Question Locked

Can I sell a product key if I can't use the product?

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I purchased icalendar and I can't use it. They told me that I could print on tabloid paper and that it would print at least 15 events in one day. It does NOT. I know that it can be used on the web, but we already have something in place and do not need this. I have tried to get my money back form them as they claimed (via emails) that it would do what I needed it to do. My delemma is I paid for it, but since we can't use it I hate to ask the church to pay me back. If I could sell it even at a loss I could live with that. The can't get this company to respond in any way to reimburse me.

9 replies

by older mycroft

You have been hard done by. You have bought a product that is 'Not of Merchantable Quality'.

You also have redress through Law. Whether you choose to invoke this redress is a matter of choice for you.

Can you sell it on, knowing that it doesn't work ? If I had bought it from you, I'd be banging on your door demanding my money back.

Perhaps you should try that first. ;)

Perhaps the software company you bought this particular program from are only guilty of having adopted the Printing industry-standard-accepted practice of defining 'tabloid' in slightly looser terms than you perhaps imagined it to be.

By definition 'Tabloid' can vary from 11 x 17 inches to some smaller variation depending on the size of the sheet of paper you start with and the amount of trim.

They may not be as cold-hearted as you imagine.

by 1stpres

I want to thank you for taking time to answer my question...
I'm sorry, I didn't mean to imply the product was BAD. It was just he implied (he said yes)that the product would meet my needs and it does NOT. I was VERY specific for what our needs were BEFORE I purchased the product. I am sure if you want or need a calendar online it works fine. I needed one to print (I found that microsoft DOES have one for free BEFORE I bought this one and I was using it then I did some idiot thing and it wasn't working - I figured it out in desperation since this icalendar did not work).
I just want to sell it, so I can recoup my money somewhat... and I didn't know if it was ok. I would definately send them to the website so they could make up their mind if they could use it or not...

by jdclyde

If it was as you say, then you would have already followed either mine or col's advice and just got your money back for the purchase.

No one in their right mind will pay much for an open package, so even if it IS legal, finding a buyer will not be easy.

Had you followed our advice, you would already have your money back, in full. Why is that?

by thechas

Old Mycroft brings up some valid points and ideas.

In regard to your specific question about selling the product key, the first thing you need to do is read the EULA.

There is usually a section that covers transferring the product to a different user. If you comply with the terms of the EULA, usually removing the software from your computer, you can sell the software. I agree that you should disclose the product limitations to any potential buyers.

One thing about selling the software is that you seldom can sell it for what you paid for it.

Chas

by jdclyde

If they sold you a product that they miss represented, call your credit card company and dispute the charges.

Nothing gets a companies attention like someone pulling money out of their pockets and I am SURE they will talk to you then.

Good luck.

by oh smeg

If you have a Consumer Protection Authority you can contact them and make a Complaint that you have been sold something that failed to do as it was advertised.

Companies dislike Government Authorities just about as much as they dislike not getting the money as they tend to cost them more in Legal Fees dealing with the Bureaucrats.

Only time that I have ever found a use for Bureaucrats and provided that I'm not dealing with them I'm happy.

Col

by older mycroft

http://www.grumbletext.co.uk/

The site is admittedly based in the UK, BUT since the 'net is worldwide, there is nothing to stop the sale of this product on a worldwide basis.

It may lend more power to your case.

by 1stpres

I DID do everything I can do, and I am waiting on my credit card people to decide. They said NOT to get to hopeful.
I emailed the icallendar company via their website, then about 5 days later called - no reply. Then I called my credit card company, and they DID do a temporary credit until they can check it out. However, I was told they didn't think they could do anything. I then directly emailed a return of the money request to the guy that made the promises and included both my previous query and his reply - still no reply. I don't plan to sell the program IF I get my money back, that would be dishonest. BUT I want to recoup it or some of it if I can legally do so...
Does that make sense?
Oh, and it is NOT an open package (unless you are speaking metaphorically). You download the sample program (calendar), then you buy the REAL program in the version you need, they send you a "key" to unlock the program you paid for. It has some great features in that it uses information from your outlook, BUT it isn't what I needed AND I was VERY clear to this guy what I DID need.

This discussion is closed to new replies.