Discussion Locked

5 Reasons that Linux is a failure

0 helpful
126 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

126 replies

by chris

a lot of people bought these things thinking it was a mini pc which means the sales guys didn't do his/her job.

They are really better suited as applicances.

But, for me, when they are 2 gigs fast I might consider em since they are easier to carry on my motorcycle. I'll just plug monitors into em.

by Member 19291532

They *are* a mini PC.

They've got at minimum a Celeron 900Mhz, and best an Atom 1.7ghz.

They'll support up to 2GB of ram.

They've got all kinds of different storage options, from Solid state to SATA 2.5" drives.

In my case, I just took an Eee PC 701 wtih 4gb of solid state drive, 16gb SD card, and 320gb external USB drive to Spain with me. It met all my mobile computing needs for the trip, playing movies from MP4 ipod images (340x200 is ideal for the 7" screen), playing (relatively dated) games, checking e-mail, and surfing the web. I also set it up with GPS via blue tooth. I picked it up used, and blew off the limited Linux OS on it and replaced it with XP, though.

Configured with Linux, most are set up as very simple "appliance" machines, but they can certainly function as full fledged, although tiny PCs.

They're not top end core duo Alienware gaming rigs. But I also traded an old IBM Netfinity 5000 server and a cheap handcam for the 701. Can hardly complain about the price.

But, I also agree that there have been some historical OSes that were quite good that ran on incredibly limited resources by today's standards. AmigaOS comes to mind.

I suppose you get into this circular argument here where we can start using Apple Newton users as an example. They claim the Newton is far superior to any PDA available today, for various reasons. I disagree, but I can see their point. It is all about what you expect from a device.

So perhaps the problem with high Linux netbook returns has more to do with how the products are being presented. With Linux they *are* more appliance device, but the people who are returning them seem interested in small full fleged PCs.

by chris

you are drawing the conclusion that having many people (mass market) users equals success.

maybe in line with this thread I suppose, but where is that written?

Is there a Linux Mission statement or Business plan or Board of Directors or Shareholders?

by chris

The funny thing is you just describer Bill Gates.

I lope linux can go on to be as successful as he turned out

:-)

by chris

sorry, but it does. From an end user corporate environment view (I use linux on all my personal boxes) it just works. It's stable and great.

It took em a while, but they did it....

right up til Vista....

by jon

No, but you did make yourself seem ignorant, and clinging to a high pedestal in which you un-doubtfully need to leave. You create a topic that you know will bring in attention from multi O/S communities and possibly somehow think that you will not be attacked by some form of mass Linux based population. I also do not believe the Jason was saying that windows was a failure, he was just stating that Windows Vista has not been doing well, and it already has a replacement on the way, but as for as far as a normal lifetime expectancy of a MS O/S, this is the norm. The bickering between everyone really needs to stop, both or should I say all O/S have their place in home and business use. The facts still exists that MS owns the business market share and I doubt that Linux will ever overcome that, really that is not what anyone strives for and being an IT Manager whom most cling to their job and MS, because for some reason their insecurities make them prone to the belief of something or someone taking over their position, you proved yourself to that example. MS is a business standard, unless your government or a bank etc., then you are highly probable to be in a UNIX and COBOL environment. The point of this was to state that ignorance is not one-sided and doesn?t always have to be a knowledge based comment, but rather the views and morals that one portrays about their fellow community or career field in his inability to hold their tongue.

by jon

1.) To most end users only MS exists.
2.) XP might run on 128MB, but add a few applications and the resorces will be completely used.
3.) Windows does not have a built-in office suit or a good light web-browser, no secure emial capabilties.
4.) No one thinks LINUX is easier, if MS didn't have a majority of PC sales for the past 10+ years, everyone would think learning any MS O/S would be a difficult task. Working as a consultant I've seen everyone stumble over the simplist task is XP or lower O/S as well.

by Member 19291532

1 - That is still a PROBLEM for Linux, either way.

2 - XP will RUN on a machine with 128mb though, whereas nice, loaded distros of Linux (Ubuntu for example) have HIGHER base requirements than that to even install. Don't believe me, check it out. A regular base load of Ubuntu requires MORE system resources than XP. For a netbook, you're not going to need that much power, so goes the idea. Yet, in either case, netbook or my old subnotebook, XP is better suited than Ubuntu.

5) The Familiarity breeds acceptance argument. I'll buy that. I've experienced it first hand. If Win32 wasn't so dominant and widespread, it would be more rare. If someone else, Linux, OS X, AmigaOS, was the dominant paradigm, we would all be used to doing it THAT way... and Win32 would seem hard and exotic and complex.

Yup. But... that doesn't IMPROVE Linux's ease of use. Linux is difficult. Props to the Linux community for improving that VASTLY in the last decade. There is still a LOT of room for improvement.

by forum surfer

My bro-in-law, a mechanic still preaches w2k and has thus far refused the switch to Xp. He's taking some local community college classes that teach various forms of linux. He loved the idea, but hated it in practice. He experimented with Vista at my house and whined like a school kid who lost his favorite toy.

Some people just won't switch until their current product is no longer supported or a upgrade is mandated by a piece of software they depend on. It's just a matter of time before he ends up with a diagnostic software utility that makes him use Vista.

Me, I'll use whatever gets the job done or is required by my job constraints.

by Member 19291532

Both had a clear impact on the direction MS took with Vista. The increased emphasis on multimedia content management and manipulation in Vista is clearly a direct response to OS X, as is the Aero eye-candy.

The security is a direct response to the Linux community and their complaints about security.

So, it was really a two stage defense. Consumers become disenchanted with Win32 after they pick up a trojan or a pop-up generator or get their homepage hijacked or other malware on their visit to the porn sites... Eventually, they migrate, probably to OS X - where they find that it is so easy to manage their giant collection of Porn.

Thus, all Linux and Mac users are Porn addicts.

Hmmm... I think I lost my original direction there. Anyhow... you're probably right, Microsoft didn't really care to address the "compalints" when it was just the Linux guys complaining. When they started losing share to Apple, that got their attention.

by Member 19291532

Most cars, you can either get a new chip or program the chip if it is OBD-II.

So, yeah, you can get a different engine management software put in your car. I've done it several times. Night and day difference.

by Member 19291532

Along those lines, in all of the places I've worked at, only two have had any Linux projects. One was Intel, and it was... such a "token project". It gave me the impression, right away, that Intel was not comitted to Linux so much as it was hoping Linux MIGHT break out and upset Microsoft dominance (that WinTel duopoly is a myth, kids. They play nice, but neither company really likes the other very much). But it was clear that Intel wasn't going to jump ship from being a Win32 based operation.

The other was a small consulting group that was strapped for resources and didn't really have the *nix experience to have *nix based servers.

I'll use whatever gets the job done or is required by my job constraints. And in 14 years of experience, there has been little professional requirement for *nix experience.

by forum surfer

I have a handful of linux systems running vmware and samba. They all had server 2003 installed virtually, eventually. I have many system critical apps and I'm more than reluctant to go virtual on many of my servers and be dependent on one piece of hardware, especialy considering these are public safety apps dealing with 911 clients. With the exception of a storage server running *nix/samba, I'm not saving any money because too many of my apps depend on m$ products. And with alot of this dependency being with ESRI/Mapinfo products there is't a viable open source alternative so I'm stuck.

But then again I don't crusade for open source or m$ so I could care less. I do use alot of open source apps, however...but all are runing on windows.

by Member 19291532

This has nothing to do with job security. I've forced my staff to look at Debian and Ubuntu as potential "Thin client" solutions hosting Citrix based connections to our back end servers. It is an almost viable solution, except we still have occasional need for a fat-client on the user end.

Listen, nothing would make me (or my superiors), happier than finding a way to dump tens of thousands of dollars in volume licensing.

I'd be an *idiot* not to consider that as a potential alternative - if it were viable.

Unfortuantely, it isn't. The ignorance is in Linux fanboys trotting out the same tired arguments and assumptions in these threads. You guys have a playbook that is as well rehearsed as any door-to-door religious group.

Otherwise, your post was kind of rambling and incoherent. I understand that my tone upset you - but maybe you should count to 10 and try again, because a lot of what you were trying to say seemed kind of confused.

by jeff.allen

I am in my 40th year in the IT industry. My intro to Unix was in 1983 when it was on a single-user graphic workstation. Since then I have been exposed to it's various flavours etc over the years, on workstaions, servers etc, using Posix, Unix (all variations) SCO and some that I discovered hiding behind dedicated operating systems on purpose-built machines.
In the last ten-ish years I have been working on almost exclusively Windows based products, so I have been "out" of the Unix world for a while.
I recently decided to install Ubuntu onto my laptop, to see for one thing, how much *nix has changed (not a lot - but that's not a bad thing).
But was it easy? No. Was it smooth? Up to a point. How long was it before I switched from end-user mode to Unix technologist mode? - About ten minutes. Just after I downloaded an MP3 I couldn't play. Just before I downloaded an AVI that wouldn't play... I gave up when my attempts at Utube proved fruitless....

As a techy I find it's great, but as an end user?
I WAS going to set up our home PC with Linux, but the thought of customizing it for my wife and kids to use seemlessly? Nup..

by jmgarvin

If you don't have the codec, Ubuntu will inform you then ask you if you'd like to install it...

by dpresley_50201

From my experience with PCLinuxOS, both 2007 and 2009, I've found as easy, or easier to install and setup than XP on many points. Particularly peripheral configuration, switching various services on and off and any number of tasks that require editing the XP registry to accomplish. With PCLOS, just open the Control Center then point and click. The one major caveat is setting up Samba to get my Linux box to network with my XP box. Unfortunately, that task is not for a casual user. Without Samba running, Linux and Windows don't communicate. This is probably THE factor that causes so many people to return a Linux netbook for one loaded with XP. Just my two cents worth--cheers.

by slayer_

These things should almost automatically lock themselves after a month or two of no posts.

by nido_rano

I agree with it.
But the point is missed. Most people spend a lot of money on computers that they think are the best in the market at a time. Simply because the vendor says them it is. So, the people with their new computers want to their computers almost fly. But when they realize that their pcs cannot fly, they are disappointed. The point I want to remark is that the pcs need a minimum personalizing in configuration. A minimal knowing of what a computer does. With Windows, most of the people don't know how their machines do the jobs, and when something goes wrong they don't figure what to do. I guess Linux breaks this habit forcing the user to know something before start with it.

But if the people insists in not knowing anything about their machines, we can do that job for a little money...

by charliespencer

Halloween isn't for two more days. Isn't it a bit early to be digging up the dead, especially a corpse as volatile as this one?

by nido_rano

...even installing Windows is the thoughest thing.
I just say:
Please press a key to enter the CD/DVD...
Fast or complete format of the partition?
NTFS?

It's easy for the PC illiterate end user?

by chriscampbellchr

I've used Linux and other Unix variants for many weeks. I can't tell you the days and weeks I've spent on the web trying to get some things to work (wireless). In the end, it was frustrating and I decided to go back to Windows for good. Whether you like it or not, the world runs on Windows and your average user doesn't wanna change. If they do, they'll go to Mac, not Linux. Linux belongs in the server room like Unix, not on the desktop.

by slayer_

Can't someone find a really big rock to put over top of this thing so people stop digging it up?

by slayer_

This is pretty old but still interesting. Wonder if in the last year, has any of the problems improved?

This discussion is closed to new replies.