replace what the customer has already paid for.

Hardware manufacturers get a sales boost when everyone suddenly needs to upgrade there hardware for the new Windows Bling version.

Hardware resellers get a sales boost from people buying whole new computers to replace old commodity units or new people jumping into this crazy computer's at home trend.

Profits decline as the sound of Microsoft's business clients asking questions rises so they hop to getting a new OS version out the door and the cycle continues another great revolution.

There are better OS available but Microsoft's business strategy has made up for shoddy craftsmanship over and over.

by jackie40d1

Seems about every other version has MAJOR bugs in it and this is one of the ones ! This is not even an upgrade of Vista . . Its a Major slip in MS thinking for all the time they kept on saying its going to be great, and then to sink this far down already . . Its going to be the best thing ever happen to Linux ! ( any version therein ) Red Hat, Linspire, SuSE, Puppy, Mandriva, Debian, and on . . .

by neon samurai

Vista won't be the end of Microsoft so that's fool's dreaming but if it's enough to convince vendors to provide at minimum driver support (if not driver development specs) then it's good news.

I'd be happy with Linux distros remaining the alternative if hardware vendors would follow the wafting smell of Windows money a little less.

Yes, I'm a little bitter today. Another four hour go at the proprietary drivers for ATI with no luck. Mandriva's included binary blob; 250 fps max. ATI's provided binary blob; wouldn't even load X. flgxconf non-existant except where mentioned in various HowTo. Community provided ATI FOSS driver; 1500~1800 fps but no video4linux support of the AIW tuner chip and no real flgrx support for games.

by intrepi

I've tried and use Linux as well as XP and I can honestly say there are + and minus to both OS's. Basically, Linux, Mac and Unix just don't have the same support as Windows. This is a sad but true fact as software support is limited and hardware driver support is as well.
Linux is better in some areas, Mac's are the biggest threat to Windows as it has the graphical interface and support to make one come to seriously consider a Mac. I've never bought a Mac but I'm certainly looking hard at the new Leopard OSX that is supposed to become available later on this year. I honestly believe it will have some serious graphical power that will put some serious WOW on the new higher end monitors. It seems as though Windows is getting bigger and bigger with a lot more in Vista but it's also causing a lot of openings for security issues to take hold in. Vista isn't for everyone but maybe the next version of Windows will make Vista look like a bad retake of ME. We can all make assumptions and be entitled to our opinions and mine could be totally wrong.

by neon samurai

For both paid and free help support along with applications. Debian's something like 3,000 applications available. The hardware vendor's support sucks though and without it, games won't come for the home user. There are those habitual user applications that people are not willing to give up though too.

osX is currently the better choice for most I'd say. Even geeks are jumping onto it because they can work the BSD under it's pretty makeup.

by randy.r.reveal

Windows 2000 wasn't all that great. Driver problems, crashes and other such nonsense. XP has been trouble free for us with over 500 users. MS should work more on security than cute screens (leave that to 3 parties). Nobody here is even talking Vista yet whereas XP, 2000, NT and 95 were all tested and installed soon after release. Than you MS for getting rid of the "are you sure?" for every little change.

by jackie40d1

What drivers did you have problems with ?
I have run a gob of stuff and never had those kind of problems

by tony k

require people to double and triple the hardware requirements so they can keep people on board with MS products?'

About the only area in which that makes sense is if you compare the minimum requirements of XP to Vista. XP's was a PII 266 with 64M of RAM (the same as 2000), Vista's is a PIII 1Ghz w/ 512M of RAM. Times change, requirements change. In other words, the machine that I put together 5 years ago to run XP can still run Vista, and it does just fine. Aero and all, I use it every day. Those requirements are for vendors, so they know what to put in the box. Not that it matters much since the minimum requirements haven't been sold for 5 years.

The biggest problem I have is MS forcing people to upgrade by stopping the support for older products.

They don't stop support to "force" upgrades. They stop support because can't support every version of every piece of software forever. No one does. You want support for Windows 95? It's out there, on the Internet. Just like for Linux (which, BTW, no one really supports old versions of, either. How often do you see Linux software that'll run on a 2.2 kernel or even 2.4?). All of the questions have been asked and answered for those older versions, but it's not Microsoft's job to help you find them. Should they support DOS, too? How 'bout Xenix? SCO isn't doing a great job of supporting that these days, after all.

So if you want a secure/stable OS then you need to follow MS with every version of Windows they put out, even when their systems are inherently insecure.

Despite what even MS' marketing guys will tell you, no OS is secure. It's not an OS' job to be secure, it's the job of the wetware that uses the machine. MS can do everything it can to secure the OS, and people will still manage to find new and impressive ways to screw it up. Security is not the job of the OS. If you were an admin, you'd know that.

Windows 9x = Useless

Useless, really? Easily the most popular version, and you think it was useless? Honestly, I find that hillarious. See, I used to be a raving anti-Microsoft twit, too. Then 95 came along. I remember the moment I converted. I was connected to my university's computers downloading some stuff using the DOS version of Telix. I decided to play a little Warcraft (that's before there was a World) while that did its thing. A little later I though I should check since the download should've finished by then and I hit Alt-Tab. I won't type the string of explitives I emitted the instant I'd realized what I'd done. "You can't Alt-Tab in Windows from a full-screen game to a DOS app! You've just lost both!", I thought. I figured with nothing to lose, I'd Alt-Tab back to the game. Surprisingly, it not only worked, but the game had paused while I was out of it! Holy crap! This was a new install of 95, so it occured to me...if it works this well out of the box, I wonder if it's been ME that's been causing all of my problems all along?! Sure enough, when I figured out that I was the problem, all of my issues with Windows went away and I became a convert, never looking back. I will agree, however, that Windows ME caused a lot of people a lot of grief unneccesarily.

and if Linux was where it is now back then we would all be using it today.

And where was it back then? Completely useless. I started playing around with it in 1994, and every time I had an issue with my Windows 3.1 box, I'd try Linux again only to reinstall DOS a week or so later. Where is it now? I'd put it about as good as Windows 95, so we'll let you decide if that's useless or not.

Windows 2000 = the entire reason I didn?t jump ship and go Linux all the way. Thank you for Windows 2000.

Yup, the first one that even a user like you couldn't screw up easily.

Cons: Still allows most programs to require admin rights to run.

Again, a failing of yours, not the OS. I know what you're talking about, though. I ran into this problem with Adobe's Type Manager back in the day. I had a user that was nothing but trouble (like installing pirated software left and right), so we wanted to lock his machine down. Couldn't, though. He was a graphics designer and ATM had to be run by an admin. Even Adobe said so! I did a little research, found secedit and figured out what needed to be done to get it to work. Seriously, learn your stuff before you complain.

Windows XP = useless improvements and a new flashy interface that doubled our hardware requirements.

Wrong. XP's hardware requirements were the same as 2000, that was well-documented. As for useless improvements...huh. Remote Desktop, increased security and performance over 2000? Yeah, now we see what your definition of useless is..."I don't know what it is."

Still allows most programs to require admin rights to run. Doubled hardware requirements from Win2000. Runs wizards by default for every configuration. No ?Classic Mode? to be rid of flashy interface and configuration wizards.

Seriously, if you're going to try to make an argument, at least get SOME of your facts right. What part of the "flashy" interface can't be turned off by simply disabling the Themes service? What wizards are you talking about? Network configuration? Nope. Display settings? Nope. Performance configs? Nope. About the only thing I can think of off-hand that I use on a regular basis is the Add Printer wizard, however most new printers come with installers that create that so I don't use it on my XP boxes (only servers) much. Granted, it's annoying, but I don't do it all that often. Again, perhaps the problem isn't the OS, but your lack of knowledge? I'm definitely seeing a patten here...

Directory layout improved (shorter directory names too). Got rid of the ?My . . .? naming convention from early Windows daze.

These are your pros? Seriously? You do know this is a technical forum, right? It's not really for end-users. Do some research on how to rename "My Computer" in earlier versions. I think you'll be seriously amazed at how simple a task that really is.

Cool but function-less Aero interface.

You listed this with pros, but isn't really a "con"? (Like this attempt to show you know what you're talking about that's only turning into an ignorance fest)

Navigation with the Windows Explorer address bar.

Which you've been able to do since Windows 95, so I guess that OS wasn't completely useless after all. Oh, and nice job keeping up with the times.

Even better USB support and new flashy icons (useless!).

Oh, I see, these are your pros intermixed with things MS says are pros, right? Tough to keep straight what you're talking about when you flip back and forth like that.

Broke most of the programs that require admin rights hence forcing programmers to write better programs that won?t make our OS vulnerable to all sorts of attacks and users who download ?free? software.

Reread what you wrote. I think it would be a relatively simple argument to make that if they "broke" because of Vista, they were broken before...you just didn't notice it. Probably because you were blaming Microsoft for all of the problems these programs were causing you.

Cons: Doubled and tripled the hardware requirements again.

Again, not "again". For the first time in 7 years, and the minimum requirements are for some seriously old crap.

Over complicated networking-Pick a zone: Home, Work or Public (Why?? Just firewall the connection like WinXP SP2)? Complicated the network browser even further (Just give us back the Network Neighborhood that worked in Win98) The UAC is not needed for every little thing I do especially if I am logged in as admin. The useless, flashy login page.

Wow, there's so much wrong with this, I wouldn't even know where to begin.

Windows sidebar is a useless resource hog and shouldn?t be default (how about get rid of useless sidebar and install Telnet by default).

Why is it things you have no use for are useless? I like the sidebar, and find it useful every day. It didn't have as much use, granted, until I added gadgets that were useful to me, but it's really up to me to decide what I find useful. Not you, not Microsoft.

Keep in mind I am operating from a admin prospective and want functional efficiency

YOU'RE AN ADMIN!?! Oh, god help the other users (I'm including you, hence the "other") on your network. Seriously, dude. You're a clueless twit at best. You want efficiency? Go have a talk with your HR department right now. Explain to them that you shouldn't be doing this job, and you and your boss (for hiring you) should be fired. You are representative of exactly everything that is wrong with the industry today.

and would like MS to work on functionality and less on wizard-like processes that are meant to cater to end-users/noobs/lamers.

Such as yourself. Um, you do know that Vista is primarily geared for home users, right? MS is fully aware that most businesses aren't going to jump on the bandwagon out of the gate. Us, we're ready for it and are pretty much comfortable with rolling it out to our 13,000 desktops. But, that plan won't go into effect until later this year.

My main contention is Windows 2000 was a great OS (add msconfig) and XP SP2 was a good improvement but put the benefits of XP SP2 on Windows 2000 because business doesn?t need the jelly icons. It doesn?t make Excel add columns faster.

No, but the other improvements in the underlying OS do. People are stupid, they only think something's changed if it LOOKS like it changed. They aren't smart enough to go beyond what's on the screen to see the other improvements that are really important.

Making the interface more attractive only appeals to people who don?t understand or concern themselves with efficiency. A similar statement can be made about the gaming industry as well which is why I can?t find a Wii anywhere!

Wow. Seriously. Wow.

by rkuhn040172

I agree almost completely, however, our Linux zealots here won't read it as it is beyond their collective attention span.

I think you did an excellent job of putting together a very thorough and well thought out response.

Thank you.

by Member 23340214

One thing this thread has taught me is that we are all professional geeks at heart. Remove the GUI, wizards, eye candy and any other feature that gets in the way of us pros and it would alienate 90% of the users. I guarantee you that what we want in an OS (i.e. the command prompt, lol) is not what the majority of users want. Windows has tried to be all things to all people and while it has failed everyone at one time or another (sometimes even miserably so!) it continues to let us all get our job done at the end of the day.

Some thoughts from reading the thread:

1. Vista is not Me. It actually runs faster than XP if you give it 4Gig of RAM. Granted, that's a lot of hardware, and for most people there is no compelling need to move from XP, but if you need Vista then drop in more RAM so you can enjoy the experience.

2. While Windows 2000 was good, XP SP2 is better. It?s more stable, more secure, and more advanced under the hood. It will be a while before I can make a solid judgment about Vista (maybe after they release SP2, lol).

3. The Aero interface is too much of a memory hog and should have been refined before release. If we can develop whole applications that can run in a browser, then Microsoft should be able to develop a pretty GUI that can run without so much hardware overhead.

4. While the new security feature is annoying and does get in the way, I like the direction Microsoft is moving. I am confident that given enough data collection and usage reports they will iron it out.

In conclusion, there are better OSes available, but they all lack something significant. For some, it?s an installed user base; for others it's usable software; for still others, it?s the ability to appeal to the masses. For all MS's faults, they also have considerable strengths. The funeral march will not begin any time soon.

by gonzogarrish

"We're all geeks at heart"
That's it in a nutshell. People in the know will always want different things to the ordinary home consumer. Windows has to be all things to all people but it turns out to be a techo nightmare for Jo(sephine) average and a wasteful sprawl to many techies. Its just a shell, after all. It's the interface between us, our hardware and the applications that we relly want to get stuck into. Just because something looks good doesn't mean it's easy to use. I suspect many home users would trade some cuteness for true plug-and-play (or even switch-on-and-go).
I don't miss the command prompt though!

by gonzogarrish

I think we.re all getting a little off-topic here. The basic thread was "why pull support for old O.S's?" After all, if Vista is so good everyone will just want to upgrade anyway, won't they?
Well, apparently not. M$ are in a cleft stick here. They,ve spent the earth developing Vista, and scrapped a bunch of functionality to get it out vaguely on time so most of the improvements are merely eye candy. So many who use PC's for a living are bound to think "what's the point?"
XP came along at the right time - '98 was getting very long in the tooth but there is still plenty of mileage left in XP IMO. The world doesn't need Vista yet. Perhaps if M$ had quietly buried their Longhorn (remember that?) deadline then perhaps they could have come up with a truly revolutionary product in a year or two's time. Still, when was the last time M$ actually listened to their customers? It would also have given hardware manufacturers more time to develop Vista drivers too (most of the stuff in my studio doesn't even have Vista drivers yet).
If there is an upside then Vista's hardware requirements mean that top spec PC's will be even more affordable. But that's a small crumb of comfort!
My main studio PC still runs XP SP1 - it doesn't have an internet connection so "patch Tuesday" is pretty much an irrelevance. It's never failed to run an app or piece of hardware, even those that explicitly claim to require SP2. It also boots to functionality in under 30 seconds.
What I would like in an OS is user-customisation. Simple things that could be configured at install like:
"will this computer be connected to the internet?"
"will this computer be connected to a network?"
"will you be the only user of this computer?"
"Will you be using this computer to actually create something or do you want it stuffed full of useless eye-candy and garbage pretending to be grown-up applications?" etc.
My main worry is that one day I'll reinstall XP and the authorisation phone-line (no internet on my studio PC remember) will be dead...
Let's hope that the O.S. after Vista will be something really worth waiting for! Or that Apple do the decent thing and release their OS to be used on PCs.

by jusovsky

I supose you'd like to strip all traces of personality or joy from humanity as well. If everyone felt the same way as you about these "useless" improvements in UI, millions of dollars would not have been poured into making them. I'm afraid you're in the minority here, and perhaps the answer for you is to get Window Blinds and make yourself a Motif or Windows 3.1 skin to strip any life right out of it.

by intrepi

Vista, XP or whatever you have is what it is, nothing more or less. Every OS out there and I've tried a few are lacking in either what we want or how we want it done. As much as I do like to pick on the negative aspects of Windows
I have to lean in and say try it before you buy it. If you buy Vista, don't read the license agreement, ignore the terms and conditions, then how can you blame anyone for it's faults ?
I never installed Vista as I couldn't get past the terms of the license agreement but I really believe the terms and conditions are there for everyone to read as it's not just for the business or corporations who want to do multi installs. I'm not going to bash MS as it's like a dog humping a football which creates a lot of friction and excitement but no satisfaction. I'm trying out Linux and I want to try Mac when the new Leopard OSX comes out. Try and be flexible in finding out what works for you and don't get caught up in the MS bashing as it goes nowhere.

by manitobamike

Go to any store
Buy a software package (any kind)
Launch the installer
Say NO to the license agreement.
(NOTE: License agreement is NOT written on the outside of the box)
Now what happens
Program does not install
Pack up and take back to store
NO REFUNDS ON OPENED SOFTWARE.

How do you try before you buy Windows?

by intrepi

Go to Micorsoft website, download and install Vista as MS has provided a 30 day trial. If I were you, I'd try Vista by renting a PC either at an outlet or via a friend or computer store.
You don't have to buy anything before you try it but if you choose to ignore the ways you can try it, then you won't be able to find one. You should be aware you should never buy any software and open it as opening it is acknowledging that you are agreeing to the terms and conditions of the license. But you can try any OS including Mac if you look for them at an outlet, computer rental or personal connections to those that have it.
Microsoft has made Vista very easy to try and I'm surprised that you've missed so many oportunities as they are a lot of websites that have Vista downloadable for trial use.
P.S. The reason I would avoid downloading and installing is it is not easy to remove and reinstall XP so don't say I didn't warn you. You also should download the software from Microsoft to see if your pc is Vista compatible before you move on to downloading and installing.

by manitobamike

Just like the old VHS, Microsoft was cheaper than the better systems (CPM for example) and rapidly took over the biggest market share. Now new releases are more for money making that improving. There is no improvement in moving functions around in the program menus, only to justify a new MS Certification course and license. "TESTED WITH WINDOWS xx" is an expensive phrase, but does MS support anything they say is "TESTED" or will they even allow MS "tech support" to talk about these "CERTIFICATION TESTS".
The real purpose for computers boils down to applications, documents, spreadsheets, list management, accounting programs, email commnuication, internet browsing and even games. This is what users want, they could care less what underlying OS is powering them as long as they work, keep working, and allow them to do it at least somewhat how they want. MS should concentrate on the OS make it small, efficient and bullet proof. Leave menu programs, browsers, email, etc. to third party programmers that have their sales dependant on how good and useable their programs are driven by the end user instead of pushing their own that do nothing more than keep the monopoly alive. If its free with the OS thats what the majority will use and thats the way MS wants it.
I personally would say each "upgrade" in MS Windows that has been released is nothing more than a SP10, a collection of fixes of program errors and poor coding.
Someone disagree and tell me one thing that MS (by MS I mean MS not buying up someone else's program and adding it to the OS) has come out with that is part of the OS release and SHOULD be part of the OS-not just an addon application.

by intrepi

Microsoft's certification is an expensive proposition for vendors to acquire for their hardware drivers. Microsoft had so many blue screens of death with earlier versions of Windows that it came to the conclusions that these system crashes were a result of bad, non compatible drivers where the code in them was creating serious issues. MS decided to come up with a certification program so they could make a few dollars from vendors and if a vendor didn't get it certified then Microsoft would reply to complainers with the reason your system crashed is because you are using non certified software of drivers that were not designed to operated correctly with this version of Windows. Result, Microsoft is off the hook. They've done the same thing with their questionable support base. If you call India and can't understand or comprehend what they are saying does it mean Microsoft hasn't supplied you with support ? It wasn't their fault you couldn't understand them but then you ask why does MS have support based in India ? Well, it has to do with the cost of support to MS which is their priority, not yours. MS has done so many slippery moves in so many ways a greased snake in an Olive tree wouldn't have a branch to lay on. This is not a bash, they are to be admired, ( by business), not necessarily by you. If you were to take and use software that isn't yours and is a direct infringement on a companies software rights, you would be sued.
If you were sued, settled out of court for 10 million dollars would you do it again if you made a profit of 22 million ? These are all calculated actions that MS has employed to maximize profits with illegal risk factors based on the fact that they have billions to play with, legal costs and suchlike are tax deductible. MS does not lose, they adapt, shift, change and have people work hard long into the night to make sure they won't. You can avoid supporting this by simply not buying their products and services. If you do decide to buy them, then don't come back to the forums to complain or bash them as you were the one who bought and agreed to their terms.

by intrepi

I'm not saying Vista is bad but it isn't an OS that I'd buy at this time as Vista was a rush to market OS and needs time to be tuned up with updates. Personally, I can't get past the terms and conditions of the license agreement but that's a personal choice. I have to point out that many of Linux commands are almost identical to MS DOS which evolved to Vista. The Linux GUI has many faces as it does distro's and I think Mac's Leopard OSX will be a very serious OS to look at in future. Vista will evolve into something a lot better than it is now, it has to or it will crash permanently. I'd seriously wait until the SP1 comes out for Vista and if XP works well enough for you, maybe wait until the next version of Windows as MS has told us they will no longer go beyond 5 years to produce the next version of Windows. We don't have to upgrade to every version of Windows and sometimes it's a good thing we don't as Windows ME will always be there to remind us of what MS does to make money.

by info

Unless they're shoving something pretty damn impressive into GPO's in Longhorn, there will be no reason whatsoever for business' to switch from 2000/XP desktops, bar hardware failures. I've worked for corporates and have been an IT manager for a medium sized manufacturing business and once a desktop OS is stable and works with the core applications that run the business, then there simply aren't any justifications for upgrade. I've been prevented in the past from upgrading to XP because certain bespoke apps, integral to the business were broken by it during testing. I think Microsoft have run out of steam regarding business desktops, for God's sake, any business with a streamlined desktop strategy these days is running terminal services anyway where they can get away with it. WOW, we're almost back to mainframe as the backbone to business computing!

If WOW = Vista then Vista = another reinvention of the wheel that business' don't need.

Oh yes, and if anyone thinks I'm missing the point of Vista etc (yawn), try asking Microsoft exactly how long they used AS/400's to run their operations and if there's still any in service. Back in 2003, they still were according to IBM support...

by Former member

>forcing people to upgrade by stopping the >support for older products. So if you want

They suppoort their older OS versions longer than Pretty much anyone else.

>Windows 9x = Useless

didn't care for 95, had lots of problems with it, by 98SE though the 9x system had become pretty solid.

>and if Linux was where it is now back then >we would all be using it today.

ummm..ok...(W.E.L.)

>Windows 2000

See, I wasn't all that impressed by 2000. I mean the multi-user advances were great, but apart from that, kind of a brick.

>Cons: Still allows most programs to >require admin rights to run.

I don't hink this one is MS fault. Rather it was Software developers that didn't follow the MS programming standards.

>Windows XP = useless improvements and a

Your opinion. XP has been my favorite to date. Easy to deploy, stable, fast...

>doubled our hardware requirements.

not hardly, check the box again

>Runs wizards by default for every

Really? I didn't think so, I mean, they were always easy to find, but they were generally just as easy to not use. Personnally, I like many of the wizards, particularly for the tasks I rarely perform. Real time-savers.

>configuration. No ?Classic Mode? to be rid

huh? Did you actually install XP yourself? You could totally make it look and act like 2k. (I set mine systems up that way for awhile, because I though all the new XP GUI stuff was 'useless'. Then I started using the new GUI features, discoverd they actually allowed me to work more efficiently, and now I loath working on Win2k because I find it so inefficient. Perspective, I suppose...)

As for resources. I have found that the XP GUI consumes LESS ram then KDE or GNOME (I say RAM,specifically, because 'memory' consumption is actually higher, but becuase of some (rather intelligent) paging, XP moves much of the unneeded bits of the GUI to Disk, ultimately leaving me with more avaible physical RAM for other applications to use.

>Windows Vista = useless improvements

I was pretty bummed that pretyt much all of the really cool features didn't make it in.

I wouldn't say the rest is useless though. Just because you don't know how to operate it doesn't mean it is useless. Take the time to learn how to use it, and you might be pleasantly suprised.

That said. I am not planning on (personally) switching to Vista, simply because I don't like the product activation. It just doesn't sit well with me that I have to 'ask for permission' to use the software I just paid for. In the past 3 or 4 years. Nearly every support issue I have had, and been unable to personally resolve, has been related to anti-piracy mechanisms, and not normal program functionality. I don't wish to pay for the 'privilege' of being treated like a criminal. Nor do I wish to pay their development costs for something that gives me no benefit, and in fact is hindering my ability to work.

>flashy icons (useless!).

To you perhaps, to other, icons are now themselves becoming a source of state-information, thus improving the efficiency of knowledge-transfer.

>networking-Pick a zone: Home, Work or >Public (Why??

Handy for a mobile user. It can allow relaxed security when on 'trusted' networks, and tighter security elsewhere.

> The UAC is not needed...

Turn it off then.

>Windows sidebar is a useless resource hog

I was quite suprised at how pig'ish this little critter is. Cool feature but, suprisingly fat.

> Telnet by default).

and I thought you were concerned about security. ;)

>Making the interface more attractive only >appeals to people who don?t understand or >concern themselves with efficiency.

I disagree. The Improvements in interface quality can allow more information to be provided more concisely and more clearly. I am glad they continue to test and improve ideas in this area. I can't wait for the first truly functional 3D working environment.

by hykenfreek

M$ has repeatedly taken the stance that what it says, goes. I couldn't care less about the Aero-glass front-end, enhanced search capabilities (I usually know where I put my files), or internet connectivity. We use a lot of computers on the factory floor for process automation where internet connectivity is limite NOR is it desired. To configure the OS to NOT connect or want to connect to the internet is a royal pain. I believe Microsoft has shot themselves in the foot as to the only group I see using Vista are the folks who know very little about computers, buy what's on sale at Circuit City, and then call a friend to help them "set it up." As for business, especially in inductrial applications, it was a hugh task to get XP certified to run process applications. We set most of the XP interfaces back to "classic" anyway for ease of use. Now that Vista carries with it a massive pricetag it bodes someone to think computing has GOT to be better than this. While Linux is usually very specific in it's application, it does have merit, especially the pricetag and portability. I agree with some of the other posts...Microsoft has set themselve above the general public and in our book...placed themselves out of the ballgame.

by intrepi

MS has a lot of money, a lot of financial muscle to enforce a hard line on what they will do and what they won't do. The first priority is money, how to make it, how to use it, how to protect, enforce and verify everything they touch so they have minimum cost that is tax deductible. Support is surprisingly good with respect to time frame and updates with some exceptions. Support with regards to technical brings a smile to my face as I honestly had no clue what the support guy in India said the last time I had to get XP reactivated as I had to call back and try my luck with another person who had a little less accent. The general public is not what Microsoft is really concerned about as it is the business market and the people who want their servers and online services. You are just a consumer who they really are not their main concern or priority. Big business where they have several thousand licenses and various forms of MS software used in business applications is what MS has focused on. The problem MS has is big business, like China, France and other governments outside of the US are going to linux. This is not a pitch for linux as I have Xandros 4.01 and it has shortcomings but none I really can't live with. I use XP if and when I have to but in all honesty, I'm keeping an open eye out for the new Mac OSX Leopard which is supposed to arrive sometime in the 2nd half of 2007. MS has shifted gears and has forced everyone who wants to update XP to agree to a new XP license even though you agreed to it at the time of the original installation. I read it for a change and couldn't agree to it so I just left XP without the updates. MS has also decided to make Directx 10 available to Vista only, why ? well it might help them in the muscle department to get you to upgrade.
DirectX has always been updatable for all supported versions of Windows but since there isn't a lot of reasons to upgrade to Vista, they had to come up with a few. Strangely enough, they came out with OneCare which is yet another money scheme to make the secure Vista even more secure. They bundled their infamous Defender into the works to make it appear like more of a bargain but the truth is it all falls short in comparison to 3rd party security software as any choice would be a better choice. The US government will not allow Vista to be loaded so it seems as though MS is going to have to spend a little and apply some pressure on their own software developers to make Vista acceptable. MS has done more to promote Linux, Mac and Unix OS's than anyone else out there. Microsoft does instill hope in me though as I still think I'll be able to sell my personal services to protect the United States from killer bees by standing in a South Dakota cornfield and killing everything in sight with my, trusty, made in India flyswatter. It's just a matter of marketing it at the right time with the right advertising agency. I wonder if Google wants a piece of the pie ?

by wdewey

Microsoft isn't even the worst offender.

As For writing this from an admin perspective you fail to mention things like improved group policy support and command line improvements (such as scripting defrag).

Bill

by intrepi

Microsoft is not the worst offender as there are a lot worse offenders out there when it comes to end of life support with respect to software and hardware. I was stunned when I tried to get a new driver for a MFC 3100 fax/copier/printer which was less than 3 months old. This happened when the SP1 fix came out for XP. This was a major change in the OS which cause this machine to stop working. I called Brother and they told me they didn't have a driver and that they would not be making one available as XP was no longer compatible with their machine. I can honestly tell you this was the worst but not the last as SoundBlaster is another I had no support satisfaction from. Needless to say I always have the choice of not supporting them if they don't support their products and I haven't done so since. Unfortunately, MS has fallen into this group for issues that are different but no less ignorable.

by philippev

End of life is about stoppong supporting old versions of the same feature, not stopping supporting things that worked.

Microsoft has spent too much time by devoloping Windows as a monolithic system with both a kernel and a huge GUI.

Windows 2000 was certainly perfect enough with its GUI to run a server, but it was a bad kernel.

Vista certainly has a much better kernel, but the huge GUI is just needlessly confusisve and too much monolithic.

Why Microsoft does not separate the product into several parts: a single rock solid kernel, with no advanced GUI, but that runs in console and that can even start with the minimum services, and where all services can be installed later when they are really needed?

Please make the kernel much more solid, and make it capable of supporting various virtualizations. We don't need that GUI on servers, not even for application servers.

Make the system work in a console with a solid shell and independant ans solid addons for each service. Make each service separately manageable, explain each dependencies even if there are required settings to make it run and that each service installed must come with reasonnable defaults.

Make applications and components easier to install, manage and uninstall. Most of the registry is confusive and not needed, in fact one thing to cleanup is the registry which is not needed for most things, and that does not help moving components from one host to another. The whole system is not scalable, and unnecessarily too complex to manage for its security.

Make sure that each kernel version keeps the strongest foundations for security and make sure that each documented interface will continue toi work in future release. If some better component provides better services but is incompatible, make two distinct services and let users choose which version they need (don't decide instead of your users about which services they need, and don't install so many things just because you think it may be useful in your own M$ environment).

Make the GUI manage its own configuration, and keep the user interfaces that users are trained with; providing a completely new interface with a new kernel is just waste of time and resources for your customers. Many don't need that to have stable systems, and there are tons of existing software that depend on the old GUI or on the old kernel.

It's increadible that Microsoft did NOT even support the XP look and feel on Vista and change every place where a user can manage its system, and completely changed the task bar, the explorer toolbar, the accessories? Where is the security benefit? Nowhere; in fact it makes the system more confusive and open to errors due to lack of training.

Why do professional users have to live with the "cute" gui interface? At least on Linux, you have the choice of your interface and it remains stable. Applications can still run within everal windowing environments. The required GUI is the worst error in Vista.

In fact one could have imagined a Vista look and feel on a NT4 or Windows 2000 kernel, or a XP look and feel in Vista. Why is it impossible?

If a system is already protected by other tools, why do you force LUAC when logged on locally as an Admin?

Why can't there be a full support for a linux-like kernel that can run linux applications?

Why can't there be a native linux shell running on top of a Windows kernel?

Why does the kernel contain so many GUI components?

Why the filesystem is so much confusive?

why isn't there support for the much simpler security model of Unix/Linux? i.e. with users and groups and Unix security settings?

All in Windows is not interoperable, not even between Windows versions.

Think about that: Linux and MacOSX have succeeded betcause they have a small kernel, and almost all other components are not installed by default (they are on the CDROM distribs, but you won't install them immediately until really needed).

For running a Office application, why do you need all this GUI "features"? Aren't all those animations just distracting? No they don't provide more helpful features, they are just distructions for graphic geeks. They don't make the PC more usable.

There are also too many undocumented features preinstalled on Windows, and information about them only comes much later, after long scrutiny (during years) by third-party. Requiring all those technologies without letting users choose if there's simpler alternatives is non-sense.

Notably when this makes your existing computing infrastructure or personal knownledge or experience immediately unusable with the new version.

Yes Linux and MacOSX are succeeding because the evolution of the system is gradual.

Too many things have been introduced by Microsoft in Windows that were made part of the required features to support to get a "Designed for Windows" label, and those things were later no more part of the recommandation. That's really ill. Pregrams have to be adapted or partly rewritten or redesigned each time. That's completely stupid: Microsoft never feels it is accountable for the hard work it will drain on its users to adapt to each new version and because it will soon stop supporting things that worked perfectly in a much simpler way in the past. When things are rewritten, they become once again instable before getting fixed after hard work!

Microsoft just complicates the life of everyone. May be this attitude was acceptable when the adoption of computers was still low in the public; but now, exposing bilions of users to such revolution is insulting for them. Microsoft forces them to look as if they were completely stupid.

What users want now: an end to the monster. They are buying simpler devices. And small appliances just to get the things done: printers that don't need a PC to print a photo, mobile phones that integrate an agenda without opening Outlook, harddisks that can play and share their photos, videos and music directly to their Hi-Fi or TV set, they browse the web with mobile PDA. They buy external routers instead of configuring their bloody Windows. They buy external firewalls.

One thing: one function, and a very reduced interface that can be understood but that gets the things done without giving them headaches. That's what I call true "Plug'n Play". But not what Microsoft did with the nightmare of devices that you buy and that immediately does not work in Windows just because some features are not supported or compatible with each other.

Windows should be really considered the prehistory huge dinausor. It will die, because since the time of dinosaurs, birds and insects have evolved and proliferated much more easily with much less dependency about their environment.

I see no future on Windows as a monolithic system. Microsoft must recognize it and return back to a simpler smaller stronger kernel without all these non-required decorations.

Everybody now had too live with all those heavy fat around Windows that he would better live without. Modernism is all about mobility and ease of evolution and adaptation.

There will still be people that will want to buy big Cherokee jeeps that eats tons of gasoline and taxes, but most people will be satisfied by buying a small cute Beetle that you can park easily in the city. They won't put lots of luggages in it, but anyway what they appreciate is the mobility and ease of use. They feel freeer with such small cars that give them less problems everyday. In the rare cases when they'll need a larger car, they'll rent it. They'll rent a concrete maker only when they'll need it to build a fence around their garden, the rest of the time, this tool will be using valuable space and will look so ugly in their garage. So why Microsoft is selling is and installing in our gardens a beetle, a truck, a concrete maker, a gasoline dispenser and a gas tank when all the house is equiped with electricity? And a set of bad quality tools that will break the first time you use it, and will require use to buy other better tools?

And why do people have to worry about the security of those unused tools? Let people get the secure tools only when they'll need it, and then dsipose it easily when the work is done with it.

Really, Microsoft still has a lot to learn from Apple, whose MacOSX system is far easier to manage, and whre applications are just as easy to install as drag and drop from one volume to another, without any prior installation (the same is nearly true under Linux with the RPM package distribution system, although there's still some installation to perform, but it is still easier to manage than on Windows).

by gonzogarrish

...makes perfect sense but would require a rewrite from the ground up, Windows components being so interdependent these days. Still, it would also give them an opportunity to junk that other grim legacy - the Windoze registry. Here's hoping!

by hal 9000

Volume License of Vista Enterprise I've had a little bit of experience with it from the release date till now and while it's excellent as a Play Console it's not yet ready for a Domain where Drives are permanently shared and things like that.

I'm not overly happy with M$ ideas of only being able to use Digitally Signed Hardware from SP1 onward and Digitally signed Software on the next release of Vista which if M$ can stick to projected release dates will be sometime in 2011.

As the Quad Cores are becoming much more popular now I'm using Linux more and more often but what I do find interesting is that the Old Unix Commands that I used to use back when I worked with Main Frames are quite acceptable to Window Server Products and Desktops. When I get those nasty jobs the Old Habits just kick in and I tend to drop into the old habits to solve problems. I've yet to find a single Unix Command Line that doesn't work with Windows and when I'm running in Windows I have a Short Cut to the CLI on the desktop just where it should be as there are things that you can do with the CLI that are currently just not possible with the GUI that so many people think compromises a Computer now days.

I love Windows to bits but I do get a laugh when I hear people criticise the Unix/Linux CLI saying that it needs to be improved when they are using the exact same thing on their Windows Boxes.

As for Windows XP has so far been about the best combining the ease of use of the 9X versions with the better performance of the NT Platform but there are still many things that where promised when NT was new that have yet to arrive. This I put down to poor programing skills at Redmond or bad business practises rather than anything else.

But on the other hand IE6 works a treat on Debian and confuses the hell out of so many people that I'm amazed that I'm not constantly being demanded to install the same copy of Windows that's on my NB because it's unbreakable in everyones eyes.

Col

by intrepi

I've supported MS since DOS and I still have an occasional use for it whenever I'm using a non graphical interface or programs that require one. I like DOS, it doesn't argue, it won't complain, no compatibility or complicated issues coming out of some security application.
I loved Windows when I didn't have to get into the verification and activation procedures as I really believe MS could find a better way of protecting their software without taking up my time. I bought it, I installed it, I shouldn't have to verify time and time again that it's valid nor should I have to go through the telephone procedure to get it reactivated. I mean 42 digits and an East Indian guy who I honestly cannot understand at times which forces me to call back and hope I get somebody with a little less accent. MS has done this to limit the cost of their support to a minimum which takes precedence over providing you with local telephone support. Assuming they did provide local support, it still doesn't make their activation and certification procedures acceptable. They could find a secure online method similar to bank transactions to protect everyone including their software if they were to improvise and adjust it to work for them. If they won't change, I will and have as there is none of this nonsense with any other OS. Xandros 4.01 has issues but they are ones I can live with, it allows me to install on as many personal computers as I own as well as 1 business pc. The OS comes with free updatable Antivirus, Adware and File Protection. There are a lot of additional reasons I like it but anyone can download and try it out. The difference is it's easy to uninstall whereas Vista is like an arc weld, easy to put on, hard to take off

by neon samurai

I believe osX is actually BSD Unix with an Apple X window manager layered overtop of it.

The base has the stability of BSD while the window manager and user applications GUI design from Apple. They've managed to combine there proprietary icing ontop of an Open Source cake mix.

Linux driver issues are completely seporate from osX. Also, since they keep Apple systems in such a small collection of products, they only need to develop drivers for Apple choosen hardware. It's not like Linux/BSD trying to support whatever the user throws at it or Windows with half baked drivers from every hardware manufacturer known.

That's only to clarify the details of osX though, not a comparison of the other OS available.

by earlyjazz

After installing Windows XP and finding only about half of our applications would run, we removed XP and returned to Windows 98SE. At the same time, we began our migration to Linux.
At that time, Linux was a little dicey to load and get running. However, for not too technical people, Mandrake (Now Mandriva) has consistantly had distributions that install and run quite well! The more recent versions of Linux are, by far, much more user friendly and , in our opinion, Mandriva 2006 rivals any Windows version in ease of installation and operation. In our 6 years of running Linux, we have never had a virus nor spyware. When installing new hardware or software, no driver installation is required since the drivers for most popular hardware are included in the Linux kernel.
While we can see some drawbacks in switching to linux in larger corporations, we believe that the majority who have made the change are happy to have done so.

by techrepublic

Run just about any version of MetaSploit against a W2K box and you end up with local admin rights within two or three minutes.

Not much to rave about, now is it?

by 706pbd

Couldn't care less about some supposed exploit that MIGHT exist. WinXP and Vista are pure unadulterated bloatware crapola, both with a kiddified interface intended for g(L)amers. If forced to migrate, it'll be to Windows Server 2003, the only professional-level OS currently available from M$. There's a reason it still uses the Classic W2K GUI- there is no desire/need for a Loonie Tune (ooooh, the PRETTY colors....) interface in the business world. BTW, did you know that WinXPx64 is actually based on W2KIII, not WinXP? Even M$ wasn't about to try to revive that dead horse with a heart transplant....

by myronjams

Most of the improvements to the MSOS really didn't need a New Name or new face. The most aggravating thing about MS is they continually force you to relearn everything; from the interface(where stuff is), to the names, and other things too numerous to mention here. I currently run Win2000 and am very happy with it. But as mentioned it will soon be on the MS chopping block; i.e. unsupported. Why this need to continually force all of us to upgrade, go though the pain of beta testing their products for them & then SP1, SP2, SP3......... Wouldn't it be more prudent to SPx up to a near perfect OS and then make chargeable improvements on it??? Instead of recreating the OS or at best renaming it and changing it just enough to justify us spending our hard earned $$$'s on it. But, then there's Visual Studio & MS Office &, & , &..... The never ending learning curve... brought to you by MicroSoft.

David M. Brefka

by dumphrey

we need to differentiate between the look of a desktop and program names. I think going so far as to say the kde default desktop is looking a little dated, but the buntu flavors are putting on nice dekstops, even FC6 is a nice looking theme. The thing to remember about the linux desktop, is that if you dont like it, change it. You can make it look as close to either OSX, WinXP/Vista, heck even RISC OS that many people would not be able to tell untill they start using the menu. Honestly, the linux aglx/beryl desktop is one of the most customizable and smoothest desktops out there. Now, installer routines and program names are another matter altogether =\

by susan.bennett

Yes, I appreciate the comments from a usability standpoint. I guess I'm wondering what is really under the hood of these various development? For instance:

- To what extent are these various versions supporting speed of application development? New libraries?

- What security vulnerabilites (or breaches) are being quietly created or uncreated?; and

- how much of the changes under the hood are in preparation for SIP and utilizing presence?

So while the changes you describe are superficial changes... can you share any information with us about what might really be going on?

by dukhalion

There's no need to upgrade just because there is a new version of something. If Your system works, don't upgrade. Besides, there comes a point when existing usability reaches a level that cannot be improved enough to justify cost and trouble of upgrading.

I'm still using win98, what do I need vista for? It can't do anything new and necessary for me. The only reason I prefer win98 over win95 is the usb-support.

As for there being no support... Of course there is support for win98, not from microsoft but from lots of others.

by philippev

The question about the need to upgrade is good not a question; every component in a computing system need to be evolvable, and it will fataly evolve over time just because there are new needs to solve.

But why do people have to upgrade EVERYTHING in Windows?

All what Microsoft is selling is NOT software, but LICENCES with right to use the new pieces of software. But then, why does it require to upgrade everything at the same time? Why can't user cumulate their existing licences to get the pieces of software they are really interested in?

If Microsoft was doing like this, it would know which features are really important for its market, and which "old" features are prefered and must be kept. And there would be several versions of the ame component, with a compatible interface.

Microsoft is best known for introducing lots of migration issues at each Windows version. The monster is not manageable by people, and given that it has now billions of users, proposing a "one fits all" solution is completely stupid: people are used with their existing solutions that work and REALLY HATE Microsoft each time it makes things so that their past solutions stop being supported or stop working.

It's like if Microsoft was the sole vendor of houses that get each time more and more expensive and where people can't even choose which furniture they want in their home, or which equipment they want in their kitchen. And they are only given the option to change for a new house with a completely different design but absolutely no way to choose between new houses. They can't keep their past custimizations, and can't move in with their own furniture.

Worse: now Microsoft requires you buy your car with your house from the same vendor, and even requires you pay using a bank account and an insurance for it and for your family anf for your car from that vendor. People are let without freedom. Either they must accept the whole package and live as Microsoft wants them, or they must be left completely out of any new improvement.

And Microsoft is even barring eany alternative house builder to let inhabitants choose the house of their dream. Windows is a severe form of modern slavery: either you get rich with everything but no right to organize your life, or you get nothing and are left without any legal solution to organize your life and the life of your children.

Stop that slavery. Start thinking about true openness. It's not just a matter of price (after all Microsoft products are not so expensive individually), but a question of freedom (because you'll have to pay the Microsoft tax for all your life within the Microsoft world, or get banned from the society).

by 2rs

Matt - right on. I'm at a non-profit. It took me 2.5 years to upgrade 20 desktop hardware + server hardware to run XP,Office 2003, & Exchange 2003. Then, Vista hit! At present, maybe 4 people even know that there is a help button on every toolbar ( whats a toolbar?). yes, I am an enabler, but that's another story......Not just a training issue, but hardware, too. Thanks for listening - Happy Monday!

by pcurran

You said "No ?Classic Mode? to be rid of flashy interface and configuration wizards."

This is incorrect for XP as there is "Classic Mode" for the menus, folders and desktop and Start menu"

I do this with all of my XP box's regardless of the user's desires. If you do this, XP will operate like, and in some case's better than 2k.

by ssaulino

Now just apply the same philosophy to just about any other industry and you will be able to understand the way I feel when I look at the cars we make, the clothes we ware, the hair cuts we pay for, and so fourth. But the single bigest problem I believe is design flaws, it almost seems as if these flaws are purposely designed, into basically almost anything. Can you say job security, be quit thou, Im still looking for work.

by tech

I agree with your POV/comments in general, and want to add three points:
a) basic lack of functionality, such as error-free tree-view drag-and-drop in Explorer, as well as lack of "real" scripting languages, are what drive me to seek other solutions.
b) i have an inherent distrust of any company that needs to issue security patches and download hotfixes on a semi-weekly basis
c) the Genuine (legit copy) verification keeps "improving" and will likely turn many users here in Spain toward Linux, a special stripped-down version named "Guadalinux", and other solutions. Half of the WinTel boxes I've seen are pirate copies of one shade or another.

My dual 1.25ghz G4 unlocked the chains, my VAIO now runs Linux, and my last windows PC will likely be the one I use for supporting clients who are still shackled to the s(t)inking barge from Redmond.

by jackie40d1

I read some where in my many e-mails that MS is going to cut XP a lot shorter than Win 2K Pro got for support! I would be supprised if it gets another year of support so you got to UPGRADE or so they think . .As for me Win 2K is about as far as I go with windows. . I will find a way to dump windows in the not to distant future . . working hard on it now . .