Tachyon - resulting to name-calling doesn't help. I wouldn't call myself a zealot, but I do think that a lot of what you posted was ignorant (not in the sense of rude and ignorant, but as in 'lacking knowledge). Your second post is perhaps ignorant as in rude.
>Assuming that anyone that dares to call the Mac UI inefficient is just an inexperienced user with an ulterior platform motive is silly.
I said no such thing - I said that anyone calling OS X 'unproductive', especially if they are familiar with Unix, has obviously not investigated it. The large majority of my most was citing specific ways in which 'power users' customise their OS X workflows.
> You can blather on about scripting and configuration and addons. But come on, the type of user that buys a Mac buys a tool, not a toy.
>They don't want to get elbows deep in the guts of the OS. Those users tend to use Linux.
If you're going to talk about facts vs opinions, that is an opinion. There's a lively - if small - community of people out there who have come to the Mac with prior Unix skills.
Mostly, however, I was talking about things like Automator and Applescript that allow people to 'script' without going anywhere near the Unix terminal, and a lot of people do use it - especially people who use Macs as their main working tool. People use UI tweaking tools too, but those rarely seem to be for productivity reasons. You can't get away with complaining about the out of the box experience, then complaining when I tell you how people actually use it.
You can't say 'the type of user that buys a Mac buys a tool, not a toy' and then pretend they're all incapable of actually using anything other than the mouse.
>A perfect example of Apple's stupidity is their complete failure to ship a decent mouse with their systems. Sure the mice look nice, and feel nice to the hand, but 3 buttons and a scroll
>wheel is the minimum these days for making the UI work for you.
Unfortunately for your argument, todays Macs DO ship with a 4 button / scroll-ball mouse. They have finally acknowledged that most of their customers were throwing the shipped mice away and replacing them. Since the 80s. Seems odd to have supported multi-button mice so long without actually shipping them.
On the other hand, I can fully understand why they did it - trying to force developers to focus on working with a one-button device, and thinking about their UI. Face a new user with 3-buttons to choose from and it is far from obvious which button does what. Software developers never actually see that at all. In fact we tend to prefer complex and customisable systems (i.e. Eclipse).
>This meta key click nonsense is annoying and slows your work.
Yep. It does undo the whole single-button point when users NEED to use the meta-keys. And increasingly that has become the problem (even with Apple's own software).
>It ships in it's prettiest, most dumbed down mode which interferes with productivity.
I'd disagree - to a degree - the OOB experience is definitely aimed at making things easy for a new user. On the other hand, features like emacs key bindings in all text windows are also there OOB (they don't need to be turned on) which I don't call 'dumbed down'. I don't quite understand what, specifically, gets in the way of your 'productivity' and as said in my original post, it seems (to me) like you have little interest in improving it. That's fine, so long as you're not going to say it's unproductive compared to a system you have spent time learning. That's like me saying I find French less productive than German.
I also don't automatically equate 'pretty' with 'dumbed down', which seems to be something you do.
>The damn finder is another example. I've never seen such a worthless file manager.
Agreed. I recall it being a POS back in the late 80s trying to use it with networks. I don't think the Finder design has ever scaled to anything much larger than floppies and the very small early HD. Mac users have been complaining about it for years, hence the market for at least 3 replacements. And it looks like, with a job ad last year for a designer to work on the Finder, Apple are about to replace it. On the other hand, I largely use Spotlight or todos (an app launcher) - so I don't really get stressed over the issues you mentioned re. icon ordering. Other people swear by Butler, Quicksilver, etc.
>Every part of the UI wastes space on eye candy, yet Apple always screws you on desktop space. Oh sure, you can get a pro Mac and a megabucks Cinema display and get a
>reasonable desktop size. But OOB, most affordable Macs have pathetic screen resolutions and mice. Look at the iMac/iBook line. Almost worthless for productivity. Apple themselves
>recognize the problem of wasted UI space, why do you think they include Expose' ?
I think that again comes down to opinion. Dock - switch it to hide. Having a single app menu at the top saves space over menus per window. Not really sure which other elements you find wasteful. Perhaps icon size on apps (typically double the size on windows)?
The 13" MacBook supports 1280x800 which seems par for the course on a laptop of that size (same as a top end Sony VAIO). The iMac range also strikes me as having a perfectly reasonable resolution - same DPI as the Cinema Displays (1680x1050 on the 17" model, more on the 20 and 24" models). These things (as with the multi-button mouse) are not difficult to research. For someone who has accused my response of being neither useful or factually based, that is a bit of a small flaw.
>Recently I foolishly decided to use iMovie to put together a short multimedia presentation. What a nightmare. The UI was constantly in the way. You can't even insert stills without first
>importing them into iPhoto. Not to mention how much Apple software won't even install if it doesn't think your hardware configuration is adequate.
Apparently you could have used the 'Import' menu option to do it, but I agree drag and drop into the timeline would have been better. (You can also drag photos in from a folder as a background to a title, but not to make a slideshow. And you can definitely drag a folder of photos into the slideshow builder in iDVD).
For multimedia presentations I'd personally use Keynote - then export to DVD or Quicktime - rather than software designed for importing and editing home movies from DV cameras. But I still don't quite get this 'the UI was constantly in the way' thing. As opposed to what? I'm not saying it's anywhere near perfect but it is fairly simple as far as movie editing software goes.
Intel : I said they are CURRENTLY in the lead. You make the point that they have thrown out the P4 technology as a dead end and copied others. That is the very reason why they are currently in the lead. IBM's new core will probably take the lead, just as the G5 did at the time. Such things are temporary, generally following generation shifts in architecture. (Although I do think that AMD gaining the technological lead, particularly in the server market, has shaken Intel out of their complacency).
mach Kernel : There are constant rumours that it may be ditched (not from reputable sources) along with 'they should use the Linux kernel'. I presume it is a legacy from when NextStep was supported on multiple hardware platforms? (although theNextStep frameworks also ran on top of multiple O/S if I recall)? It's certainly been tweaked and optimised enough to support OS X that no one else wants Apple's fork.It is also probably something down to Apple's stubborn behaviour (one-button mice, Objective-C, Finder, not licencing the OS).
Micro-kernels were one of those ideas - like OO programming - that also make a lot of academic sense and had (have?) a lot of backing in academic circles. The original Linus / Andy Tanenbaum discussions, show how heated the debate was back then. Not that mach is a true microkernel, and both Linux and Windows are moving some drivers out into userland on a pragmatic basis. Anyway, I'm not really that bothered by the debate (as with what CPU they use) - last time I compiled a Unix kernel was 1995.
However, while it may seem a bit of a cop-out to disregard kernel benchmarks, I will say that on some levels it may be a bit like comparing the performance of C code and Java, as people did for the first few years, or hand-coded flat-file access wirth databases - the historical trend is towards abstraction over performance. (On the other hand, if you implement your idea to far ahead of performance - as both Smalltalk and early micro-kernels did - you'll be forever tarred with the 'badly performing' brush). At the end of the day, desktop systems spend most of their time idle and waiting for UI events.
Whether I'd consider running OS X Server to support a web server based on mySQL and apache receiving thousands of requests is another matter of course :-)
>If you are a user who wants a computing tool that is a black box, then Macs can be great, IF you add a real mouse and a decent sized monitor.
>If you want the ultimate in configurability and versatility, go Linux.
>If you want somewhere in between, go Windows XP and lots of security and anti-malware tools.
And this is really the source of my disagreement with your original post.
I won't dispute that Linux is, by a long way, the most versatile OS, but I would definitely dispute that OS X is any way less configurable / versatile / dumber than XP - particularly out of the box. I think you don't have enough knowledge of it to be qualified in making your comparison.
Go back to my previous post and consider how easy it would be to set up the File to Bluetooth phone workflow I discussed, under Windows (I know it would be trivial under Linux). Consider if it would even be possible for a non-programmer to do it.
Ignoring the fact the phone came with Windows client software . . .