Discussion Locked

A K6-2 or a Celeron

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I'm in the process of upgrading my aging Pentium 133 and I'm undecided between the AMD k6-2 500Mhz and the Intel Pentium II Celeron 533Mhz or higher. Which is the better choice?

11 replies

by some guy in seattle

Since you will also have to upgrade the motherboard, there are no real differences in price/performance for either of these devices. I personally choose AMD since lately they seem to be less focused on their marketing forces and more focused on thequality of their hardware. But, like I said, not much difference between them (although I believe the AMD will have more L2 cache - check the specs).

Hope that helps,

by jctech

I've had considerable experience with both AMD and Celeron processors, and have found that the Celeron has a tendency at random errors and lockups with a number of systems. Also, in industry comparisons, AMD processors have consistently run about 10% to 15% faster, MHz for MHz, than the Intel processors. How is that possible? Clock speed is not the only factor to consider in processor performance. Another factor that directly affects performance is switching speed of all transistors used inthe processor.

by tony.colgrove

IMO I would avoid the K6-2. For the price vs. performance if you go with AMD choose the Duron. It has onboard L2 cache and its supporting chipsets are definately newer and should hold a longer life span then the K6-2, which is a retired desktop chip. It doesnt go higher then 500, a Duron starts at 600M (I think). I would avoid any celeron below 800mhz as they still run @66Mhz FSB. Do yourself a favor and if you go the Intel road, buy a 500Mh PIII. One good reason is the motherboard will give some life incase you wish to upgrade the chip (in the nearer future).
My pick for price, get a Duron 600.

by ojfamak

Due to financial constraints I'm stuck with either a Celeron 500/600 MHz or an AMD K6-2 500MHz.

by grbeckmeyer

I know you already rejected it, but I would have to second Tony's opinion on going with a Duron. I just checked prices at www.tcwo.com, a k6-2 500 is $40, a Duron 700 is $44. I've seen steals on "kits" for k6-2's, but it would be worth some sacrifices to move up to the Duron as it can easily be expanded to current leading edge (maybe spend $60-70 on a 1.2gig Athlon in a couple years), where the k6-2 system is already at it's limit. Even if it means waiting a month or two or sacificing some other components, I think you would be FAR better off with the Duron

by ojfamak

After much reconsideration (and pressure), I'm eventually getting a raise in my budget which will allow me go for a K7 Athlon (probably 600MHz). I'm a Nigerian student and the price deferential here is about N10,000. In perspective my allowances areN6,000 a month!

by sales

I am a service tech. I repaired hundreds of PC's last year . I wouldnt wish an AMD K-6 on my worst enemy. Go celeron or Athlon(duron) . You were warned.

This discussion is closed to new replies.