Discussion Locked

Did you see the youtube on Susan Boyle?

0 helpful
38 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Saw this yesterday on CBS, everybody judged this 47 year old woman on her looks before she stated singing on the English "So you think you have Talent"

http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=4949467n

Just the look on Simon's face is worth the view. :D

38 replies

by cupcake

I am with you... everyone - including some of the people in my office who told me about it - had simply written her off because of her looks.

The only thing that I worry though, is talented as she may be, someone will dig their hooks into her, make her get plastic surgery, dye her hair, work on her teeth, skin and figure and she won't be the person she really is.

I hope she stays true to herself.

by boxfiddler

[i]dye her hair, work on her teeth, skin and figure[/i] change [i]the person she really is.[/i]?

The good looking blogger isn't what she looks like, but the not so good looking singer is?

Y'all people need to make up your minds.

by jamesrl

As someone who has been paid to sing and works with professional singers on a weekly basis....

A blogger is selling ideas. Doesn't matter what they look like, its the idea that counts.

A singer, on the other hand, is a performer. Honestly, you sell the song with more than your voice, it is also your stage presense, manner, your eyes even.

You don't have to be gorgeous, Pavarotti to my eyes isn't attractive, but you also don't want your manner or appearance to detract or distract from the vocals.

I wouldn't suggest she needs plastic surgery, but a hair stylist and some coaching on presentation would not be amiss, if she wants to be a professional singer and not just a gifted amateur.

James

by oz_media

It was her common as muck accent and her gyrating hips when she made dumb comments before she sang. As always she picked a really big song that sounded well beyond her abilities, like so many others do that can't sing to begin with, it was just 'oh no, here we go again' and then she sang her heart out.

Well done, but the rest of the show was pretty entertaining too, I think I'll go on and try for that world record myself next year. :D

by gadgetgirl

It's been all over the news since, which is how I found out about her since I don't watch it. She seems well grounded (and Scottish!) so I don't think she'll let herself be pushed around that much!

Another one to look out for is "Flawless", but I don't know if it's on YouTube.... fantastic dancers with fantastic moves.

Both these acts should surely go somewhere!

GG

Edit: found Flawless - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6GrOMLylvhQ

brill .....

by jamesrl

...is as she stated, to become a professional singer, she isn't there yet, but her performance has certainly moved her light years closer to her goal.

James

by dadspad

I enjoyed that clip, good dancing. Unfortunately, it is very hard to have a dancing career as a group. Gone are the days when dancers like Fred Astaire were world famous. I really wish them success.

I found this, but could not confirm:

The Sun reports ? how the singer, who admits she has ?never been kissed?, is now in demand for interviews and performances in the US and even Australia. Talent guru Simon Cowell is lining up a record deal in a bid to repeat the success of opera star Paul Potts, who won the first series of Britain?s Got Talent.?

I had a feeling she would be a success without winnning a contest.

by oz_media

Usually you see these dance crews out of the US, but Simon really does have a good eye and ear for who can succeed in the industry and will see these guys get a deal even if they don't make it through BGT.

When he started with IlDevo, they were beyond laughed out of record companies all over the world, they couldn't geta deal to buy lunch, but his development abilities really worked magic with them and look where they are now.

I think between Flawless and the young guy that sang with his family, Cowell has his eyes set high already for post show development deals.

by hal 9000

Particularly after that one that they had last year. It nothing else it's good for Ratings but maybe I'm just Cynical. ;)

Col

by oz_media

I usually download BGT about an hour after it is aired. The same thing happened in season one with Paul Potts, a goofy looking, tubby guy with horrific teeth who sang like Pavoratti.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1k08yxu57NA

But if you get a chance to see the whole episode with Susuan Boyle, she's great but the Lord of the Dance father and son team are side splitting hilarious.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q4fPHt0FjEU

I also like the guy who decided to beat the Guniess Book record for eating the most Ferrero Rocher chocolates in one minute.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b3o7jRLr14g

The funniest part is that the record is only 8 chocolates in one minute, and he only did 4! When asked what his record was, he said 6, so he went on without even having done it before. Even the guys on the side stage ate more during the same minute. All in all a good laugh.

Remember the winner gets to perform for the Queen, maybe she likes Ferrero Rocher, but she endorses Quality Street.

There was also a family, with two young girls and a preteen boy who has excellent vocal skills. With Simon being big on male groups and male solo acts, his ears perked up right away and the dollars signs lit up his eyes. He zeroed in on the boy and (as they won't win the show) you can tell he will be offered an artist development deal anyway.

With a songwriter, stylist and vocal training, the boy will see some decent cash too.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xjm2i37xSM8

This show is so much better than Idol, which is 100% predictable as usual, nothing but talent in the top 8, which you can easily pick out during the early performances. One thing about Idol is they mix up the good and bad with too much contrast it makes audience selection so predictable.

But American Idol is simply an artist development show anyway, why pay out of pocket and take a chance when you can develop them in front of their audience first and have the network foot the bill.

by ksoniat

Oz, thanks for posting that - it was hilarious!!!!

The best part is they really could dance - but it is better thay way they do it.

by oz_media

While being accused of being pompus and stuck up by most of the world, Brits have no problem having a laff at their own expense, especially when in this sort of a context.

by bfilmfan

That was an amazing performance.

And she was just going to walk off the stage at the end of it.

I hope some smart producers snatch that woman up!

by charliespencer

I don't see any reason to click a link about someone I know nothing about. Just paranoid, I guess. Should I already have some level of name recognition? Is she a politician, business person, entertainer, IT person, or something else?

by oz_media

And while I don't deny her anything, she truly has an incredible talent and is a joy to listen to, there is always a similar 'pick' on each season. There is always one completely unexpected artist that allows them to plague the media and create more of a buzz to keep viewers glued to the show.

I see nothing wrong with it, it is far from exploitation, but do recognize that most of these appearances are all booked by the shows own media crew and approved/contracted by the show's legal reps.

But I still can't wait to catch her next performance!

by dadspad

I found this at: http://www.mirror.co.uk/celebs/news/2009/04/17/britain-s-got-talent-star-susan-boyle-won-t-get-makeover-says-amanda-holden-115875-21283622/

A week ago nobody beyond the residents in a cluster of Scottish villages had heard of Susan Boyle.

But her electrifying Britain?s Got Talent audition last weekend changed all that.

There have now been an astonishing 20 million internet hits around the world to see the performance that blew away the judges and audience on the ITV1 show. And yesterday she won millions more US fans when she again belted out Les Miserables show-stopper I Dreamed A Dream via satellite on the CBS Early Show.

The unmarried, unemployed cat-lover, known as the Hairy Angel, also featured on NBC?s Today Show where presenter Kathie Lee had to dry her eyes with a sock being used for the next segment.

Demi Moore is also said to have been moved to tears and Susan has been lined up for The Oprah Winfrey Show.

Amid the frenzy yesterday, Britain?s Got Talent judge Amanda Holden made a plea for the 47-year-old churchgoer from Blackburn, West Lothian, to stay just the same.

Amanda, 38, told ITV News: ?I won?t let Simon Cowell take her to his dentist and I certainly won?t let her near his hairdresser.

?She needs to stay exactly as she is because that?s the reason we love her. She just looks like anybody who could live on your street.

?The minute we turn her into a glamour-puss is when it?s spoilt. That can perhaps come later when she?s signed the album deal and conquered America.

?For now we?ll keep her exactly as she is because that?s why we?ve all fallen in love with her. I think it?s the underdog thing. It?s somebody who?s looked after her mother all her life. She?s had real dreams, real aspirations and obviously she thought she?d had to say goodbye to those things.?

Advertisement - article continues below ?

Yesterday Susan?s life in West Lothian was interrupted by camera crews and phone calls from around the world. But she showed no signs of any make-over as she gave a thumbs up to photographers.

She said: ?It was nerve-racking to begin with but once I started and the audience accepted it I relaxed. It has been surreal. I didn?t realise this would be the reaction I just got on with it. I can hardly remember what happened. I had my eyes closed most of the time. It really didn?t dawn on me what was happening.

?I did it all for my late mum. I wanted to show I could do something with my life.?

Susan, the youngest of nine kids, started young with dreams of being a star.

She began at 12 in choirs and school concerts and moved on to singing in clubs.

But the dream ended when she had to give it up to look after her ill mum who died in 2007 aged 91.

Susan?s performance on Saturday was her first since her mother?s death. And last night she was already writing herself into the history books with bookmakers.

At 5-4 William Hill have never quoted such a short price for a reality TV show act at such an early stage. Previous Britain?s Got Talent winner Paul Potts was 5-1 after the first heat.

William Hill spokesman Rupert Adams said: ?This is absolutely unprecedented.

?We haven?t even seen all the contestants yet but people who have never had a bet in their lives still want to back Susan ? even at these short odds.?

by dadspad

Britain's Got Talent: Susan Boyle is not a very good singer, calm down everybody

Susan Boyle may be a great Britain's Got Talent story - but she is no great singer.

Her rendition of 'I Dreamed a Dream' was spirited, sure. It was also wobbly - and she was entitled to be a little nervy.

But was it charismatic enough, technically accomplished enough or even demonstrate enough potential to see her installed as the bookies' 5/2 favourite to win the whole shebang?

Absolutely no way.

For me, the most entertaining element of the whole performance was Amanda Holden's reaction when her gobhole seemed to be collapsing in on itself.

And genuinely comparing Susan Boyle's off-key warbling as being on the same level as Julie Andrews and Elaine Paige is just inane.

If I brought out my hip-wiggling and karaoke-level 'It's Not Unusual' vocal efforts out in front of Simon Cowell, Piers Morgan, Amanda Holden and an audience baying for the sacrificial blood of attention-seeking oddballs, would I deserve similar likening to Tom Jones?

Only if everyone in the theatre and watching at home had spent the entire day in the pub.

So why has the world and their Twitter stream gone mushy for Susan Boyle? There's no doubt her personal circumstances provide a heart-warming dose of drama to her reality TV journey.

But break it down - why is it making so many YouTube commenters and Ashton Kutcher and Demi Moore ("You saw it made me teary!") react so emotionally?

Looking especially to those who become aware of Susan Boyle via the hype machine - are you really moved to tears by the power of her singing voice, or the self-satisfied knowledge that you yourself would NEVER have pre-judged the "unlikely", "drab-looking", unemployed, never-been-kissed, self-deprecating, bullied-at-school, "quintessential cat lady"?

Well done, y'all. You are the good ones.

As for talk that Susan Boyle's YouTube success (12 million views and counting) was "unlikely", are you sure? Britain's Got Talent contestant web fame is hardly unprecedented. YouTube notoriety also helped propel Paul Potts to BGT victory and international fame in 2007.

It isn't Susan Boyle that is the internet sensation: the kudos belongs to Simon Cowell and his extremely clever, perceptive and powerful promo powers.

The astonishing instant worldwide fame has seen her turn up on Good Morning America, NBC Today and rumours have emerged that she has been asked to appear on Oprah Winfrey's chat show.

No doubt the viewing figures for this coming Saturday's show will be even healthier than the 10.3 million that tuned in last week. But will Cowell and company be able to fulfil the expectations of Boyle-boosted viewers?

And will Susan be able to live up the expectations placed upon her when she returns to our screens?

An undeniable crowd-pleaser - on whatever level it may be - but she's going to be an hard act to follow.

Not only for other contestants, but for herself too.

http://blogs.mirror.co.uk/we-love-telly/2009/04/britains-got-talent-susan-boyl-1.html

by ksoniat

In case you didn't already check...

She is an amateur singer on Britain's Got Talent (or whatever it's called) who looks quite plain and sings like an angel.

Oz has a hysterical link to a father-son act that is not to be missed.

by jamesrl

...that alone is reason enough to check it out.

I've watched him win a competition on Top Gear and not crack a smile. He isn't the warmest individual around.

James

by ksoniat

Love that show!

I saw that episode also - Simon seems to excel at whatever he applies himself to.

Warmth isn't one of them.

by oz_media

A/R guys are all like that.
[b]Bruce Allen[/b], Brian Adams/Michael Buble/Anne Murray/Rock and Hyde etc. TOTAL prikk in most people's eyes but VERY successful in his career and someone the best talent begs to have on their side.

[b]Sharon Osbourne[/b]Ozzy and countless others she has taken under her wing and showcases through OzzFest, mouthy, crass, hard a$$, and the best manager any touring band could hope for.

[b]Simon Cowell[/b](better known British pop acts) Angelis, Curiosity Killed the Cat, 5ive, Gareth Gates, Il Divo, Journey South, Robson & Jerome, Bianca Ryan, Sinitta, Sonia, Westlife, Will Young

[b]Bob Rock[/b]Metallica, Motley Crue, Aerosmith, BonJovi, The Cult, Skid Row, David Lee Roth, the Tea Party, Tragically Hip etc.

[b]Mutt Lange[/b] AC/DC,Def Leppard, Foreigner, The Cars, Bryan Adams, etc.

Its a job that makes you thick skinned and soft hearted. You learn to take no crap from anyone, get straight to the top in a hard, overpopulated marketplace simply but not letting people slow you down.

Cowell is actually known to be fun, easy going, loving and caring and laid back, as a person, not a businessman. I think he plays on his 'image' more than he lets on.

When I first started learning the ropes in the music industry, I worked alongside a guy who I HATED I thought he was the most uncaring and unfeeling a$$hole I'd ever met.
years after I stopped working with him and had worked with several others just like him, I began to see what makes all these people the same. They are hard, they are kind and warm, but hard.

I have become much the same myself, I had a friend tell me a few weeks back that, just when he thinks I'm the biggest prikk on the planet, I do something that blows him away and makes him realize I'm one of the nicest guys he knows.

Some people feel the surface and get scared, but once you break through the tough skin you find a real person that will be your best ally when needed.

People thank me for saying what they WANTED to say all the time, the people that I pi$$ off are people that need to be kept at bay or else they run all over you. I am not comparing myself to any of the people I mentioned above, I can only hope for such success, but it is something that runs through the industry and those that win are never sweethearts on the surface.

Its just not an industry for the faint hearted or easily offended and its not a business for soft people, passive caring personalities.

by boxfiddler

[i]someone will dig their hooks into her, make her get plastic surgery, dye her hair, work on her teeth, skin and figure and she won't be the person she really is.[/i]

You're telling me that 'personhood' hinges on how one looks in relation to one's career aspirations? And/or that 'personhood' hinges on what one 'wants to be'? And/or that being is encapsulated by one's stated goal?

by charliespencer

I avoid talent competitions and so-called 'reality' show. However, I wonder if Cowell's on-screen persona is 'what you see is what you get', or if it's just a TV image. NASCAR driver Tony Stewart has cultivated a 'bad boy' public image while quietly writing six- and seven-figure checks to a summer camp for handicapped kids. Howard Stern easily separates his on-air character from his off-air self; ditto Steven Colbert.

by oz_media

He held top of the board, they ended up getting a different car and Gordon Ramsey took the top slot, so Simon was asked back, at which time he again topped the board.

Its not a matter of not being warm, its a matter of when to be a pushover. Cowell is actually known as a real sweetheart, even by Paula Abdul who gets off on making him seem so mean (that twisted skank that she is) but its all for ratings and he has to play bad cop or all these developing artists won't learn anything. AI is simply an artist development show, most new signings have similar talent but are then crafted by the industry pros and wind up as stars. He's no dummy that's for sure, anything he touches turns to gold it seems.

by jamesrl

I said that IF she aspires to play a different role she may have to look into some of those items which touch her outward appearance. Does that impact her personhood? Please, don't be silly.

Does changing her appearance impact her charecter - it may. Some people become famous, change their lifestyles etc, but never give up their core essence. Some let the external changes change their internal self, they lose touch with who they were and how they got where they are.

James

by jamesrl

And on both occasions Simon didn't do what most people (actors, musicians and other notables) do when the "Star in a reasonably priced car" thing, which is have fun.

He didn't have a sense of humour about the jokes on him, he did try and take the piss out of Jeremy. He cracked a bit of a sly smile when he won, but hardly looked excited.

James

by oz_media

I have a lot on disk now too, and I don't disagree that he had his 'too cool for you' look on, but again that doesn't display his actual character, just his professional persona.

by jamesrl

I won't disagree that Susan's performance wouldn't match up with a "professional" standard of Julie Andrews or Elaine Page.

But if you think those professionals or just about any "classical" or "Broadway" singer got there without lots of coaching, you'd be mistaken. Most singers that I know get coaching into their 30s - so even after lessons when they are young, university degrees in music, they still go to better and better coachs to get themselves to the higher standard.

I may be making an assumption, but it sounds as if Ms. Boyle did have access to that kind of coaching, but she will now.

She has a good set of pipes, and passion, and not every singer out there has that.

Sadly she may be late in life to have a big career, but even still she has the chance to achieve her goals.

James

This discussion is closed to new replies.