Discussion Locked

World and dog to be IT pros

0 helpful
36 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Apologises in advance if this has been asked before, or just that no-one is interested, but this is my first post so here goes...

Why is it that every man and his dog believe that because they have a PC in their house that they have what it takes to be an IT professional?

For example a client is currently setting up a new environment and is constantly asking advice, and then ignoring it.

The latest trick is that because he has a server configured to do X, he can build another server that also does X. Even though he paid someone else to build the server and doesn't seem to have a clue how it actually works.

So on this logic I need to ask:
Does owning a chemistry set mean I can work for a pharmaceutical company?

36 replies

by jamesrl

A good business relationship has benefits for both sides.

Unless you enjoy cleaning up other people's mess, then thank him and move on.

Some IT pros will progress from someone with their own home computer to an "IT Professional". I only took one half course in computing 25 years ago in a language no one uses anymore. I learned most through job experience and home experience. No certs.

That doesn't mean your current client will.

James

by waity85

unfortunately if salesman and management can make money from us clearing up other peoples mess then guess what we end up doing? :-(

by jdclyde

This client does not want you to tell him how to do something, he wants you to stroke off his ego by agreeing that what he wants to do is correct.

Are you getting paid for this advice? If not, stop giving it.

When someone goes off on a project, the FIRST thing I do is make a list of the PROBLEMS with that project. THEN I make another list of the good that can come from it. I then present both and keep copies, stating which route I would take, and why. When the bad things happen in a project that you advices agaisnt, no one can hold it against you. (just don't insult people by rubbing their noses in it later).

As for duplicating a server. If you have a working example, it is much easier than if you had to do it from scratch. We will have a "expert" do a project if it is something we are new to. But we then use that as our template from then on.

Don't take your clients wish to do things for himself personally. Just don't spend time for FREE on projects your not going to be doing.

by jdclyde

done that! ;\

Had SEVERAL projects where I was the bump on the log saying "this will happen, this will happen, and this will happen". A year later, I had to go in and fix things because this, this and this ALL happened and the project what a failure. (yes, the people that pushed for it tried so hard to cover the failures, which is the only reason it lasted a year!)

I have learned at work and in my life, to allow people to be wrong. Time will prove me right, EVERYTIME! :D B-)

by leee

Waity, I don't know why. All I know is, a significant number of PCs out there come bundled with an automatic leap of logic that endows the owner with skills that real pros like you spend years honing. (Same thing with would-be graphic designers, photographers, videographers...)

My favorite is when a client asks you for an estimate, then chokes on it. (This is usually the case in smaller markets, where the price has already been reduced to accommodate these cheapskates, lest we 'experts' get paid at all.) They then say, 'My nephew can do that for $25.' At which point, your response should be, 'Then hire your nephew.'

Trust me, they'll learn when the low bid/nephew screws it up, and will be happy to pay you whatever you ask, and then that $25 will have become the most expensive $25 they've ever spent.

So, bottom line: Stop giving free advice. If you start charging for it, your 'client' will eventually turn to you when it dawns on him that he isn't an expert 'just because.'

by jdclyde

You would not believe how many horrible web sites are out there NOW, or messed up networks NOW because they DID let nephew do it.

They see it works and think it is GREAT! Why? They don't know the difference. They don't KNOW how bad it is until someone holds up the full lenght mirror to them and says, "did you really mean to show up in public dressed like THAT?"

I now get FREE auto car for cleaning up behind someone else. All I EVER pay is parts at COST. They in return get free support, but not on an "on call" basis. They call and I am there in a day or three.

by tony hopkinson

people with some knowledge and naff all experience is very lucrative.

Apparently there are sound business reasons for paying me to clear up after them instead of hiring me in the first place. I'm just a tech though, I don't understand the high brow business stuff.

by shellbot

OMG..if hear my:
cousin
nephew
uncle
friend
sister

one more sh@gging time...last week i slipped up and said stuff in a meeting which could have been disasterous for me, but kind of worked out in the end..*wipes brow..whew*
"Well, my nephew works in IT, he does this, and he's and expert, and he gets paid this much per day, so i think we should get him do the review and he can make all the recamendations, we might even be able to get him to do some of the work for a reduced rate"
(this was gettng to be a tedious meeting, me being the only "tech" there, so over an hour listening to "well,can't the computer ")
my response:
"well, if you had paid a professional project manager or consultant some good money for a couple days work, instead of hiring your nephew to come up with a few requirement "ideas" to give to the development company, we wouldn't be in the mess we are now and that 2 grand spent then would have saved us about 40 grand now, PLUS all the hard work trying to fix it along the way"

a silence decended..my previous manager not happy, as it was her nephew.. BUT everyone else agreed and said that using family was not the way to go as it had not initially worked anyways. Then the most senior person there thanked me for speaking up about it..*phew* i could have made things very rough for myself..i'm sure i'll get a bit of flack later..but whatever :)

by jdclyde

It doesn't ruffle my feathers one bit, because it takes much longer to straighten out a mess than it does to do it right the first time.

The added bonus, the are thankful as they hand that bigger check to you than if you would have done it right for them in the first place. ;\

"Maybe just anybody CAN'T do this?"

by tony hopkinson

we are just glorified clerks and labourers. Two a penny.

Take one correspondance course get a career in IT, saw it on the telly last week.

by waity85

All the advice pretty much confirmed what I thought however this leaves me with a couple more problems.

How do you go about saying 'no' without get the clients backup?
This seems to be especially tough for me as, as part of the clients contract, they get 'support', this is intended as (basic) help when initially setting up their network for the first time, or rebooting a machine to save them having to gain access to the server. Some clients however keep pushing to see how far we'll stretch.

This problem has been sorted out with one troublesome client, but only after Management made them take out an extra support contract after we had been doing their day-to-day admin tasks for a month.

by dmambo

IT folks are not the only intelligent people in the world. I know this will shock many of you, but some people out there can actually think!!

Is it possible to work with the client to develop a plan for that 2nd installation and to divide the tasks between those the he can do after observing it done once, and those things that he'd better have support on-site for?

Before I was the IT guy, I worked with a vendor to set up the initial network in our plant. It was a small LAN with a single NT server and about a dozen clients. Things changed, our needs grew, and I was able to work with this same guy, under his supervision in a way, to expand that initial network significantly. Most of his time was put in over the phone. It worked for him, and it worked for us. Now, several years later, I am the wizard that you all know today! ;)

As far as the unending support goes, your contract should specify a number of support hours or calls to be included for the initial fee. Others are billed at normal rates.

by jdclyde

We do the same thing. If there is new technology that we need to put in place, we hire someone to do the first location. We watch and take notes. We then copy what he did for the other three locations.

There is nothing wrong with this.

BUT that for the most part does not sound like what waity is describing. Except for the server, the biggest complaint seems to be that they customer gets recommendations and then runs off and does what he wanted to do in the first place. I have seen this many times, and it is someone that is just looking for you to validate what they are saying, not tell them something different.

Wizard? You forgot "modest" too! :D

by jdclyde

when you create this contract, it should be made clear what the terms of it are.

What is covered, and for how long.

It is only when a customer is allowed to expect more either by a misunderstanding, or being misled by a sales rat promising the moon so he can get his commission.

Full fill your part of the signed agreement, and have your manager clear up any misunderstandings.

Don't take them wanting to do something for themselves as a personal insult.

by waity85

That is the most common phrase to come out of a salesmans mouth at the moment. So anything after the contract is signed is generally left to engineering department. Usually without any formal, written description of what is required or should be provided.

I common example of this was a customer ringing to inform is that they had lost connectivity. After several minutes solution was found, so we rang customer.

"Yep, its your firewall, you may want to fix that."

"But you manage our firewall, whats broken?"

After a quick call to the salesman, "yeah we manage they firewall for them. Did I not tell you?"

So this really makes life interesting. In terms of fulfilling the signed agreement. Just about every contract is standard with the usual stuff the company provides plus 'support'. Definitive isn't it?

While I'm complaining, did I also mention that customers have 24/7 access to engineers, and we're meant to be able to get to work within roughly 20minutes?

I didn't take the client wanting to do the work himself as an insult. I enjoy helping people as much as possible (only reason I've managed to put up with this so long). But the guy is clearly in over his head, and I just can't understand why he ^wants^ to do it himself. Especially not when its business critical.

by jdclyde

made an enemy.

CYA and good luck! Never a good position to be in, and doing your job well NOW did mean you had to step on his toes, but he had it coming from the sounds of it.

I have learned to try to keep a low profile when it comes to other peoples work when possible. That didn't sound possible. ;\

by shellbot

do what i did..it just came out..this manager was head of a "committee" that spearheaded the database & application development..not one tech in that group might i add. that was 2 years ago..she has cost the company a lot of money / manhours and has been given a "promotion" to another office...that meant she had not time to deal with the database and has had to back away from the majority of dealings with it..
so its all cool..i only have to see her once a month and she seems to have gotten over it already (she has short memory..it was great when i didn't get work done..she forgot she even asked me to do it)

but ya..not a smart thing on my part, have to learn how to control myself :)

by osumiller

Promote them....
This is done all the time in large organizations. If someone is doing damage in their current place and role, promote them out so that they can't deal with it anymore.

I never have really understood this from a business standpoint, but I really like it when I am working for/with the person who is messing up. At least it gets them out of the way.

by dmambo

Now maybe I'm wrong and the TR censors will disable my account for posting that in the title, but I'd bet that "shagging" will fly right by their filters.

Regarding the nephews, any manager who recommends family for outside work should be ashamed. The conflict is just too great.

shagging, SHAGGING, shagging....see, they're all there!

by shellbot

i have to disguise it on this side of the world so just a habit now...won't go through our email filters :)

well..lets just say the manager in question is not regarded as highly as others..

by jdclyde

It all depends.

I work for a family owned business, and it can work out very well.

The problem isn't using family, it is failing to hold family to the same standards as anyone else.

I have seen two family members let go in the last five years because they just weren't working out, and one was in IT for a while. Talk about no eye for detail or pride in your work! Glad to see that one gone!

by dmambo

It's called nepotism, and it's caused a lot of problems for politicians and managers, as it should.

Family-owned is one thing, the rest of the world is quite another. It never looks good to the rank and file.

But in the case you described, it's good that the boss had the cojones to make the call. Impossible to do without pissing off some family members.

by waity85

In theory working with family should work, I think. Providing everyone can keep it purely professional. (Not sure that is actually do-able though...)

But at the same time I have seen many, many, MANY arguements between family as a fault out at work.

If you have an 'heated discussion' with someone at work you can just leave them to it and cool off. What can you do when its your nephew, brother, father, wife?

Theres got to be a reason someone coined the phrase:
"Never do business with family"

by jdclyde

Many companies have a policy that even forbids you working in the same department as a family member. If you marry someone, one of you has to leave or transfer. This is assuming you are ALLOWED to date inner office in the first place.

I would not like corporate IT nearly as much as I do the family business. I know the top owner on a first name basis and have been to his place working on his systems as I am the one he trusts to do the work. More than once he has given me a key and had me get things working while he was off and running.

Trust is a good thing. All on the company dime, because he works from his home office half the time. (bad leg/hip so he doesn't get around well anymore) but is still very active in the company.

by hal 9000

Originally I came from the Big End of Town and if the company involved didn't need 3 floors of Mainframes and several thousand Workstations they where ignored by the Big Boys.

This meant that the smaller companies where virtually on their own and it's only fairly recently that people have realized that there is a Profitable Market in Small to Medium Business and they then wonder why they are not snapped up to serve this market.

Most of these people had to [b]Make Do with what they could get[/b] and just get by in the process so they became self reliant even if they are doing things all wrong and the expensive way they are used to doing it themselves as previously they didn't have any option as the Big End of Town Laughed at them and refused to offer any service.

I saw this personally and tried to help as much as possible but even then I was limited in what I could and could not do for this side of the business.

About 10 years ago now I walked away from the Big Boys and started playing with the Small to Medium Market who generally speaking approve of my methods but will still do things their own way as they are so used to doing it this way and will then call me in to fix up the problems that they have created.

Sometimes I can short Circuit the procedure and sometimes I can't and I just have to live with the results but things are getting better as over time when new hardware is purchased I explain why it is wrong or too expensive to run even though the Sales Person told them it was exactly what they needed. Things Like Multi Function Devices being used as Network Printers because you can scan from them but what isn't told is that you are limited to the desktop where the unit is to scan and generally you can provide a scanner and printer to the same costs that are both better and cheaper to use but of course they do take up more desk space.

The one that I really liked was a brand new Bubble Jet printer running out of Red Ink after 1.5 days and it required a expensive Color Cartridge even though there was plenty of Yellow and Blue left and they where effectively throwing away a half full cartridge. When I told them the costs involved in a unit with separate Ink Tanks they where stunned as they just didn't know that these units existed let alone have any sales person explain the difference and this was really a High Volume Printer that was going to be producing well over 5,000 color pages per month and what they saved on the original purchase was more than made up within 2 - 3 weeks with replacement ink cartridges.

Really they should have had a Corporate Color Laser Printer but that option wasn't offered to them.

Now I find that I have to work with these people and eventually I get my way and I end up saving them money and making a good name for myself along the way. If I spend a few hours answering silly questions at first I don't really mind as I know that eventually they will get the message and ask me to setup things properly and pay me to do it properly!

Currently there is a very hard time involved in dealing with small to medium business as they have had to fend for themselves for so long and it's only now that people in the IT Sector are beginning to Realize that there is a good living to be made from that area particularly with the really small companies who can not justify having a full time IT staff member on hand. If I can I fix things remotely I do and if a Service Call is required they pay me from the time I leave Base until I return and so far no one has complained.

But the ones that get me are really the non IT related jobs like [b]How do I Download Music for My I Pod?[/b] and things like that which are really nothing more than play toys for the owners of the business. One of the best ones was reprogramming a GPS to work properly in Europe from AU and the owner just had to try it out after the European Maps had been loaded and went out to his car plugged the thing in and requested a direct route from his work to some destination in Europe. I had already told him that it wouldn't work and at best it could only give him a distance reading to where he wanted to go but that wasn't good enough so I had to stand outside in the Hot Sun and wait till the unit failed and then I asked him [b]Exactly How do you Plan to Drive there from Here? I know that you're Jag is a great car but I didn't realize that it could travel underwater and there are no roads to let the GPS tell how to get out of AU onto the Sub Continent and then into Europe.[/b] At that stage he realized just how silly his request had been but was none the less impressed that the unit could tell him exactly how far he would have to travel to get to his requested destination.

I then took him back inside and set the starting point from the airport where he would arrive and the way points and he was as happy as a [b]Pig In Mud[/b] and when he returned he just had to call me and congratulate me for doing such a great job for him as he never missed a single place that he wanted to go and even better was always on time for meetings.

By doing things like this I get asked what Hardware that they need and eventually they not only ask advice that they pay for but get me to supply the Hardware that I gave to them at reduced rates just to get the business and because I'm supplying better hardware I don't have to return for Hardware related faults.

Remember that it's only been sometime in the last 18 months that MS has got the idea that Servers are required by Small Business previously they didn't address this area of the market and nor did most IT people.

Col

by waity85

As I've had to try and re-clarify the point of clients wanting to do things for themselves several times, I think I possibly was clear enough in my initial post.

The clients that I'm curious about aren't trying to handle the IT requirements of their company. They are setting up as service providers to other companies. I just can't see the logic behind trying to provide a service in a field where you have limit abilty yourself.

Although thinking about it judging by their cars maybe I'm the fool and not them?

by hal 9000

They Network and if someone has got something to work everyone of his business associates thinks that He/She is an [b]Expert who can help them.[/b] When the truth of the matter is that they generally just fluked the solution and even then went about it the expensive way as they knew no better and had no one to tell them differently.

I now get asked to fix the Electronics in Heavy Earth Moving Equipment which I know absolutely nothing at all about but because I can setup their network they think that I know everything relating to anything electronic. :^0

It got a bit nasty a little over a year ago as I was standing beside a Excavator with my MB sitting on a track with the diagnostic tools plugged in and the thing took off all by itself and crushed my NB. :(

But they didn't hesitate to pay for a replacement one and I was insistent that I knew absolutely nothing about the equipment but as their Fitter didn't have a NB to plug into the unit I was [b]Volunteered[/b] to help out. Now if only they had told me what the problem was I wouldn't have sat the NB on the track. :^0

Col

by jdclyde

He might fancy himself a tech. People that don't do it full time seem to think it is more fun than it really is.

He might enjoy playing with the toys.

He might be too cheap to pay for any more support than he has to.

Worst case and he destroys things, that is why he has a "catch-all" contract for YOUR support! :D

Your a 24/7 shop? Poor you. I am out the door and they are unable to contact me for anything until I walk through the door the next day. Breaks my heart! B-)

No company phone for this one! :p

by waity85

I love being a tech and 'playing' all day. I know you probably wouldn't think it considering the number of gripes I've had today. But then I'm still young, fresh and idealist (and not looking forward to the burnout that seems to be commonplace)

As for 24/7, I fancy getting away from that part of the job as soon as possible. It just doesn't leave enough time to play with *MY* toys and projects.

by hal 9000

Just [b]AIN'T GOING TO HAPPEN![/b]

I've been trying for well over 20 years and if anything things have got worse as now I've gone from the IT Manager to owning my own business with 10 Techs working for me and I'm now on call 36/85 per day. :D

I've got to pay others to play with my Play Toys well restore them anyway as I have very little time left to do any work myself thought I do try to get a few hours per year. And I'm trying to remember what a [b]Holiday[/b] is though I did get 2 weeks off in 2001 when I dropped a Mercedes on myself and nearly managed to kill myself but even then my generous staff visited me in Hospital and brought along a NB and Ceil Phone Adapter so I could download their e-mail and answer their questions and do anything else that was required. The nursing staff just couldn't understand why I had 3 Cell Phones beside me. :^0 But on the up side when I wanted copies of the pictures that they took of me for the medical journals I had all the necessary hardware on hand to directly interface with their system and get my pictures. :D

Col

by jdclyde

but it is only after a lot of hard work that it really becomes fun, by learning all the hows and whys.

I personally don't "work" with computers.
I get paid to play with all the cool toys. :D

But there IS stress involved that isn't for a home user when you can't get that widget to work. Playing with your own system at home, you don't have an angry end user glaring at you the whole time as if it were your fault that they broke the system. B-)

by oz_media

Get on ething straight, if people own something these days, they are masters of it too.

Buy a sports car and become a rally driver (on the city streets until you and several others are dead).

Own a PC, become a tech everyone else is, why not me? The issue is that people feel because they can learn something simple like how to setup and email account and then show someone else to do it, that they know it inside out.

I used to help a guy, okay he's actually sorta slow due to an accident so I had more patience with him, with his PC all the time, and I mean daily (calls, visits etc.).

He would hopver around while i was working on his PC and it drove me nuts because I knew whatever I did, he woul dtry it himself as soon as I left. If it didn't work, he would call a fe wother friends without a clue and try to fix it, because he wouldn't want to call me by then, and I would end up patching all of their mistakes too.

If I reformatted and reinstalled his OS, he woul ddo the same as soon as I left, but would fail miserably at getting the right drivers and such so it would be all screwed up.

Just don't help fools, they will help themselves. Let some other new admin deal with them, some other 'MASTER because he owns a PC' can help them. Don't waste your time.

by mjd420nova

But can they walk the walk?? I've had to train
and breakin new employees, and it can and truly
a LIVING HELL. How these people managed to get
a degree or certification is beyond me. And the
gall of those who attempt to mooch skills from
others and try to take credit. I keep my crews
divided into two catagories-- Techs and gorrillas
No digs or disrespect to those who don't have
but the rudimentary skills, like identifing
a monitor, a PC, a printer, but if you can't
do the work I'm not gonna make that part of your
job. Can you handle simple instructions and find
this unit in this room in this building??
Big enough to do the lifting but gentle enough
to handle the equipment with care.

by nazil dsouza

......... let me ask you one question ? why are human beings not at all happy with whatever they have. It does not matter how rich and flamboyant you are....... you still have that tendency to make some extra bucks dont you ? well, all through the evolution of mankind the tendency to get someting more than what others have is common to our intellectual. So its no good that he stops doing that. And Finally when he does not succeed its time to wait for some help........

by craig herberg

Perhaps you should direct your client to http://techwoes.com/ for assistance. According to one testimonial on the site:
-------
" Like everybody else, I have been confounded by computer problems. Thanks to you and your tips and tricks, I am now an IT guru, and I solve other people's tech woes. You're awesome! "

Michael Rosoft
-------
If nothing else, you and your client should have a good laugh.

Craig Herberg

This discussion is closed to new replies.