Discussion Locked

100% Spyware free for 2 years and counting...

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I recently spoke to a friend of mine who said that she was tired of Spyware, Ads, what have you, attacking her desktops, and having to format the pc over and over every two months.

I explained to her how I stopped it on my pc. A long time ago, when the dark ages ruled, ok it was 2003, I let Spyware win. That's right, I let it take over my pc and fill my screen with nothing but popups, banners, ads. Then I wiped all of them out without losing any sensitive data. No it wasn't magic(I know cause I tried that too). I was on a different partition.

Most of you know that you can partition your hard drive for different os systems, different uses, and misc. Those who do not need to get their hands on the neighborhood techie, or just google "how to partition your computer". So I created a partition where I install any and all questionable applications, and other misc applications you know you shouldn't be installing anyways.

There is no way to 100% verify if a software application/webpage/webpage app will install spyware on your pc, and close to impossible to tell someone to check every single questionable application for spyware/malware/etx. With a different partition you can install all the applications you want, even the ones with spyware, to get your work done or surf, or whatever. You can also have more then two partitions if you need it, games, media, backup, spyware etx.
And if you start seeing a lot of ads on that partition then just wipe or reinstall your OS on that spyware partition.

Once partitioned just restart your pc and select the partition you want. It really is as simple as that. You have one partition where you can install all the applications you want, and the other where you log in, check email, buy stuff, music, online without worrying about spyware taking up your screen. But there are a few things you need to watch out for.

1) On your spyware partition(Partition B), never log in to your main/personal/private email account, create a separate account for email, but do not log in to an account that includes your private info, or any account that requires you to type your password.
2) Never buy anything on your Partition B, this is kind of like the first part, except in this case it also includes private information, like credit cards, ss#, and other information that you dont want a spyware knowing(unless you really like that one particular spyware that's been eyeing you).
3) Always remember that when you are on this partition that you should treat it as if someone is spying on you. Spyware --- Spying on you, get it(nevermind).
4) If you can try to keep parition B free from viruses, spyware, make sure you have a firewall, and if none of that works you can always format it because your main / sensitive data is not located on this partition.
5) Remember this only works if you install suspicious applications, webpage components, misc on the spyware partition. You can share data between the two partitions, but try to scan it for viruses with an up-to-date virus scanner before you do.
6) If you really really want to stop spyware, buy another pc. Use one pc for installing application that you trust, and the second pc for when you're not sure.

This can also work by keeping your email free of viruses, spam, and other annoying emails. Create an email account for personal/family/ecommerce sites, and another email account for sites that you dont trust.

Does it work? The partition I'm on right now hasn't seen a SINGLE ad/popup in almost 2 Years.

Enjoy.

23 replies

by apotheon

These days, I couldn't imagine wanting to do something like that.

I just run a user environment that isn't really vulnerable to all that crap. I have a couple email addresses that are my spam-magnets, and others that aren't, but I don't set up multiple OS installs with some for "secure" and "stable", and others for "hosed".

You said "[i]There is no way to 100% verify if a software application/webpage/webpage app will install spyware on your pc[/i]" and I'm here to tell you you're wrong. There is a way. You do it by reading the source code.

If you can't, you might be using the wrong software.

If you don't have the time . . . well, I sympathize, but it doesn't change the factual accuracy of my statement that there is a way to do it. Luckily, with the number of other people reading source code to determine its relative security, I don't have to read all application source code to be [i]reasonably[/i] sure that the software I run is all free of spyware and adware. That's one of the beauties of open source software.

I, too, am 100% spyware free, and not just on designated partitions: on ALL partitions of all computers I run. Even if I find myself running a closed-source system here again at some point, I think I'll be able to keep it spyware free, because I'll avoid using it for any activities that might collect spyware (such as touching the Internet). Where software with closed source is concerned, I tend to subscribe to the old saw that "only an unplugged computer is a truly secure computer".

by netlyte

I completely disagree, but then again that's not new, seeing as how this is a discussion form.

But this time I have a good reason. I say this because I can't imagine going through lines and lines of source code everytime I want to install an application.

I would rather spend the 1 to 2 hours that it takes out of 2 years to set up a partition and never have to worry about rouge applications.

But you know what if reading source code works for you, then more power to you because from the look of things it doesn't look like spyware's going to go away anytime soon. How many source code lines are you planning on reading before you actually think of this idea with an open mind.

I've even read in articles that more and more companies already are or thinking about advertising through spyware apps.

As for Ludicrouss reply, I'm not going to wait until each software provides disclosure form from vendors and web sites because even the ones that do include their disclosures write in a legal format that not everyone can understand. That's the sole purpose. To make it harder on you to decipher their "full disclosure", and get you to click on the I Agree button.

As I said earlier It's actually the opposite, spyware has gained so much power that real companies are considering advertising through spyware companies.

As for having multiple partitions being much more to manage, no. It isn't. It's easy, and it's getting easier and easier. Plus you dont have to be an engineer to be able to fix problems for users. If a user is smart enough, as you mentioned to pay for and then install some sort of antispyware then they can create a partition just as easily.

Best of Luck on staying spyware free.

Later.

by apotheon

Check again what I said.

I said that it is possible to be 100% sure by reading the source code for everything you install. I didn't say that's what I do. That would be prohibitively time-consuming.

Check again what I said about trusting in the statistical likelihoods provided by the hundreds, or even thousands, of other people reading through source code of what I use -- people who aren't paid by a software vendor and prohibited from telling anyone except the boss when something untoward is found.

by richard

nothing personal, but you must be somoking something. I don't have popups and spyware. I feel for those who aren't technical enough to handle the challenge and can not pay to have it done. The cost is a real burden to an individual and I don't see a knowledgeable engineer wanting to spend his time on such problems for a price most of us want to pay.
What will happen if poor souls listen to this advice is that they will have even more to manage and have an even bigger mess.
That is why we need to require full disclosure from software vendors and web sites. No one has the right to do what they want to your computer and we need to enforce it. If we fine the enough to bring the to the brink of bankruptcy and remove all financial gain, the problem will become much smaller. To Aphotheon I say, you are correct, but I don't thenk that everyone who wants to use a computer should have to learn code. Most who drive a car can't fix it, even many who think they can :-).
The fact is we have a desktop OS monopoly by a very shoddy corporation using a very poor architecture. The last thing I would ever do is connect a windows computer directly to the internet, the next to last thing is a special one or special install to let others distroy and consume my time and resources.

by netlyte

Check again what you said. Now my question is are you on crack. You don't think the readers on this post noticed that you edited your post so that you could say "Chekc again what I said". hahahahah.

No what you had written on there was different earlier.

So your edited post now says that using hundreds or even thousands of other people reading through source code. That may well be, but can you trust every single one of those people. How do you know that one of them is not a spyware creator.

This doesn't mean that reading code isn't effective, but doing a different partition gives ME the choice and freedom to not worry on relying on others to make sure that the application is free of malware and misc.

I'll stick with my partitions and for the sake of all those who use opensource everywhere I hope you don't ever find yourself in a situation where someone may have knowingly installed or allowed spyware to get through opensource.

later.

by apotheon

Do you know how to count? Two comes before three. I posted my message about going back to check what I had previously posted on the third of the month. I edited a typo in my previous post on the second of the month. Unless you credit me with being able to travel back in time to edit the post before I decided it needed to be edited, you're way out in left field and possibly need your head checked by a professional.

In point of fact, it said all that in the first place, before you posted a response. Moron.

I don't have to trust every single one of the people who has looked at the source code, dumbass. I just have to trust that of the hundreds or thousands who might have looked at the source code of one application, at least some of them are honest and diligent enough to tell someone about what they've seen. In fact, you'd be "lucky" to find as much as a single percentage point of people with any vested interest in keeping vulnerabilities in the source code. Are you too blind to see that there's no benefit in not reporting a problem for most people? I'd rather have secure software than software that has trojan-like vulnerabilities being used by someone else. If one of those people reading the source code is a spyware creator, I'm pretty sure he doesn't have the hundreds of thousands of dollars necessary to bribe all the rest of them, to say nothing of the fact that some just wouldn't be bribable.

You clearly have zero understanding of how the open source development model works. None. Period. Jackass.

I wouldn't be nearly this harsh on you if you hadn't just tried to paint me as some kind of deceptive manipulator of text for purposes of lying to "win" some imaginary damned contest with you, ya simpering, willfully ignorant, unregenerate nematode. Piss off.

NOTE: I just edited a typo, removing an extraneous letter S from a word, shitheel. Don't later try to claim that on the eighth of January I came back here to the second of December to edit this thing for some obscure reason. Nincompoop.

by jmgarvin

Rather than take the approach that the USER is doing something wrong, why not take the approach that MS is doing something wrong by not creating a secure OS.

Sure, I can spend MY time securing an OS that should have been secured by the manufacturer.

Until MS is hold accountable for their POS (and that doesn't mean point of sale folks), then we will keep getting the same ol' run around.

by netlyte

It's true that MS holds some of responsibility for not creating a secure OS but there's only so much that an operating system can do for security.

If a user decides to install an application that contains spyware then it's not that easy for OS to figure that hey this is not secure, because the OS will treat it just like any other ordinary application.

The main way that I see is if the companies that advertise using malware / spyware apps are held accountable for their actions. But that's not easy either, they can always deny it, and then again a spyware creator can create an ad claiming to be for a company just to tarnish their corporate image.

There are some good signs such as the new IE 7, which goes a step further then previous versions in identifying harmful websites, and also their acquisition of GIANT company which created AntiSpyware, currently free beta version from Microsoft. It was good at removing a majority of spyware / adware apps and it will be released, as Shield or some other name from MS.

by tony hopkinson

acquired an adware company. Course they only did that to investigate how adware works.

Oh look a flying pig

IE7 is still integrated into the OS, MS is still welded to client side execution of foreign code and there is still no partitioning of user vs kernel space in windows. Another unfortunate combination that suggests to me IE7 will end up where IE6 is now, never explicitly run on my PCs.
Adding tabbed browsing and integrating windows security software which is p1ss poor anyway, does n't do anything for me.

by halibut

We can blame MS for the insecure OS but if the spyware company wanted to they could spend the time to create a linux version, but the majority of Linux users know what they are doing, where the majority of windows users don't.

I can just imagine as Linux vendors make the desktop OS more and more stupified and popular for the regular user, spyware, malware will increase. Especially with vendors like Linspire that give the user Root access.

The other issue will be with the modular kernel that linux has, the malicious software could much more deadly. Installing a rootkit or adding a kernel kit where Winblows doesn't have that issue.

The point I am trying to make here is that if the user of the system doesn't click the ad that gives us a "free iPod" over half of the spyware wouldn't be an issue.

BTW I have been 98% spyware free for a number of years now. (I have kids so education is vital to keeping that number so high) So I keep programs like spybot S&D installed to assist in keeping the tracking cookies and the like down to a minimum.

my $.02 CDN

by apotheon

"[i]if the spyware company wanted to they could spend the time to create a linux version[/i]"

Er, sure they could, but it wouldn't work. Spyware needs to be running to do anything, and it requires root access for effective installation in addition to needing to be run by the user. Linux systems don't autorun code, and implement strict privilege separation: so much for that.

"[i]I can just imagine as Linux vendors make the desktop OS more and more stupified and popular for the regular user, spyware, malware will increase.[/i]"

There is some danger of that with some distributions. Ubuntu is one in particular that I see angling in a dangerous direction that way. I don't know much about Linspire configuration under the hood, but if it's granting normal users root permissions, it's definitely a problem.

Any modern end-user OS can be intentionally configured to be unsecure, including Linux. I don't see that being a problem for most distributions.

"[i]The other issue will be with the modular kernel that linux has, the malicious software could much more deadly.[/i]"

What?! What the heck does that mean? Are you just making stuff up as you go, using terms you overheard in dinner conversation to make it sound more authoritative? How does a modular kernel in any way make malware "much more deadly"?

by jaqui

and more effective method:

use an os that doesn't have adware and spyware problems.
use browsers that will actually kill popups.

which means, do not use anything from ms.

by tracy_anne

That's an awful lot of work.

I don't want to have to spend time worrying about wether I'm in the right partition, or wether I should install here, or open my email here, or which account to use, or if it's safe to use my password.

I just want to use my computer, that'a what I got it for, and not worry about spyware and adware or even how to stop it. I certainly didn't get it to spend all my time making sure I'm in the right patition, and if I can open my email here etc.

If there is one thing my partner and I agree on (she's been using computers for 18 months, and I for 25 years, as a professional developer), and that is that this is way too much work.

There really has to be a better way.

by brichpmr9

is simple...use a Mac.....no spyware, worms, trojans or viruses in the wild. Simply run NAV 10 on the Mac to catch any Windows junk that could harm your PC-using buddies...it's all good :-)

by apotheon

It's not just using a Mac that is a better way. It's using anything other than Windows.

by stargazerr

Get rid of MS ...

Is it just me or do we keep landing up in MS versus any other OS a tad to often ??

Oh Well .. MS deserves it

]:)

by alangeek

Just use a Knoppix live CD.

A.) It's not MS. (only half kidding)
B.) It's Linux, so generally much less susceptible.
C.) It's running from a CD, so you can't clobber it anyway! (Can't touch this - Hammer time!)

This one's so simple that I'm gonna have my dad use it since he's always trashing out their computer by going to the wrong places. It'll recognize and use most hardware right off the bat, has most of the utilities and apps that they need, and will play most of the media stuff with effectively no danger, unless he learns a whole lot more than he has in the past 15 years.

by halibut

Essentially what I was meaning with the modular kernel being more dangerous is the fact of the kernelkits. Windows with it's use of a monolithic ernel are not be effected. You seem authoritative in this area, tell me if some sort of malware was a kernel module and somehow alter system calls to other modules, would that not be a more deadly form of malware than what is present today?

I commented according to my experience. I don't pretend to be an expert and I don't pretend to be a developer. If I am wrong I am wrong.

I was not expressing this to say that the code would be autorun, but more the fact if the user was tricked into running a perl script that runs the code could this not be a problem? If the user is unaware of the dangers, which is most of the case in the windows world and runs the code, problems could arise. Of course not probable but feasibly possible?

by apotheon

1. I'm not sure what you mean by "kernelkit". What's a "kernelkit"? I've never heard that term, except as the name of some software development projects that have nothing to do with malware.

2. There's a point beyond which a security compromise essentially cannot get any more "dangerous". That point is the one where the person that has cracked system security has more control over the system than the intended user(s) with root/administrative access. That's why those of us with a fairly experienced view of computing security say that once a computer has been rootkitted it's time to dig out your data backups, then do a nuke and pave of the compromised system: once rootkitted, you can't trust the system's current install ever again. Period.

3. It's always possible to trick a user into doing something stupid, of course. The Internet is a "buyer beware" environment. The techniques of tricking the user to circumvent security for you are collectively known as "social engineering" attacks. System security can be configured to discourage this sort of thing, but ultimately there's no perfect patch for the "human involvement" vulnerability of any system: a determined bout of stupidity in the right place can always sabotage security.

by halibut

Kernel Kit is essentially a Kernel RootKit.

Good point stating that there isn't really a more dangerous point, than the point of no return. I guess it was poor wording on my part.

Truly Social Engineering is 90% of the main part of the having spyware installed on your system. Isn't the point of this to point out that a window's host typically has a limited knowledge user behind the keyboard and would more likely be to install the enticing piece of software or not put appropriate measures in place to prevent the automatic installation of said toolsets.

Whereas the typical Linux user has a considerable more knowledge that "this tool seems too good to be true" would be at the forefront of their mind.

Thanks for the discussion, I appreciate learning more of the background layout of how the Linux OS works, and maybe I can take this offline for future questions.

by tracy_anne

That is precisely why I started using Linux (Mandriva, then Mandrake) back in 2002. The desire to be free from viruses. It worked, I am.

What confirmed my decision was when I was developing a proposal for a client, using Open Office.org, and the power blacked out (Sydney in the Summer). I hadn't saved for about 4 hours (bad mistake, due to total concentration on the task itself), so being familiar with Microsoft Operating Systems and products (MS Office) I assumed I had lost 4 hours of work.

Upon restarting the computer, I was presented with a message from the OS, well actually the Desktop (KDE in my case) that I had and open document, and would I like to restore it. Naturally I said yes, and the system opened Open Office.org with the document, and I found myself staring at the complete document down to the last key press.

I can think of nothing that would induce me to choose to go back to MS Windows.

by tracy_anne

quote::Truly Social Engineering is 90% of.............

Whereas the typical Linux user has a considerable more knowledge ............::quote

The point about social engineering is essentially true. However, a truism regarding the relative merits of security vs system knowledge; On a MS Windows System the less you know, the more likely it is that you will be socially engineered into installing malware, because you can, easily, without much thought. Conversely on a normal Linux System Linspire and possibly Ubuntu excluded, the less you know the less likely you will be able to install the malware, no matter how convincing the social engineering was.

For example my partner uses a Linux System I set up for her, she can't install anything, let alone malware, because she doesn't understand enough about the system to do so, she hasn't yet learned how to use the command line or use the installer. I expect that by the time she is proficient in these things she will also be less susceptable to such social engineering. On a MS Windows system any user can at any time install anything, usually because to get around the inconvenience of the way security is set up everyone has Administrator access (in a home system)

Another point here. In general Linux users usually expect that they can install any and all software for their particular distribution from the distriubutors mirrors, or from mirrors that are known to be secure, and, naturally malware free.

Microsoft OS users have been trained to look for useful software from everywhere and anywhere.

The expectations are different too. Microsoft users expect that they will never see the source code, and in general blindly trust that what they are getting good. While Linux users, in general, expect that the software will be Open Source, and available from an Open Source Software repository.

This discussion is closed to new replies.