Discussion Locked

Clowns & Harlots: Town Meetings - Democracy in action

0 helpful
15 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

by Christopher Corbett

The end of the winter is still far away when rural New England begins the annual spectacle of unrehearsed, uncensored and too often unbelievable live entertainment that is the annual town meeting.

A town meeting is where all the business in a community is conducted in a daylong event that provides any legal resident with the constitutionally guaranteed right to make a fool of himself. Voters may still get a good hot lunch (cheap, or even free) courtesy of the Patrons of Husbandry or the Order of the Eastern Star, part of a principle understood since ancient Rome -- bread and circuses.

The custom of town meeting is as old as New England, an unchanged constant for centuries. There were town meetings before the states were united. Although a couple of Maine towns have recently abandoned this tradition (abandoning tradition is never a good idea in Maine) most of the state?s 450 towns and villages still hold town meeting.

It is a style of government ideally suited to a community small enough to fit its voters into a hall belonging to the Odd Fellows or the Order of the Eastern Star on a cold March Saturday. Observers of the American scene hail these gatherings as examples of rural man at his best, democracy in its purest form. But as an observer of many a town meeting, I think that?s rather like citing big-time wrestling or roller derby as sport in its purest form.

Some few years ago, Hillary Clinton, who now has grander ambitions, told us that ?it takes a village.? If you?ve ever lived in a village, you know that?s ridiculous. But we?ll let that pass.

On closer examination, a town meeting most resembles another New England pastime: semiprofessional ice hockey. The action is fast and rough.

Rural New England supports a standing army of eccentrics who yearly fuel the town meeting. They assemble early at the back of the hall. From there, the unwarranted comment, catcall or hoot may be most successfully issued. No town or village is too small or too remote to have its own gallery of corner boys and gas station philosophers, fellows who regularly hold up the front of the Farmer?s Union or the bait and tackle: idlers, rogues, the shiftless, poachers, men known to the country sheriff.

Each town boasts its stars whose past performances have earned them certain notoriety. There are the armchair orators, retired judges of probate, born-again fiscal conservatives, defrocked ministers, advocates of holistic medicine, lawyers with lean practices, law students eager for attention, enthusiasts of that old-time religion, former state senators with time on their hands, former state senators? brothers, disc jockeys, deinstitutionalized mental patients, heavy drinkers, deep thinkers, hermits, unpublished poets, self-published poets, the man from the Maine Organic Farmers and Gardeners Association, retired state police sergeants from New Jersey who have moved here to give us the benefit of their wisdom, anti-vivisectionists, one-term congressmen, beekeepers, rednecks, Reds, vegans, objectivists, organic farmers, windmill salesmen and the odd Socialist. I actually lived in a county in Maine with such people.

Some speak in tongues, recognized or not by the chair, red-faced and leather-lunged. Others will strut the aisle, arms waving wildly, reveling in their time in the spotlight. Others tell pointless stories, parables to amaze and confuse. Some merely want to tell a joke or get a laugh. And each man in his time plays many parts. (Some actually quote the bard.)

Town meetings are presided over by a moderator, often a traditionally held post with preference given to former judges or the oldest lawyer in the county seat. It is an office best suited to those who may have missed a calling to the pulpit or an amateur production of Inherit the Wind:

The purpose of a town meeting, if that matters, is to hold local officials accountable and to anguish over every nickel spent. Every leaf-plugged storm drain, dead elm, mad dog and unplowed side road will be vividly recalled. Rural New Englanders -- Maine, New Hampshire and Vermont, primarily -- know how to hold a grudge. (New Hampshire?s motto is ?Live Free or Die? -- that?s not Kumbaya.) Special vitriol is saved for the commissioner of roads, usually guilty only of failing to have psychic powers when it comes to maintaining the community?s byways. In my native state of Maine, ferocious rancor was also reserved in days gone by for the poor little man from the Maine Publicity Bureau, who yearly begged for funds to do that thing that residents of ?Vacationland? most loathe -- promote Maine as a tourist resort.

A year?s worth of town business is painstakingly itemized on the warrant (a document like a racing form) and serious meeting goers follow this line by line. Complex issues, however, are usually avoided. They have little appeal to the average voter, who probably does not understand them anyway. They are more interested in the salaries of town employees, believing that anyone who works for the government can?t possibly be doing a day?s work and is, therefore, overpaid.

Town meetings attract the curious. Tourists, lost skiers, immigrants, visiting professors, graduate students, social scientists, the man from the Boston Globe and perhaps a photographer from the National Geographic Society find these gatherings enriching. They thrill to see the bumpkin in his lair.

When you do not actually have to live in a village, the rustic always seems enchanting (attention, Senator Clinton). Once in a rare while, a stirring moment will occur such as a motion that the bridges between Maine and New Hampshire be dynamited to keep the tourists out. I actually heard someone say that once, but in these nervous times, a man talking like that would wind up in the Kennebec County Jail or Guantanamo Bay. Of course, the man who made this suggestion was being facetious, but he felt better for making the suggestion, and such behavior is, at heart, what a town meeting is all about.

[b][i]Kind of like what off-topic used to be like back when it was called [u]Miscellaneous[/u] and it was easier to navigate your way around TR.[/i][/b]

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

15 replies

by av .

It reminds me of Norman Rockwell's paintings. Actually, its really a look at old-fashioned America.

I don't live in Maine or New Hampshire, but I do live in the more rural Northeast and that is what it is like. There are public meetings and a sense of community that is missing from the large cities.

Somehow, when they changed TR with their upgrade, it became more of a faceless, nameless city. If they didn't have "my forum posts", I would have a hard time finding anything I did the day before. Even so, I can only find those threads that I posted to, not the ones that I read and would like to post to at another time. I have to search for those. Sometimes I can't find them. It used to be so easy.

Something else was lost too. The town meeting, community feeling. It seems to me that Miscellaneous was really Miscellaneous back then. Now, off-topic is pretty much everything. Their tag system is a total failure.

Do you think they'll ever fix it?

AV

by nicknielsen

something is lost in translation. I was hoping they could get the new look going and keep the feel, but they didn't quite get it.

Aside: AV? Are we abbreviating now? Should I go to NN?

by av .

NickNielsen is perfect. AmericanVoter is too political, so I went to the abbreviation. I'm not sure I totally like AV, but I think its easier. I basically need a new name, but I can't think of one at the moment, so I went with an interim solution. One thing I've run up against is that people don't know I'm a woman and maybe some of my posts are misunderstood if the reader doesn't know that.

TR is a little messed up at the moment. I had suggested they create a more exclusive area for the people that have been around for more than a day, but it hasn't happened yet. You're right. Something is lost in translation with their new design.

by tig2

And I miss it.

These days, I throw what ever out and hope that folks find it. If they don't, a gentle email and a link might be good enough... or not.

Regardless, we do manage to find each other. I have learned to set a link to the "Off-topic" header on my home machines. I end up there anyway.

I would love to see a place called "The Watercooler" that operated in a manner similar to the way the old one did. Dreaming, of course. But it would be fun.

by tig2

Thinking with Tits. MMM. Maybe not.

Thinking with YOUR dick. No. You have better options.

SmartChix. That could work.

Not BrainDead in Seattle. Way too long.

Girlz With Thots. Potential

JessicaSimpson. No. Just don't go there.

Bright beats Bad. Ish.

Betty Boopboopbedo. Best ever. That way you can just floor people with your brain power. And an avatar is a Google search away. I think I even have one with a pink ribbon.

by av .

When I first signed up for TR, I was really into the politics of outsourcing. I didn't know what to call myself, so I went generic.

Now, years later, I want something different. Definitely not Jessica Simpson, as you say. I might as well call myself blonde and brainless.

How did you come up with TiggerTwo, if you don't mind me asking?

AV

by tig2

I was born and raised in Southern California. I worked for a large amusement park there where I wore a striped furry costume and was largely unrecognisable. And if you saw me today, you wouldn't know that experience lurked in my misbegotten youth.

When I joined in this incarnation (this is my second identity in 8 years), I decided to use that experience as my UID. Unfortunately, the singular was unavailable so I became plural. It seems to work for me.

You are, like many of the women on TR, intelligent and quite capable of holding your own in a discussion on any topic. So you can pretty much go with whatever name you like.

I tend to gravitate to cartoon characters because the strength of them is so beautifully masked for the idiots among us. Betty Boop is a favourite because, like Gracie Allen, she could say things that sounded silly on the surface but on reflection were the result of comic genius. Betty was the first female character to really BE female, not gender neutral, and still quite smart. And she has become an icon of Breast Cancer awareness, quite by accident.

Probably way more answer than you were expecting but what the hey!

by deepsand

And, for those who wish to experience it first hand, but moving to New England just isn't in the cards, try the Appalachion regions of, for example, Pennsylvania.

Thanks for the memories.

by sleepin'dawg

Hey you live there, or close by. Cletis and Bubba could come callin'; assuming they can read and are smart enough to figure out what you meant. :^0

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by drowningnotwaving

As you know, many writers here would tell us that this is the epitome of all that is right and decent in participatory democracy.

What are you suggesting?

Democracy AND moonshine?

Sounds great to me. And butt sex with my cousin? The dream grows by the minute.

Those writers were correct. Those were the good ol' days.

by deepsand

Question: How do you circumcise a hillbilly?

Answer: Kick his sister in the jaw.

by nicknielsen

Besides, I've had experience with the NN abbreviation. In the military, we used our initials as our call sign, responding with the phonetic equivalent to identify ourselves. "November November" was a mouthful.

The one time I asked for suggestions of other words that would serve the same purpose, large numbers of my co-workers responded. Numb-n_ts was the most socially acceptable of those suggestions. :0

I eventually went with "No Name" B-)

Edit: Anonymous Vixen? You keep the AV initials and remove all doubt as to gender...

by av .

Anonymous Vixen. That might be a keeper. Hmm. I have to think about that one.

I think I like NickNielsen instead of NN for sure. I think that creates an online persona. I would sure wonder who I was talking with if they called themselves Numb-n_ts. That is just so funny. :^0

AV

by av .

Its definitely alot more fun than some of the jobs I had in my misbegotten youth. I definitely wouldn't want to be known as Checkout Girl.

Thats a good story about why you chose TiggerTwo. I would have never guessed that you actually were Tigger. I think it would be interesting to know how some people come up with their names here.

I see what you mean about cartoon characters. They're non-threatening in alot of ways, but definitely cleverly disguised. I know Betty Boop has made a big comeback. Who would ever have thought a 50+ year old cartoon would still be relevant today?

Good story, Tig. One day soon, I'll come up with a new name. :^0

AV

This discussion is closed to new replies.