Discussion Locked

DSL Modem verses Router

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

A side from firewalls which is better a DSL Modem or a DSL Router?
Reason being, we switched to DSL from ISDN for cost savings. Now we see performance go down considerably. We are running Low Speed DSL because high is not available yet. We are supose to have 128k Up and 384k Down.
The only difference is that we went from a ISDN router to a DSL modem.
The signal from our ISP shows good connection both ways.
Does anyone have any ideas?
Thanks
Bobb@billygoat.com

6 replies

by stillatit

A DSL router is, in fact, a DSL modem, with a router immediately behind it. (There are also things calling themselves DSL routers which are ONLY the router, and work WITH a DSL modem.) There should be no real difference in performance between a modem and a modem/router if all you are running is a single PC. You need the router if you are running a network, and you want the whole network to use the DSL.

As far as speed is concerned, your DSL should run about as fast as your ISDN, which was 128K (max) both up and down. A lot of the real speed you get depends on whether your ISP has oversubscribed his resources. Many or most ISPs have sold many times their backbone bandwidth in DSL bandwidth, knowing that it is the rare user who uses all of his bandwidth even most of the time. (You type something, a page loads, you stare at the page for some period of time, and so on.)

There are various sites which have bandwidth meters, so you can see what your real speed is. I like this one:
http://www.2wire.com/services/index.html

You might think about one of the freeware/shareware programs which claim to boost your bandwidth by multiplexing your data requests. One such is Netsonic, at:
www.netsonic.com
They have a free version and a for-sale version.

Good luck.

by ebob

And the other side of the coin is that your ISDN Router also had an ISDN "modem" in it, or very near it.

The layout, if you could see all of the key pieces is always:

your LAN ---> router ---> dataset ---> NET

"dataset" is your DSU/CSU, or modem, or whatever actually puts up the physical connection to the telco service.

It is common for your router and dataset to be in one box. xDSL users at home and in small businesses, typically have a vendor supplied DSL "modem" to which they connect a separate DSL router.

by ebob

In more detail, the connection looks like this:

(the PCs on your LAN)
---->
your hub and/or switch
---->
your router
---->
your firewall
---->
the dataset ("modem", CSU/DSU, etc.)
---->
physical link to ISP and "the Internet"

This applies whether your link is DSL, ISDN, T1, Frame/Relay, dial-up, X.25, whatever.

The typical "DSL Router" combines the switch, firewall and router into one box, often with other functionality. Some models also include a DSL "modem", but in general your ISP wants you to use a specific "modem", so be careful here.

This discussion is closed to new replies.