Discussion Locked

Windows XP Pro in an NT 4.0 Environment

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We've had a few students install Windows XP Pro on their personal computers. I discovered this when unknown computer names began appearing in Server Manager (listed as Windows NT 5.1 Workstation).

After asking all of our folks that have access to create computer accounts, and getting no ownership of doing so, I was pretty alarmed.

Since then, I have installed WinXPPro on a computer myself and duplicated the issue.

Without being added to the domain, the computer name is displayed in Server Manager. It concerns me that this could happen. Has anyone else seen this? If so, could you shed some light on it for me?

Thanks,

-Joe

5 replies

by jb007

Automatic addition to the domain list is by virtue of information supplied by the master browser.

The information you are looking at when using srvmgr is derived from there.

So when a machine joins a domain and advertises its services to various systems (wins, ddns, master browser) a part of that advertisement is registering its machine name (if not already taken).

The way this has been traditionally protected is by making sure that no-one but admins have been given the right to join amachine to the domain.

hope this helps,

jb.

by erikdr

Answer 1 is basically correct. Addition is to the master browser system, just like W9x machines can be added to that (without having any domain account at all!).
This is as far as I see it _not_ a security risk. The XP workstations are still not part of the NT domain and users on them cannot access server resources unless they know a domain user id and password. (NET USE /U: works always, no matter whether the workstation itself has a computer account in this specific domain.)

So please inform us which risks you see, then we can discuss any related problems...

At your service,

- The Netherlands

This discussion is closed to new replies.