Discussion Locked

Both CD RW & DVD ROM doesnot work in XP

0 helpful
15 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello Techrepublic,
This is a typical problem for which I have no solutions so far. I have an assembled un-branded computer with XP-Pro-SP2.
The problem, as described below, is there since before & after installing SP2.
ISSUE:
Both of my CD RW drive(AOPEN CD-RW CRW2040) and DVD ROM drive(LG DVD-ROM DRD8160B) cannot read any CDs or DVDs as applicable and gives error msgs
1. "Please insert a disk into drive D:" &
2. "The disk that you have put in drive E: is not formatted."
Also if I want to burn a blank CD, it gives error msg "The format of the CD you inserted is not recognised or the CD might be damaged or corrupted, try another CD".
In Device Manager properties for the individual drives, there are NO errors reported & everything looks perfectly normal.

Now, I have found interesting fact after doing some research on this.
1. In Safe mode both the drives can read all CDs perfectly. Also can play all music files ok from any CDs.

Just to be in the safe side, I have re-installed the drivers for both the drives -- good for nothing.

FYI, I have the Norton internet security- Professional version installed in my pc. Dont know if it can create any problem !!!! Disabling the firewall and antivirus doesnot help.

I have change the BIOS settings to defaults , but still no good.

I need help from you on this issue. I am guessing that my hardwares are fine, only some programs ( better to says SERVICES) creating problem for the drives to malfunction. Whats is it ?

Thank you in advance for any support extended to me.
Ciao,
Sub

15 replies

by cg it

Stab in the dark here and TheChas is the hardware guru but some CD-RWs DVDs dont like to be on the same channel as each other or the master/slave/cable select configurationon each drive might be causing the problem.

Further, Windows associates programs for CDs DVDs meaning that if a music CD is inserted, then your music program like windows media player will automatically open, or if a blank CD is inserted then your burning software program like Nero or Roxio will open automatically. If no program is choosen, you should have a window pop up asking you to choose a program. Since this works in Safe Mode, and safe mode is basically not loading any drivers so on the surface this would appear to be a driver issue. However if its a driver issue, Windows would normally not boot than boot but not use your removable media devices.

by kakatua

Well, I need to provide you with more information on this. Both of my CD & DVD drives were working fine for the past 2 years, and I have all necessary DVD codec & the latest WMP installed. MOREOVE, (I forgot to give this info in my original Question) if a CD is inserted in either DVD or CD Drive & the computer is restarted, then the CD works fine, WMP opens the CD automatically & even my NERO can burn CDs absolutely ok. Which means the motherboard or CD/DVD drivers are working absolutely fine. Problem comes when I open the CD/DVD tray & reinsert the same CD. Thenthe drives cannot recognise the CDs. Isn't this weird ? Now what do you think is happening ?

by thechas

First off, the drivers that come with your CD and DVD drives are NOT used by Windows. These are the DOS mode drivers.

What you need, is the IDE controller driver for your motherboard. Windows is either using the wrong, or an out-dated driver for the chip-set on the motherboard.
I usually use the latest "reference" driver from the chip-set manufacture.
You are safe using the latest driver from the motherboard manufacture.

You may need to remove all 3 IDE controllers (Primary, Secondary, Root Hub) from device manager and re-boot to correct the problem.

Then, for CD-RW disks, you can either use the application built into XP, or the commercial application of your choice.

To watch DVD movies, you will need to install a codec, or DVD player application.

Chas

by kakatua

Well, I need to provide you with more information on this. Both of my CD & DVD drives were working fine for the past 2 years, and I have all necessary DVD codec & the latest WMP installed. MOREOVE, (I forgot to give this info in my original Question) if a CD is inserted in either DVD or CD Drive & the computer is restarted, then the CD works fine, WMP opens the CD automatically & even my NERO can burn CDs absolutely ok. Which means the motherboard or CD/DVD drivers are working absolutely fine. Problem comes when I open the CD/DVD tray & reinsert the same CD. Thenthe drives cannot recognise the CDs. Isn't this weird ? Now what do you think is happening ?

by wcp

The fact that the both CD-RW and DVD-ROM work in Safe Mode indicates that it is not hardware issue.

The problem could be due to driver, application, or Windows.

1. Driver: If you had the problem before you installed driver, the driver may not be the cause. However, uninstall both CD-RW and DVD-ROM from the Device Manager and let Windows find them again. You can do this by rescanning in Device Manager or simply restarting Windows. Windows will install the right driver.

2. Application: I had a few instances that Norton caused the problem. Norton says it is a timing conflict between the antivirus program and the CD-RW (DVD-ROM) software. The error message I got was ?incorrect function?. Nevertheless, this is most likely the cause. Disabling Norton after starting up may not make any difference. You have to disable Norton from starting up. Uncheck Norton from MSCONFIG and reboot Windows normally. If this resolved the problem, you know that Norton is the cause. Simply uninstall and reinstall Norton. http://tinyurl.com/uw0k

3. Windows: Sometimes CD-RW and DVD-ROM do not behave well in Windows XP. You may need to tweak Registry.
Do Method 1 in http://tinyurl.com/yt4uk if UpperFilters or LowerFilters exists.

by kakatua

The above solution didn't help me out. I disabled all instances of Norton Secuirty (firewal,AV, bla bla bla)& rebooted my pc. Still same error in drives. Then I deleted the upper & lower filters in Registry, & rebooted, still same error. No good. Whats else solution you have pls.

by kakatua

Due to the difficulty level of the problem, I am doubling the techpoint value. IF anyone can solve my problem, then I will give him extra surplus points too.

by ggovier

I have the same problem.
I can not correlate it to SP2, but it sounds plausible, I did update XP Home around when it failed.
Two LG drives, GSA-4040B (DVD RW), and GCE-8160B (RW). Both give the same error you describe. I've tried with power diconnected to either, no results. Answer 2 sounds possible, but you seemed to dismiss it. Did you try it? Let me know if you find a fix. ggovier@shaw.ca

by kakatua

Here I give you more info on this issue.. My issue is still unresolved, though I came to know of the reason..
I have changed motherboard, drivers, blown out the drivers for CDRW & DVDROM drive, but so far no good. Only when I reinstalled windows in my new hard drive, & used the same motherboard & CD drives, I came to know of the reason... The issue is Windows security updates.. Till the time I didnot install any MS Security patch, I was fine.. When I did a windows update with latest security patches, I have the same problem again.. Now it is very difficult to understand which patch is creating problem.. Some patches cannot be uninstalled too.. And you cannot stay connected to internet without proper security to your browser.. So I dont know the solution...

by chau96

since you have 2 different type of CD RW and DVD Rw on your machine; when you start up your window with one type of disk in your rom (either DVD or CD), window will load that particular format and when you insert different type of media, it does not recognize that format.

Solution: Shut down your computer completely for 2 minutes so it flushed out the memory. Remove the media and INSERT TYPE of media (either CD or DVD)that you want to play in the rom then play. If it doesn't play. go to My computer menu and right click property of that drive. and:
1/ select autoplay tab
2/ select an action to perform then close it

hope it helps

by willcomp

Interesting point is that drives work in safe mode.

Since, I believe, safe mode uses PIO access versus DMA, try setting drives to PIO access.

You will find settings in Device Manager -> IDE/ATAPI Controllers. Select primary or secondary channel (as appropriate for you connections) and look at Advanced Settings under Properties.

Will be interesting to see if that is the issue and why a security update caused the problem.

Dalton

by kakatua

I tried setting the drives to PIO access just as you said Dalton. Still didnot work. Just to let you know the drives work fine if I insert the CD or DVD in the drive & then restarts the PC. It will work fine till I open the drive door & insert the same CD/DVD again or any other CD/DVD. Once the drive door is open, nothing works & II get error msg, "Invalid Drive", or "Drive is not accessible, you need to for mat the Drive or check the hardware compatibity of the drive ". If I restart the PC again with the same CD/DVD, it will work fine till the drive door is open. " Weird " isn't it ? :-) Till the past 1 year or may be more, I didnot get any solution on this issue & have started to believe that this might be due to any particular MS security patch that got installed in the last couple of years.

by cray1

I had a similar problem and found my old drivers were at fault, ordered Roxio Easy Media Creator 7 and installed it. With a little tweaking everything works fine now.

by kakatua

Well, Roxio is a software program. My drive does not work even with normal windows explorer. It is inaccessible once I open the drive door. I didnot try Roxio, but tried most other CD writers, All works fine till I open the drive door.

This discussion is closed to new replies.