Discussion Locked

America WILL become free from its dependency on foreign oil

0 helpful
27 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

[b]The Claim:[/b] America WILL become independent from its dependency on foreign oil.

Yea, right! In your dreams!

Republicans will do it. No, Democrats will do it. No, Republicans will do it. No, Democrats will do it.

http://www.thedailyshow.com/watch/wed-june-16-2010/an-energy-independent-future

I've heard this rhetoric my entire life (50+ years).

Solar energy; wind power; alternative fuels; electrical; batteries; mice running on a wheel. All are pie-in-the-sky pipe-dreams.

[b]The truth:[/b] Energy independence for America [b]IS NOT POSSIBLE[/b] any time in the foreseeable future. Because Energy independence from fossil fuels [b]IS NOT POSSIBLE[/b] any time in the foreseeable future.

If you believe otherwise, perhaps you'll consider buying this bridge I have for sale.

If you agree or disagree, feel free to make your case.

27 replies

by jaqui

you must be losing it Max, to believe that. :D

there is no way America can get rid of it's dependence on foreign fossil fuels, without completely rebuilding the American psyche to make the automobile an evil thing.

by jaqui

yeah, we all know exactly how likely it is for America to lose it's love affair with the personal automobile.

I think the proverbial snowball has better odds. :D

by jackofalltech

I don't think we'll be weaned from fossil fuels anytime soon but we don't need to use foreign oil. America has enough to last 300 years at our present usage rate. We just need to ignore the stupid tree-huggers.

by tony hopkinson

it's cheaper!

The boys who make money off it want usage rates or prices to go up continually. As long it will last to the next fiscal report, retirment or promotion alternatives will not be considered.

Management by crisis is where we at.

by tony hopkinson

the bulk of the developed world won't become independant of oil in the forseeable future.

I suspect we might disagree on the ratio of can't and won't though.

There's a lot of inertia, natural and contrived within the energy market. At some point in the forseeable fossil fuels will no longer be economically viable. Increasing prices will stretch viability (hopefully as long as possible as the energy moguls are concerned), but we are starting to reach the point where we won't be able to afford it and leave them in profit.

The thing that irritates me is that this situation was entirley predictable and very little has been done to address it over the last fifty years. All we've had is excuses, false dawns, unachievable promises and co-incidentally of course, massive profits for those controlling the supply....

by charliespencer

Sure it is, but we're not willing to pay the economic costs or make the social sacrifices. I'm not saying we should, but it appears we as consumers and businesses are unwilling to make any compromises to reduce our dependence on fossil fuels in general or foreign oil in particular.

Incidentally, how are we defining 'foreign oil'? Doesn't all oil pumped in the US go onto the world market? Don't US oil refiners buy it from there?

by thechas

Max,

Yes, we will become free of our dependence on foreign oil and even domestic supplies of fossil fuel.

How?

Not by the adaption of alternate energy sources. No, economic forces will remove the US from the oil consuming nations.

I think it is only a matter of time before the value of the US dollar drops so low on the global market that the US will not be able to afford to import any oil products.

Then, in order to repay our loans, China and Japan will demand the full export of our domestic oil gas and perhaps even coal.

Of course, when that does happen, there will be a sudden interest in alternate energy sources. But, with no funding for the research and no money to buy the alternate energy, that effort will fail.

Since I don't expect that we will ever raise taxes, grow the US economy, or cut spending enough to be able to pay down our foreign debt, this is more a question of when than if.

Chas

by av .

I'm part of the 50+ crowd and I've heard this mantra too since the late '60s. Nothing has changed since then.

The only way we'll get off oil completely is if its totally depleted and we have to. Otherwise no. Still, we'll probably look to the Moon or Mars for other oil sources.

Solar energy has never really taken off. Its too expensive and just not good enough. Wind power isn't good either. Maybe the next generation will come up with a better solution.

AV

by delbertpgh

Dimethyl furan is a ring molecule, four carbons and an oxygen, with two methyls dangling off the side. Seems to be a workable substitute for gasoline, with slightly better energy density. You can make the stuff from fructose.

Some custom-made algae could give you exactly what you need for a feedstock. Build an algae farm the size of Massachusetts in the Sonoran desert, supplied with Colorado river water. Might have to kick a couple thousand Navajos off the land first, but hell, we've done that before. Sounds like a plan! Petroleum independence is at hand.

by Member 25348569

Craft an algae that lives in sea water. Stick it in a suitable bit of desert next to, say, Las Vegas (OK , you'd need a pipeline for the seawater) or Los Angeles and you get to do something with the city's crap, too. As much fertiliser as you can use.

sunshine + seawater + sh:t... sorted.

The problem with this is that no one is really doing much research as you can still make money from oil and from current biofuel production from food.

Burning food is only marginally less ridiculous than burning oil.

Then again, you could just use smaller cars but that would be against your precious freedom to consume.

by charliespencer

The Colorado is the most overtapped river in country. Lake levels on Mead (behind Hoover Dam) are down to historic lows, down 100 feet or more from what they were 15 years ago. While there have been similar lows on record, none have lasted as long or shown the same trend of long term decline.

http://www.arachnoid.com/NaturalResources/

Not a bad idea over all, but you're going to have to get the water somewhere else. The rest of the southwest is sucking it dry.

by xnavydk

I think in my lifetime it wont happen, maybe, but I am both a pessimist and an optimist depending on the subject.

Technology and necessity rarely run neck and neck but I believe in tech. The oil companies want to stay in business. Currently Hydrogen gas is manufactured by using fossil fuels by turning a gas into a gas, and about 4% from water splitting. When the ratio is 50/50 I think we see change. Big business will have to get behind it either by incentive or forced due to supply. Either way I see using the most abundant element on the planet is the way to go. It just makes sense to me.

by charliespencer

why the oil companies don't spend more on developing non-carbon fuel sources. Seems to me if my core business was clearly facing obsolescence and cultural opposition, I'd be looking at the Next Big Thing. If Big Oil went heavily in bio fuels, they could break the stranglehold Big Corn has in this country in favor of cheaper, more efficient, non-food sources.

by jck

Reason 1: Complacency. They already have price-control status, and own most of the government officials.

Reason 2: They're greedy. They won't spend a huge amount on it til they see a 2x or better ROI than what their maintenance of their sub-standard, antiquated oil/gas extraction systems give.

Reason 3: Lack of conscience. Oil companies are just that...companies. Their ultimate, one true legal responsibility: returning the highest dividend they can. Most put less than .5% of their profits into their "alternatives" research, and call it "making great strides toward renewable sources". Yeah right.

If BP had put $20B into alternatives infrastructure 4 years ago, you might be seeing more synfuel, electric, hydrogen cell, or even compressed air cars.

But instead, they kept up the status quo.

by xnavydk

I personally think bio fuels was a mistake. Notice how food prices went skyrocketing. It takes as much energy to produce the biofuel equal to its output there's no cost savings and the source is not exhaustible. Its very expensive to make because the big agri corps jacked up prices of corn with the demand following the oil companies pricing schema. And notice also that our food prices are still higher even though the fuel prices are down. Its all a conspiracy! also why make fuel out of a food source when so many millions of people are starving.

But I agree, they should start looking to alternatives NOW if they want to stay in business long term. They already have the manufacturing infrastructure and a delivery method.

I also think our modes of transporation will change to smaller more agile vehicals to match lower consuption. but people have to want it. when gas prices hit $5 there were a heck of a lot more scooters on the roads.

by tony hopkinson

they would lose money.

While we haven't got any, we have to pay what they ask.

As they expect to be in power then any alternatives they choose to come up with will yield a tidy profit for their shareholders.

What are you, some sort of damn pinko tree hugger? :D

by charliespencer

Or should that be 'Switchgrass today, fuel tomorrow"?

Either is contrary to the apparently popular shortsighted approach.

This discussion is closed to new replies.