Question Locked

Any fast (7200 RPM) pocket-sized USB drives?

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Broadly speaking there are two form factors for external USB hard drives - "bricks" typically 8"x5"x1" or so (e.g., Lacie Quadra, Maxtor One Touch) and "pocket" drives typically 3"x5"x0.5" (e.g., Western Digital Passport, Maxtor Mini).

I do nightly backups for my personal and business files and store them offsite. I do a complete, uncompressed backup of all data and configuration files so that in the event of a fire or theft I can attach the backup HD to any PC or laptop and have instant access to all my files without special software or hardware.

I used to use "bricks" (above) but they were too big to fit in my safe-deposit boxes and harder to carry around. So I've started switching to "pocket" devices (above) which work OK but take a LOT longer to backup all my data. A complete backup on a "brick" takes about 5 hours; the same data on a "pocket" drive takes 7 hours. This seems to be related to spindle speed - bricks are usually 7200, pockets are usually 5400 RPM.

Does anyone make a pocket-sized drive that's 7200 RPM? (I don't care if it's bus-powered). I need about 300G, so that rules out any affordable SSD's.

Thanks in advance.

6 replies

by inet32

I want "USB". In the event of a disaster I want to be able to take the backup drive out of the safe, attach it to any random laptop and have instant access to my data. That's why I said no special software _or hardware_. If I used a SATA drive with a special USB enclosure, as you suggest, then I would also have to cache extra enclosures offsite, which would complicate recovery.

BTW, what did the above Tornado enclosure mean by "Maximum Total Capacity Supported : 340GB"? It's just an enclosure - why does it care about drive capacity?

by inet32

"this one might be better: http://www.microcenter.com/single_product_results.phtml?product_id=0282161
"Supports any capacity 2.5" Serial ATA Hard Drives" "

I went to the mfg'ers (MacAlly) website. The unit is USB bus powered. It says an AC adapter is "available" but when I called them they knew nothing about it.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but so far every 7200 RPM drive I've seen in its own enclosure takes a separate AC adapter - the 5400 RPM pocket drives are bus-powered. I always assumed this was because 7200 RPM drives exceed USB 2.0 unit load of 100 mA (up to 5 unit loads per port).

I don't have any requirement that my solution be bus-powered, as long as the AC adapter is small enough to wrap around the drive when I put it in a safe deposit box.

So back on topic - I'm really not trying to come up with a DIY solution involving bare drives, enclosures and AC adapters from tiny companies no one has ever heard of (MacAlly?) I just want to know if anyone makes a pocket-size 7200 RPM USB HD.

by inet32

After hours of digging I found one on my own, and it's actually gotten pretty good reviews. It's a line by OWC called "Mercury On-The-Go Pro" http://eshop.macsales.com/shop/firewire/on-the-go

They also supply an AC adapter for people like me who are fussy about current-drain specs. The drives are made by Hitachi. I'm not familiar with OWC but apparently they have a cult following in the Mac world.

It took hours of searching on the web and calling vendors to find this, and everything people here suggested was DIY. In the future, is there a more SYSTEMATIC way to find out if a product with a certain set of attributes exists?

This discussion is closed to new replies.