Discussion Locked

Wireless NIC for Ubuntu/Debian Etch

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am looking to put a wireless NIC into either a Ubuntu FF or Debian Etch box. I have no problems reinstalling, as the box has no data atm. This box will be used to view streaming data in my bedroom from a storage server and MythTV backend.
Any thoughts/experiences on wireless PCI nics and linux?

6 replies

by deepsand

Try the "Questions" forum; the "Discussion" forum is for matters of general discussion, not specific problems in search of a solution.

Post problems such as this to the "Question" forum, rather than the "Discussion" forum. There are those who specifically seek out problems in need of a solution, and that's where they go to look for such.

Additionally there are the benefits that:

1) The "Questions" forum provides for your feedback, by way of your being able to mark "helpful" responses as such. This does not necessarily mean that a given response contained the complete solution to your problem, but only that it served to guide you toward it. This is intended to serve as an aid to those who may in the future have a problem similar to yours, so that they might have a ready source of reference available, thereby perhaps obviating the need for them to repeat questions previously asked and answered.

2) The revised TR makes it quite difficult to find both "Discussions" and "Questions" that have not had a fairly recent post, owing to some functions comingling them in the listings. By keeping each type in their respective forums, it is easier for all to find what they are looking for.Try the "Questions" forum; the "Discussion" forum is for matters of general discussion, not specific problems in search of a solution.

Post problems such as this to the "Question" forum, rather than the "Discussion" forum. There are those who specifically seek out problems in need of a solution, and that's where they go to look for such.

Additionally there are the benefits that:

1) The "Questions" forum provides for your feedback, by way of your being able to mark "helpful" responses as such. This does not necessarily mean that a given response contained the complete solution to your problem, but only that it served to guide you toward it. This is intended to serve as an aid to those who may in the future have a problem similar to yours, so that they might have a ready source of reference available, thereby perhaps obviating the need for them to repeat questions previously asked and answered.

2) The revised TR makes it quite difficult to find both "Discussions" and "Questions" that have not had a fairly recent post, owing to some functions comingling them in the listings. By keeping each type in their respective forums, it is easier for all to find what they are looking for.

by dumphrey

but discussion on native driver vs ndiswrapper would be interesting. I posted here because in any linux/hardware situation, it seems that topics vary and shift, and the simple question/answer format does not fit.

by deepsand

The Questions forum, though, has the added Feature of being able to "rate" responses.

The purpose of such is to [b]aid others[/b] who seek like or similar advice and/or assistance, as another has here indicated.

by dumphrey

was that the ndiswrapper version in Ubuntu feisty was to old. I removed ndiswrapper from the install through apt, then built the latest (1.43 or 1.45 i cant remember atm) version of ndiswrapper from their web site. That was all I had to do. Pretty embarasing that I did not try that sooner, but we fall into the trap of "they provide it, it must be good." After using gentoo for over a year I should know better. I then used ndiswrapper to install the windows xp driver inf/sys for my cards chipset (I got this from the chipset vendor and not the card vendor) and had wpa2 secured connections to my AP. I spent several hours last night finishing up the install of various programs (VMServer, mplayer, codecs, etc) and had no problems with wireless stability. The card I used was a netgear wg311v3 pci.
I now have wireless that just works, as it should.

All that being said, I am still having problems with a linksys wmp54g v4.1. It uses the ralink chipset. Ubuntu comes with the serialmonkey rt61.ko driver, but it is broken for the v 4.1 of this card. It sees wireless networks, but can not even connect to unencrpyted, wide open, access points. Ralink offers a driver source code package, but it also did not seem to work. I may have just instaleed it wrong, so I really should try again. But, the ralink driver and the serialmonkey driver are both called rt61.ko, and thats where I had issues. I couldn't tell which was which, and if i just blacklisted rt61........ sigh. Maybe if I build my own kernel for the system without the serialmonkey module.

This discussion is closed to new replies.