Do undegraduates with experience stand a chance to get hired?
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by kaceyr
by prplshroud
If you want to make it in this world, having that degree is more key than ever. Plus it opens more doors than you would think.
If I were going through a pile of resumes, first priority is to find folks that actually completed their degree programs.
Dropping out of college in favor of getting a professional job tells me a few things about the candidate straight out. In most cases this means that the candidate gave up on a 2/4 year commitment to make money. Sure we all want/need/could always use more money in our pocket, but completing that degree shows that a candidate can make that commitment to something.
I've worked the people that were "working on their BS" and they were a couple of classes away from finishing. These are people that went to school full time and stopped so they could earn the "big money" and finish while working. Well, in most of the cases of these people, the time was measured in years they were working and not finished with a BS program.
Do yourself a favor, stay in school, get the degree. You might not realize it now, but it will get your foot in the door later in life because you made a commitment to something.
I'm proud of my accomplishment of going to college and graduating. My diploma is proudly displayed on a wall in my house.
I think if you stick with it, 10 years down the road, you'll be happy you did because you'll have a job and you got your foot in the door because of that section on your resume that says you've got a BS, a BS, or some other degree that starts with a B.
Most of the umemployed I know today are those that gave up on the degree and went for pictures of dead presidents instead.
by kpotts
After going through my Technical schooling, it was obvious that my already 10 years of experience (no schooling) was deffinitley a help to me. Others that did not have any experience but an interest were absolutley in left feild.
Computers are one of the few things like people that without exsetnsive experience and practice are almost impossible to reason with. All the schooling is not going to help you if you have not come face to face with the problems that can happen with a computer that they don't teach you in school.
In my opinion, troubleshooting has to be your strong suit. Along with that - if you are a whiz at resourcing, you have it made.
Don't get me wrong, schooling is important as well. The basics are good, degrees etc... just look good.
by louisrizzo
by lnair78
by mevcmv
by yulnores
by tomsal
Largely I agree with you...I believe in one single means of knowing what you know though...
I think formal training/education is very important, if someone things there is no creedance AT ALL to training/degrees/certs -- then I think they are a bit of a whack job to be honest.
That said, certs/training/degrees ALONE do not automatically mean you truly know your stuff -- so experience kicks in at this point. Experience is highly valuable, especially true in more specialized fields.
Keep in mind always though, and I think ALL hiring/HR/IT managers should be open to this tidbit...NO ONE, I don't care who you are, don't care how many certs,degrees hell in this case I don't even care what your experience record is -- NO ONE knows everything.
Everyone one of us, admit it, has had to supplement our knowledge be it but referring to a book, researching the 'net, attending a seminar, etc. at one point or another.
I'm not ashamed -- I'll tell you I use several books very frequently in the course of my job.
Of course I personally believe that TRUE intelligence isn't knowing all the answers, but knowing how to get "all" the answers in as fast, efficient and accurate time-frame as possible.
Also if you hire folks --- make sure you also look for those willing to learn, those with a lot of ambition, drive...not someone who will just use what they know at that time and never advance him/herself any further.
by james.chau
by rburello
by cdgun
by blatkn
by c_djraj
Barry please elaborate. What does English 101 got to do with this? Please address your answer directly to me at c_djraj@hotmail.com
Looking forward....Thanks a lot, Chris
by mrleo1957
by nico
by james.chau
It matters not a bit if the hiring company is loaded with $ or humongous in size. These companies are loaded with people who are not worth much in relation what they can produce but they will always bring in a buddy, degreed or not. What u said is totally false and u know that, u will also bring in a buddy if he is ok, degreed or not.
While a degree may invoke some kind of nominal trust it wouldn't last and in reality it is more of a hinderance because of the added expectations, most grads couldn't last more than 2 months due to the added pressure because the non-degreed workers gladly un-operate with these wiz kids and would love to see them stumble on silly yet essential things such as time reporting system accesses, infrastructural elements such as values used for program variables....in other words, politics and friendships rule supreme !
Unless u r an accountant, lawyer, engineer or doctor, degrees mean nothing !!!
And please, admit it to urself that if a real pro who can make u look like a kiddie in abilities is worth gold but u will never hire him because he will take ur job, especially if he is young, degreed, and not that experienced.
by admin
"And please, admit it to urself that if a real pro who can make u look like a kiddie in abilities is worth gold but u will never hire him because he will take ur job, especially if he is young, degreed, and not that experienced."
Actually, I really would hire that person. If he is young, degreed and not experienced but highly skilled in areas we need, I want him on my team. That makes me, as a supervisor, look good when I have people who get the job done effectively, efficiently and for lower cost, as a person in that situation would be. It's all about the skills once you get the job with me. I hate politics, and, as a supervisor, hiring your friends is a bad road to go down if you want clarity, minimal political problems and good decision making.
The problem isn't that companies generally torture the kids coming out of school. It's that some of the IT schools aren't teaching the students what they really need to fulfill business IT goals. The schools are too often focused on their own needs. Most of the best fresh Graduates I have worked with are the ones that were already doing the work anyway and just getting a degree or cert as a formality, to increase their earnings and to gain other related advantages.
I know a lot of unfortunate people who have got degrees or certs and work for CompUSA etc in sales if not the local sub shop unable to stay with IT jobs when they find them. They are usually ANGRY so at least for a while they form an opinion similar to your post. Until they get over this and go back to the drawing board and develop an in demand skill set they do not succeed and this reinforces their errant opinion. The best thing to do if you are in this situation is to find out what businesses need that you want to work for and learn those skills. The business world is not all about you- your skills- your needs. It's about what you can provide that the business needs. When schools teach this their students succeed, but when they try to recruit more people by offering programs that appeal to students without appealing to businesses needs, their graduates fail.
I do not know why there is not more information shared against certain educational facilities by graduates.The unhappy graduates without good positions seem to keep coming out of the same schools and it is plain wrong that they would continue to do this IMO.
by james.chau
by collins_rf
by phantasm32
By experince, i could tell you that a person with a degree gets hire more than a person with experince. I know this for a fact, I have deal with computer since the early 70 when programs had to be type in and you had to know how to fix a computer where it was hardware of software you had to fix them.
An example I worked for group and I was in charge of a military installation on maintaining the system running and maintaining them where it was software or hardware. I was military under civilian who were in charge. I would received call from the persons over me on how to fix a problem, and these guy had master degree and one thing that always got me is how someone with a degree would not know the simples thing as to fdisk a harddrive. And belive me it still happens I have apply for some TI and a person with a degree would get the job before I would
Thank for letting me get some of my thoughs.
by mansurk
by gario
by rdc02271
Some of you said that formal education gives more skills/knowledges than plain experience, but the truth is that those you wish to become the best will
buy books,attend seminars/courses(not degree related) to improve their skills.
This has nothing to do with formal education. A person may have a degree but their grades might be low. But then, when I think about it, do I want to hire someone that was the best in their class, but only knows what he/she has been taught at the university, or, someone with an average of C who has made a superb application, research work,etc that truly shows what that person is capable of?
I have completed 3 of a 5 years degree. I left the university becomes I wasn't learning anything I could not learn (at a lower cost) with a few books and the fundamental will power.
Thanks for your attention and please be gentle when replying:)
Jorge C.
rdc02271@yahoo.com
by poppi
by likeminders
Definitely a experienced person can proved a reliable n timely solution for a problem than
a fresh graduate.
So the Experienced Undergraduates must considered.
At the end of the day the thing that counts in the company is whether the work is done or not.
In my opinion the technical interviews must be 100% Practicle Oriented.
So the person can be better accessed.
I have no degree, but I do have a HNC in Business IT and a HNC in Civil engineering, the value if the two qualifications would possibly add up to more than a degree but not all employers recognise the fact that HNC students are usually working full time as well as studying a "degree level" qualification which is potentially more difficult than concentrating on study alone. I have 8 years experience in my field, I have just had a payrise of around 30% and my job title upgraded, there are graduates who work for me and are managed by me - so in all I would say yes, in many cases depending on the field of expertise that experience is more valuable than a degree. Realistically the two combined are better but how can you get experience while you(most students)are partying er... sorry studying.
Regards
Luke Lincoln
by cjc9
There's two issues here, the individual, and the job at hand...I would hire and undergrad with no degree in a minute to help build an application that he or she had relevant experience with in the past.
Would I hire that same person to be the tech lead for such a project? Probably not.
Undergrads with experience can help out immensely with the job of building an application, or set of applications...the drawback for the undergrads is that they would probably not be paid on an "even keel" with other "degreed" employees.
Later on down the road, a degree doesn't matter much. If someone has been building applications for 10 years, and demonstrated good working knowledge of what I was looking for...I could care less...
Also, I've seen people with degrees in Art History working as programmers, does that matter? Well, if I have two candidates applying for a software engineering/architect role, one with a degree in Computer Science and one with a degree in Art History, I'm going to ask the one with the Art History degree many more "tough" questions!!
I've always said a degree might get you your first job, but what you do on that first job is going to get you your subsequent jobs...the same way that most employers really don't care what you scored on your SATs in high schoool...
...just my 2 cents...
by cab2
by cab2
by cshipman
by rx3241
Monday, August 16, 2004
The piece of paper will open doors. SBC has its? Leadership Development Program. Graduate from a ?Name? school and HR will check you out. You?ll do three years in the program, each year in a different department, and than you?ll make second level manager ($80 - $100k).
I finished my BS degree in Management in 2002. I was hired as a Manager for special services (HI CAP, T1, OC 12-48?). The paper got me in the door, but I still had to perform. Telco is a de-reg. business now. Look at ATT., now that Dorman can?t rip folks off, He wants out of the Local business.
You could spend money on Career counselors (clones) or you could keep it simple.
Your great at chess (dynamic strategies), you win most of the time. You have no written proof that your great. You spend a lot of money for written proof (your no better, just ?got paper? now). The difference is now you have a chance to show your stuff. You can still fail. If you go for what you enjoy, that will be the most sustainable gratification when your doing your thing. Solving problems is what any job is about. The problem today may change to a different problem tomorrow (dynamic strategies). The difference between chess and Business is this: In chess you can see the whole board, in business you have external environments undermining your goals, your blind to attack unless you delegate team members to know what your foe is doing.
Asses your self honestly, think outside those boxes, never stop learning?that?s like being half dead.
This is mostly ?secular stuff?. Faith in yourself and the big guy can?t hurt.
by starat300
Area of spealialisation in ICT, the competence of the individual, the exposure of the individual to the require IT infrastructures, that will be needed on the job.
In my part of the world, craze for paper qualification is utmost, so if the person does know, he must be able to speak to many grammar and wear beautiful suits to make up.
The point remains, hand-on experience is better, the side effect is that such ones may not get pay rise on time.
These are my submissions.
Maxwell
by laredoflash9
by krogelr
The IT industry can employee any number of people at all levels. I have worked for several companies over the years in IT at these various levels.
The biggest obstacle I see people facing is ability. I have hired people with little experience that have great potential and turned down people with a lot of degree and certification but no real troubleshooting skill.
Prove your ability to solve problems and get the job done in the technical area you will be working. To me that is the most important thing. And be prepared to move for better pay if your area is depressed.
by mlanphea
by tonyh
by kphillips
Simply put, anyone with reasonable brains can take a class and pass it. But put in "real life" situations...like the ones I see daily..these "text book junkies" are just not prepared.Sure they know what causes this and that...and how it works...but when the system is down and you have a multi-million dollar company loosing money and everyone's stress level is at high...just see how great that "degree" will help you...I have been currently 6 yrs. on this job and it is a factor of all past problems and solutions that keep me in the "know". I keep files on all troubleshooting problems in the past and you have to be a great diagnostian and know where to start first all the while you have co-workers calling your phone constantly asking you when the system will be up...and what are you doing to hurry it along...etc. And you cannot ever forget the simplest things...like the other day...someone accidentally just unplugged the RJ-45 from the wall...connection went down on two isolated pc..and network printers...gee...I CAN SEE THAT "DEGREE" ON THE SERVER NOW...JUST LOOKING AT EVENT VIEWER...WASTING TIME...
I am not against getting a degree, but for me...I have all the skills and experience but I AM A MUTT...NO PAPERS...
LOL!
by kphillips
by kphillips
MCSE...=MUST CONSULT SOMEONE EXPERIENCED..I LOVE THAT ONE...
KEEP IT UP!
by gsosis
Don't get confused about this issue. Both are necessary. You need to be tutored in a career in order to understand the language and symbols in that line of career. Experience is what you acquire when you start applying the knowledge of the career. Experience do count a lot. A saying in my place: you don't face challenges, you say you are wise, who taught you?
- CRO, GSO Sistemms.
by unomas
by chaigram
by rknrlkid
The situation you just described illustrates poor management and supervision.
I don't care how a person got the job, if they are NEW to the company/position then it is the responsibility of the supervisory personnel to train them to do the job. If someone was in and out of a company in 8 months, then that company lost a huge investment in terms of money.
This is another huge problem I see on these threads. No one is ever realistically expected to know EVERYTHING on day one. Not college grad, certified, or experienced person. Not assisting a new employee to meet their maximum potential is seriously poor management.
From reading over these posts, I am starting to think the real problem developing in IT is in inexperienced people in supervisory positions, not in technical skills.
I am surprised sometimes how any business, anywhere, actually stays in business with such waste going on.
by bashar9090
by mdodd
by lantonio
A degree shows that an individual has the capability to learn (assuming they didn't cheat at least ... =) ).
I believe that this is the thought driving many of the replies in this thread ... ABILITY TO LEARN! So, perhaps, a degree could be considered a watermark, so to speak, for learning ability (whether you are studying something relevant, like CS, or not) ... although, the actual knowledge gained is of consequence, if someone can learn and understand all/most of the information in a degree (i.e. they don't scrape a pass by the skin of their teeth), then surely that must count for something.. that and anyone truly serious in getting a job/career in a given field should be doing work over and above what's in the formal degree course (i.e. getting (lots of) practical experience), thus making their chances of success, better.
(apologies if similar comments have been made - i really don't have time to dredge the whole lot and am going by title alone)
by jamesjmots
"...avertise..."
"...dissapoint..."
"...I helped got higher degrees..."
"...did not even understand..."
"...dont beleive me..."
You may be a helluva coder, but prose is not your forte.
by carterdn
Degree: 1. A Uni I attended in 1996 was using IT Software that was 10 years out-of-date and never in the popular mainstream. 2.The Lecturer showed all his students how to cheat the exams. 3.I had to teach the Lecturer how to make IT Templates for the Uni software package. 4.In 2003 I applied to learn Oracle at another Uni. First I was expected to learn Marketing (40 hours), Systems Analysis (18 hours), Normalisation (22 Hours), HR (40 hours), Java programming (40 Hours), Harvard Report Writing (20 Hours), and Radio Broadcasting (20 Hours). A broad education? Or a waste of valuable time for a 60 year old with 20 years IT experience? or a way for the Uni business to make easy money? 5 of the 6 Uni lecturers were IT illiterates unable to use the Uni computers to discover how many students were in their classes, and how many seats would be needed in a classroom. The Java Lecturer was Asian with a (foreign)degree in Maths. He had no previous teacher training and had never heard of the term "Debug". He was firmly convinced that A Maths degree was essential for any Computer Studies student.
I conclude that the Uni's primary purpose is not to educate but to extract money from Government Funds and immature student victims.
Grammar and Spelling. Some of your contributors are of foreign origin. I hope you do not think they are dumb just because they are not English language experts? Spelling is inexcuseable laziness with today's Spell Checkers. However, the best spell checked prose can be changed by the publishing process.
Corporate Presentations: As a former Air Traffic Controller I had to twice daily brief aircrew on Weather, Missions, Aviation Hazards, Etc. I had sickening stage fright for the first 10 years. My Point? Experience in any form can help solve problems. My advice to IT Hirers? Play chess with your candidates. You will discover who can think and resolve problems "on the fly".
by clindell
There is NOTHING like real world experience! NOTHING. NO classroom will teach you what to do in a real emergency. Don't get me wrong I respect any degree holder for taking the time to get one but there are to many classes needed that have NOTHING to do with what you are studying for! That is a problem with our education system.
I would first hire an experienced person with a degree then the experienced and lastly someone with a degree.
There is NO substitute for EXPERIENCE, NONE
by admin
by poppi
by qrubim
by bcgreaves
by pka
by james.chau
by aldanatech
by gjanes
Dropped out of high-school (1974). Dropped out of Tech-School (1981). Long-haired, grey-haired (whats left), 370/390 DOS/VSE, CICS Command... It doesn't make sense but that's where I started.
Today, I'm .NET, C#, Biztalk 2004, ASC X12, ADABAS/Natural 2.xxx, and historical (remember when????). Certification is when I offer a co-worker a breath mint.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending