131 replies

by ontheropes

I find it interesting that people get the label of conspiracy theorist whenever they believe something that's a bit different from what the mainstream media seems to want you to think.

I haven't yet scrolled through the entire list of 30 conspiracy theories but I imagine I'll find myself labeled a conspiracy theorist more than once.

Just so people know, I didn't go looking for this. I was lead to the link I posted by a link at Fark.com and wanted to share it.

by forum surfer

And that's the global warming hoax. But I guess that's enough to brand me.

I also beleive it to be remotely possible that Pearl Harbor was allowed to happen, but I very seriously doubt it. But it could be true. I beleive the problem was our focus on isolationism at the time, coupled by the government's elected officials not wanting to upset the isolationists and send us into a multi-front world war...which no majority populace in any time frame wants to see happen.

by tig2

I have always known that there is a butterfly net with my
name on it out there. An "I love me" jacket too.

Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean that there isn't
someone out to get you. Your only defense is to THINK.

by road-dog

I believe that man made global warming is a load. I don't think it's a conspiracy, dolts moving together in large groups do not a conspiracy make.

by ontheropes

I'm surprised, a little, to see that I'm branded a conspiracy theorist once again. We won't go into the other times here, thank you. ;\

by Member 25348569

"I believe that man made global warming is a load".

Yeah, and I believe that you must be right because...

Um, because...

Ah, um, because...

...

by tonythetiger

[i]http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/picturegalleries/howaboutthat/3477148/The-greatest-conspiracy-theories-in-history.html?image=6

explains Obama's election :)

(I drink well water... never had a cavity either)

by ---tk---

I really dug in deep on that one... Just because my co-worker, was going on and on and on about it... He is a little extreme when it comes to these things. His theory was that fluoride is a bi-product of Nuclear waist, and the Gov. is feeding it to the US citizens to dumb them down, keep them sick, and to get rid of all the waist they have accumulated. Well, to shut him up, I researched it. The fluoride that he was talking about and this conspiracy theory states is one version of fluoride is harmful, however the fluoride thats actually being used is a different version. In massive amounts it can be harmful, but those that drink tap water, do not get exposed to that kind of quantities.

by ontheropes

Some were new to me. Others? I knew they'd be included.

I'm keeping my peace, pretty much, about all of it. It really doesn't matter, shouldn't matter what I believe anyway. Every person is free to believe as they'd like, last time I checked. It's what we do with our beliefs...

by charliespencer

I concede it is possible FDR allowed Pearl Harbor to be bombed. Please note my allowance of possibility is different from accepting this as fact.

I agree there is some evidence at least some of Shakespeare's works could have been authored by someone else.

Elvis? In Terry Pratchett and Neil Gaimen's "Good Omens", Death is quoted as saying, "I NEVER LAID A FINGER ON HIM."

by Member 25348569

We have "been there, done that". But thank you for the offer.

For me, it would be interesting to read the coherent, internally consistent set of interpretations that Road-Dog has derived from the freely available climatology data that leads him to his conclusion that "man made global warming is a load".

I mean, with eloquence such as he displays above, coupled with such an obviously incisive intellect, he might even convert ME!

Neil :)

But, then again...

by road-dog

First, let's establish a frame of reference. I'm not skeptical of a generalized warming of the earth's climate.

However, I'm not of the belief that it is in any way man made. That's a significant distinction, as conventional wisdom calls for large scale modification of humanity's activities to prevent it. Whereas I submit that it is a natural and cyclical climatological trend.

Rather than disputing the validity of this climatological model or that one, I submit the geological record and longstanding interpretations of glacial evidence.

The North American portion of the polar ice cap has at times extended hundreds of miles south of where it currently ends. Existence of large amounts of southward glacial movement AND RECESSION indicate large scale deltas in ambient temperatures at different times over the geologic record.

The geologic record indicates that this has occurred many times over the eons, a period of time predating human civilization and our presumed effects upon climate.

Man made global warming only takes into account the small slice of time since we as a species reached a number where we could possibly influence climate. It ignores many similar cycles and posits us as the cause. It is blindingly anthropocentric when the long view is taken! Looking at THIS upward trend at THIS time-frame deprives us of a means to draw a truly comprehensive conclusion.

One might also wonder how industrialization on earth has affected the polar icecaps on mars, which are receding also:

http://www.enterprisemission.com/warming.htm

One might also wonder why MMGW gets a pass from the usual steps of the classical scientific method which has served us so well since Aristotle. We have bypassed hypothesis straight to conclusion whilst ignoring a lot of empirical data established by solid science. It is scientifically reckless since the geological record was established separately from and previously to the hysteria that surrounds MMGW.

I am more inclined to believe in backward looking hard science than in forward looking climatological models of questionable validity. Hindsight is 20/20 after all!

At best MMGW supports correlation which is entirely different from causation.

Think that at least makes the case for more science Max?

by Member 25348569

We are coming at this from absolutely opposite directions. You quote - as does Max and like heretics - past geological records as significant factors in the discussion. "It's happened before and it'll happen again". There's something that you fail to take into account.

The increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide, in rate and in level, is unprecedented. There has never been a straight increase in carbon dioxide level at at the rate that is happening now and all of it - I repeat, all of it - is down to us. Nature has only come close in a major - and by this I mean something akin to the Yellowstone Caldera kicking loose - volcanic episode and that cannot be compared to the current CO2 increase as the accompanying ash and SO2 aerosols set it as something completely different in effect.

Hindsight doesn't work if it's the first time something is happening.

You make huge (and insulting) assumptions about the ethical and professional motivation of climate scientists. There is a HUGE body of data that follows all scientific method, Aristotelian or otherwise. You simply choose to ignore it and post a reference to "Martian Warming" as if, in some way, this proves your point.

What I don't understand is how you can be so presumptuous as to believe that [b]no one has thought of this[/b].

By the way, a small quote from the article seems to nail its relevance: "Recent reports, published in the December 7, 2001 issue of the journal Science". Things move on.

Neil :)

A couple of questions. I'd be VERY interested in a "no" for 1 & 2 and I'd really, really like your answer to 3.

Is CO2 a greenhouse gas in that it absorbs infra-red radiation?

Has the concentration of CO2 in the atmosphere increased significantly in the last hundred years?

Where has the excess heat gone?

by santeewelding

Then it degrades again to the equivalent of discovering the stoma on the underside of a particular leaf, or exposed rock in Ethiopa, and pointing with glee.

So well...

by deepsand

The cause or causes of a present effect is not limited to previously observed causes of the same effect.

Example: That you may have never witnessed food being cooked by any means other than an open fire does not preclude the existence of other means of cooking.

If you truly "believe in backward looking hard science" then you should study the underlying Physics of spectral absorption & radiative forcing, and ignore both the geological record & climatological modelling.

by notsochiguy

Seriously, everyone knows we parlayed the technology from Roswell to get to the moon!

What were they thinking to put the lunar landing on the list??

:)

by charliespencer

I thought the Roswell saucers were doing follow-up visits on the pyramids the aliens helped the Egyptians to build. Why isn't 'Chariots of the Gods' on this list? How soon we forget the classics...

by notsochiguy

...but a truth is a theory that's graduated into belief; and thus, it wouldn't have qualified!

:)

by tonythetiger

but it also softens enamel. So you have a choice between the teeth rotting from the inside, or wearing out from the outside.

Either way, your dentist wins :)

by deepsand

Many of them simply have all of their teeth pulled at an early age and replaced by dentures.

by jamesrl

This has been debated a number of times on some newsgroups I've belonged to.

If FDR had known (the theory is that British intelligence/Churchill found out and told him), he probably didn't have the naval strength to stop the attack from achieving its main goal - crippling Pearl Harbour. The dry docks, air fields, naval base etc were in the end just as important as the ships themselves. But, if he had played his cards right, and sent the battleships out at dawn(while th planes were taking off), he could have dramatically reduced the loss of life without stopping the attack, and getting the US into the war. Even if he had sent just a few ships out, it would have not tipped his hand.

So I have a hard time believing that FDR wouldn't have done something.

James

by jamesrl

But ..at the time, no one,save the Japanese really thought the carrier more important than the battleship.

James

by Member 25348569

I would hardly "gleefully" point out a potential global catastrophe! I mean, schadenfreude might be a hobby of mine but you can take it too far.

:D

by road-dog

Once again, back to tried and true scientific principles.

The Martian reference was to point that a phenomenon similar to our observed global warming was also occurring in a totally separate environment. I liken this to the methodology where a test group and a control group are kept separate and the test group has a variable introduced and deltas are observed and measured. For the sake of discussion, co2 is the variable. Global Warming (as indicated by icecap decrease) delta between the control group and the test group delta is minimal.

Since similar effects are observed in both the test and control subjects, on concludes that co2 (man-made and otherwise) is NOT the cause.

I think that you'll grant me the given that the number of Chevy Tahoes on Mars has not increased during the period of time under discussion.

In this case, the solar system is my laboratory. I suggest it is more valid as global warming is a planetary level phenomenon and scale is a valid consideration in any explanation.

I'm not sure where you draw your assumption that I presume nobody else has come to conclusions similar to mine. I am quite sure I am not alone in this. I don't believe I implied it, you inferred it.

Further, I made no judgment as to the motives of those who choose to believe in MMGW, the choice to be insulted (on behalf of the scientific community, apparently) was entirely yours.

I find your choice of the word heretic quite illuminating. Heresy is a departure from theological orthodoxy. I submit that MMGW has become an orthodoxy of sorts. History has proven time and again that orthodoxy is the antithesis of science. Orthodoxy begins with conclusions and brands other ideas as "unthinkable". Such is the case with MMGW. Your response is similarly visceral to what a priest might have said to Copernicus when the geocentric view of the universe was threatened by helio-centrism.

OK, as to your questions, I'm not going to baited into trying to prove your assumptions. Why? I've already attacked your view globally. It's your job to connect atmospheric co2 (man made)with global warming. That's your dogma, not mine, absent of any conclusive cause/effect. I submit again that correlation is not causation.

I hope that we'll agree to disagree like gentlemen.....

by road-dog

I simply approach things in a reasoned and temperate way. Funny how that seems to make other folks to lose their minds as evidenced by the above statement!

by road-dog

Is the proper punctuation to end an exclamatory statement. It is proper for use in any forum. All the kids are doing it these days!

by santeewelding

You haunt what Neil haunts what I haunt.

What's missing is the strike of the terrible swift sword.

Sometimes, I think, Neil explores his grip, fumbling now and again.

You need to find it.

by Member 25348569

I used the word heretic deliberately, not because this is in any way a religion for me but because I believe it is for some. It was a small aside aimed at Max, whose anti-GW stance is also not a religion to him but is inevitable taken in the context of his libertarianism. Whether that is his true religion we'll leave for another day.

I find that a number of US peers - and I would suggest large sections of your population - seem to adopt the same attitude because if they were to believe that GW is real, man-made and can be mitigated by our actions, it justifies action on a governmental and even global scale. Given that personal antipathy to government interference and the absolute contempt that the US feels for other governments and (shudder) the UN, the easiest thing is to cherry-pick those few articles and reports that support your views. And then post them as "evidence"!

What is mildly insulting (I would reckon not intentionally so because you don't know me) is that you think that such articles could influence me.

The Mars data and observations are real, no doubt about that, but the conclusions drawn in those reports that quote the data as some form of negation of the GW theories are facile. The article that you posted included and perhaps more than most.

Mars has a different orbital eccentricity and very different precession to the Earth and although it has long-term climate cycles similar in effect to the Milankovitch cycles on Earth [b]they have different time periods[/b]. Mars has no oceans and a thin atmosphere and this means that its thermal inertia is low. Martian climate is easily perturbed by external influences. What happens on Mars has NOTHING to do with what happens on Earth.

Satellite measurements show that Solar output is currently DECREASING slightly and has done for the last few years as we move to a (predicted) Solar minimum.

Read on through the link you posted and you find the following "it is receiving energy from 'outside forces' that are acting on the entire planet, but not through conventional '3-space' electromagnetic energy transmissions."

Hyperspace energy? Yeah, or maybe fairies. Aliens? Yes, that's the one. Read the links in your posted article, they are hilarious!

Neil :)

by road-dog

Final post on this, I had hoped to engage in a reasoned discussion on the subject.

I submit a couple of photos as evidence supporting my position and you choose to chase down links in the article in order to discredit my position by association.

Differences in orbits aside, I pointed out that both Earth and Mars are both experiencing a net gain in energy. You accuse me of cherry-picking facts while ignoring an entire planet.

Rather than proving how your CO2 theory accounts for MMGW, you:
1)Take offense on behalf of science in general. Classic misdirection.

2)Attack my nation, as if that justifies YOUR assertions. Classic Ad Hominem / misdirection

3)Attack Max's politics, after you asked to debate me and he graciously stepped aside, granting you some intellectual respect. Apparently there is no reciprocity. At your request, the debate is with me on this one. Libertarianism alone does not create antipathy for MMGW. Classic misdirection / non-sequitur

4)Drag into the conversation a bunch of links totally unrelated to my discussion. Ah, the classic strawman argument.

Well, I stand by my assertion that MMGW is a load. Your techniques are flawed and ineffective. This "discussion" has taken it's course. Follow this conversation through as an intellectual exercise and ask yourself, "how did I prove that MMGW is NOT a load?" After all, that was the question.

If your assertions are so weak that they can't stand on their own, then perhaps some reconsideration is in order.

I'mjust sayin'. do have a nice day!

by road-dog

Not anyone else's. If one chooses to subscribe to MAN MADE co2's absorptive or radiative effects on global climate, that's their job. You're putting the burden of proof in the wrong place.

My dispute is with the MM part of MMGW. I posit that GW has occurred before, absent of industrialization. MMGW believers are asking numerous concessions of us as individuals and as a species in response to this belief. Thus the burden of proof is upon them to convince humanity that they are correct.

If one asks me to leave my house at 3:00 AM on a cold and rainy night, they had better have a good reason, such as calling me from the hospital or jail.

I'm not playing Socratic method games, nor am I playing the proving a negative game. CO2 performs in such a way under lab conditions. It is a leap to conclude that these effects account for this particular planetary net gain in energy. Further, good science is based upon drawing solid and reproducible conclusions.

My thought process begins and ends at a planetary level on both fronts. Apples to apples. The opposing view goes from a sample in a spectrum analyzer and projects to the global level. Mustard seed to 2,000 pound pumpkin.

I stated that I think MMGW is a load, thusfar I'm unconvinced otherwise.

by deepsand

Interpretations of data, past and present, are observational artifacts, and cannot serve to change the underlying Laws of Physics.

The past may be relevant to our understanding of the relationships between certain causes and effects, but it is immaterial with regards to what causes are currently extant.

How the Physical Laws of Nature operate is independent of when and where ones observations are made. You cannot simply dismiss them by arguing that laboratory results are not necessarily authoritative.

When I say to study the relevant underlying Physics, I refer to the [i]Theoretical[/i], not the Experimental.

by road-dog

I'm not the one attempting to link THIS particular law of physics as cause for THIS particular effect.

If you will notice, I made NO assertion about what caused previous instances of global warming, other than observing that man was not a factor. I precluded no other thermodynamic explanation.

Conversely, MMGW proponents separate this event from previous others and attribute a particular cause. A more finite interpretation requires a more compelling explanation. If one assumes greater certainty of culprit, one must bring forward not only a smoking gun, but THE smoking gun.

THIS period of GW is different because THIS gas produced by man is having THIS effect on climate. And THIS (insert very expensive remediation here) is necessary to stave off disaster.

Physical laws (once proven) are an acceptable constant. I grant that. However,I believe that for the purposes of the opposing argument, physical laws are being misapplied.

Instead it turns into: Right wing, libertarian, typical American, anti UN, but this model by so and so, my climatologist can beat up your climatologist. WHARRGARBL.

Or worse...This is too serious to wait we must do something right now regardless of what it does to our economy and standard of living.

by road-dog

HMMM. I point out that your debate on this topic has dug into several well established as counterproductive debating techniques and you assume I'm angry. Where do you get the impression that I'm pissed? Even were I, how is that even a part of the discussion? Why is it so important to you that I be angry? Why is it so important to you to point out that I'm angry? Why is it that AFTER I asked to disagree like gentlemen, it was so important to begin hammering bad debate techniques? I'm wondering what "winning" means. Is causing anger how one defines victory in absence of resolution?

I knew where this was heading. Although I've been away and not posting, I have been reading. MMGW topics are almost never discussed in a cogent and reasoned way. Almost always it turns into exactly what this one did.

I only entered the conversation to see how many of the bad debating tactics would emerge and how quickly it would happen. I am not disappointed. A friend (thinking of pre-law)has been looking over my shoulder at the discussion; not in terms of technical validity of positions, but in how the points were raised and responded to.

My objective was to point out how communication is subject to technique, how bad technique so often takes place of reasoned debate, and how ultimately these techniques spiral the discussion downward and preclude any effective resolution.

She knows that arguing on the Internet is pointless, but didn't really believe me about bad debating techniques and how they are used. She thought debates cratered because people are stupid. For her sake, I chose simplistic supporting evidence intentionally to make linguistic judo more apparent.

Now, she has an idea how not to encapsulate an argument in the courtroom if she wants to sway opinion and end conflict in negotiation.

Thanks. You helped me make a point!

Now I'm thinking that this sets up another thread pointing out flawed debating techniques , how to recognize them, and how to avoid them.

by maxwell edison

Regardless of who's right or wrong - the advocates or the skeptics - the $64,000 question is:

Therefore what?

It should be up to your side - the advocates - to answer that question with one that's palatable to both sides. That?s where you (the advocates) fail in advancing your cause.

by road-dog

This was a case study not in the effective advocacy of a position, but the systematic quelling of dissent.

Classic attacking of the messenger and his motives, throwing out evidence, sidestepping points, etc are common ways to avoid engaging opposition and giving the appearance of victory.

Sadly, this is how the MMGW debate plays out nationally. "Summits" assume MMGW is a reality then focus on remediation in the form of carbon emission reductions, etc. Debate is quashed.

For the more vociferous proponents, dissent must be labeled as heresy because MMGW is much like religion. Dogma is defended not on it's own merit, but because it is accepted!

Look for a thread on debate techniques. The other forum where I found it might not have been improved, but here at TR maybe we will do better....

by deepsand

"[i]MMGW proponents separate this event from previous others and attribute a particular cause.[/i]"

Which is precisely as it [b]must[/b] be. Please re-visit my early statement re. the irrelevance of past causes to present effects.

"[i]I'm not the one attempting to link THIS particular law of physics as cause for THIS particular effect.[/i]"

If you understood the Physics involved you would know that 1) such cannot be divorced from radiative forcing, and 2) any increase in atmospheric "greenhouse gases," e.g. CO2, CH4, H2O, etal., cannot [b]not[/b] increase radiative forcing.

"[i]one must bring forward not only a smoking gun, but THE smoking gun.[/i]

No; each and every input that affects a particular output shares responsibility for that output.

Lastly, the hypothesis that atmospheric levels of CO2 could affect climate in a manner so as to raise temperatures is far from new. Per Wikipedia, "The greenhouse effect was discovered by Joseph Fourier in 1824, first reliably experimented on by John Tyndall in the year 1858 and first reported quantitatively by Svante Arrhenius in his 1896 paper."

So, to claim that this is a case of "[i]Right wing, libertarian, typical American, anti UN, but this model by so and so, my climatologist can beat up your climatologist.[/i]" is historically incorrect.

by deepsand

Not that I'm a believer in the conspiracy in question, but merely pointing out that which might be claimed to be a supporting fact.

by tonythetiger

[i]The increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide, in rate and in level, is unprecedented. There has never been a straight increase in carbon dioxide level at at the rate that is happening now and all of it - I repeat, all of it - is down to us.[/i]

And yet, despite the 'unprecedentedness' of CO2 Levels, global temperatures HAVE been warmer before. That leads me to believe that we don't understand the effect of increased 'greenhouse gases' as well as some of us think we do (Some of us just have a harder time admitting our ignorance than others).

[i]You make huge (and insulting) assumptions about the ethical and professional motivation of climate scientists. [/i]

Actually most of the assumptions of motivations are being directed toward those who [b]hired[/b] the scientists. Evidence the treatment of scientists who don't toe the MCCG line.

[i]What I don't understand is how you can be so presumptuous as to believe that no one has thought of this.[/i]

Human history is full of instances of "Why hadn't anyone thought of this before?" (My favorite example is interval windshield wipers...). What I don't understand is how you can be so presumptuous as to believe that no one had thought of that!

On the other hand, maybe a certain group of scientists has it exactly right, and that maybe the citizens of the planet are just stupid dolts who will never get it and must be forced into line. That job will be a lot harder thanks to science... which made it possible for the dolts to survive long enough to breed... Serves you right!

by tonythetiger

[i]The cause or causes of a present effect is not limited to previously observed causes of the same effect.[/i]

does it [b]exclude[/b] previous causes (whether known or not). Yet many scientists seem to have chosen to don their blinders...

by deepsand

cause and effect?

I.e., the presence of a currently observed effect is not necessarily the result of a previously observed cause.

In logical terms:

Given "If A, then B" = TRUE, it does not necessarily follow that "If B, then A" must be true.

by deepsand

However, you persist in clinging to previous causes in the absence of any evidence to support such.

by deepsand

"[i]However,I believe that for the purposes of the opposing argument, physical laws are being misapplied.[/i]"

Mere "belief" is not sufficient to rebut; empirical proof is required.

by Member 25348569

As I saw it, you post a sh:t link and throw your toys out of your pram when somebody points out that it smells!

Obviously, you didn't even read my post where I pointed out the obvious fact that the climatology of Mars and Earth are not comparable in any way. I got THAT without exploring any links or reading past the first paragraph. I pointed that out using the ONLY law of debate: Devalue your opponent's logic or facts.

When I DID read on, the article descended into farce. THEN, you complain that I read the article and followed it up. Not my fault. I didn't post the frigging pathetic link! You did! If you want my advice, read what you link to. Some of us DO read.

Now, of course, we find that you only entered the debate to highlight our poor debating technique. You and your "thinking of pre-law" friend (what?) must have been pissing yourselves with laughter at our inadequacies. "Patronising sh:t" springs to mind. Or can I say "Changing the Subject" as a debating tactic when you're losing?

Whatever...

Probably a good thing you did change the subject as you obviously know nothing about climate science, scientific method or honesty.

:)

Not quite [i]ad hominem[/i] (by my standards) but I can do that as well. Aren't Latin tags pretentious bollocks, eh?

by road-dog

OK, Where is the empirical proof that I'm wrong? Yet another shift in the burden of proof. Is this a contest of science vs science or a burden of proof shifting contest?

As stated, I believe a scientific principle is being misapplied. It is not my job to prove the opposing view, it is my responsibility to objectively evaluate it's merits.

Not only is the burden of proof being shifted, but the degree of proof is apparently higher on one side! I must provide empirical certainty to rebut what is presented as fact but is questionable in its merits.

Nice try, though!

by Member 25348569

and also won't.

The chances of me finding an answer that is palatable to you is vanishingly slim. I have posted on this subject on TR to the point of exhaustion and neither of us have moved at all.

I do accept - and share - one of your worries in that the more extreme attempts at a "cure" may be more damaging than the disease but that is the only common ground that we have. As, at this time, I see little movement by the US in doing anything to change its society's behaviour, we are a long, long way from "extreme" and we don't even have that common ground.

I know that it's your position that the burden of proof lies with those of us who wish to change the status quo and I could sympathise with that viewpoint were it not for the fact that I can't see why you are so resistant to the huge quantity of evidence.

Neil :)

by road-dog

I and others (Max can stand up for himself) believe that individual rights, self-determination, and by extension national sovereignty are paramount and only to be subordinated for firmly established cause.

This makes the burden of proof very high, enough to supersede very fundamental individual freedoms.

As relates to MMGW, international action is questionable both in extent and results. It relies on a few big assumptions. Assumptions aren't compelling enough to justify most of proposed solutions.

1) MMGW is man made, meaning that it is even preventable by behavior modification.
2) Remediation will be effective in light of nations like China who simply ignore international agreements, placing the complying nations at a considerable disadvantage in the market.
3) International bodies will propose solutions that will actually work.
4) International organizations will not do things under the auspices of MMGW remediation that are in pursuit of other objectives.

IF GW is a natural and cyclical thing, then spending bazillions of dollars in remediation would be better spent on moving away from the coasts or perhaps going Sci-fi and building floating settlements.

by Member 25348569

Climate Change is real and caused by Man's actions, specifically the release of fossil carbon into the atmosphere. The responsibility for causing that rests fairly and squarely upon Western Civilisation and, for the major part, upon the United States - admittedly with some help from Japan, Europe, Australia and Canada.

China produces, NOW, as much CO2 as the United States with five times the population. Given the United States' historical production of CO2 and, much more significantly, their current reluctance to do ANYTHING, why should China try? Then, to use that in return as an excuse for the US not to do anything is major hypocrisy.

If the US would reduce its own carbon footprint then international bodies would not NEED to propose solutions. It would be fairly easy to manipulate expectations to save huge quantities of energy were it not for the much-vaunted "individual rights and self-determination" which is used to justify waste to the point of selfishness.

We arrive at the burden of proof. In that I put it to you that it is something that is SO important that you should make an effort to find out the truth for yourself. To search out the original information before it has passed through the politician's kidneys is difficult simply because of the size of the data but by no means is it impossible. I put quite a lot of personal effort into deciding whether I believed in Climate change and more effort into deciding that it is - in part - Human-caused. I did it because it is IMPORTANT. It is perhaps the most important thing in my lifetime to get it as best we can for the next generation.

If you want to be spoon-fed an answer that you find palatable or if you choose to use your "individual liberty" as an excuse for doing nothing at a personal or national level then there is nothing I can do but don't expect me to applaud.

by road-dog

We arrive at the burden of proof. In that I put it to you that it is something that is SO important that you should make an effort to find out the truth for yourself.
======>
Funny!
SO important..to you

SO important - I must research.

SO important - I must discard the research I've done and assume your point of view. If I reach a different conclusion, I am wrong, because it's SO important.

So important - that the US should subordinate itself to some international body whether other nations do so or not!

But then it's easy to call for action... on someone else's part!

That is where MMGW takes on much resistance. It is considered SO important that it requires action... NOW. On the part of the US. Even if independent research dictates otherwise.

by maxwell edison

1. Start to replace coal burning plants with nuclear energy. Upwards of 50 percent of the United State?s CO2 emissions are from coal-burning power plants. We hear about clean coal burning technologies, which should be pursued; but nuclear can be both clean and safe. Unfortunately, the environmental-left has been blocking their construction for decades.

2. Dramatically reduce CO2 emissions from petroleum-burning automobiles. If ? and this is a big IF ? technologies do indeed exist that could power automobiles with an energy source other than oil, then transfer all the private dollars, effort, and political capital now being expended on spreading the global warming claim to instead finance fledgling companies that would actually compete with our big-three auto makers. Competition, alone, would entice the big-three to follow suit (assuming they survive their current financial crisis). We wouldn?t have to force people to purchase these vehicles either. [i]Build it and they will come[/i] would certainly apply in this case. But for some reason, the deep pockets of the environmental-left would rather try to force people to change their behavior than invest in a viable alternative.

3. I?m not convinced that wind power is a viable alternative, at least not on a large scale. Larger manufacturing facilities might be able to build private wind farms to power their individual plants, and some smaller communities might also be able to benefit to a significant degree. But these will still need a back-up alternative source, which could be provided by the existing coal-burning plants that are currently providing all their power. What we?ve seen in the past, however, is the NIMBY (not in my backyard) syndrome ? the environmental-left loves to tout wind power, but they balk at where they?re built and how they might adversely affect birds.

4. I wouldn?t even be opposed to study and consideration of the possibility of transforming a lot of our largest metropolitan areas ? the largest cities ? to have significant automobile-free zones - on a voluntary basis, of course. Let the loony-leftists in San Francisco and Portland lead the way. It would increase participation and use of public transportation, reduce traffic jams getting in and out of congested areas, and it would even necessitate increased spending on public transportation, which seems to be one of the battle-cries of the environmental-left.

5. Encourage investment in high-speed and clean-burning Interstate Train Systems, one that could even be modeled after our current Interstate Highway System. Unlike most European nations, the United States is a very large country with a lot of wide-open space that stretches for hundreds or thousands of miles. Not only would it reduce cross-country Interstate Highway travel, but it would providing a viable alternative to air travel. We?d see a reduction in both the CO2 emissions generated by jet engines, as well as a reduction in a lot of the other down-sides of current air travel. If a start to finish 1,000 mile journey by train could be accomplished in under 8 hours, for example, many people would choose that as a viable alternative ? and perhaps a preferred alternative ? to the same 1,000 mile journey by air.

6. Put ourselves on a goal to limit oil imports as coming only from North American sources, with perhaps a 20 year deadline. Make it as much a national defense issue as an energy issue. Open up our own fields to compensate, as well as the implement the aforementioned measures. Stop the nonsensical thinking that we can?t drill ourselves out of this overnight ? we can?t do anything overnight. Admit that continued oil use and production will have to be a part of the equation.

7. Stop the demonization of American industry, such as big-oil. Stop suggesting that profits from big-oil should be invested in other industries. There?s enough investment capital available to compete with them. Stop the blame. Stop the threats to infringe on individual liberty ? in fact, emphasize that that underlying principle of our country will be protected at all costs. Stop making it a world issue. Keep the United Nation out of our national policy. Lead by example, not by coercion.

8. Give people, industry, and investors an incentive to do these things (and more) instead of idle threats to punish them for continuing the status quo.

9. Call the cap-and-trade schemes what they really are. Trading energy credits is a scam, and transferring one unit of CO2 emission to another source does nothing to reduce anything ? except it reduces freedom and liberty.

10. Stop the sky-is-falling nonsense. Stop spreading the doom-and-gloom scenarios. If Al Gore?s predictions were accurate when he first made them, the end of civilization as we know it would have already happened. It?s time to discredit these loony-tunes and be realistic about it. Acknowledge that economic considerations are just as important as environmental considerations.

In short, the environmental-left should put its money and efforts where its mouth is. Don?t attempt to force others to change their behavior, but rather give them incentive to do so. Lead by example, and acknowledge that the cap-and-trade schemes, the purchasing of energy credits, et al, is nothing but a ploy to transfer money from one person to another.

by Member 25348569

I do consider this important so I'm interested in what you have to say that might change my mind. Doing nothing is such an easy option and I'd like to justify it.

I'll happily lend you my back copies of Nature.

by road-dog

You sell your product.

I don't send spam emails to Viagra telling them why I don't need or want it.

You desire action on my part, you convince me.

Max, could you move your

"But Neil, I have solutions that should be palatable to both of us"

post hanging directly off the root, I deserves a tree of it's own. THX

by Member 25348569

But the "loony left" do not have the money. The "loony left" do not - can not - build nuclear power stations or new mass transit systems or major civil engineering works such as tidal barrages. The loony left do not set the preferential tax on gasoline and on trucks and SUVs so that the US uses twice as much gasoline per mile when compared to Europe.

Bedtime. More tomorrow.

Neil :)

By the way, I am invoking Godwin's Law. You KNOW you are not allowed to mention Al gore in a Climate change debate when posting to me! you know my views. He is entirely a US phenomenon and should be recycled immediately as soap.

Consider yourself reprimanded.

by tonythetiger

into human nature. As inputs we could use the fact that some humans depend so heavily on other humans that they think they must CONTROL their every behavior, and the other input could be that some others may react to such attempts at control with large caliber gunfire. We could then run the model and test whether those who think they're saving the world can enjoy it much with three inch holes in their heads.

by road-dog

Baiting is childish and beneath you!

My research doesn't convince you, yours doesn't convince me.

The difference is that your position solicits some action / capitulation on my part. I on the other hand, am not asking the UK to do anything, except maybe a Shaun of the dead sequel.

I submit that those desiring action on someone else's part must justify such action to those being called to action. The onus is entirely upon the solicitor.

by maxwell edison

Thanks for the laugh on the Al Gore comments. I laughed so much that my dog jumped up onto my lap wondering what was going on! (A Golden Retriever)

By the way, I never said the loony-left should build the nuclear plants, just GTF out of the way.

I did suggest, however, that the deep pockets of the loony-left (and they DO have deep pockets) COULD start in motion the design and manufacture of a whole new automobile, one that could, conceivably, replace half (or more) of the oil-burning autos currently on the road, and maybe in ten years. (Man, the profit potential is huge! I?d even invest in such a company myself.)

by deepsand

And, closing ones eyes to the present isn't "rejecting?"

To repeat - Cause and Effect are [b]not commutative[/b].

Current effects are wholly independent of past causes.

Please stop going in circles; it's no less annoying than the child who responds to every answer that he has solicited with the repeated question "why?"

by deepsand

you elsewhere rail against.

"[i]I believe a scientific principle is being misapplied.[/i]"

That is your premise to prove, not mine or any other's to disprove.

What principle is being "misapplied?" How is such being "misapplied?" These are issues for you to address, not for others to guess at.

"[i]I must provide empirical certainty to rebut what is presented as fact but is questionable in its merits.[/i]"

What is "questionable in its merits?" The Physical Laws of Nature that result in Spectral Absorption and Radiative Forcing?

If it is these that you challenge, then yes, the burden of proof is most definitely yours.

As noted by Neil, it is not in our place to teach you the relevant Science; learning such is your task. After your having learned such, should you think it flawed, then it is in your place to construct & test a suitable alternative hypothesis.

by road-dog

I've pointed time after time, that this discussion doesn't succeed, meaning nobody's mind gets changed.

I kicked all this off with describing MMGW as a load. Then it amused me a while to demonstrate debating tactics for a young college kid.

At some point, the entire debate becomes tedious. It seems MMGW proponents have this inexhaustible desire to engage in deceased equine abuse.

Misapplied - I disagree with your position, It doesn't change my mind. I don't think that This proved anything conclusively. I'm not going to explore every possible permutation of why. If I prove one negative, I will be presented with another.

It is usually bad news to argue from the specific to the general anyway. That's why I start at a planetary level on my interpretation. Arguing upward is a waste of time because it leads to arguments not needing to happen if approached top down.

I stated my case, take it or leave it, I'm not expecting any action to come of it.

Your case, I'm not going to argue again and again about this or that aspect of it. I don't have a dog in that fight. Either you convince me or you don't. You haven't. I'm sure that that if some MMGW action occurs, it will be because the rest of humanity just wants a little bit of silence.

At some point somebody needs to just drop it. So, argue amongst yourselves....

by tonythetiger

I have discounted nothing. Some others, though, think that they have reached [b]"The Conclusion"[/b], and think that because they've stopped thinking, that everyone else should too, and just agree with them and do what they say. That's NOT science, that's bullying!

You can't bully someone into believing you. Denigrating their attempts at questioning doesn't work either. You (the community of people who believe that your conclusion is correct) have nearly painted yourselves into a corner.. you're to the point where you're going to have to convince governments to use force on their citizens so they'll comply with your views. The problem is that the backlash to the attempt at such control will probably cause more damage to the planet than has been done to this point. Does being right really mean that much to you????

by grax

You all missed the real point.

Lump everything together under the "Conspiracy Theory" label and all becomes nonsense.

A bunch of headless chickens waste a load of bandwidth arguing about Global Warming, which may or may not happen and nobody can do anything about it anyway.

Waste of time and effort!

Tucked in amongst all this stuff, near to the end, is the real kicker. What really happened on the 11th. September 2001?

I realise you Yanks would all rather not know but there are legitimate questions that have never been answered. Think on.......

by notsochiguy

What do you believe to have happened on 9/11??

Or, what questions do you feel need to be addressed?

by grax

According to Wikipedia: "By November 2008 there were around 150,000,000 web pages dedicated to 9/11 conspiracy theories".

I'll make it easy:
1: What happened to the wreckage of the "airliner" that is supposed to have hit the Pentagon?

2: Why did U.S. armed forces completely fail to carry out their mission to protect the country?

3: More curiously: why has nobody ever been disciplined for this outrageous failure?

4: What was the Commander-in-Chief doing when his country cam under attack and why wasn't he removed to a place of safety?

5: Why was a major crime scene precipitately cleared before a thorough investigation of the collapse of the towers could take place?(I understand this to be illegal under US law).

Want more? Read "The New Pearl Harbour".
http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=va&aid=10166

In any crime investigators look for motive, means and opportunity. Only one organisation had all three and it wasn't Al-Qeida.

Watch your backs.......

One final question:
6: How many towers collapsed?

by deepsand

I've observed the same kind of behavior in many a discussion now. The going in circles, the persistent insistence that past causes must be allowed as somehow being responsible for present effects, even in the absence of any evidence for such, the infinite strings of "why," the appeals to ignorance, etc. [i]ad infinitum[/i].

Both Absolutely & I have been most patient in these regards, going to great lengths to explain and assist in your understanding of the underlying Science, and have justifiably taken you to task for showing no evidence that you have, or will ever, accept that about which Science informs.

I make no apology for not accepting your failure to learn as justification for your ignorance.

That being said, my offer to buy you a drink at the [i]Phyrst[/i] and/or the [i]Rathskeller[/i], should you ever travel to State College for a PSU vs OSU football game still stands.

by tonythetiger

[i]Not bullying, but simply calling it as I see it.[/i]

Talking is not bullying exactly, but (collectively) trying to force someone into a course of action certainly is.

[i]The going in circles, the persistent insistence that past causes must be allowed as somehow being responsible for present effects,[/i]

To not consider past causes to a phenomenon that has happened repeatedly in the past (if you even REALLY know the causes), is beyond ignorant... and if the past is NOT important, why even look into it?

[i]I make no apology for not accepting your failure to learn as justification for your ignorance.[/i]

I'm ignorant because I don't agree with you??? I'm 'not learning' because I haven't yet reached "The Conclusion"??? That would require 100% certainty, which I know that science cannot (honestly) claim. Now THAT'S Hubris!

by boxfiddler Hot topic

You bet. And I invent my own. And they're bigger than anything at that link. ;) :D

by nicknielsen

1. It was removed during the cleanup. Those parts that could be analyzed were taken to a secure hangar for analysis. Images of aircraft parts at the crash site here: http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread79655/pg1

2. The mission of the US armed forces is to protect the country from attacks originating [u]outside[/u] the country's borders. This attack originated from domestic airports.

3. It would be inappropriate to discipline anybody for failure to perform duties outside the scope of the mission. See number two.

4. The Commander-in-Chief was in a classroom in Florida. He was immdiately removed to Air Force One, which took to the skies [u]with fighter escort[/u]. Air Force One and its escort fighters were, for several hours, the only aircraft in the air over North America. How much safer do you want?

5. The actual crime scenes at the Towers were the impact sites on the towers themselves. As a result of the tower collapse, those sites no longer existed.

6. Three buildings collapsed that day. Towers 1 and 2 collapsed that morning. Tower 7 (already evacuated) was damaged and caught fire when Towers 1 & 2 collapsed; it was allowed to burn for over 6 hours before collapsing itself.

If these aren't the answers you desire, don't blame us for your confusion.

by deepsand

This from one who has repeatedly demonstrated little to no grasp of Science in general, and Physics in particular? One who has elsewhere admitted that their education in this regard ended decades ago in high school?

And, no, this is no attempt to denigrate based on ones lack of knowledge and understanding; rather, it is an indictment of all who insist that their limited knowledge and understanding is sufficient for arriving at any and all correct conclusions.

"[i]You can't learn what you don't want to know.[/i]" - anon.