Discussion Locked

Copyright laws , Intellectual Property rights, and Software development

0 helpful
12 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a theoretical question.

Say Company "A" develops a software program. While unique in it's inception (it preforms a task that no other program has attempted previously), it uses common programming code, pre-established formulas, and a generic interface. In a nutshell, it automates a task normally done via pencil and paper. Let's call it "Menu" for simplicity's sake. (And also, that is what it basically is.)

Company "B" enters the picture, and buys the "Menu". They purchase the code, as is, and request that Company "A" no longer use it, or allow their clients to use it.

What are the restrictions, requirements, etc, regarding Company "A" writing a NEW "Menu" program? Of course, the graphics would be different. But what else is protected?

And, uh...do I need to be more specific about anything?

12 replies

by jaqui

makes the assumption that there is no patent on the software.

copyright belongs to who wrote the code, unless that was included in the sale, and if not, then company b can't stop company a from using it, or thier clients.

if the copyright was included, then company a has to stop using the code.

if there is a patent, then company a is screwed.
if no patent then company a can write similar code all they want.

by mickster269

Jaqui -

Sorry about that. Let me clarify.

Company "A" has no intent on using the exisiting program. What they want to do is create a new program, that performs the exact same function as the previous program.

There are no patents on the original program, and while not "Officially" copyrighted, the standard laws concerning copyrights apply.

What, if any restrictions are there on the creation of a new program ?

by jaqui

Copyright cannot stop company a from creating similar work at all.
Patents could.

by rob mekel

If a company creates a brand NEW MENU
not using any program stuff put in the first MENU, they will be allowed to do so.
Regardless what the outcome off that MENU will be. But do keep in mind that it has the restriction of not using any of the stuff put in the prior MENU!!

Whenever using stuff of the prior MENU they could get trouble.

by apotheon

Copyright covers the source code. Patent covers things like process, "look and feel", and so on.

The easiest way to ensure that an attempt to sue for copyright infringement won't meet with success when reimplementing some software concept is to rewrite it from scratch in a different language. Your software can, structurally, be identical without infringement of copyright, as long as your source code bears no syntactical resemblance to the original.

This can actually provide additional benefits, as the semantic structure and syntax of the new language might suggest improvements over the original design architecture as well.

by stargazerr

If company A produces a "similar" software since the original one was not patented. But if something which seems to be a xerox copy of the first one is created, it will cause a problem since Company B will fail to understand that it is a brand new copy and not the original.

There will be some trouble yes (in the manner of verbal disagreement)... But legally, it should be ok to produce a similar Menu.

]:)

by cactus pete

There may be a question about the owner of the Intellectual Property.

The original statement was the B asked A not to use MENU anymore, and to not allow their clients to use it.

The trick is in the wording of the contract you signed. You'll have to pose this same question to your attorney and let that person review the contract for this specific case.

Without seeing the contract, there is no way any of us can give you good advice.

At any rate, you'll have to determine, even if creating NEWMENU is deemed legal, if you want to potentially be sued by B for it. Is this worth the litigation costs if that were to happen?

Always have your attorney review the contracts before you sign them, and always try to think about the future work when entering into the contract. Future works should always be specified in the contract.

by tony hopkinson

If they've bought the unique concept, it's theirs. If they've bought the code that's merely one implementation of the concept, coming up qith a recognisably different implementation would be easy, whether it's worth doing that depends on how marketable the concept is.

by deadly ernest

If the sale contracts forbids A from making any Menu style products for a period then they would have troubles if they did so in any form for that period - a contract that did not put a time limit on such a restriction would be challengable in most jurisdications as being unfair trading practices.

If the sale contract just forbid them from using Menu then they could easily write a Newmenu program using different algorythms - just recompiling in a different compiler would not constitute sufficient change. In software sales it is common to include clauses stopping the seller from using or selling the software that they just sold, except where they have bought a new licence from the new owner - prior clients who have bought a licence usually still have a legal right to use what they have already bought. I know of a case where a company wrote a specialised form of a database and later sold it to another company, the buyer promised to keep it going, but it soon became clear that they only bought it to get it off the market. Two years later the original owners then wrote an improved version using better algorythms (they ahd learned from their earlier efforts) and amrketted that under a different name and advertised that it was totally compatible with the earlier program for those that wished to upgrade. Perfectly legal actions - new algorythms made it a new program.

All the above is to do with ownership rights of a product. Copyright laws and IP laws are more to do with the ownership of the concepts within a restricted process. Often people will own the IP and or the copyright but not the product, as it has been sold. An example of that is the court case, may even be finished by now - I have not heard, between SCO and the people who sold them the Unix product rights. The claim is that the rights to sell Unix and Unix licences was sold but not the copyright of the code - would like to know how this went if anyone knows.

Then again patent laws can come into play and further confuse the issue.

An example of the differences between IP rights, patent rights, and product rights is the Swash Plate (I hope I got the spelling right) fancy gizmo on a helicoptor that keeps the blades at different angles of attack between when they are at the front and the back of their circle. The original inventor of the concept owned the IP rights (think he may even be dead now) and a company owns the patent right for the use of this in aeronautical vehicles, yet in the 1980's a fellow was able to get a new patent the very same device in the very same design as he was applying it for use in ground based vehicles - different intended use that was not covered in the original patent.

by miep.visser

I'm writing text for a website.
Are there standard PRIVACY and COPYRIGHT rules that one is allowed to copy and add to the website?

This discussion is closed to new replies.