Question Locked

Email flagged as Junk/Spam

0 helpful
27 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Most of our email have been flagged as Spam
Hotnail, AOL, and many major corp.
Gmail receives email ok

We have an exchange server,
I have called sbc to setup a PTR record for
email.bhccrane.com IP 206.171.90.242
My server dosnt seem to be an Open Relay

I am running out of ideas. Any suggestions?

Copy of resturned hotmail email:

27 replies

by thechas

Start by seeing what the different postmasters have to say about your domain. If you can get them to respond, they should be able to tell you why your domain is being flagged as spam.

Take a close look at your domain name. Can you pick out any "flag" words from a string of letters in the domain name.

How about the pattern of your mailings? Do any of your staff or departments send out emails to large address lists?

If you use email to communicate with clients and customers, or for advertising, how easy is it for someone to opt out? How quickly do you remove names from your address list?

Most flagging comes from 3 main sources:

A hijacked domain or email server.

Mailing patterns or messages that look like spam.

Complaints from recipients.

In the case of the major web-mail providers, if the bulk of their users classify your messages as spam, you get on the global spam list.

The best way to stay off of spam lists is to only send email to those who want to receive it.

Chas

by pilot80

I have tried sending Normal email to hotmail and aol, ad they both return as spam though it works with yahoo and gmail.
No spam like email or flag in our domain name I think.

Also, we are flagged on corp like boeing.

Do you think it is local to us, maybe I did not set up the DNS right?

Or do I need to check into blacklist at this point?

by scott_heath

Verified you aren't on any blacklists? If your server was unsecured at one point and used as an open relay you could have gotten blacklisted.

Can you verify the reverse lookup is working right? Use dnsstuff.com to verify it's good.

by scott_heath

The MX record for bhccrane.com is set to email.bhccrane.com and reverse dns show to resolve properly.

I did a spam abuse lookup at dnsstuff.com on bhccrane.com and you are blacklisted on the following lists:

CBL
HOSTKARMA
PSBL
SPAMCOP
UBL
UCEPROTECTL1
TQM-SPAMTRAP
SPAMHAUS
XBL

If you go to dnsstuff.com and do your own search there will be a link next to each failed listing. Many have a request to be delisted link. It might be a long process, but you can get it resolved.

by pilot80

So it isn't normal to be listed on so many list right? So many of those big corporation use those list?
Does hotmail and aol use some of those lists also?
If sending email works for gmail and yahoo, it means it is not local to my server correct?
I want to make sure I have not setup something wrong on my end before blaming others.
I am thinking also about using one of these list on our exchange server as we are getting so much spam, even with the reverse dns on.
Is it a good idea?
Lastly, why would we be on so many list, we are a small company and I am sure our employee do not spam?

Thanks so much for your time Scott

Yann

by scott_heath

Someone reported you at some point, I'm not sure what the criteris is. Different companies use different lists, which explains the inconsistency with rehjected mail.

I can tell you how to log into your SMTP server and attempt to use it as a relay. If it works, then you need to do some tightening. The server could have been open two years ago or something and had gotten blacklisted then.

by pilot80

Please do, so I have to go to each Blacklist and ask them to remove me?
I will go to dnsstuff.com
So you dont see anything wrong with my dns right?

by pilot80

Looks like someone is using our server:
This is one of the result from spamtrap:
Or COuld it be a trojan?

From 0adave.gordon@bbc.co.uk Wed Nov 07 17:11:57 2007
victim@smtp.example
Delivery-date: Wed, 07 Nov 2007 17:11:57 -0500
Received: from [206.171.90.242] (helo=email.bhccrane.com)
by mail.victim.example with esmtp (Exim 4.63)
(envelope-from <0adave.gordon@bbc.co.uk>)
id 1Ipt7r-0003Dp-Kz; Wed, 07 Nov 2007 17:11:57 -0500
Received: from [206.171.90.242] by mx0.bbc.co.uk; Wed, 7 Nov 2007 14:06:14 -0800
From: "Galen Bowers" <0adave.gordon@bbc.co.uk>
To:
Subject: Madeleine McCann's father returns to work
Date: Wed, 7 Nov 2007 14:06:14 -0800
MIME-Version: 1.0
Thread-Index: Aca6Q2T6ABJCCZYSZ52LT09CZU066Y==

by scott_heath

You are most likely being used as a relay. trojans typically use their source PC as an SMTP server. You can run a SMTP server from any PC that has access to the internet.

Look at your SMTP logs and you should see odd IPs connecting to it. What mail server are you running?

by kjell_andorsen

Which version of Exchange are you running and do you know how to check if you're set up as an open relay? And more importantly, do you know how to close it if you are?

by pilot80

Sorry cannot reply, it says I have reached maximum message level
I am using Exchange 2007 and I have checked to make sure it wasnt an opoen relay.
Can you check . the ip is 206.171.90.242?
How do I check smtp logs?
Thanks so much

by scott_heath

I could be wrong. I telneted to your smtp server but it wouldn't allow me to send an email to myself.

You could have a client that has a virus and it is using their email profile to send out messages. A lot of the viruses I have seen send thousands though. Do you use perf logs or anything to monitor your email flow?

by pilot80

Um, so it means, my exchange is secure and not open relay?
I do not monitor, but I just installed MOM
What else could I use
Thank you sooo much

by scott_heath

It seem secure with a cursory glance, but you might want to get a best practives document and make sure all your settings are good. Remember, you could have been blacklisted a while ago. But I would make sure all the desktops have good antivirus. Remember some legit email is getting bounced back as spam. Lok for users with extremely high numbers of email sent per day.

by pilot80

I noticed some of the spam was still going out as of 10/05 and it seems it was sent to UK for some reason.
Do you know how to check logs for email sent of hand?

Thanks

by pilot80

Thank you I have used this tool , and it seems my exchange server is running well.
I have gone through message tracking and found 2 users that just left the company are sending lot of spam.
How can I find out which pc it is coming from?
I think that is the problem, probably a trojan installed

by scott_heath

The Exchange Server should have the source IP for the message.

by pilot80

I cannot see ip in Message Tracking Center.
I can see the spam messages there.
If I look in LofFiles, I cannot find anything related to that user
How do I?

by pilot80

I was lucky to be on the server when it happened last.
Under current session, I found an IP that belong in Netherland, sending email with one of our username

How could that be?

Do you want to see the log?

by scott_heath

Something is definately not secure on your system. Did you run the best practices analyzer? I'm not an email guru, but post it and I'll see what I can do.

by pilot80

I included new log with the method:
it shows RCPT 250:
Does that mean they are using relay to login?
If so how come the port is 0?
And then how come when I try to relay it gives me 550 error?

#Fields: date time c-ip cs-username s-sitename s-computername s-ip s-port cs-method sc-status sc-bytes cs-bytes time-taken cs-host cs(User-Agent)
2007-11-12 17:00:05 200.106.75.211 esquema SMTPSVC1 SBSERVER 192.168.11.11 0 HELO 250 47 12 2266 - -
2007-11-12 17:00:05 200.106.75.211 esquema SMTPSVC1 SBSERVER 192.168.11.11 0 MAIL 250 59 46 0 - -
2007-11-12 17:00:05 200.106.75.211 esquema SMTPSVC1 SBSERVER 192.168.11.11 0 RCPT 250 0 30 15 - -
2007-11-12 17:00:05 200.106.75.211 esquema SMTPSVC1 SBSERVER 192.168.11.11 0 RCPT 250 0 28 0 - -
2007-11-12 17:00:05 200.106.75.211 esquema SMTPSVC1 SBSERVER 192.168.11.11 0 RCPT 250 0 32 16 - -
2007-11-12 17:00:05 200.106.75.211 esquema SMTPSVC1 SBSERVER 192.168.11.11 0 RCPT 250 0 33 0 - -
2007-11-12 17:00:06 200.106.75.211 esquema SMTPSVC1 SBSERVER 192.168.11.11 0 DATA 250 122 1088 234 - -
2007-11-12 17:00:06 200.106.75.211 esquema SMTPSVC1 SBSERVER 192.168.11.11 0 QUIT 240 67 4 0 - -

I am thinking about getting an email security appliance or gateway or firewall at this point. I cannot even stop people to accessing my server

by pilot80

I also run Best Practice Analyzer
Shows all good.
Found out from my router that one client is connected to an address in Amsterdam, probably an smtp engine on there too
So it seems I have trojans on the network, and outside IP rcpt relay with the server.
So far i think I have disabled the relay problem by disabling all relay even including Authenticated Users. But some spam is still coming, but at a lesser rate

by scott_heath

I wish I could be of more help, but I'm just not familiar with all the different SMTP settings you might need to check. I would Google 'secure exchange ' and see what sort of tech papers it might bring up. Hopefully if you have more questions an email guru will show up!

This discussion is closed to new replies.