Question Locked

XP Movie Maker vs Vista Movie Maker

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I realize Windows Movie Maker is not the greatest choice for rendering video, but for now it is all I have.

Here is my problem: Rendered a video into XP Movie Maker then tried to import it to Vista Movie Maker. Vista reports a codec is required to be downloaded before said video can be imported.

First, why would Vista need a required codec that XP has, apparently native? Both machines have all current updates.

Second, was referred to Codecs.com by HP to download a BETA version which would remove all apple components from machine. Not acceptable as I use iTunes for music and activation of iPhones online.

Does anyone have an answer that is not destructive?

3 replies

by oh smeg

Don't use Vista to attempt any Video Editing that was originally performed on a XP Machine.

Or if you absolutely have to use this on a Vista Machine use a different machine to do your I Tunes and I Phone applications with. As far as I know there are still major incompatibilities between Vista and numerous other Applications.

If you must use Vista and only have the 1 machine you could Dual Boot to different installs of Vista and have 1 with the Apple Software and 1 without. That would remain legit with M$ Licensing and be a temp cure for your current problem.

As to why Vista lacks things that XP has you need to remember that Vista isn't an Upgrade of XP but a completely new product which works differently to XP so they really are not compatible in many ways.

Col

by thumbsup2

Computers purchased from various manufacturers don't have a full version of the OS installed on them. You get a watered down copy of the OS plus preloaded crapware which helps them pay for the system.

If a specific codec is required, search first at Microsoft, then the internet for a free one. They're all over the place.

Also, what type of file did the XP Movie Maker create? If it's the right file type, you wouldn't need to IMPORT it, just open it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.