Discussion Locked

BOSE - the REAL story

0 helpful
142 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Just a tad off topic on this one, but it is something I read about, hear about and see online all the time, BOSE, the marketing gurus and their amazing sounding speakers.

I for one have often said that BOSE is all about marketing and that for the price, you can find speakers that dance circles around the BOSE line of misrepresented speakers. I have also had that opinion contested more than once by people saying how wonderful BOSE sounds.

For the average ear, they SOUND 'okay' but they do not sound amazing (as their price or marketing would suggest)one fact in the linked article (which if you are interested in audio at all, is VERY informative indeed and well worth the read.) is that BOSE spent more on marketing last year than ALL of the high end speaker companies combined.

That's Paradigm, JBL, Mordaunt Short, CerwinVega, Acoustic Research/RBH, and literally DOZENS more, combined.

And the frequency response is simply laughable. While all high end manufacturer's display their frequency response levels based on a 3dB loss or gain, BOSE shows ridiculous levels based on a 10dB loss or gain (in case you are not sure of what that means, in order ot get the correct frequency as noted, the speaker is so far off axis it will be distrorted and playing at a different volume than the rest of the music, making such specifications absolutely and completely useless.

THE LOWDOWN ON TEH BOSE LIES VS REALITY:
http://www.intellexual.net/bose.html

[b][u]Disclaimer:[/b][/u] This is simply intended as an off topic post for those who may be interested, as there are peers here who have expressed an interest in the field.

Before you post about how wrong it is to post non IT related discussions, use the navigation tab and select "BROWSE" and then choose your topic of choice.

The main page simply shows recent discussions, not discussions of a specific interest. This HAS been posted according to site rules under the Off-Topic threads,

142 replies

by the maverick phantom wanderer (formerly macoza, nodice, kp, etc.)

"Disclaimer: This is simply intended as an off topic post for those who may be interested, as there are peers here who have expressed an interest in the field.

Before you post about how wrong it is to post non IT related discussions, use the navigation tab and select "BROWSE" and then choose your topic of choice.
"The main page simply shows recent discussions, not discussions of a specific interest. This HAs been posted according to site rules under the Off-Topic threads,"

... that you have to post this in order to prevent people from rising up in anger against you.

As for BOSE, I never did think their speakers were that good anyway (I can't tell several of my friends that though, regardless of how much proof I show them).

by oz_media

I've been around a while, I know all about the 'Hey this is not a technical post" BS by people who can't navigate a website, but are trusted to run a company's sever.

as for your friends, it is subjective. if you have a discerning ear, you already know about teh BOSE lies, if you do not, they sound fantastic and chances are you bought on hype and what other friends said, not what engineers and audiophiles say.

I've told many people about BOSE before (been in audio for a few decades now)and they just say, "well to YOU they sound crappy but to the average ear they sound great!" What they don't realize is that the $299.00 speaker in a box system would sound just as GREAT to them too, but they never get to THAT part of the store. (Read the part of the article on Bose store setups and positioning far away from other speakers. I know this one myself, first hand.)

To each his own; I work with speakers in excess of $30K pair, but I don't expect everyone to hear the difference between them and a $1000.00 pair, it took me years ot understand what is sound and what is colour, it jumps out at me now.

To most, the $1000.00 speakers sound great, thus referring back to Bose, what a waste of money the $1300.00 BOSE system is.

by the scummy one

just perceived glamour of their friends. They think that their friends/others know better and are just following hype/store displays, and salespeople. Often they dont trust their own senses in case these other people are more right :0

Did I mention a few months back I was listening to an mp3, and asked what I was doing. In the conversation this lady told me that she got an ipod and wore it at party's, but didnt know what it was. She spent about $400 on it because it was trendy :0

And people wonder why marketing works so well. People want to be parted from their money, and then b!tch about it when it happens...

by Tammy.Cavadias

.. that I bought back in 1993 - two small cubes and a subwoofer - course I got a heck of a deal on them (when they placed them onsale in the store they misquoted the price - they were suppose to be 495.00 dollars and got marked and advertised as 49.50) - I actually love them speakers to death - but I wouldn't pay what they want now as I just don't think they sound as good as my old set (still going strong after all these years) - and heck who can complain about 49.50 speakers :D

-Tammy :-)

by magic8ball

Is what I've always heard from audiophiles with more experience/use than myself. I have always been a Vega kind of guy for home speakers and I like Pioneers offerings for my vehicles.

by oz_media

YUO like teh Japanese sound then, which is just fine and saves you a lot of money too.

It's popular due to pop rock music, which accebtuates treble and sub bass frequencies.

European speakers will be focused more to the upper midrange witha reserved tweeter. This is why they are often called "old people's" speakers or 'Classical Music/Jazz" speakers.

Now that I am spoled, and yet still unable to afford my preferences, I am very focused on accuracy, detail, imaging etc. In which case you need a perfect balance between driver materials, crossover feequency, cabinet bracing, crossover capcitor type etc.

Yeah, 'Music snob". I won't aplogize for it, because a discerning ear in my field is a good thing, but also an expensive thing I've found :(

by magic8ball

Mainly I listen to my mp3 discs (rock and metal) but I still like to hear lyrics as well. I have my eq adjusted to be able to hear lyrics with good low, mid and highs. The amp has a pretty good range on the crossover. I don't turn it loud very often but I like to be able to hear what I am listening to in the land of the lowriders with the bass turned all the way up. Those lowriders sound horrible. I like a good sound which is probably why I spent two weeks fiddling with the eq and x-over, but its not necessary for my job like yours. Just a preference. I know a couple of 'music snobs' and it's not a bad thing. You should hear Vivaldi or Beethoven in my truck. You just might be impressed for what it is.

by the scummy one

a few years back, and how they got their start. It was a huge scam which revolved around inferior products ant high prices, all lead by a top notch marketing department.

I have never really paid much attention to Bose since.
Personally, I think many manufacturers have good sounding equipment, however, I would likely also fall in the 'average ears' arena, as many do not make much difference to me when listening.

So, I guess the info I got a few years back was pretty correct... Glad I never gave those b'tards any money

by oz_media

I am currently one of very few reps for Utah based RBH Sound, also manufacturer's of the famous Acoustic Research product line.

RBH used to be the designer and builder for JBL, MacIntosh and Rockford Fosgate in their OEM days.

You will be hard pressed to find anything but a stellar review from any real high end audio publication, the prices cover the gamut from small bookshelves at a few hundred dollars to floor standing towers that reach the ceiling (both physically and in the wallet) to in-wall counterparts that are simply stunning, putting out the same sound as the towers at a fraction of the cost. Having worked with retail and commercial audio for decades, I must say that overall they offer the best build quality and sound for the money that I have ever worked with.
http://www.rbhsound.com

NO...I don't get comission from them. :D

by dumphrey

of mid size AR towers back in the day. loved em. They paired well with the Yamaha amp I had. A friend of mine is using them now (those speakers are all of 12 years old now I would guess). They were replaced by Paradigm and Marantz amp/receiver.

by oz_media

here's a funny one for you. I bought a use Explorer and it came with every available option Ford ever put into one, including a JBL LUX CD sound system. Yeah, I laughed too (not quite a stock deck).

It sounded 'okay' but used a 6.5" bass driver in custom cabinet hidden in the rear panel, actually sounded 'okay' as the crossover and system was pretty well designed for what it was.

Needless to say, I killed the little woofer (distortion at high volumes etc.).

I was looking on craigslist one day and a lady was giving away a pair of Yanaha bookshelves, not realizing they were high end studio monitors (shhhh). she had been given new speakers for a wedding gift and they passed the Wife Acceptance Factor (WAF) which is always small and unseen.

So I hooked up these two bookshelves in teh back of eth Explorer for the drive home (My amp drives 6 ohms no problem) and almost crapped myself. It sounds like a $1500.00 amp and sib cabinet combination!

SO now I hae a little less room in teh back, but it sure do pump out the Iron Maiden and BLack Label Society like there's no tomorrow, and the Bruckner, Vivaldi, Cirque Du Soleil etc. Yeah , WIIIIIDE musical tastes indeed! :D

As for EQ's, haven't played with them since the mid 80's, I am into my snobby flat tone music now. If it needs and EQ, I want to listen to something better (snov).

but I do understand and aprpeciate how they can be used to colour the sound to your liking (had a 24 band on my old Pioneer SPEC 1&2 system, their best ever, traded a truck and nearly $10K for a used one!!), in my case I've trained my ears to a flat response now, which is better for comparative/critical listening I think.

Its amazing I can hear at all, having worked so many concerts over the years and before the days where ear plugs were a consideration. :D

by magic8ball

An older pair of Marantz speakers that are in a back room to my house. I dont recall the model number off hand. They are the ones that look like they have dual 8 inch subs but in fact only one. I know I opened the back. They are impressive enough to just about shake the house and I have never heard them distort. Of course with the wife and kids I can't really crank it too loud anymore. Not a bad deal for the 30 bucks I paid for them.

by oz_media

That second sub is just as important as the powered one actually. Many companies pull off fake passive radiators, however Marantz was not one of them, truly tuned passive radiators set completely out of phase.

From Audioholics:
[b]"Passive Radiators"[/b]
[i]A passive radiator is a device that looks just like an ordinary driver, except it has no magnet or voice coil. A radiator is usually a highly compliant device, with a similar cone material and surround found on regular active drivers. A clear advantage of the radiator is the absence of port noise, and some audiophiles claim the radiator provides a better sounding bass than a ported enclosure. Disadvantages include difficulty in tuning, and the extra required baffle area for the radiator. One must take caution in buying loudspeakers with this type of driver implementation. Many manufacturers simply implement one or several of these drivers disguised as normal woofers to give the illusion of more drivers in the cabinet. In fact some companies take it one step further and utilize passive radiators and porting in the same enclosure. Incorporating both is redundant and unwarranted as it will most likely result in loose, sloppy and undefined bass response."[/i]

http://www.audioholics.com/buying-guides/how-to-shop/loudspeakers-buying-guide

VERY informative site, everything you wanted ot know and more can be found on Audiohlolics.

by dr dij

kitchen mini sound thingy.

After seeing their ads so many times, I automatically realize I don't want to buy something where half the price is for the TV ads. I hear that 'for only X number of payments' and get worried about total cost.

However I DO thank them very much for sponsoring my fav shows. :)

by oz_media

See them as sponsors of other entertainment you enjoy, great observation!

That kitchen radio does sound okay, yuo can't expect high end from a little radio afterall, though they try to imply it.

Fortunately, any of the aftermarket copycats sound just as good in this case, at a fraction of the cost.

by dr dij

include that finallyfast.com, which is supposed to be questionable anti-spyware.

and a string of 'work at home' web sites.
I was curious if they would show up on site-advisor. Even lack of malware doesn't mean they won't take your money without malware. Which really DON'T give you work at home but probably try to collect money from you for info of questionable value, or pay per click for referrals to similar sites.

tHE latest TV ad scam is various medications such as natural sleep aids or stop-smoking pills, or acai fruit extracts. THey offer you a months supply 'free' plus shipping. Problem is they need a credit card. And they never stop charging you $40 or $80/month or so, making it near impossible to cancel unless you actually close your credit card account or get a new card#.

But my fav new ad is Slap-Chop! again, vince from sham-wow is hawking them. So far have avoided buying any sham-wows in spide of seeing them in person at our county fair. Very clever marketing. You remember the young guy with headphone and mic, spikey dark hair. THen you see the cloned guy at the fair and yell 'Hi Vince with smah-wow!!! You've forgotten his exact face so he looks identical.

Slap-chop actually looks USEFUL! Of course I'll probably wait till the cheap chinese knockoff shows up (probably from same factory that makes it for slap-chop).

I love to use chopped onions and peppers in cooking. Add them to my curried version of hash-browns. My wife doesn't do much cooking (except to microwave her dinner) and won't chop onions, makes her cry. Cure or prevent most things I say! and if you add garlic they even prevent VAMPIRES! :O I was at our Farm Boy produce store and tell the store guy that hte cabbage in their home made kim-chi helps prevent cancer. He thought that was neat, then cracked up when I told him the garlic was good too, prevent vampires. No vampires in korea he declared. Doesn't matter. I feel good when I eat the stuff. Problem is they leave the nappa cabbage in slightly too big chunks. Guess they need a Slap-Chop!

by oz_media

I am sue there isn't an audiophile or scrutinous reviewer on the planet that didn't agree they were worth fifty bucks!

Well done, I love those mistakes too...unless I'm the one who makes them (thus my need for editors, with my typing issues and all)!

by Tammy.Cavadias

a bargain once in a while... I will say though considering how long they have lasted so far - it was money well spent.

- Tammy :-)

by nicknielsen

Bose used to advertise the "unlimited" power handling capability of the 901 series.

I had just purchased a new amp and was shopping for new speakers to go with it. The [commission-motivated] salesman in the local stereo store was trying to sell me a pair of 901s. I told him I wasn't interested. He kept pushing, emphasizing that I could pump as much power as I wished into them and never destroy them. Since it was obvious to me that I had forgotten more about audio reproduction than this guy ever knew, I laughed and told him I could destroy them with 10 watts RMS. He responded (in front of witnesses...and the manager! :0 ) that if I could destroy a pair of Bose 901s with 10 watts using off-the-shelf equipment, he would [u]give[/u] me a pair of the best speakers in the store.

I found a 10-watt per channel BSR receiver, hooked it up to the speakers, and turned it on. Finding a station I liked, I turned the gain up until it was audible in the speakers. Given the combined natures of the Bose 901 (highly inefficient) and the BSR receiver (grossly under-engineered), the signal at the input to the speakers was so highly distorted that it was probably the next best thing to a square wave. The speakers tolerated this input signal for less than 5 minutes before the first cone burst.

I walked out of the store with a pair of AR-2ax speakers. B-)
The salesman kept his job for three more months to pay for them. :^0

Moral of the story? Take your pick:

1. No matter how much you think of yourself, there's always a pr1ck to burst your bubble.

2. Friends don't let friends buy Bose.

3. If only I had chosen a Klipsch dealer...

by oz_media

While I think Klipsch is still building an okay speaker, they certainly aren't what they used to be. One thing I have grown to really dislike with Klipsch is the horns they use on home audio speakers. They are so honky that they mask th lack of upper midrange ( a common ploy by most manufacturer's is to colour speakers this way due to the cheaper capacitors in the crossovers, cheap wofers or the use of horn tweeters.)

I have replaced a few of their subs with alternate products as customers find they have one note bass for theatre rooms.

They aren't all hype and BS like Bose, they just don't do anything for me, that's where speakers become personal taste.

Since working with another manufacturer (to be named by peer mail if you're interested), I have been so disappointed in all the former speakers I found great, Mission, Paradigm, even Mordaunt Short (though I still have a soft spot for Mordaunts).

I remember when Polk made a decent speaker for the average listener, but they really went to hell in a handbasket too!

Big Box stores really trashed the market for teh mainstream consumer, it's bottom end or you have to go hunting for specialty dealers these days.

Great website: http://www.audioholics.com

by jamesrl

...have simply closed up shop and sold their name to some crapy manufacturer.

Back when I was working on Campus radio in the 80s, I used to produce ads. I bought myself a nice Sennheiser headphones and it really made a difference in what I could hear.

Couple of weeks ago I needed new headphones for the home PC and found Sennheiser headphones on for $15. At that price I didn't expect "real" Sennheiser sound and I wasn't dissapointed - they were ok for $15, but nothing like the ones I paid $80 for in 1980 dollars.

The number of brands that have gone that route are legion. I am old enough to remember when Fisher was one of the first to go that route - from decent equipment to crappy knockoffs. My Advents at home are ok, but the last of the decent kit.

I saw a similar site on Bose in the mid 90s. It reminded me of an audio engineering society meeting that I went to in the 80s (friend was a member) and the lack of quality in Bose and their crazy white papers were the object of much discussion.

I was dissapointed to see Klipsch cheapen their product line.

James

by xnavydk

I love em, they make my computer system at home sound great, I did have to add two midrange JBLs and a tweeter to get the sound I wanted for my gaming but for the price and application, the only real problem I have with em is the 5.1-2 cable input is tricky to balance and the "rear" is not digital.

by av .

I have a BOSE stereo in my car, a GM car, and it was hyped to be a top of the line system. It came with the sport package on my car and I thought it would be good, but overall I think its a mediocre system. I wouldn't have bought it if it wasn't part of a package. BOSE knows how to market itself.

AV

by oz_media

An inclusive system in a new car will beat out the stock (manufacturer's)systems in most cases. As I noted elsewhere, my Ford came with DECENT JBL speaker components and amp/crossover network, 6-CD etc.with a Ford head unit (again okay for a stock deck). It would cost me about $1000.00 to top it even with manufacturer direct pricing.

But to visit a big box electronics store and be faced with smoke and mirrors and evasive sales techniques is just pathetic. A good dealer has everything to support their A>B with other models in the same soundroom for accurate listening tests.

Again though, its all about what sounds good to you though, and to be conned into thinking you are getting high end audio, without a fair comparison and at a ridiculous price, is just a scam.

by jaqui

I will only buy the 199 / pr speakers, they meet my needs fine.

I remember when "Lear" systems were being said to be the best. Was just as unimpressed with those as you are with Bose.

by nicknielsen

I once helped a friend select speakers for his new stereo. We took his amp around to various audio dealers and plugged in many pairs of speakers.

He ended up buying a pair of mid-line Clarion speakers from Radio Shack because he liked their sound the best.

by jamesrl

I haven't bought speakers in decades, but when I did, I always brought source material with me - a record or a CD that represented the kind of material I listen to.

It is important to ignore the prices, brands, and actually just listen to various speakers. I used to only shop at places that would allow me to do that. Oz probably knows the last place I bought at (Bay Bloor Radio is one of the biggest and oldest independants in Toronto).

Of course your listening environment is important too. I'd buy a pair of 901s for a bar where people are talking and drinking at the same time the music is playing, cause they can fill a large room with reasonable sound, but I'd never buy them for listening to classical music in the quiet of my small rooms at home.

James

by jaqui

it's also in how you use the system.

for low level background music in a quiet space, you don't need no fancy high-end system, a basic system will give you exactly the performance you need.

by oz_media

OK you stumped me.

Clarion, built teh first car radio in Japan, first bus PA, fist dual cone car speaker, first hybrid navigation for autos, First in-vehicle computer etc.
They are a pioneer and leader in the car audio industry, but HOME audio? Never seen Clarion home speakers, maybe you got the name mixed up with Citizen or something?
Or were you suggesting he took his car amp to stores for testing with car audio speakers?

by oz_media

i find that most people who buy $2000.00 spekaers will find the $500.00 ones just as pleasant, even if they can tell teh difference the cheaper ones are adequate.

In that same sense, you could visit my Queensborough sound room and would instantly hear the quality and tonal difference between $200.00 speakers and $2000.00 speakers, but would probably find the $200.00 ones to be good enough for your needs.

When my customers sell a $30,000.00 pair (not too often of course) the end user is a wealthy audiophile, or a growop owner who pays in cash. They are ridiculously expensive, but again outperform much more expensive speakers. At that point, its usually a matter of show value and having the best or the best, more than appreciating the sound. $30K takes apretty discerning ear, however those people exist too where a $5000.00 pair would sound horrendous to them.

Its taste; just like drinking, it's supposedly cool to boast about needing to drink a case in order to get drunk but getting the same from 2 beers is not such a bad thing is it?

by jamesrl

Weent to Epcot in the mid 90s, I was in Orlando for a conference and had half a day before my flight.

They had a blind setup between $1000 speakers and $20,000. And once you did the demo, they explained that while the $20,000 speakers were studio reference, most people preferred the pleasing warmth and richer bass colour of the cheaper speakers.

As a classical musician, I prefer something as colourless as possible.

I know my baby Advents don't have the bottom end sufficient for hard rock, but for most classical (ie choral) music they are sweet. If I am playing the 1812, I might wish for a sub, but don't really need it.

James

by charliespencer

Look at that Slap-Chop device closely next time the ad is on. Focus on the physical size of the device. Notice the relatively small size of the hopper. Consider whether you will have to pre-slice what you're cutting so it will fit in the hopper. Ask yourself, "If I'm going to have to pre-cut what goes in the hopper, why don't I just cut it up manually?" Repeat for most devices of this type.

Work at home? Notice how the spokesperson never reads the web address or phone number as part of the recorded pitch. Watch the text at the bottom of the screen over several weeks. Notice how the web address and phone number change at least monthly. Ask yourself why they have to change their contact information frequently. Repeat for radio 'work at home' ads; notice the phone number and web site are announced by a different voice from the rest of the ad, and how they change with each new ad.

by dr dij

even if same company they may want to know wht ad is most effective. This is standard for companies. however they often do it with a sub page instead (e.g. rosettastone.com/phelps for when his ads on.)

Still, I think you're right. Besides the nice feeling of chopping something, even if just onions or peppers or cukes or zukes, with a big knife and the small amount of time these things save..

Here's what happend when I bought a 'brix n mortar' onion dicer at walmart: I got it home, unpackaged it, tried to put an onion thru.

It had serious problems dicing onions: probably for 'safety' (read lack of lawsuits from people who would carelessly dice their fingers when washing it or something like that) they dumb it down so blades are quite dull. It kind of smushes hte onion instead, making a huge mess and wasting alot of the onion. Needless to say, I'm skipping cheap gadgets now.

by dmambo

Anybody use Slacker.com/Slacker portable? I bought myself the Christmas gift of a 1st gen Slacker portable radio. I think it's a great concept. You can create custom "radio stations" and they push up to 4GB of licensed music to the player which can be used offline. A basic membership is free. I've only been at this for a couple of weeks, but I love it. As much music as I need for a TOTAL investment of $70 for the HW.

by oz_media

At first glance i am thinking, so what, its programmable internet radio?

There are dozens of FREE internet radio sites that let you build and broadcast your own internet radio station. I don't bother because if I need music, I throw it in my MP3 player, burn a quick disk for the car etc.

But the handheld G2 looks pretty cool! okay so its a portable internet radio station, with a subscription service and customizable playlists, now that's pretty interesting, not completely unique but still more than worthy.

The handheld looks like its a Janam device, any ideas who made it?

they may want to reword their marketing though. "UNLIMITED SKIPS!" Okay they mean skipping through playlists but it sounds like they mean it will skip without limitation. :D

Looks pretty neat, only in America, eh? Pity. ;)

by dmambo

It has a beautiful screen, but with no true Internet access, it's basically good for displaying album art. It's also a bit of a brick. But can't quibble for the price I paid. No idea who the mfgr is.

It's nice because it can be offline for up to a month and still play. Replaces XM in my view. And you can't beat free. If you like DJ interruptions, that's available with the pay service. I prefer the radio aspect so I can hear more cuts than I would with music that I own.

Yeah, only for US market. I guess I didn't really think about that.

by oz_media

the issue with ALL manufacturer's now is what to send to offshore manufacturing and what not to.

Take RBH for example: Their Signature series is built in Layton Utah. The rest of their product line is mixed. They spin aluminum drivers in the USA, design and build their own capacitors, baskets, baffles, etc in the USA and shop all the parts to China for assembly. This actually STILL works out less expensive than a US manufacturing plant. american made, assembled in China.

A lot of other companies use the exact same warehouse/assembly plant in China and they just pull from mass parts bins. For example, Wharfedale will roll down the same assembly line as Kenwood, JL audio, Klipsch etc. They simply select parts from a catalogue and build a product at the same plant.

Then there are the true Chinese products that are mass amrketed at retail outloets like Future Shop and Best Buy, not worth discussion.

As for Sennheiser, my friend picked up some really nice heaphones at Christmas, back to teh $200.00 mark though and noise cancelling were much more.

P.S. Did you read about the noise cancelling headphones Bose tried ot pawn off to the US military? The military wanted headphones and bought on name brand, but when they were received they didn't do what they were supposed to, sounded like crap and didn't cancel most noise. After retrofitting jets to allow for the proprietary (and outdated) Bose plug, they ended up replacing all the panels again to accept the new headphones, after kicking Bose to the curb.

You just have to be careful, don't buy anything CHEAP (there is no such thing as cheap/quality in electronics)and DO YOUR HOMEWORK FIRST!!!

by oz_media

Know them very well, been there many times, great staff and VERY clever management!

rE 901'S, I'd still pass on the 901's in that case though and go for something commercial (I'M AN AUDIO SNOB).

by jamesrl

..Bay Bloor advertises their lineup of Bose.....

When I did some work with bands and helped out my roomate who worked at a record company, I got used to 901s. Its kinda the baseline for small band loudspeakers. I'm sure you could get better for less. When my audio engineer friend went to work for Tannoy, I got to hear cheaper better sounding competitors.

James

James

by oz_media

I had Tannoys on my Pioneer Spec 1&2 system. It was worth a mint (even when I got it used for over $10K) and the speakers absolutey thundered.

Tannoy makes great cabs and commercial products for live recording too.

by oz_media

not to be a know it all but hopefully explain how/why it works.

Its is subjective. A high end speaker is usually far more efficient, this means it is able to reproduce fair sound pressure levels at low input.

Speaker sensitivity is generally tested by sending 2.83V signal and testing the output volume in dB from 1 foot away.

You are right in that cheap speakers, generally with weak magnets and loose motor structures, play with low input. However the sound reproduced at that level is generally abysmal. As I noted in my BOSE comments, th frequency range was displayed as +-10dB (with +-3dB being teh normal test procedure).

This means that a sound in the high range (18-20kHz will be no more or no less than 3dB diffent in volume from other sounds in the main range). A cheap speaker will nto reproduce these sound without an extreme change in volume (Bose was tested with poor frequency response even allowing for a 10dB change!).

So if yuo are listening to music at low volume, say 23dB-25dB and you frequency graph shows a variation of 10dB in teh low and high range, when it is supposed ot play those notes, it will be so quiet as not not even be heard, so you miss a good portion of your music entirely.

Ever listened to a favorite disk on a good stereo and hear sounds, ambiance, background sounds etc. that you'd never heard/noticed before?

I live in an apartment and keep my volume low, yet I have a pretty rare, high-end integrated amp (late 1980's Harman Kardon PM665 high current capable in champagne gold, my pride and joy)and ScanDyna speakers (1970's, Danish built, rare as hell, one-offs from the beginning of the ScanSpeak and Dynaco merger).

I can play it at almost inaudible volume and still hear all of the bass, treble, upper midrange etc. You can even tell the distance of instruments form eth microphones as teh imaging and soundstage is incredible even at VERY low volumes.

In fact for people in apartments, the better systems are the best bet. You don't have to turn it up to hear the fullness and rich textures to detailed music.

In a big home, some cheap Kenwood towers with gaint paper woofers are usually just fine, crank 'em and party away.

by magic8ball

Good site. I could spend way more time than I probably should there. I really couldn't find too much information on them a few years back after I bought them. They do have a a gold ribbon nameplate across the top of each speaker. I will have to check the model number when I get home tonight to be certain. Unless they are knock offs or something. I dont know about your area but several years back there were a few of the 'white van' type speaker outfits trying to sell their crappy knock offs in the Albuquerque area. Had to laugh at them whenever I was approached by them a couple of times at college.

by oz_media

White Van guys are all over the globe, selling knock offs.

BOK, is a name they used for knock off BOSE (same lettering an all).

Klearwood was the Kenwood knock offs, They even had a JBC (JVC).

I know them all too well, believe me. And its always teh same story, "we were just on our way back to the warehouse and have extra speakers to clear out or the boss will be PO'd."

a friend picke dup some actual kenwood towers in the late 80's, he couldn't afford the Missions I sold at the time. They wanted $499.00, he's pretty shrp so he ended up getting them for $99.00. Taking them apart there were two drivers that had no connections (not passive radiators just unconnected drivers) and no crossover at all.

I trip to Radio Shack got the all working good for less than $20.00 ( I had some 2nd order crossovers laying around myself).

They are STILL in use, after being played in the garage for years, dragged to big beach party's, campign trips etc. They now sit in another friend's living room and do he job, playing loud, thumpy rock music.

For the most part (99.99999% of the time) the White Van guys are something to run screamign from, but if you play your cards right, you can get a cheapo deal from them anyway.

by oz_media

Telarc makes the absolute BEST digital reproductions, for Jazz and Classical available.
Well next to Chesky records of course, but that's a one off shot with him and always vinyl.

by jamesrl

I only have it on vinyl, so I don't play it that often....back on the good old days when the Columbia record club had CBS Masterworks titles as part of the buy 10 albums for a dollar promo. :)

James

by oz_media

The recoding is intense, it comes with a warnign to run at low levels until yuo know it won't kill your speakers. They used genuine 18th century field cannons, recoded digitally, said to be the best cannon recording ever recorded.

It was my fav demo for years, they also have a Telarc disk called Time Warp, which is a collection of Sci Fi movie tracks. 2001 Space Oddyssy, Star Trek, Star Wars etc. another great demo CD to really show off your system.

1812- 3 releases http://www.concordmusicgroup.com/search/?

Time Warp -
http://www.concordmusicgroup.com/albums/Time-Warp/

YOu won't be disappointed with either recording the sonic quality is second to none, no matter how well your system performs.

by nicknielsen

POMM POMM POMMM[b]ka-BOOM![/b]POM-POM-POM-POM-POM-POM-POMMM[b]ka-BOOM![/b]

Another Macallan moment!

Edit: fix html

by jamesrl

In high school the senior band played it, and we recruited a few extra percussionists. I was playing the drum set, someone else the tympani, someone else the bass drum, someone on the "crash" cymbals and yet another person playing a garbage can.

I was using the edge of the snare to throw in the odd rifle shot between snare rolls, bass drum thumps and cymbal slams. At some point my enthusiasm got the better of me and the tip of the stick broke and went spinning off into the woodwind section. I just turned the sticks around and played with the "fat" ends.

Later in life I heard the Toronto Symphony play it at Ontario place. They used the 4.5 inch guns of the WWII Canadian destroyer the Haida to add some thunder. They had to use radios to signal as the Haida was docked a few hundred yards away. They couldn't heard the orchestra well, but no one could not here them. The Haida was moved so it won't happen again, but I am so glad I was there for it.

James

by jdclyde

Although after over a decade of being a shop rat, my hearing is so damaged it isn't worth it to buy a high end system.

I guess in a few years I would be interested in upgrading my surround system to something that thumps more, but it won't be a bose system.

by oz_media

living in the US I suppose it isn't much of a problem for you anyway.

I figured it would be the other way around though, paid service = no DJ interruptions.

I'd pay to get Howard Stern off the airwaves anyday, what a loser. We have a local jock here called Bro Jake, (rock 101), he's a complete tosser.
I can't listen to his grade 4 hunour for more than 10 seconds between songs before I change channels, however he is popular in his small demographic anyway (though he's sunk that station pretty well now).

by tig2

Regarding BOSE- I have a BOSE iPod dock. I like it okay. But then, unless I'm listening to the SO's iPod, I pretty much tune it out. It's purpose in life is to provide a bit of noise so that I don't get too distracted. Yeah- I know. Counter intuitive but it works for me. If it is the SO's iPod it just irritates me- we don't have the same taste in music. That isn't the fault of the dock though.

I will admit that I thought the disclaimer was a bit on the side of too far. We have been making off-topic posts for ages and this is the first I have ever seen one with a disclaimer. So I figured I would make it my mission to bump it back to the top of the discussion page. I can only assume that someone got their panties in a twist over an off topic post that made the front page. Must have missed that one. Frankly, Oz, I am surprised that you went to such lengths.

Love ya, Ozzie. I don't intend to berate you with that. Whoever had the snit fit over off topic posts is my target.

by oz_media

Political posts, music posts etc. There always seems to be some n00b who whines and needs to be told how to navigate the site, it's been going on for years. With this one completely off topic, I just wanted to stop a possible lengthy side thread of people jumping on someone for bitching.

by nicknielsen

Realistic? I have no idea where Clarion came from; I can only blame confusion caused by a low caffeine condition. :D

by oz_media

Radio Shack! Sparkomatic days!

actually, BOSE also designed a speaker specifically for sale at Radio Shack in the mid 80's, the 601.

by nicknielsen

And the original 501 as well. Based on simple "listenability" (is that a word? it is now!), I much preferred either to the 901s. The original 501 and 601 series speakers actually had woofers in them (10" & 8" respectively) and, to me, provided a much more natural sound than the 901s ever have.

by jamesrl

...we all wanted the Realistic Mach 1 Speakers with the 15" woofer, so we could blow our windows out...

That was the late 70s.

James

by nicknielsen

The first time, the fireworks show was synchronized to the music; it was pretty impressive, but didn't sound too much like cannons.

The second time I saw it done, they used aerial flash-bangs to simulate the cannon bursts. That was really impressive, especially since you could only hear the firework itself over the music and not the mortar.

Every other time I've seen the 1812 performed, it has been in a theater and they used a huge bass drum.

by oz_media

Like I said, whateve sounds good to you.

I am speaking more from years of watching them get weaker and weaker, while trying to imitate new technology without implementing it due to their base design requiring old technology.

by hal 9000

If anything I thought that the BOSE came off looking better than they actually are.

About the only plus is when you need to move house the Bose Enclosures are no where near the weight of something like a AR9 Enclosure that gives you a Hernia attempting to lift it. :D

Someone thought I was being weak getting 2 people to carry one enclosure even though it was about 6 feet tall it just couldn't be heavy enough to warrant the need for 2 people to carry. :0

Oh I see you are posting [b]Off Topic[/b] Posts again Naughty Boy :D :^0

Some people are bound to get upset as this isn't computer related unless you use Bose Speakers as a surround sound system on your PC of course. :p

Col

by oz_media

I have a pair in the early 90's, they were gorgeous and sounded great but, as you say, you pretty much need a separate moving truck for them as tey are bigger than most of my furniture, and far heavier! Make nice tables/mantles though.

the surround system from BOSE was exactly what lead me to post this, as per reading another forum (which I don't post to) and noticing someone arguing that there is no better surround system than BOSE and that he challenged anyone to name one company that put out a better product.

Needless to say there was a list offered by at least 5 different people of dozens of FAR better products. So I went looking for this review, which I had seen some timme ago. Instead of posting it there, I figured it would be more mature conversation here. (hee, hee, I said MATURE, hee, hee) :p

by hal 9000

The only real problem with the AR's besides the weight is that the Bass Drivers regularly blow the Outer Cone Ring. You can only have the drivers re doped and the roll replaced so many times before they start sounding strange well not right.

Currently I have to replace the Bass Drivers again but I can't afford the Transport of the actual Drives as there are 4 of them so that sort of meant 2 completely over loaded Semis to carry all 4 of the drivers, While the drivers are a tad expensive the Transport for them is Horrendous.

Currently I have a Set of 91 doubling as NB Stands the 9's are just too big to do much with. :D

I still maintain that those first set of 18's I bought for $200,090 odd are far Superior to any offering by Bose but they are certainly not small or thin even for a 2 way bookshelf speakers they are big and heavy which is defiantly not something you'll ever see from Bose. Nice Light unsealed plastic enclosures if you don't like good sound though I suppose but why pay that for them when you can use what comes with a Off the shelf system that sound as good for nuthing?

I actually went in to pickup some tapes recently and the new guy behind the counter tried to sell me some Bose Speakers cus in his words that [b]Where simply the best[/b] but I still insist that he misread the advertising and was mistakenly using Best instead of beast. :D Luckily for that idiot salesperson the owner came in and saved him from me by telling him this is a [b]Real Customer[/b] not a passer by. He then told me that No I wasn't allowed to enjoy myself at his staff expense. :^0

Col

by thmiuatga

BOSE makes good speakers. Most people aren't sound engineers or musicians. I'm not an engineer but I'm a practicing guitarist. It depends on the personal taste of the individual anyway. I have a pair of 501 Series IV's I bought back in 85 when I lived in the Netherlands but I bought a pair of Cerwin Vega D3E's (that I still have)first. It comes down to what you hear and I have a musically eclectic taste. turn on the stereo and the sound will be different after the circuits warm up than when they are first started up. Introduce DBX noise reduction or Dynamic range expansion (224X & 3BX III units I own)the soundscape changes. The general objects of any room affects the acoustics first of all and the type of wiring to the speakers is a factor.

For me, the combination of the Bose and the Cerwin Vega setup is a balance as the Bose covers the low to mid-range and the Cerwin Vega's handle the mid-range to high levels.

But as I said, physical placement and room acoustics ARE a factor.

A friend of mine had a pair of Klipsch speakers which he said could not be blown and he ended up blowing one of the pair.

There is no need to exceed the rated wattage for any speakers. turning it up loud doesn't mean it will sound good and if you have to yell to talk to anyone in the room, it's too loud.

You check the amplifier's wattage against your speakers and make sure that the speakers exceed the rating of the amp to give you a safety margin, not below. You turn it up to the point of distortion, you're only damaging your hearing and making others mad.

There are rules for speaker placement for optimum sound quality but as I said it all goes back to personal preference.

Maybe you have serious issues with BOSE and that's rather obvious. I have a 24 year history with owning and using their product as well as Cerwin Vega, DBX, AKAI, Pioneer, Denon and Technics (known also as Matsushita Electronics Corp LTD).

You either deal with it and go on or you let it rule you.

by cmiller5400

No need to call people stupid.

If you had been reading the board for a while you would know that Oz is a music person. I on the other hand know virtually nothing about sound systems and am glad to have another peer let me know when something may be overpriced for the quality.

Granted some of it may be personal preference, there is nothing wrong with stating your opinion. Just do it in a nice way.

by oz_media

You know I can play that game too, I don't mind, but thanks for your support all the same. ;)

by nicknielsen

When most people think of Bose, they think of the 901s or the Wave radio, neither of which, IMO, performs at an acceptable level. Your 501s are in fact, one of only two models of Bose speaker that I would consider purchasing, and even at that they are overpriced.

BTW, calling somebody names just because their opinion differs from yours seems pretty stupid to me...

by oz_media

Bose did make a couple fo good direct reflecting models. Even the 301's have a place in your home, if you can find that specific sweet spot.

I just lik ehow he repeated pretty much everything I had already said but did it in a defensive way, indicating that he had either misread or didn't fully read my comments before posting his little rant.

Kinda funny though, dumb, dumb face, poopy head!

by oz_media

First of all, I have already said that personal preference is the key and no, I'm not stupid, nor sucker enough to buy into marketing.
What I did say was thay they are overpriced and overmarketed, you can get FAR better for FAR less, which is a plain fact whether you like it or not.

Sound:
You mean the room makes a difference? Is that what accoustic treatment is for then?

Funny you should say that actually, as that is the key drawback with BOSE; if you so much as move an ashtray on a table you change the DRS and the imaging is lost. It's almost impossible to replicate the sound at the showroom when you are at home. Which is exactly why BOSE doesn't let you A>B them in a normal sound room with other manufacturers products for side by side comparison.

Cheap build: for today's home theatres they offer NO magnetic shielding, not even a second rear cap on the motor structures, what is this 1976? The cone materials are lightweight, untreated and prone to warpage through excursion (distortion and inaccurate presentation). Also essentially damaging your LCD panel and making the speaker lose any hope of timbre matching, thus making it the equivalent of a $299.99 surround-sound-in-a-box package (however even they are usually shielded).

The focus to my original post was that BOSE speakers are OVERPRICED and OVERHYPED, like SONY, which you haven't touched on at all.

People believe in marketing hype so much that they will fool themselves into thinking they sound better than they actually do. Your defensive comments reiterate that perfectly.

I've done such tests myself, taken a crap pair of speakers and told a client how fantastic they will sound because they use Linkwitz-Riely 2nd order crossovers (standard)and stamped steel driver baskets, and polycarbonate woofers, as any $150.00 speaker will. The customer then is in awe when listening to them.

Then you play a real set of speakers and tell them how the bottom end sounds muddy (they quickly nod and agree), how the upper register is reserved etc.
"oh yes, I know what you are saying, I can hear it now!...what does reserved mean?"

Of course I would never recommend anything based on such deception but its always fun to demonstrate to a customer that they will buy what they are told to buy and to them teach them a little about sound, quality, sales terminology, what to look for or avoid when comparing models for themselves etc.

Take for instance the restaurant test where they fill up empty water bottles from a garden hose and sell them inside as gourmet water at different prices. Customers will swear that they taste different and that the $9 bottle tastes far more natural than the $2 bottle, when its all from a garden hose out behind the restaurant. It's simply done by using closed ended questions to drive atonement.

I've been into marketing, sales and psychology for over 30 years, even the most astute people don't realize how easily they are fooled and lead to believe in things that simply are not true, just look at all the BS people begin to spew around election time, regardless of their party choice. One slags the other and people buy into it and start repeating it without even investigating it to find out it is ocmplete BS.

Are you also suggesting that you can actually hear a good speaker at low volumes? No, I already said that(and explained SPL level measurements), you wouldn't simply repeat me in order to correct me, would you?

Personal tastes differ? I heard that somewhere else already, oh yeah I said it several times in my replies too, that's right.

BUT...
Wire does make a LOT less difference than you think though. I've seen two $6000.00 (yes, six THOUSAND DOLLARS) cables (guaranteed to sound better than anything you've heard before) tested on high end product at an electronics demo in Utah. after more than 40 tests with various cables, amps and speakers, there was no discernable or electronically measurable difference between them and standard 16/4 low voltage wire used in most new homes. But you'll probably disagree because your system has proven otherwise I suppose.

I don't disagree that at least 16 guage wire must be used and a tighter copper twist helps carry the Low Voltage Signal, but the LVS is the key here; you dont need a big pipe to carry a low voltage signal, you don't lose anything at all. Even in $250,000.00+ custom home theatre rooms, 16/2 or 14/2 is standard wiring, not fat cable.

Almost anything that fills a spade, banana plug or binding post is enough, and they are all designed for 14-16 guage.

Thanks for your comments though, I am sure you are more than happy with your system, I wasn't intending to suggest otherwise.

by magic8ball

Stranded CAT5 cable in my back room setup. Kinda nerdy but it seems to work pretty well. Its what I had laying around when I hooked it up.

by thmiuatga

I said it's personal preference stupid in comparison to the phrase "it's the economy stupid" which is an obvious answer to an obvious question. Since it was taken as hostile, fine. Attack if you want as it is your constitutional right to the freedom to do so; a right I defended in my former military life in peacetime and war.

As for playing nice, I am very civil and probably more accommodating to people and situations I shouldn't tolerate. But I don't put up with BS artists or liars cause you don't solve anything or accomplish anything in the end by deceit so you cannot rightfully claim that people are discriminatory or adversarial towards you if you openly treat others the same way.

And as for so-called professionals, I had a salesperson some years ago try to sucker me during a purchase of a VCR on maintenance. He stated that the video heads needed demagnetizing to which I told him they don't.

When I purchased my laptop in September, I got the full spin about service plans and setting it up for performance from the salesperson of which I informed that I could do myself. After building 4 systems, setting up a personal network with both windows and Linux as well as multi-booting 6 different OS's on a single PC I consider myself quite capable of handling the problems of a self-tech.

I am no expert, and I do not claim to know everything. Just like anyone else, I know a little bit about something and that is that.

by oz_media

On with the rights and blah blah blah. I'm in Canada we don't have a Constitution.

Glad you didn't get your VCR demagnetized.
Super that you know enough not to get suckered into extended warranties.

?wtfwta?

by oz_media

CAT5 is used throughout most homes these days, most rooms get at least 2-4 CAT5 runs. Some are terminated to control pads, others for data, phone etc. used in structured wiring systems and fully automated homes. However, for new home construction I always recommend at least one or two 14/2-4 or 16/2-4 runs also for multiroom music distribution systems.

again, the NEED for largefat cables has been oversold for decades now, becaus esome people mak a living simply selling cables.

That is not a matter pf personal preference or anything else though, it is pure fact that there is no discernable difference to either the naked ear or even through finite electronic tests.

by magic8ball

CAT5 should be better than some wire because of the design to eliminate crosstalk. I know that large wire companies **cough monster cable cough** have sold the bigger is better for a long time.

by oz_media

Will usually have a really good insulator, I've worked with quite a few brands of standard low voltage wire, some cheap from China and others mroe expensive from USA or China, and the more expensive ones DO make a difference. Better copper quality, more strands in the twist, better insulator, makes for better sound.

Beyond that, size really means f-all. If you can hear the difference between 6 guage monster cable, and 14 guage (fair quality) LV wire, you'd be teh first on the planet and have much better ears than computerized test equipment.

Just a decent cable is all you need, whether it is Cat5, LV wire, monster cable etc. Just don't buy the cheapest crap you can find and you are fine.

by dumphrey

to be fair, is an actual audiophile company, unlike Bose.

Lord... I can rant for pages about Bose and their crap. Sub woofer.. Yeah, right. I have 4x6 plates in car's front door that do deeper, cleaner base..
Bose is fine if you just want tiny and sleek. If sound is at all important, please shop around. Take the time to go to a real audio store. Look up reviews. Set a specific budget. Its amazing what you can get instead of Bose.

by oz_media

I think I still have two Marantz amps/receivers. May have sold one though, don't remember off hand.

I still have an excellent Marantz dealer in BC that can get me great pricing but even with the stack of vintage amp etc i have collected over time, nothing even stands close to my Hraman Kardon PM64 (even my Luxman tube amp (circa 1979).

I saw a McIntosh tube ampe a while back, ancient, no fancy case justa block and tubes on top, MAN what a treat! No wife would allow it in her home, not pretty enough but for $3K USED, I think that would be the lasy of most people's problems.
Similar pic of smaller amp here: http://img.alibaba.com/photo/100754535/Mcintosh_Tube_Stereo_Amp_Mc_275_Amplifier.jpg

Seriously, who's wife would let them spend 3 grand on THAT monster!

by oz_media

RBH didn't make AR's, brain fart. Though I really enjoy listening to AR's, RBH was/is responsible for Status Acoustics! SA has got to be the best speaker that has ever filled my ears!

Status Acoustic Decimo's are amazing, now look at what Shane has been designing, the Titus!: $50,000.00/pair and UP, 20POUND (not 20oz) woofers.

Yeah, Shane hasn't even finished designing an internal crossover yet, he's still using an external corrsover system.

Status Acoustics Titus (for that extra $50K we all have laying around): http://www.audioholics.com/news/trade-show-coverage/2006-consumer-electronics-show-ces/status-acoustics-titus-speaker-system

by jamesrl

One of my friends in Ottawa had a good friend who was a doctor, and I house sat for him in the early 80s. He had a great setup with a Luxman tube amp and Boston Acoustics speakers. Very nice setup. I only had a ghetto blaster at the time and I was in heaven.

I was also in heaven because it was a block from a real wood fired oven Montreal style bagel place. Breakfast was hot and fresh bagels, great coffee and listen to good albums.

James

by oz_media

No other bagel comes cloes to comparing to a Montreal bagel! I argued against that until I had atually had one and now I am in complete agreement, they really ARE the best you can buy.

Stick to your mouth like peanut butter but worth every second of it.

by jamesrl

As bad as Bose if you ask me - fine cable but not needed and very overpriced.

The big laugh I remember from the 90s was "directional" speaker wire -which they told us had to be oriented using the arrows printed on the plastic - what a crock of nonsense.

James

by oz_media

They colour teh crossovers to offer that high end "clarity". Yes it does sound shrill to many,but without crossover adjustments, you'd have no high end detail at all.

The problem is thw design is out dated. sicne horns were a good answer to standard tweeters, tweeter design has implemented an aliminum dome, this cap offers unprecedented etail and high end clarity. Nowdays, everyone is used ot that tight, clean high end, whereas at one time it was all about good low midrange and bottom end 'warmth'.

Remember when CD's first came out? Everyone complained that they were too shrill and tinny sounding, they were all used ot DOLBY cassette tapes, now its the acceptable norm. This happened in speakers too, where people have become accustomed to clean crisp high end, but horns just fail..unless in a large cabinet concert configuration fo course. I find a lot of teh older clients my customer work with are tge ones who find horns nice and like the TK series from RBH due to the fibreglass cones (like B&W) which sound warmer with a mellow low-midrange.

by dumphrey

but I kinda expect clean response across the board. the paradigms I have do tend to be more "top" heavy, but thats the titanium dome tweeter. Over the years they seem to have mellowed out some.

by oz_media

they STILL sell that crap to unsuspecting clients, at a ridiculous price.

This is what really PO's me about the industry as a whole too, people are suckers but don't want to tell a sales rep they don't know or disagree with them (making them feel ignorant) and they let the industry dictate to them, just like marketing crappy new acts that labels pick up.

"Sounds great, RIGHT?" yes.
"You can hear the clarity in the high end, RIGHT?" yes.

Closed ended questions lead consumers without them realizing it.

Compared to:
"How do you think they sound?"
"Do you like the high end? Too forward, too reserved?"

That's how to find out what the customer really thinks without leading them. It asks for opinion and for them to listen and respond based on what they haar, not what you tell them they are hearing.

by thmiuatga

I recall one of my former compadre's some years back that had a pair of 501's and I think the difference between his and mine was the style of the cabinet.

Anyway, I had my 501's in storage out of state (SC where i used to live) and when I did get them home, I had to replace the woofers because they deteriorated. i replaced them with another set of a different brand but the same watt and ohm specs. can't tell the difference.

Sadly the woofers in my Cerwin Vega's have suffered the same fate so I will have to replace them. Luckily, I have locations of dealers and retailers for Cerwin Vega.

But back in 84 in the Netherlands, a friend of mine had two pairs of 901's and wanted to get the DBX subharmonic synthesizer. Another friend and I urged him not to because he was already rattling the walls of our barracks with those speakers and the eq unit needed for them. I always viewed the 901's as odd balls and you needed the space to set them up in first and then everything else around them.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

some of us haven't the moolah to spend on speakers. Doesn't matter how much we love music, moolah is the issue.

by jamesrl

Unless you buy Bose...

I paid $200 a pair for my baby Advents. They are much better built than many more expensive speakers. Use your ears and you will find something. My speakers have lasted 20 years and no signs of need for replacement.

James

by dumphrey

I still have a pair of those. I have never been able to part with them. Have em set up in the bedroom.

by oz_media

Don't get suckered into press, go for what sounds best to your ears for your budget.

I picked up a pair of circa '78 Yamaha speaker (made in the USA not China!)for free off CRaigslist. They will outperform most Bose models and anything new under $1000.00.

I got a pair of vintage, VERY rare ScanDyna's for $150.00 (very expensive new)and I have put them up against $2500.00 towers with subs in my soundroom, only to be just as happy listening to the ScanDyna's.

Speakers don't have to be new either, there is excellent vintage and pre 90's product readily available. In fact I prefer vintage equipment to new, next to the latest massive tube amps but those ARE way out of my budget anyway.

by dumphrey

it doesn't have to be expensive. There are many bookshelf speakers in the $180 - $400 bracket that will sound much better, with better staging then many towers costing 4x as much. Its just a matter of finding the right ones =)
A pair of Athena LS-100's can be had new for ~$100 US. They should last a good 20 years. These are well built, well designed speakers. You don't pay for their advertising.
A solid Dennon Stero amp is ~$400. A Yamaha cd player ~$80. (An optical output on the cd player, and an optical input on the amp will let you bypass the cheaper DAC's on the cd player and use the better DAC's on the amp for improved sound quality).

Oh, and investing in even the lowest grade Monster speaker cable is better then zip cord or other cheep wire. Speaker wire does make a difference. But that's pretty much the last stop on the train.

$580 system that will kill (in terms of clarity, sound stage, and enjoyment) many costing $2-3k. Don't expect THX levels, but solid audiophile doesn't need massive volume. Its quality, not quantity =)

by oz_media

You menationed that you are having problems with older drivers falling apart on you. Is it the foam surrounds that you are talking about or the cone material itself?

If its the foam surround, just take teh speakers in to almost any hi-fi shop or speaker shop and they should be able to replace them easily with Butyl rubber surrounds.
That's what I did with my Scandynas, that way you keep the drivers, in my case coated paper that is an incredible sound, way better than newer polypro. The drivers are vintage and nothing sounds like that at the same price these days, so new surrounds it was and what a great solution as I would never get the exact same imaging from newer materials.

by puppybreath

Is that also true for their noise cancelling headsets (overpriced)?

I've been looking around for a good set for air travel and all of the reviews seem to put Bose at the top of the list.

Can anyone recommend an alternative that would be the same quality at a lower price?

by oz_media

Okay first one didn't work, patch cord fell out. :D

Sennheiser, have got to be the best noise cancelling headphones on the market, as far as many profesionals go, Senn's are the preferred playback headphones and AKG 260's are the popular studio headphone.

All the current models available in the USA.
http://www.sennheiserusa.com/newsite/category.asp?transid=cat8

The Bose NCH story:
Many moons ago, the US Air Force went looking for a Noise Cancelling Headphone provider. Bose won the bid based on their market visibility and popularity.

Due to using old technology, BOSE used an old adapter which meant the AUAF had to retrofit the planes with new inputs. After testing they found the BOSE to be useless and denied the remainder of the contract. BOSE then sold them all to commercial airlines to get rid of them and claim the aviation slot.

Today they have improved and they are used in the USAF, and you don' want a pair nor want to spend that much money. ;)

Best of luck with Senn's, really worth the money, I know several peers here that here already use and prefer them too.

by hal 9000

These are simply the best possible Headphones that you can buy.

I actually don't know of any Broadcast station that doesn't use them. Even a Cheap Community Based Station here where they have a Shed Load of Rubbish insist on Sennheiser Headphones for all On Air People.

The Announcer there thought that they where just Cheapies like the rest of the stuff in that place then they started to go missing. Maybe not a good idea to tell people just how good these things are. :D

Col

by oz_media

You can always take just the woofers in to a local (I know it's Australia, within 500kms) shop and get them to put on butyl rubber surrounds instead of foam ones that rot and crack. They'll be so tight for the first 15 hours it'll be like breaking in brand new speakers! :D

Seriously though, the rubber surround replacements don't hinder or change the sound and will last for a goood 20+ years, and it costs f-all to get done. I had my Scandyna's done and they are excellent.

by hal 9000

Before the drivers start sounding not quite right. Here they Dope the Cones and then apply the Butyl Rolls.

I've had that done so often that it's not an option at the moment. Besides the places that do this complain about the weight of these drivers. :D

Col

by sleepin'dawg

Assuming price isn't an obstacle, what's best for someone whose primarily unterested in jazz with some classical thrown in. Occasionally some G&R, Zep and Metallica might get some play time.

Right now using a pair of Dayton-Wrights cica '75, with a subwoofer that was added in '84 - '86 a pair of Radcliffes circa '80 and a pair of B&W D6s. They're all in different parts of the house; the Radcliffes and B&Ws still perform well and SWMBO has gotten used to them(sort of).

The problem is the Dayton-Wrights. They're monsters. The sub woofer doesn't take up too much space but the main speakers themselves, are monsters; approx 30" X 66" X 3.5" plus air compressor. These are slectro-static speakers and were state of the art in '75 when I was somewhat involved with the audio equipment business but time moves on and so has my involvement. I still have dealer pricing available to me but the question is what to buy. Each one of my guys has a different opinion, which is to be expected, but I've got to admit I have no idea what their private musical interests might be. I think that would have a bearing on the type of speakers I should be auditioning. What would you advise for jazz along the lines of "The Modern Jazz Quartet" "Joe Pass" "Oscar Peterson" etc.

[b]Dawg[/b]