Windows XP was originally launched with the idea that people would change (upgrade) parts of their systems over time. It was determined that if you changed 4 items in your system (6 if you had a network card installed) it would then need to be reactivated. They eventually made it where this applied in a 120 day period, since some people complained about testing equipment, etc.
More recently, however, I found out this had changed at an MS event. The MS rep said that they now say once you activated the copy of Windows, it is now bound to that motherboard forever. If the board proves defective, it may allow a second activation, but only (during the warranty)if it is replaced by the OEM that installed it. The big names all have corporate keys, so that does not matter to them to put a fresh copy on, but the little guys may not have any option but to "eat the cost," if MS will not. Seems unfair if someone sells you a motherboard and it fails 3-6 months down the line, you would have to buy a new copy of Windows if you did not buy it with the board.
This is bad for small OEMs, businesses, and consumers who like to build their own equipment to their own specs. Now, everytime you upgrade your motherboard, you have a new system, requiring a new copy of the same Windows you had previously. It doesn't matter that the old motherboard will never be used again (or that you would put Win 98 on it, then give it to your grandmother for email) They want a new license for the "new" computer you just assembled.
We were told by the rep that this allows us (system builders) the chance to sell another license, and what did anyone expect when they were already paying half the price of the retail version. (That $150 piece of cardboard)
I am an Action Pack subscriber, and this was never mentioned to me, but I was wondering why MS would not (flat out told me NO) activate my software.
They originally said that the AP software was for testing and evaluation in your business. While I did install on some systems to use, I kept some of the licenses for testing on various systems, which I changed. Now I found that I have licenses bound to what is now old hardware, that I can't use on newer platforms to see if they are viable alternatives. They did not even send me new keys to use when I renewed my subscription earlier this year, just took the same $300 they did last year. They also dropped the $100 discount for renewals.
Obviously I am not happy with MS, but why alienate the people you need to evangelize your software? Between this and the WGA fiasco, who really wants to have a Windows PC if they have to jump through hoops to maintain it? Rumor is that this only applies to people who buy OEM copies, not retail. Since I do not know anyone who actually owns a retail copy of the full version of XP Pro, I can't confirm this. Anyone out there know for sure?
WGA is just plain spyware MS forced down users throats. This was not a critical update that should be installed ASAP, it was a piece of software that if given the choice, most users would not install. This would mean that MS would not have had as large a "beta test pool" to work with before rolling it out as mandatory. It did nothing to repair a flaw in the OS, it just phones home everyday (or 14 days, now) to say, "Yes, everything is fine here, no piracy detected." It records your IP address, so with the push by the government to have ISPs track users IPs for months to years, it would not be difficult for MS to come back on someone now (or later) for "piracy" violations. If MS would do this, how much longer before they just decide to force down a patch to give them all the info of a user or system? Could this already be something being implemented in Vista? Sounds like paranoia, but could it happen before anyone found out? Do not forget what they did to DR-DOS years ago. Where do we as a community draw the line and say enough? Could it be time to have the world move to Linux? Stay tuned for the next exciting chapter.
OK, I will get off the soapbox now to allow others to agree or disagree at their whim. I'll just get an icy cold one and see what anyone else has to say. Thanks for letting me vent :)