Question Locked

wire run from demarc to router is too long

0 helpful
21 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
We have an installation of a T1 whose demarc is located 500' from the router. We are constantly losing the T1 connection. We were told to use a repeater, but I'm wondering what kind of repeater should I get? Does anybody have any recommendations? thanks....

21 replies

by tig2

If your company is mostly Cisco, go Cisco... or whatever you prefer.

Your max distance cannot go over 330 feet at any point. It is a known limitation of CAT5 and CAT6. When you place your repeater, that is the guideline to watch for.

Yes, you can get signal. It just won't be dependable, as you have discovered.

Another possible solution would be to have the service provider extend the demarc. While a bit more expensive at first, it is a more dependable solution as you eliminate the repeater as a potential point of failure.

I've done both. Both solutions are valid.

by jdclyde

if that won't work, then what you do from there depends on the size of your organization.

If it is small with light network needs, any switch will do. If you have a network with higher demands, better get a high end Cisco Switch.

by cg it

as Tigger and jdclyde suggested, stick a low cost switch in there.

by retro77

What you could do it install a fiber switch/repeater at the demark and run a fiber line to your office.

by richard.gates

I would want the dmarc to be moved but AT&T says it can't be moved, also the signal is a T1 synchronous signal, not ethernet. I've been told that an ethernet device will not work. There is a T1 extender repeater but it's the only one I've seen, just wondering if there are any others? thanks again...

by tig2

Did ATT tell you WHY they can't move the demarc? I have had a few that they couldn't extend due to common (single shared closet) POP but in general, the demarc could at least be extended to my closet. A few on airport demarcs simply could NOT be moved but could be extended to within wire tolerance ranges.

You might want to talk with ATT about an extension (as opposed to a move, they might not suggest this) to accommodate your needs as this will be the best possible solution.

Alternatively, what is your layout? Is it possible to site your core network at the POP an convert the sig to support your network downstream? I have also pulled this one in situations where I could more easily closet my network with the POP and then extend using a 4-port repeater.

Not real fond of repeaters but if you can't pull cable, they work. Had more than one of those situations.

Can give you some contacts for solutions if you would like. Just peer mail me.

by michael kassner

Hello Richard,

I have experienced what you are seeing on a few occasions. I am curious as to how the demarc is extended, ie what kind of cabling and what the cable encounters along its path? Many times the extension is Cat5 using in house cross connects. Where shielded Cat3 cable maybe in order because of the distance, possible EM interference along the path and for some reason T1 serial connections do not always like Cat5/6. I have many extensions that are in excess of what you are running and they are not experiencing any problems. That is why I am suspect of possible interferences or cabling issues.

I also have used the repeater you are looking at and you are correct, it is the only one that will work with T1 synched serial lines. It seems to work quite well in that particular situation.

I just checked some of my Cisco notes and this maybe of interest to you.

If Receiver Has Loss of Frame

Step 1 Check to see whether the framing format configured on the port matches the framing format of the line. You can check the framing format of the controller from the running configuration or the show controller t1 command output.

To change the framing format, use the framing {SF | ESF} command in the controller configuration mode, as shown here:

maui-nas-03#configure terminal

Enter configuration commands, one per line. End with CNTL/Z.

maui-nas-03(config)#controller t1 0

maui-nas-03(config-controlle)#framing esf

Step 2 Try the other framing format to see if the alarm clears.

Step 3 Change the line build out setting using the cablelength {long | short} command.

Line build out (LBO) compensates for the loss in decibels based on the distance from the device to the first repeater in the circuit. A longer distance from the device to the repeater requires that the signal strength on the circuit be boosted to compensate for loss over that distance.

To configure transmit and receive levels for a cable length (line build out) longer than 655 feet for a T1 trunk with a channel service unit (CSU) interface, use the cablelength long controller configuration command. To configure transmit attenuation for a cable length (line build out) of 655 feet or shorter for a T1 trunk with a DSX-1 interface, use the cablelength short controller configuration command.

by richard.gates

I'm beginning to believe that it's the cable that's causing the problem. I think another run of cat 3 is what we'll try next. thanks for all the replies.

by michael kassner

I think I would try that as well. I would also humbly add that if it is an overhead run I would avoid any electrical devices and lighting if at all possible. If it is not too much trouble, I would appreciate hearing if it worked or not as well. Good Luck.

by jdclyde

it doesn't have as high of a shielding from EMI's, nor will it handle anything over a 10t connection.

If you want to do this the right way for that long of a distance, go fiber. eliminates both EMI's and distance from the factor, and the saving of future problems will cover the expense.

by tig2

Why would you trust your network to CAT 3?

In my opinion, it may be more helpful to review your cable layout before moving forward with a solution or pulling new wire.

See other post- is a demarc extension possible where a move is not? While I have had to use a series of repeaters in some situations- generally when concrete was simply in the way- I have usually been able to get a demarc extended by the provider to my preferred location. ATT will (in my experience) not tell you about the difference in extension versus move. You have to ask them specifically.

Distance tolerance for cable doesn't change- 330 feet for UTP (unshielded twisted pair) versus a virtually unlimited distance for fiber. CAT 3 is UTP. The distance of the pull is the stopper, not the cable categorization.

I think that Michael gave you best advice.

by michael kassner

Nearly all major manufacturers of wire and cable supply a version of T1 cable. In general, T1 cable is two twisted pairs of 22 AWG, 100 ohm wire with the added characteristic that each pair is individually shielded. Both of the shielded pairs are enclosed in a single PVC jacket.

The reason Cat 3 is suggested by one side of the dabate is the fact that Cat5/6 has more twists per inch and that in fact will induce more interference between the TX and RX pairs.

Also serial runs can go 655ft before they need to be enhanced or have the power turned up.

As for the debate I am not sure where I stand, I just try very hard to use actual T1 cable, the initial expense is usually worth it if you are troubleshooting connection issues later on.

by jdclyde

And from my understanding, the more twists BLOCKS EMI's and cross talk, not adds to it?

by michael kassner

I mentioned that this is a popular topic for debate and I try to remain neutral about it. I have used Cat5/6 and it worked just fine. I have ran Cat3 because that was what I was told to use and it worked great.

I also have split the T1 between the two binder groups in the multiple pair cables. Putting the TX pair of the T1 in one binder and the RX pair in another binder. T1's are always put in separate binder groups to reduce cross coupling between transmit and receive. So these are basically house circuits without any twist at all, but the TX and RX pairs are separated.

This method is often used in multi-office situations where there is one main telco room and they run 25/50 pair cables to each office's telco room. The T1's are then extended using those cables. If done correctly you will notice that one pair is always near the top of the 66 block and the other at the opposite end. This is a good indication that the TX/RX pairs are in separate binder groups or maybe even separate cables.

This is from some notes of mine:

CAT 5 cable should not be a problem when extending a T1 from a DEMARC . It is not the cable itself that determines the cable selection/design. Rather it is DS1 signal loss that determines if TX/RX pairs must be isolated from each other. With a 0.0 to -7.5DBDSX T1 hand off level by the Telco at the DEMARC, A T1 can be extended for a reasonably long distance as long as the insertion losses of the cable @ 772KHz are not excessive enough as to allow signal cross talk from one transmission pair (Strong signal) to the other (Weaker signal) to occur. Twisted 25 pair cable is OK for relatively short runs, however if used on house riser, it is recommended that different 25 pair binder group pairs be used to isolate T1 RX/TX pairs.

My understanding of best to worst might be:

1. 2 pair twisted with each pair individually shielded.
2. Isolated house pairs only because typical cable runs are in conduit and the runs usually avoid EMI sources.
3. 2 separate Cat 5 shielded cables TX pair in one and RX pair in the other.
4. Cat 5 shielded
5. Cat 5 unshielded
6. Cat 3

I must qualify my original comment about using Cat3 versus Cat5. The original poster was looking at using signal enhancement methods and I used the device mentioned on one occasion and it stipulated that Cat 3 be used. I also will mention that I have been in situations similar to what the original poster has described, ran Cat 3 along the exact route and the problem cleared up. I would not want to debate whether it was just bad original cable or something else as I do not have enough degrees or smarts to understand the intricacies of EMI and low frequency EM radiation.

by richard.gates

I personally have learned alot about T1 signaling thru all the posts. Unfortunately, the location is remote to where I am and I have to go thru subordinates to work on this problem. We're double checking for any interferences with emi, the people who ran the cable says it passed their tests, we're probably going to run a shielded cable of some sort temporarily. I'm still a bit peaved that AT&T says the demarc can't be moved. But I will post the solution as soon as we have one. thanks again to all

by jdclyde

It sounds like it is time to talk to your reps supervisor.

You should NOT have to purchase additional equipment in order to get connections to their lines.

Insist that it be moved and start barking up the food chain at AT&T until someone listens. And no, calling "customer service" will only serve to get you further ignored.

by michael kassner

In most cases here in MN the telco is only responsible to get the circuits to the demarc, usually in the contract. Extension becomes the responsibility of the facility management if it is a multi-tennant building or the building owner if a single tennant site.

Telcos in some cases will do extensions and be responsible for the CSU/router, but that will have to be spelled out in the contract. It means an additional one time charge as well as monthly maintenance fee.

This discussion is closed to new replies.