Discussion Locked

Degree in Computer Science = Know how a Network works

0 helpful
48 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

There's been a great debate about the value of a Microsoft certification or a CompTIA certification. I've read a couple of recent articles on paper MCSE's, one in particular in Redmond Magazine. I've recently began looking at just what certifications are supposed to mean vs having a degree in computer science and how that equates to actually doing the job. Just look through Careerbuild job offerings for network administration and many companies want a bacholars degree in computer science with a couple years experience. So what exactly is a bacholars degree in computer science? Do workers who have a bacholars degree in computer science actually know how networks work? Could they actually setup DNS, DHCP, Active Directory, design a network infrastructure? For that matter could MCSEs? [MCSE's are supposed to know but heck what about the paper MCSEs?].

Are companies really getting someone who has a degree in computer science that can do the job better than someone who has a certification?

48 replies

by craig herberg

A CS degree probably includes coursework in networking, and may or may not include hands-on networking. Students are essentially given a roadmap for life-long learning, and the potential for getting some pretty good jobs, doing and learning many things that they may or may not have covered in school. At the other end of the spectrum is a trade school certificate designed for a fairly narrow range of jobs. Of course there is no substitute for experience, but in the long run, to me potential is more important than a fairly narrow skill set. People with either or neither can be successful.

Craig Herberg

by tony hopkinson

Networking is a specialized subset of computing. A cert is usually a specialised vendor/platorm subset of that. Admittedly my cert in DECNet networking helped me with windows networking, but that was I could map the tools from one to the other. A strong background (not a degree) in computer science did help me do that.
But I've met people who think DNS or TCP/IP would be wholly different under different platforms because they couldn't and some of them had a degree in computing.

by deadly ernest

Don't know how it is elsewhere but in Australia most big companies hiring staff for IT organisations hire people with Tech College qualifications or years of experience not Uni Degrees. Experience has shown that the Uni quals are more theoretical than practical - some unis are now addressing that issue and this could change. NB some uni grads do have extra knowledge obtained outside there curriculum that means they are useful.

Some organisations are also revisiting the need for over specialised qualifications. One organisation I know had been hiring staff to manage their servers and insisting that they have quals related to MS software and eyars of experience with Exchange, Win 2000 Server and the like. When recently reviewing their operational security they had a report recommending that they switch some servers to Linux and found that they needed new staff as no existing staff were able to build or manage non MS servers.

by tbragsda

.
I don?t think much of certs. I have hired many people with certs that were worthless. On the other hand I have meet people with advanced degrees that could hardly understand a router. How is this possible? Well, nothing means much of anything till you have your hands on the equipment, the problems, and the projects that prove skill.

Get your certs or get a degree. They will go a long way to getting your foot in the door, but nothing makes you a good net admin other than experience.

TBR

by flowcom

I think that a degree is good and having certs are good. Both really puts you in the mix for getting a good job. The bottom line, is texperience. I have seen job advertisements for all kinds of IT positions, and most if not all want experience to backup the certs or the degrees. I would say that do what you can to get expeerience while you working your certs or heading towad your degree. Experience go a long way.

"Good judgment comes from experience, and experience comes
from bad judgment." Rita Mae Brown

Experience is a wonderful thing.

by krypt

All I have is experience. Not much, a couple years is all, but I work with a team where they all have a bachelor's degree and a bunch of certifications without them being better or worse then me.

To me, you don't learn IT, you are IT.

I will go get my degree because I aim to higher responsabilities but experience and individual character are really what counts.

by caestelle

I did not learn what I know about networking while in college. I had one class that dealt with networking and it was strictly theory, with no hands on experience. The rest of the course load was all programming. It wasn't until I landed my first IT job and starting working with networks, that I actually began to truly understand the theory that I was taught in my class.
My brother also has a BS n CS from another school and his experience was the same.

by cg it

Most of the CS degree holders I've come across are programmers. They can program [or write scripts] but many haven't a clue what DNS, DHCP routing tables are much less Active Directory, Group Policy, OUs.

However, if one takes a look at Careerbuilder jobs and use MCSE as a keyword, up pops all these jobs for Windows based platforms and they want a BS in CS., couple of years experience on a Windows platform plus they add MCSE cert desired. I see this time and again. Whats worse is I see these "schools" who advertise internships and what I found out was they are job retraining programs that give the graduate a MCSA or MCSE.

I for one am glad that Microsoft has put in their Windows 2003 certification program hands on configuration questions to be able to pass the exams.

Still I can't fathom why companies would want to hire someone with a bacholars degree in computer science that is is mostly programming based for a network administration position that requires really hands on skills with the operating systems.

by obiwaynekenobi

As far as I know a CS degree is 100% programming; my co-worker has one and while she can do programming, she knows next to nothing about networking (I have given her some cross-trainining in it since it's a small company). From what she has told me it's almost all programming theory (i.e. the basics of programming languages and such) and tons of math (which is the reason I didn't go for it). I don't think she took any networking classes at all.

by tony hopkinson

what computer science is, I do, he does and she does. HR don't though, that's why they got stuck with it.
As an adendum, without some experience in the commercial environment the programming skills they do learn aren't a lot of use in development either. All the practical work is snippets and rigidly controlled questions where the only right answer is the theory they should have learnt. Not like that in the real world at all.

by rayjeff

This is going to be a reply to you and to Tony. I rad his post below here and since it's coming from this thread, I'll reply to him as well.

For CF IT, colleges/universities have CS broken up as just a computer science degree or either a BS in computer science (which is majority software) or BS in computer engineering, which is majority hardware and this is all under the computer science degree. The university I attend has computer science broken up as the latter. I'm in the CSCE or B.S. Computer Science major. Looking at the course catalog, 99% of all of the computer science classes are dealing with software/programming, with a few networking classes
(approx 2) with all of the other networking classes as electives or application areas.

For Tony, you are certainly right. My programming classes never prepared me for the real-world experience of programming. I'm coming up to my second year as being a professional programmer and it's been a learning experience. The programming projects you have in a class are very specific. To be honest, I can't evne compare the issues that came up in class to the issues of a real-world program I've created. But I have to say the theory that you learn is very important because it's that building block. Hands-on without theory is like theory without hands-on; you need them both.

by krypt

Hence the importance of the background. Degrees and certifs are but introductions that get you the interview.

In the case of certifications, they just outline a particular field of interest (not expertise).

Anyone can read a book and pass the exams.

Degrees don't provide particular skills either if the program is too general or did not focus enough on the required skill at time of employment...

by support#netropole.com

your right, i dont think they really know what they are looking for. they just know the insurance company or whom ever is telling them they have to have someone with a college degree.

by tomsal

I don't know where the poster got the idea of a CS degree = computer networking, because it doesn't.

My bro is nearly done his CS degree - they only lightly touched upon networking. Its a lot of math, a lot of theory -- that's the summary he gave me on it.

by n.salooja

I have my degree in MIS. When i started college i looked at both CS and MIS and found that MIS degree is much more beneficial than CS degree. Even though both degrees deal with programming but MIS adds some business courses which help you understand the business part of IT also. I want to be network administrator and based on my degree i hardly know anyting about networking. All of my knowledge is based on what i learned on my own and from friends. After doing some research i found out having a cert means that you have 6 months of experience in that field so i have decided to go for some certs which include A+, Network+, Security+, Server+, MCDST, MCSA. And also i am starting my M.S. in Information Systems soon. I know its lot of money to spend on getting certs but i think if you have the proper education and knowledge you can do anything and get a really nice job in IT. Any comments and suggestions will be appreciated.

by varnum.brian

I went to a fairly small Private College that placed alot of emphasis on hands on training. We covered everything from MS 2000 Server, Linux, Novell and Cisco. Admittedly I did have some amount of experience before I went to school, but my degree did help me land a pretty decent job with no Certifications.

by cg it

I could see Trade School degrees where you are actually taught Windows/Unix/Linux/Solarius/Netware networking along with Cisco networking. Sorta a combination degree that merges MCSE with a CCNP to give a bacholars of science Computer networking degree.

but I see job postings and all want a 4 year degree in computer science, which based on everyones comments is all programming. That has no revelence to managing a computer network that has combinations of server, routers, switches, firewalls.

But I see schools such as Computer Horizons Learning Center that advertises getting a MCSE in weeks [as part of job retraining programs ] as undermining the value of obtaining such certifications. I see HR departments wanting CS degrees and getting people who haven't a clue about networks.

by jck

Degree = theory (usually...unless u have a good school w/hands-on experience/labs)

knowledge is from experience...because knowledge is more than speculation and preparation...it's about knowing what happens.

I've got a degree in Computer Science with a minor Mathematics. Our CS dept was *totally* Unix-based. I didn't start learning GUI computer programming for PCs until I got out of college. Now, I write .NET apps and have written VB6 for some 6+ years, and Delphi, VC++ and Gupta/Centura SQLWindows before that in the GUI world.

I saw the IT industry really shift to thinking certifications were something special in the late 1990s around the tech boom. It's actually scary how many "joes" are out there with a piece of paper and how many people would hire them to do a job based solely on that.

I'm not saying that there aren't qualified people out there doing good work with certifications, but the fact is that too much emphasis is being placed on having that certification. If I had to take my pick of a guy with 2 years experience and a CCIE, or a guy who'd worked in Cisco hardware for 8 years hard and heavy in the same technical areas...I'd take the experience anyday.

by yzfdude11

My CS degree means that I have technical knowledge, but that I have the ability to learn technical matters. Most college degrees have an added bonus to employers in that they teach other things to make me a more rounded individual.

Classes like english or technical writing have exposed me to writing reports as well as having shown that I have an ability to communicate. A Certification means that I have specific knowledge about a small subset of specifications that are correlated to the company offering the certification.

In my opinion, both are highly desirable, but they by no means dictate that you are all knowledgable in an area. They are complimentary to each other in that the certifation is specific, while the college degree is more general.

by cg it

If a computer science degree is necessary to get a job in the computer field [network admin, etc], reguardless that said degree has nothin to do with network administration] then having a certification really is of little value in finding a job in the computer field.

So someone who knows computers and O/S like the back of their hand [because they have solid practical experience, the geek, will not get hired.

The result is companies have IT personal who #1 really don't know how the network runs, #2 doesn't really want to know how networks run, #3 would rather create the next Google than monitor the performance of servers, apply security patches, change out bad cards or add a DC at a site to make the network run better or be safer.

Go figure!

by tony hopkinson

My certs are out of date, haven't got a degree of any description but I've been in the job 18 years and counting and HR twonks still ask me for them. Given my age and experience, why would a degree in computer science be relevant in the modern business world, unless I went back to school and took one now. OO was science fiction when I started learning. My first formal education was with an Apple 32 or TTY and punched tape to the local university mini.

by jaqui

the hr dweebs can't rate experience without that piece of paper.
that's what thier training has shown them to rate.

after all, in real practical knowledge was of any use, then they wouldn't have thier jobs. ~l~

( can ya tell I have no use for hr types? )

I have a simple test for technical positions.
hand the applicant a mess of parts for older *system, get them to assemble it, get it running, and connected to network.
since only os available if linux it also proves they know the os.
if they can, then they have the skills needed for the job.

during that time can usually get to know them as a person enough to be able to assess how well they would fit into a team.

* i386 / i486 isa eisa systems.

by jck

a degree in CS is more relevant to programming.

a degree in IS is more relevant to networks and databases.

they intermix somewhat, but they have distinctly different focuses.

by tony hopkinson

What do you think of VB ?
LOL
In a developer I look for discipline, and an understanding of programming, not a specific language. Anyone who has them is useful.
Innate skills such as lateral thinking and seeing inside the box are valuable bonuses.

by jck

One time, this won me a job I think:

I interviewed for a programming position, met all the skills, etc.

The IS manager was an ex-Microsofty talked about him before...(my nickname for him: The Anti-Christ...one girl who was part Danish used their word for "Devil" to his face and he thought it was a compliment the whole time)

He asks: "If you were configuring an FTP server, what port would it listen on?"

I said: "Whatever port I set it to."

He looks at me and says: "Hmm...good answer."

He wanted the vanilla answer...21...I gave him the proper one. :)

by craig herberg

if you want to get into the business end of IT or the more technical end. CS requires a lot more math and MIS more business courses. A master's degree in the same field is generally not as good as one in a different field.

by tony hopkinson

Colleague using asp script, wanted to exit the script early but there's no exit command in VBScript for a script. My solution was to wrap all the code in a dummy subroutine call it from the page and then he could use Exit Sub to come out. Don't know where the idea came from but it worked.

by rayjeff

I've been lucky throughout my career to be the exception. I've been in the IT field for five years. I started while as a workstudy at the technical college I attend. Had hands-on time while also being able to apply what I was learning. After I graduated there, I transferred to an university where I was able to get a job in the computer services dept, while also pursuing a computer science.

It rally amazes me that I've been able to get so much knowledge and experience while still being in school. This is helping me because I'm getting to see all sides of IT: management, business, technical, supervisory, etc. The experience is definitely the key. If student they have interest in while being in school, it helps them to really know what's expected in the real world and not what someone's sugar coated version of the truth is.

by tony hopkinson

I think firms would get a lot out of work study / IT apprenticeship programs, if they didn't cry about the salary requirements of a trained and experienced IT professional. As it is they know they won't guarantee the investment so they all leave it to someone else, which of course is us.

What formal academic training I've had to underpin the hands on was correspondence courses while already in the job.

Given they were reasonably fair how many kids who want a career in IT would be happy to sign on for x years to be molded into the professional the company will need. Big firms do it all the time with management graduates, but us tech's are just easily replaced widgets. Interchangeable as well, after all theres no real difference between an admin and a developer as far as HR are concerned.
MCSE is a suitable cert for either job, apparently.

by cg it

from all the posts I've read, I see a consensus that to get a foot in the door one needs a degree in CS even if said degree doesn't give one any idea on how to run a network. Companies HR departments realize that certifications mean very little in the initial screening process. If they have a degree in CS, companies HR departments see a certification from a software or hardware manufacturer like Cisco or Microsoft as an added bonus.

by jaqui

with experience, you have learned how to look inside the box, think laterally and developed the problem solving skills that the schooling didn't teach.

while I don't say no schooling is needed at all, I have seen more people with schooling that are useless, while those with on the job training are usually much more capable.

schooling is a good foundation, but if you are going to be working technical areas, you should have some interest, and most likely, done more than the schooling minimums on your own systems, so you have some knowledge outside of the theoretical from the degree programme

by tony hopkinson

lateral thinking and outside the box, more like I applied them. I've certainly learnt to cultivate my intuition, but that can cause me problems as it's not just me who's skipped the steps between what and why, but any one who I have to explain it to.

by catherine

college degree in CS is only a passport to the real world. My college prepares me for a variety of IT exposure - programming, networking, security, OS, etc. It was not 100% porgramming, but having to squeeze so many IT, Maths, and humanities modules into a 4-year course might mean some dilution somewhere.

Industrial certifications might be of some advantage, if you are still young (in terms of experience), and want to specialise in a certain area. In this situation, industrial certifications can give a strong impression to employers, shadowing your age.

But if you have already accumulated some experience over the years, experience definitely has the final word. You are able to make Calculated Risk from real experience, instead of Theoretical Risk from the textbooks.

Taking MIS degree is different from a CS degree. There is much more dilution in the former. If you do want some business knowledge later on, you can try a MBA in Business IT, or part-time business courses.

by atxstranger

I graduated from an MIS program that awarded me a Bachelors in Business Administration degree. We had one semester of Networking that involved a couple hours of lecture and an hour of hands on lab experience with small networks (usually only 4-8 nodes). The class was a good foundation course that working in the real world has helped augement but the experience has been worth a lot more in terms of generating real results.

by mjd420nova

As we all may have already experienced the tech who could talk the talk but not walk the walk, with or without the paper still doesn't get the job done. Take a pile of junk and make a PC, Throw in a satilite link, and infra-red link and fibre-optics between server nodes and no cert will show you where to start when problems arise.

by rayjeff

From doing research of other institutions, networking is usually a part of MIS programs, even at my university.

by tony hopkinson

Bit's of paper get you interviews, experience gets you the job. There are fortunate cases such as myself with no paper but lots of experinece who can get round this and unfortunate cases such as the people with lots of paper but no experience who I tidy up after.
But yes in the main you need both to move on and academia to get a start.

by prolifiq

The main reasons why the companies you've mentioned (and countless others) insist upon degrees plus experience over certifications probably aren't technical reasons. At a technical level, they really don't care if degrees or certs are better; as long as the system runs properly, and gets fixed promptly when it doesn't.

Instead, businesses often insist upon these credentials for benchmarking purposes. How does our IT department stack up against other people's? Are we paying too much for the service levels and skill sets we have? Should we keep IT in-house, or should we outsource/off-shore? How can we get the most value for our tech dollars?

Different companies have various corporate and business goals they want to achieve. Some want to become "high-performance companies", achieve higher tier ratings, or whatever describes the higher echelons they want to reach. But in order for them to do that, they have to pass rigorous benchmarks set by reputable R&A (research & analysis) firms (i.e., Gartner, etc.). And many of the benchmarks involve - yep, you guessed it - the academic credentials and composite skill sets of your IT department.

In a nutshell, they insist on degrees & experience largely to justify the IT dollars they spend, where they need to spend more, and - most importantly to us IT people - where they're going to spend less.

by prolifiq

It's not a justification. Rather, it's an explanation of how the corporate world thinks when it comes to IT's value. They only care about spreadsheets, charts, numbers & their bottom line. That's how degreed, certified, and experienced people get laid off like it was nothing.

by meubank

JK is absolutly correct. I work in a Global 100 company and can tell you as someone with a masters degree in Technology management there are some absolutes that companies look for.
A good example is certifications, while this varies from company to company what I tend to use them for is to show me someone has the decilpine to actually study and achieve something. There are plenty of UNIX admins that are 35 years old and live with mom and dad in the basement and complain how they never get the "good jobs". Yet they never try to improve themselves. I am not trying to slam anyone but I can tell you as someone who HIRES network admins (having been one for almost 15 years) that certs are of great value IF you atre running the platform your cert is in (i.e MCSE in a Windows enviornment) I agree that there are paper MCSE's out there thanks to braindumps etc and this is where the Degree comes into play. If I have 2 people trying for the same position and one has a degree and the other does not, AUTOMATICALLY the degreed person is going to get a closer look, they may not get the job if the non degreed person has tons of experience but the value of a degree cannot be overstated.
I suppose a lot has to do with your goals as well, if you want to be network or sys admin for 30 years and cap out your pay at maybe 80 a year with 30 years experience, that is fine. If however you have goals that go past that, you NEED that degree, again because it shows self dicipline and a desire to not jsut meet you current job requirements but exceed them and have potiential for the future.
Sorry to go off on a tangent here however I hear this argument all the time and mostly it seems to eminate from people that do not have certs or a degree. that is fine trust me, however it has been my exdperience that without either one of these, even with tons of expereince, if you have to go job hunting you will have a tough, tough time!

Just my 2 cents,
Thanks!

by prolifiq

Thanks for the assist, meubank.

As a degreed & certified IT professional, I can attest that although certs are great for showing product-specific and procedural knowledge, there is a ton of perceptual and political significance attached to having a degree.

Generally a non-degreed-yet-certified tech will need far more experience to get the same job that a degreed person is applying for (regardless of his/her experience), because to most managers, a degree communicates teachability and well-roundedness (whether that's true or not).

It also communicates that you can commit to and achieve a goal that typically takes 4-5 years to accomplish - a trait that is very, VERY important in the business world.

by tony hopkinson

I think the candidate's degree is to cover your arse with if you pick wrong.
Week after next I start with another FT100 company as a senior developer. No certs, no degrees. 24 years solid employment except for about ten weeks since 1981. Interestingly they had four jobs to fill and I was the only one out of eight who got a start, apparently none of the other candidates were of my calibre. Guess how many of them had bits of paper to indicate they were better than me ?
So the importance of a degree can be overstated, in fact was, by you, just now.

Self discipline and desire eh.
I started work at 18 as a goverment sponsored clerical gopher. I've just resigned from a position as a Senior Design Engineer. Got my start in IT while bringing up and providing for a family, working shifts and doing correspondance courses. This was while others were kicking girls handbags about on the dance floor while drunkenly trying to chat them up.
Dedication to what ?
I didn't study hard I worked hard ! One's much more valuable than the other.

by prolifiq

... as you've mentioned, that was 24 years ago. In terms of computers, that's ancient history.

Times and perceptual significance of computer degrees in the job market have changed dramatically since then.

Your example is remarkable, but it's certainly the exception, not the rule. Don't believe me? Just ask around!

Was I saying that degrees make anyone a better candidate? No, and I've seen proof that they don't. Personal ability, skill, hard work, and dedication makes the better hire.

None of those qualities, however, are tangible. Degrees and certs are, and unfortunately for many job candidates, that's what most businesses will zero in on, for the various reasons that were stated in previous posts by myself and others.

by tony hopkinson

I would never have walked in off the street to get the job. I'd already been working for them for six years. If you look in heavy industry for large manufacturers (I know they are hard to find nowadays), you'll find a lot of guys like me.

If you want the chance to employ someone like me though all you have to do is stop pimps and HR filtering us out before you're even allowed the privilege of making a choice. There are a lot more of us out there than you see.
All my employers did, though admittedly I'm only on my ninth.

by mdhemphill

A CS degree is structured around programming, an IS degree is structured around, either network Administration, Programming or Database Administration.

The issue with having a BS degree in one of these disciplines is more desirable has to do with the ability for the individual to pick up new concepts or different platforms with very little hand holding.

With a college degree you under stand theory and some practical knowledge. Granted, there are some that can't do squat straight out of college, but there is a grater percentage of individuals that can perform with little to no suppervision as compared to someone from a trade school.

The problem is that a majority of business want to have someone that is extremely versitile versus taking a chance on a person from a trade school which only directed them in one area.

I have an AS degree in Information System, structured in networking and Programming.

Michael

This discussion is closed to new replies.