require people to double and triple the hardware requirements so they can keep people on board with MS products?'
About the only area in which that makes sense is if you compare the minimum requirements of XP to Vista. XP's was a PII 266 with 64M of RAM (the same as 2000), Vista's is a PIII 1Ghz w/ 512M of RAM. Times change, requirements change. In other words, the machine that I put together 5 years ago to run XP can still run Vista, and it does just fine. Aero and all, I use it every day. Those requirements are for vendors, so they know what to put in the box. Not that it matters much since the minimum requirements haven't been sold for 5 years.
The biggest problem I have is MS forcing people to upgrade by stopping the support for older products.
They don't stop support to "force" upgrades. They stop support because can't support every version of every piece of software forever. No one does. You want support for Windows 95? It's out there, on the Internet. Just like for Linux (which, BTW, no one really supports old versions of, either. How often do you see Linux software that'll run on a 2.2 kernel or even 2.4?). All of the questions have been asked and answered for those older versions, but it's not Microsoft's job to help you find them. Should they support DOS, too? How 'bout Xenix? SCO isn't doing a great job of supporting that these days, after all.
So if you want a secure/stable OS then you need to follow MS with every version of Windows they put out, even when their systems are inherently insecure.
Despite what even MS' marketing guys will tell you, no OS is secure. It's not an OS' job to be secure, it's the job of the wetware that uses the machine. MS can do everything it can to secure the OS, and people will still manage to find new and impressive ways to screw it up. Security is not the job of the OS. If you were an admin, you'd know that.
Windows 9x = Useless
Useless, really? Easily the most popular version, and you think it was useless? Honestly, I find that hillarious. See, I used to be a raving anti-Microsoft twit, too. Then 95 came along. I remember the moment I converted. I was connected to my university's computers downloading some stuff using the DOS version of Telix. I decided to play a little Warcraft (that's before there was a World) while that did its thing. A little later I though I should check since the download should've finished by then and I hit Alt-Tab. I won't type the string of explitives I emitted the instant I'd realized what I'd done. "You can't Alt-Tab in Windows from a full-screen game to a DOS app! You've just lost both!", I thought. I figured with nothing to lose, I'd Alt-Tab back to the game. Surprisingly, it not only worked, but the game had paused while I was out of it! Holy crap! This was a new install of 95, so it occured to me...if it works this well out of the box, I wonder if it's been ME that's been causing all of my problems all along?! Sure enough, when I figured out that I was the problem, all of my issues with Windows went away and I became a convert, never looking back. I will agree, however, that Windows ME caused a lot of people a lot of grief unneccesarily.
and if Linux was where it is now back then we would all be using it today.
And where was it back then? Completely useless. I started playing around with it in 1994, and every time I had an issue with my Windows 3.1 box, I'd try Linux again only to reinstall DOS a week or so later. Where is it now? I'd put it about as good as Windows 95, so we'll let you decide if that's useless or not.
Windows 2000 = the entire reason I didn?t jump ship and go Linux all the way. Thank you for Windows 2000.
Yup, the first one that even a user like you couldn't screw up easily.
Cons: Still allows most programs to require admin rights to run.
Again, a failing of yours, not the OS. I know what you're talking about, though. I ran into this problem with Adobe's Type Manager back in the day. I had a user that was nothing but trouble (like installing pirated software left and right), so we wanted to lock his machine down. Couldn't, though. He was a graphics designer and ATM had to be run by an admin. Even Adobe said so! I did a little research, found secedit and figured out what needed to be done to get it to work. Seriously, learn your stuff before you complain.
Windows XP = useless improvements and a new flashy interface that doubled our hardware requirements.
Wrong. XP's hardware requirements were the same as 2000, that was well-documented. As for useless improvements...huh. Remote Desktop, increased security and performance over 2000? Yeah, now we see what your definition of useless is..."I don't know what it is."
Still allows most programs to require admin rights to run. Doubled hardware requirements from Win2000. Runs wizards by default for every configuration. No ?Classic Mode? to be rid of flashy interface and configuration wizards.
Seriously, if you're going to try to make an argument, at least get SOME of your facts right. What part of the "flashy" interface can't be turned off by simply disabling the Themes service? What wizards are you talking about? Network configuration? Nope. Display settings? Nope. Performance configs? Nope. About the only thing I can think of off-hand that I use on a regular basis is the Add Printer wizard, however most new printers come with installers that create that so I don't use it on my XP boxes (only servers) much. Granted, it's annoying, but I don't do it all that often. Again, perhaps the problem isn't the OS, but your lack of knowledge? I'm definitely seeing a patten here...
Directory layout improved (shorter directory names too). Got rid of the ?My . . .? naming convention from early Windows daze.
These are your pros? Seriously? You do know this is a technical forum, right? It's not really for end-users. Do some research on how to rename "My Computer" in earlier versions. I think you'll be seriously amazed at how simple a task that really is.
Cool but function-less Aero interface.
You listed this with pros, but isn't really a "con"? (Like this attempt to show you know what you're talking about that's only turning into an ignorance fest)
Navigation with the Windows Explorer address bar.
Which you've been able to do since Windows 95, so I guess that OS wasn't completely useless after all. Oh, and nice job keeping up with the times.
Even better USB support and new flashy icons (useless!).
Oh, I see, these are your pros intermixed with things MS says are pros, right? Tough to keep straight what you're talking about when you flip back and forth like that.
Broke most of the programs that require admin rights hence forcing programmers to write better programs that won?t make our OS vulnerable to all sorts of attacks and users who download ?free? software.
Reread what you wrote. I think it would be a relatively simple argument to make that if they "broke" because of Vista, they were broken before...you just didn't notice it. Probably because you were blaming Microsoft for all of the problems these programs were causing you.
Cons: Doubled and tripled the hardware requirements again.
Again, not "again". For the first time in 7 years, and the minimum requirements are for some seriously old crap.
Over complicated networking-Pick a zone: Home, Work or Public (Why?? Just firewall the connection like WinXP SP2)? Complicated the network browser even further (Just give us back the Network Neighborhood that worked in Win98) The UAC is not needed for every little thing I do especially if I am logged in as admin. The useless, flashy login page.
Wow, there's so much wrong with this, I wouldn't even know where to begin.
Windows sidebar is a useless resource hog and shouldn?t be default (how about get rid of useless sidebar and install Telnet by default).
Why is it things you have no use for are useless? I like the sidebar, and find it useful every day. It didn't have as much use, granted, until I added gadgets that were useful to me, but it's really up to me to decide what I find useful. Not you, not Microsoft.
Keep in mind I am operating from a admin prospective and want functional efficiency
YOU'RE AN ADMIN!?! Oh, god help the other users (I'm including you, hence the "other") on your network. Seriously, dude. You're a clueless twit at best. You want efficiency? Go have a talk with your HR department right now. Explain to them that you shouldn't be doing this job, and you and your boss (for hiring you) should be fired. You are representative of exactly everything that is wrong with the industry today.
and would like MS to work on functionality and less on wizard-like processes that are meant to cater to end-users/noobs/lamers.
Such as yourself. Um, you do know that Vista is primarily geared for home users, right? MS is fully aware that most businesses aren't going to jump on the bandwagon out of the gate. Us, we're ready for it and are pretty much comfortable with rolling it out to our 13,000 desktops. But, that plan won't go into effect until later this year.
My main contention is Windows 2000 was a great OS (add msconfig) and XP SP2 was a good improvement but put the benefits of XP SP2 on Windows 2000 because business doesn?t need the jelly icons. It doesn?t make Excel add columns faster.
No, but the other improvements in the underlying OS do. People are stupid, they only think something's changed if it LOOKS like it changed. They aren't smart enough to go beyond what's on the screen to see the other improvements that are really important.
Making the interface more attractive only appeals to people who don?t understand or concern themselves with efficiency. A similar statement can be made about the gaming industry as well which is why I can?t find a Wii anywhere!
Wow. Seriously. Wow.