Discussion Locked

Death of the "Progress Bar"

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Has anyone else noticed that what once was called a "Progress Bar" has been replaced with a moving animation that is utterly meaningless? The "Progress Bar" was originally designed to give a visual representation as to the PROGRESS of a given task. When the bar reached the end, the task was complete. I have noticed that the latest incarnations of this feature do nothing of the sort (see IE7 installer). They move along, going from one side to the other, then, just when I think my wait is over... It starts over! Exactly what does this bar measure? What is it showing me? Since it can (and does) repeatedly start over (with no other indications of how many times it will do so) the bar itself is completely useless! What function does this bar now serve? Is it just eye candy to let you know your PC hasn?t completely frozen up? Is there actual logic behind this meaningless animation?
Why has this bizarre transformation occurred? Has it become impossibly complicated to calculate the amount of time required to complete a task and display an indicator of said tasks progress?
What is a progress bar that doesn?t show progress??
If a tree falls in the woods??.
Why do we drive down a Parkway, but park in a driveway?
Why? Why? WHY????

9 replies

by absolutely

that I prefer over what it replaced. "Progress" indicators that indicate 99% complete, for 3 hours, are not helpful because the "information" they display is untrue. The new animation indicates "progress", or lack thereof when inanimate, and omits the never-accurate estimate of percent completed.

by dmarston

*nix has been able to accuratly display progress for a LONG time, why can MS just FIX it instead of putting a psudo-progress bar in it's place?
Ahhhh it's the little things that drive us nuts!
:)

by nicknielsen

[i]...why can['t] MS just FIX it instead of putting a psudo-progress bar in it's place?
Ahhhh it's the little things that drive us nuts![/i]

That's exactly it.

by charliespencer

Who actually controls the progress bar, MS or the developer of the application being installed. I've seen several different bars and they don't all behave the same. Some are the preferred style reflecting the actual percent of installation complete. Some are the detested kind that just keep starting over for an undeterminable number of times. Since I've seen both on the same machine, I've assumed each developer's installation process displayed it's own custom bar.

by dmarston

True, both are indeed at fault. The one that go my goat (and hence the post) was the IE7 installer (M$). You have to admit it though, M$ has NEVER been good at telling time. I have had untold installs / downloads where the M$ dialog box says "3 minutes remaining" for HOURS!
:)

This discussion is closed to new replies.