Discussion Locked

Your medical records on line

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

How do you feel about your medical records being computerized and going on line? Do you view it as good or bad?

Are you afraid of who would have access to it?

Are you afraid that the insurance companies would have total access to it and what that would mean?

10 replies

by mjd420nova

I don't think that either of these two are a very good idea. We've already seen where a credit history will get you, now they want to add medical history too? I don't think so, not for me. I have a lousy cedit history because I don't have any credit cards and haven't since '91. Does that mean a bad risk? My medical history is non-existant as I haven't been sick or needed medical attention since '82. Does that also make me a bad risk of health insurance? The less personal information about me that is available online the better I like it and intend to keep it that way. If someone wants to know about me by going online and finding nothing then maybe they need to come and see me and get the real story, not some convoluted, distorted or contrived details compiled by a database that is totally lacking in any details whatsoever.

by kino.mondesir

While I know their are benefits from having your medical information completely accessible I can agree that their are security concerns around.

Does that mean we do not do it, absolutely not. What it does mean is that we have to come up with ways for securing this new system. Smart IT professionals leverage the advantages that new features bring with security concerns.

What I propose is that professionals should wait until a standard is developed for security before jumping into the cloud. I have read so articles regarding this and collective wisdom says that the major drawback to using the cloud is lack of control over your information. I can totally agree with that.

by dr dij

and we don't seem to be having major problems.

most hospitals are largely computerized.
larger practices with multiple doctors are also more computerized.

small practices with just one or a couple doctors are the least computerized.

what we SHOULD fear is ONE MASSIVE DATABANK of health records. britain's health records have had breaches for example.

by dr dij

I didn't find a perm job with eye doc after interning with him for 3 months so I'll have to change that.

I am still working in the medical industry. the job has weird hours (I don't get to watch tv primetime) but is incredibly interesting with lots of cool gear.

I did take foam tho and create a model, color with watercolors and markers, of the eyeball and a separate slice of the retina, which is like the CCD chip in a camera.

by robo_dev

If I goto my health insurance company website and logon, there are all my medical bills for the past five years.

While there is less detail in that information, the big things are there.

For example, if there are visits to heart specialists and prescriptions for a blood-pressure medicine, obviously I have some heart issues.

The insurance company has, effectively, about 90% of my medical records, since they pay claims based on office/hospital visits, prescriptions filled, etc.

The big issue, obviously, is an insurance company refusing to offer coverage based on pre-existing conditions.

Here the medical insurance companies should do what the auto insurance companies do, an 'assigned high-risk pool'.

The assigned-risk pool for car insurance says that every insurance company must offer coverage to a a certain number of high-risk drivers, based on the amount of business they do in a given state. Thus the worst multiple-DUI offender is able to get insurance, since the insurance companies are forced to take them in.

The bigger potential issue would be if a prospective employer finds out that a job candidate has an expensive pre-existing condition. If the company had access to medical data, they could decide not to hire an individual to save on their health benefits costs.

by jamesrl

While we may hava e anationally funded system, its run by the provinces.

One province has already done this, others are in the works.

We don't have private insurance for medical (except dental etc) so I am not so much worried about insurance companies having access, though I would if I were in the US.

I am of course worried about security in general.

But the idea that a doctor in an ER, who I don't know, who can't ask me questions because I am unconscious, can access my records and get my entire history quickly, without paperwork or phone calls sounds really valuable. It could be lifesaving.

James

by robo_dev

or maybe a 8gig USB jump drive surgically implanted in the arm.

The doctor just reads the RFID data, or plugs that mini-usb cable into my arm, and he's got all the data.

Even better, ambulances would have a USB-cable, and they could instantly get your medical data right on the stretcher!

The RFID thing is already being done.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microchip_implant_%28human%29

by jamesrl

The data becomes corrupted
The encryption gets cracked
You run out of room and need more space?

Seems like you might be in and out of the doctors office regularly.

And the whole point of the thing is to get all the disparate data sources into one big database. Who is going to load all of that onto a chip, the family doctor?

I'd prefer the central server idea, where at least there is one point of entry to secure, and all of the data from all of the doctors and hospitals can combine to allwo the whole picture to be seen.

James

by robo_dev

Ideally you have the data in two places...both on the central server, and on your person.

For example, many people wear medical alert bracelets or carry organ-donor cards in their wallet.

If nothing else, give me a bardcoded card with all my info on it, and when I go to a new doctor, scan all my data off my card. I HATE filling in the ten page 'new patient data form' at the doctor's office.

This discussion is closed to new replies.