Question Locked

64-bit slower than 32-bit with same amount of memory?

0 helpful
26 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I suppose having a 64-bit system without correspondingly more memory installed would not help with the efficiency. In fact it could have adverse effect on performance. Am I right?

Say, for example, a system with 2G memory if installed with a 32-bit Windows 7 system could perform better than with a 64-bit Windows 7 system installed.

To take advantage of the 64-bit system, I understand we have to install more memory. Analogically, it is just like a big car needing more petrol for running the same speed.

Would you think so?

26 replies

by healer

is 1GB for 32-bit or 2GB for 64-bit I infer that 64-bit requires more RAM to achieve equivalent performance efficiency as for 32-bit. So when the RAM is constant then 64-bit would be less efficient though it might not be appreciable at this stage depending upon what is actually running I guess.

by willcomp

All the comparisons I've seen for Win 7 64 bit and 32 bit on the same PCs with 2GB or 3GB of RAM show performance is essentially the same. x64 has the edge with 4GB of RAM since all is utilized. x64 also has improved security. Given the choice, I'd install x64 since 64 bit drivers are not likely to be an issue -- older hardware without 64 bit drivers probably won't have 32 bit drivers either. Win 7 does an excellent job of identifying hardware and installing drivers.

by healer

32-bit can take up to about 3GB RAM. 64-bit takes much larger maximum. Certainly 4GB for x64 would be much better. I am not too sure what you mean by "all is utilized" though.

Regarding improved security I read on http://ask-leo.com/are_64bit_pcs_more_secure_than_32bit_machines.html whether you agree or not it seems to say 64-bit operating system does not offer better security.

I agree that newer devices do in most cases offer 64-bit drivers if they want to survive the market change. People who want to keep their old devices might be out of luck when they have to have a 64-bit system installed.

Yes, Windows 7 indeed does an excellent job of identifying hardware and installing drivers.

by willcomp

You need a bit more understanding.

32 bit Windows has a 4GB address space limit (2 exp 32). Although 4GB of RAM can be installed, not all will be available due to reserved addresses for motherboard components and other hardware. About 3.25GB is an average amount that is actually usable although I have seen as little as 2.75GB on heavily configured systems with dual SLI video cards. 64 bit Windows will use the entire 4GB since it has 2 exp 64 addresses (16,000 terabytes) available and the reserved addresses are at the top of that range.

It's additional features included in Win 7 x64 that improve security, not that a 64 bit OS is inherently more secure than a 32 bit OS. Those additional features include hardware-backed DEP, Kernel Patch Protection and mandatory driver signing.

by healer

unless the computer has heaps of memory otherwise there is really no point of installing 64-bit system.

by bizintelligence

is correct..

I won't do it. It is about communication between RAM, processor and 64bit OS. If they are not equally compatible then no point of getting one.

by kenone

I have noticed that the 64 bit systems run much slower during software installation, particularly with 64 bit software. That is, software that demands 64 bit OS, some CAD and engineering programs eg.

by tony hopkinson

I remember when we went from 16 - 32 bit a lot of installer software lagged and for NT was still using 16 bit code.
The other point to bear in mind is a lot 32 to 64 bit conversions are just straight translates particularly if they support 32 bit as well, so they aren't optimised for 64.

Simple boundary alignment could quite easily double memory needs for instance, which would explin why upping available ram had an efect.

by purpleskys

require a lot of ram to run in the first place...personal opinion, I would bump up the ram a bit more, you might be more happy with the results

by healer

we need more RAM (minimum 2GB) for 64-bit in order to have it run. So if the RAM is the same then 64-bit should be less efficient.

by tony hopkinson

running code not optimised for 64 bit then yes you do. But 64 bit can be faster, that's the point of it.

The level of optimisation required will proabably only be in play when we are scratching our heads wondering why our 128 bit systems are slow. :p

It's an expensive do, even if only in terms of tools. We've all been designing code to be efficient aligned on four byte boundaries for years, now it's eight (if we are doing 64 bit only!), so straight addressing alignment could up to double the memory needs.

by peconet tietokoneet

You can make any operating system run fast if you have fast memory, harddrives and the processor to crunch the numbers (data) though you will have to have a bigger PSU for the power.
If you have slow components you will have a slow system.
But saying that. any 64 bit software is going to be more secure and more stable than the 32 bit version. More memory is better than less in computing.

by healer

64-bit more secure and more stable than its 32-bit counterpart for the same amount of memory?

Certainly more memory is better. There is no doubt about it.

by oh smeg

On the same hardware I can say that there is no real difference in the speed of the different versions of the OS's with the real advantage coming when you use more that 4 GIG of RAM. Well it's actually something like 3.25 GIG but the reality with Dual Channel RAM to get the best possible performance I use 4 GIG configured as 2 X 2 Gig Modules which are the cheapest way to buy RAM these days.

Provided that the actual System can use 64 Bit Programs there is no real difference in speed between similar applications. The real differences become apparent when you install something with more in it than the 32 Bit version as it has more running processes it takes longer to execute applications on the same hardware as a 32 Bit OS would but if you are comparing Apples to Apples they work about the same speed with the 64 Bit version showing better Benchmarks than the 32 Bit Version, though I'm not sure that this turns into better performance.

Though to be perfectly honest I have not tried comparing the different OS's on a NB with a upper limit of 2 GIG of RAM mainly because I don't have any that can not carry 4 Gig's of RAM handy.

If it was me personally I wouldn't be bothering with 32 Bit versions of any new Software be that a OS or an Application. It is effectively dead as it is too restrictive on what Hardware it can be run with and as all new Hardware can carry more RAM that a 32 Bit OS can use why bother restricting your Computer to Old Technology that will not be as useful as the 64 Bit systems are. ;)

Col

by santeewelding

Your experience, and your observations here and elsewhere over time, led me to set up my latest rig as you describe.

by healer

using 64-bit system instead of its 32-bit counterpart provided that we have all the right program and device drivers we need.

The original question was comparing the efficiency between a 64-bit operating system and a 32-bit operating system installed on a 64-bit capable computer without varying the amount of memory.

I guess we can only see the real advantage of a 64-bit system if we have lots of memory installed. With barely enough memory in view of their different minimum there might be some negative effect in performance which we might not readily see it.

by purpleskys

All the software that I have here has installed without a hitch. My anti virus, maleware programs, Simply Accounting, MS Office, paltalk, paragon back up and recovery, CD burner XP, my HP all in one, a multitude of different digital cameras, and different flavors of MP3 players; the only thing I couldn't get to work was my old webcam, but like I said, it's old.

In my husband's line of work, 32 bit just doesn't cut it anymore, the pretty much require having 64 bit OSes and programs; needless to say, the machines in his office run on more than 8 gig ram. With the different types of mapping software, GPS stuff, AutoCad, and other stuff they run, anything less would take them forever to do their job.

I might be wrong in saying that most new computers today would be 64 bit compitible. Most of the tech folks I personally know say it's the way to go and the way of the future

by oh smeg

Was with the Beta of Office 2010 which didn't have the necessary file to run after deleting a 32 Bit version of Office from that system.

Not a big issue though more than slightly annoying at the time. But as I use the same rig for all testing which isn't by any means the newest available a 775 Duo CPU with 4 GIG of Corsair RAM and a 256 MEG ATI Video Card all running on a Gigabyte P45 M'Board it's not overly geriatric either.

Under that the 64 Bit OS benchmarks faster though I can see no real major difference in speed. I threw the Trial of 7 onto a Acer Aspire AS90 with 2 GIG of RAM and it worked quite well. I was more testing the hardware there however than the Beta of 7 but for the 90 days of it's life it worked perfectly well all within the limitations of 7 which didn't matter which hardware it was installed on though I didn't try a 32 Bit version of 7 on that system but if this helps throw it's 32 Bit version of Vista Home on it and it fails to work after about 20 days. Not sure why that is but the person using the Trail of 7 couldn't fault it. ;)

Col

by healer

the computer must have much more RAM installed in order to take advantage of the benefit of a 64-bit system.

by healer

you mean that all positive features of Vista 64-bit are implemented in Windows 7 64-bit as well and no more negative aspects are found either.

by healer

Windows 7 64-bit does as well as Vista 64-bit in terms of features and capabilities, such as stability, security and efficiency.

This discussion is closed to new replies.