Discussion Locked

DOWNLOAD: The metrics of IT: Management by measurement

0 helpful
2 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5138-10878-5843513.html

After you take a look at this download, please post your feedback, ideas for improvements, or further thoughts on this topic.

Thanks,
--The TechRepublic Downloads Team

2 replies

by wayne m.

I am not sure what the authors of this paper intended to accomplish, as the paper lacks a proper introduction or conclusion, and seems to consist of an unrelated jumble of opinions and unsupported observations. I would recommend that any reader truly interested in measurement and the analysis of measurements should read Dr. W. Edwards Deming, particularly "Out of the Crisis".

Two areas I have of particular concern are, one, the authors' confusion over assignable cause problems versus systemic variation, and, two, the use of arbitrary targets.

Root cause analysis is effective in analyzing problems arising from a single identifiable cause. Measurements are often useful in this analysis, but serve no purpose once the problem has been addressed. To continue the measurment is this case is wasted effort.

Systemic problems, however, are based on a myriad of interactions and reflect the natural variation within the status quo. The helpdesk support cost is representative of this type of problem. Improvement in this area requires changes by leadership in levels higher than the helpdesk.

This leads to the second issue. After stating early in the paper that one should not rely on "gut feel", the authors propose that an arbitrary target for cost of the helpdesk be set. On what basis is this number derived? How in the world is the helpdesk staff going to address the issue? Apparently, they can either reduce helpdesk costs by taking unpaid leave of absense, or they can increase the number of helpdesk calls.

There are known methods for the analysis of data, notably Control Charts. Use of these provides informed decision making based on a history of data rather than a single, simple calculation made at a single point in time, and can provide an objective measure of performance rather that relying on arbitrary target values.

by tigerbright

Although it's implied in the article, I believe that IT metrics start with the determination if IT performs a Support function or is a Line / Business function within the organization. Using that as a start provides you with two different paths for metrics; a Support line function needs to substantiate it's existance through helping the Business line or lines achieve the objectives (using as a basis that line's Business Plan(s)). As a stand-alone Business Line, IT would need to substantiate it's existance using the Corporate Plan (how much does IT add to the 'bottom line', for example) as a basis. I believe this concept should be included in the article. Opinions ?

This discussion is closed to new replies.