Discussion Locked

Wins Replication

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
We are getting ready to setup trusts between 3 domains in 3 locations seperated by t1 lines. First we will be replicating our wins servers. Each location has a primary and secondary wins server. There isn't a firewall between the links. How should I configure replication and how often? Our sites are far apart so our roaming users take most of a day to travel to another site.

8 replies

by tony.colgrove

A) Scatter/Gather I/O
"Scatter/Gather I/O is a special type of high-performance I/O available via the Win32 ReadFileScatter and WriteFileScatter functions.
Enables higher I/O throughput when application data is located in noncontiguous memory locations, and data needs to be written to a contiguous file location."
Info taken from Windows2000 Reviews Guide, Section 5-Windows 2000 Server Feature Tables

by tony.colgrove

Whoops. This answer is for a different question.
To answer your replication question. I would create push/pull replication between the 3 primary servers. Depending on the number of users at each domain, it might change the schedule a little. You dont want all of them at the same time. Stagger each by a half-hour or so, and you probably only need an update once in the morning and once in the afternoon (If you even need that). If it is server access they need, those IP's are not going to change day to day. The biggest replication changes would come from your roaming clients, registering with the local WINS servers.

by ronnonf

If you set up 3 diff WINS servers and configure them to replicate to each other can cause a serious problem. This has been document by MS. You should place your WINS servers in the busiest domains and configure them with Push/pull replication. Be aware that the more times the servers replicate the more traffic is added to your network.
For the mobile users either give them and LMHOSTS file or implement DNS. DNS might be a better choice b/c it is a good going foward strategy (MS is using Dynamic DNS in Win2k and not WINS).
With DNS you can have a Primary DNS server and a secondary in each domain.

by nettek

You are asking for serious WINS corruption problems if you have six WINS servers for three sites (I learned this the hard way). You do not need to have a WINS server at each site. MS recommends one primary WINS server and one secondary for up to 10,000 clients, even across routers. If you are worried about WAN traffic, don't be: WINS traffic is minimal, and once a PC has the name resolution in its cache it doesn't need to check with the WINS server again. Put the primary at one site and the secondary at another, and configure them as Push/Pull partners. Set all servers and clients to point to the same primary and secondary WINS servers.

For more detailed info, check the Microsoft Knowledge Base article: Q185786

This discussion is closed to new replies.