Discussion Locked

Fighting a futile war

0 helpful
485 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post

485 replies

by $$$$$$$$$$

What he says in paragraphs 2 - 4 is accurate, but his only interest in the facts is how they help or harm Republicans' chances of getting into office. If he was a non-partisan, independent contractor for policies he believes in I could respect him, but he's just horrible.

"OK. But what if Iran moves into the vacuum and takes over Iraq?"

OK. But what if we're struck by a killer asteroid and green Reptilians take over what's left of the Earth?

I'll explain shortly, in a reply to your original comment with the link to the newsmax.com article.

by jck

They've been trying to rip out each others' plumbing and put their own in for over 2000 years.

I say...why try and compete with dozens of em? Let em keep at it til one survives...then we can move in on the market...like any smart capitalist would do lol ;)

by $$$$$$$$$$

Iran [b]has the right to develop nuclear reactor technology[/b], under Article 4 of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, and as a signatory to that, [b]the United States is legally obligated to respect Iran's right to develop nuclear reactor technology[/b]. Nevertheless, Iran has offered to negotiate even on that, in return for normal relations, and an end to the Bush administration's pursuit of "regime change." (3:00)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XctgkYj5aVk

Dick Morris' arguments and suggestions from paragraph 5 to the end rely on fallacies, which unfortunately are also common "knowledge." Morris and McCain and Cheney and Lieberman and Bush might very well get away with it, if we all refuse to pay attention.

In closing, I repeat Scott Ritter's encouragement to [b]carefully[/b] read the March 2006 version of the National Security Strategy, the war powers authorizations, the 911 Commission Report, and any other relevant, unclassified documents. He takes a responsible approach to forming his opinions [b]based on facts[/b], and the various proponents of war with Iran demonstrably do not.

by oz_media

Political posturing and positioning.

Everyone knows that Russia wants in on the oil, as does China. With Russian bases setting up in in the Middle East, it was imperative for the USA to do so before China could get a good foothold too.

The fight is for oil, we should all at least agree with that now. We know it has nothing to do with Saddam, WMD, poor Iraqi's being downtrodden or religious choices, it's all about oil.

The Taliban in Afghanistan, oil. They want to conttrol the pipeline and money in Afghanistan, which is not in the best favour of the rest of the world. I fully supported the Afghanistan occupation, it was ridding the area of Taliban forces, AlQaeda and other terrorist groups whom I watched attack our neighbours to the south. I think that occupation was needed, was justified and was wanted, I have no problems there.

Iraq, is different story all together. unjustified, no terrorist attack on other free nations etc. Just invasion, occupation and destruction of another country and its citizens.

It is only NOW justified as an occupation due to the uprising against the US occupation, which should bever have started to begin with.

So who gets the oil?

It's just like in WWII. Germany turned tail and headed toward Russia long before D-Day. Hitler realized he couldn't invade England after the UK downed most of the Luftwaffe and retaliated by throwing even more back at him.

In order to set himself up and gain a foothold and full control of the East, Hitler needed Russia's oil. Hitler was mad with syphillis by that time and his megalomania resulted in him trying to take out Stalingrad, removing needed forces from southern Russia, against his defecting military commanders wishes. He sunk pretty quick at that point, Russia proved to also be more than Germany could handle, especially in winter and Germany was worn down and slaughtered.

So I hope that now we have more and more truth uncovered and more and more LIES prove to be simply excuses to invade a country, that people will finally see the true objective. Who gets the oil?
Russia, China or the USA?

Why did the USA go there to begin with and help the Taliban arm themselves against the Russian's years ago? Taliban had taken control of the Afghan pipeline and Russia wanted in on it.
Soon after, we went in to remove the Taliban from the same oil we helped them protect, wonder why THEY are p1ssed off now?!

Just as Bush convinced Americans they were in danger of WMD, Bin Laden has effectively turned Afghans against Americans, seeing you as infidels and using religious differences (taken out of context) to gain support.

Unfortunately, nothing has changed in Afghanistan, fighting is more aggressive than ever before, the Taliban rule Kandahar and the outskirts of Afghanistan again and soldiers die there more often now than when the first invasion took place.

It's such a simple plan, it's such a simple issue, it's amazing how many people simply refuse to see it.

by jck

Who controls the middle eastern oil is all the world's concern, since it is the largest known, tapped supply.

There are rumours that huge deposit are in the ANWR and off the coast of Brasil, which would power even a growing, modernising populous for over 100 more years.

If leaders were really so concerned about getting off of the dependence on foreign oil reserves, they'd take the billions upon billions in "incentives" and "programs" to corporates and turn that into a modernisation scheme to get truly alternative, efficient means of transportation out there on the market at a realistic price by 2020.

I mean, what is a young couple who are just starting out going to buy to conserve fuel?

The $26,000 Toyota Prius Hybrid?

Or

The non-hybrid $14,000 Kia Rio hatchback?

That should be a no-brainer.

by $$$$$$$$$$

What do you have against "the magnificence of foothills"? Or, is it specifically the enjoyment of them? And if so, where does your grudge against others' enjoyment begin & end?

by santeewelding

I chose more better in order to slow your order.

Didn't work.

I need to point out, I guess, that I signify progress along a right line of good by "more," not demarcation and disavowal of one segment for another -- analog, not all or nothing digital, atheist.

Nor may you hold me to revulsion in the case of magnificence, where my word ought plainly say I enjoy the same.

"Grudge" is thus dispatched, its predicative dispatched.

Operate beyond magnificence.

by oz_media

But you are looking for help from people who's advice you spat upon.

YOu were told not to play with the copier as it will probably break, but you did and it broke. Now you want empathy and support putting it back together.

Ever had one of your boys break something that you WARNED them they were going to break if they weren't more careful?

Did you tell them it was fine and help them fix it right away, or did you say I TOLD YOU NOT TO DO THAT TO BEGIN WITH BECAUSE YOU'D BREAK IT!

sure, in the end you will sort it out but not before a bit of a tongue lashing.

In the case of starting a war and killing thousands of innocent US and Iraqi citizens; you don't expect a tongue lashing and just want everyone to forget the screw up and help out instead?

Sorry, doesn't work that way.

by oz_media

Okay, well we all know Bush and his minions are oil grabbing slime balls. He couldn't run an oil company properly so he has to save face by catering to their whims.

Not just Bush though, the US oil and pharmaceutical companies have more control of your country's government than the voice of the people or congress; it has been that way for decades now.

So while you are 100% right, the funding needs ot be dumped into a better resolution, can you imagign how good the USA would look to the world if they actually pulled off a better renewable energy source? You have the money and capital, why not? Because you are funding a retarded war (sorry if I offended any retards).

Take that same billion and throw some more in, most Americans wouldn't mind, you would have allies helping out however they could for sure!

There are other resolutions, take the value out of this oh so precious energy source and
the Afghans and Iraqi's don't have much left to protect or fight over. That would end the war in Iraq immediately. I promise you that if a better source was found, you'd be out of Iraq in a heartbeat, proving to the world what the true intent really was.

But, what about Halliburton and others? They would be PO'd with Bush, and while he doesn't care what the public think of him, having his buddy's turn on him would be absolute turmoil. Who would he go and play with after his term in office, average Americans? Not bloody likely.

Yeah, detatch yoru government from teh massive conglomerate that rule over the USA and you'd be on your way to greatr things. If they weren't buddies you could also start regulating and capping thier product and service prices, saving everyone some money in the process.

But hey, listen to the others, this is NOT about oil, it is about protecting American families from the WMD which Saddam is gonna use to kill you. :D

by oz_media

No matter what happens, win, lose or draw, you will always be painted in a negative light by the Middle Eastern media.

Remember just how many Germans were convinced that concentration camps didn't even exist? I know an older lady who STILL doesn't believe it today, figrues it was all just a setup by the Allies to make teh Axis look worse.

No matter what happens in the Middle East, America will never lose the scars, the terrorists will simply con everyone into thinking they fought and you ran. But to stick around and lose thousands more US lives, for an occupation that may NEVER end is simply stupid.

Either cut your losses and get out or seek a better resolution that war....well, it's too late for the latter now I suppose.

by oz_media

Errr, the US IS still there, or have you forgotten about the troops that don't make the daily headlines?
I understand that if you have been campign for teh last 5 years that you may be a little out of the lopp but that's either complete blindness or just ignorance of facts.

In Canada this is still a daily news item, as Canadian troops have been heading the war in Afghanistan since the US removed thier embassy and many troops to segue into Iraq, leving a few US, UK and scattered other allied troops with Canadian troops.

The war in Afghanistan is far worse now than it was before, the Taliban have increased thier size immensely since the invasion in Iraq, they have moved back in and taken over Kandahar and now are the same except larger than when the war first started. There are many more formerly peaceful Afghans now joining AlQaeda and tha Taliban because of the war in Iraq. You made things FAR worse, left while declaring premature victory, invaded another Muslim country and now have more threats upon you and the rest of the world than ever before.

Afghanistan is back to its old self now though, wells destroyed, women downtrodden, wearing burqas in public, they have ousted the women in government, women no longer go to schools or hospitals for training as you left security in those areas up to the same people you kicked out when you arrived (no, not the Taliban).

How quickly people forget reality when the media stops spinning it.
Great resolution! Go put some more gas on the fire, it's bound to go out one day.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Put it on YouTube and spread the word. With a sufficient volume of Internet activity, even Rupert Murdoch's shills aren't allowed to ignore a story. If it's as popular as what they normally fabricate, even Faux News will cover true stories. Grudgingly.

by oz_media

Canadian news is full of the latest Afghan updates every day.

CBC, Global (formerly BCTV), CTV, 24, BBC News Canada.

It doesn't matter what is put on YouTube, if people don't want to see reality, they don't. If people don't want to accept truth, they won't.
If people wish to feel they are doing the right thing, they will.
If people think Us news is correct, they sure as hell aren't going to accept altermnate news no matter of its source.

You can Google them all and see the latest in Afghanistan, but to read someone defening their political view by suggesting that Afghanistan is a done deal and over with, stating that the US is not there anymore, is simplly blind, ignorant and WAAAAAAAy out of the loop.

just couldn't let that one go.

There are some really backward comments in this thread, makes me wonder where people have been hiding out.

Now there is even suggestion that Iraq is justified because of the terrosists?

terrorists that didn't terrorize America or American troops until long after you invaded and AlQaeda rebuilt and recruited en mass because people didn't like the US occupation in Iraq.

Many more, would be allies, are now dead set on harming the US and US soldiers. Well done! Way to do the absolute opposite of what you set out to do. Guess its time for the rest of the world to sit on our hands and say I told you so, while watching more and more of your citizens get killed by your choice of government. (YOU and YOUR referring to America, not you directly)

by $$$$$$$$$$

...Chomsky says some interesting things.

[i]You can Google them all and see the latest in Afghanistan, but to read someone defening their political view by suggesting that Afghanistan is a done deal and over with, stating that the US is not there anymore, is simplly blind, ignorant and WAAAAAAAy out of the loop.[/i]

No kidding! Until this thread started, I really was not aware of Kucinich's attempt to impeach Cheney.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJYbgouqlMw&feature=related

I don't understand why that didn't happen. It's not like he's a real Republican, he's a neo-conservative, William Kristol-loving commie in GOP clothing.

by $$$$$$$$$$

"With proper media spin
jdclyde - 04/29/08 we will hear how it is all Bush's fault that the killing fields start to fill thanks to the Democrat retreat."

Is that really your only objection? Bush will look bad? Because you should know, all of Democrats, and roughly half of Republicans, will now never hold a favorable opinion of him. You may as well write that guy as a loss to the party's prestige, renounce his neo-con agendas, and see if you can revive the Gingrich plank.

by $$$$$$$$$$

"I need to point out, I guess, that I signify progress along a right line of good by "more," not demarcation and disavowal of one segment for another -- analog, not all or nothing digital, atheist."

Too much allegory. I'd rather try to understand BALTHOR.

"Nor may you hold me to revulsion in the case of magnificence, where my word ought plainly say I enjoy the same."

Oh, I may still choose to do that.

"Operate beyond magnificence."

You may pay me before you presume to give me instructions.

by nicknielsen

[i]...I signify progress along a right line of good by "more," not demarcation and disavowal of one segment for another -- analog, not all or nothing digital...[/i]

He believes in incremental progress in a number of areas, not in a single magic bullet. He sees shades of grey and not just black and white. In other words, he's not only capable of objective thought, he actually prefers it.

I like the way he thinks.

Edit: formatting

by oz_media

First of all I have to agree, if the money wasn't being spent on war, it doesn't mean it would be spent on new energy sources, even though that was merely a suggestion/proposal and not a statement of fact to begin with.

As for your statement, what year is it?

"If you want to lower the dependence of foreign oil, how about opening up areas for drilling? They allow China to drill 50 miles off of our coastline but we're restricted from doing so."

opening up what areas for drilling? Places such as the protected wildlife habitats in Northern Canada? the problem with Americans getting ANY resources is that they have absolutely NO IDEA how to manage resources.
american companies rape and pillage others and then wonder what they can take next.

The concept of replacing an unrenewable and quickly dwindling resource is not to extract MORE of it but to find an ALTERNATE source.

Yuo bitched about China drilling off your shores when you are nto allowed to?
In teh early 80's MOST fisheries in BC closed down. US fisheries who can't replenish their own stocks were pushing for openings in the south island, BC coastal regions. With Canadaian fishermen havign tight restrictions on boat sizes, catches, openings etc. and getting little government support financially, they all went out of business. I can name at LEAST a half dozen friends who lost livlihoods and almost their homes due to the US unflux on Canadian fisheries in the 80's. They have NOT recovered and rebuilt, they have simply gone away.

But hey, Chinese steal your oil, why shouldn't you steal Canadian fish, eye for an eye right?

There was a massive and very healthy lumber industry in BC, the companies thived and everyone made a strong living.
Today, any unprotected land on Vancouver is under US owned and operated Weyerhauser's thumb. Now, many once gorgeous parts of Vancouver Island are clear cut. Completely barren and waiting for the next cut. I used ot live at the base of one of their logging roads and knew many employees of Weyer's, most were americans working here on Visa's a few were ex.Canfor workers who just lucked into teh job when their own plant was shut down.

To make matters worse, NAFTA imposed a softwood lumber tarriff on exports ot the USA, you still owe us several billion in unpaid tarriffs, dig deep you now owe a lot of coin.

That is just teh asolute TIP of the iceberg, then there's WalMart, who should be shut down for exploitation, false advertising and a gazillion other illegal activities, which they always get off on in court. Unfortunately a family member USED to offer their legal council up here, now he has moved on to other companies.

But hey, lets not whine and complain about what you take form others, lets just focus on obtaining MORE resources from people.

The other day there was a vote on a Canadian radio station to cut the US off from Canadian oil, 60% of your imported oil comes from Canada's Alberta reserves. It was unanymous that Canada should styop providing teh US with oil to hopefully drive our prices down, which obviously wouldn't work at all anyway. The point being, everyone sees teh US as a gluttonous waster of resources, you refuse to accept a global problem, you refuse to accetp that you MAY HAVE TO CUT DOWN A BIT on how you piss away your resources as well as others. You may not be able to rive as far, you may not be able to pollute as much, you MAY have to become more responsible (god help us!). The bottom line is everyone in the world knows you wouldl never see being resourceful as more imprtnat than havign your personal comforts and luxuries, you are a young country with a young population and a very young government. It's like watching a little kid sometimes, except for now you are considered a powerful nation due to size and financial wealth.

But that will end, always does, and someone else will be in the spotlight, I am sure another superpower, even if teh Middle East could not possibly cause more harm to the rest of the world than the USA has anyway. bring on President Bin Laden, all hail Allah!

whining about China drilling off your shores, whiel you dump bilge oil all over our costlines, ship crap through our natural whale habitate and much worse. Way to go America, way to show the rest of the world your ideals, or lack thereof.

by santeewelding

You responded with near blunt-force trauma. each thought terminated in a period, no further movement indicated. Your gerundive is misapplied.

by santeewelding

Leaving for not belonging is not possible. Being all around you, is, and so easily so.

Flit and shoot from everywheres you care. Your positions are known, numbered, and not near up to it.

True, as you can see, I seem to yield from the very go, or I seem to one as you. You shoot through a veil of no other side.

That I am awkward and faux wise, you subjective as you can possibly be, rendered otherwise, tempts a snarl and a bite, I remembering how, breaking not the skin, and a whole lot more.

Rein it in.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Some IT guy calling himself Locrian_Lyric made a sensible observation, that "there are no benchmarks as war is a constantly changing environment." I don't agree wholeheartedly, but I can see some sense in it. But his role here is, by my assumption, only a hobby or a pastime. Paid mouthpieces of Bush/Cheney haven't done nearly so well, with stronger motivation and access to at least some Classified documents, unavailable to us.

Go straight to 3:00 if you dislike or expect to dislike Keith Olbermann.

The questions of GWB's honesty do not stem [i]only[/i] from partisanship and hatred of his personality -- those exist, but they do not [i]nullify[/i] the many legitimate complaints. People like me, who were enthusiastic for none of the 2000 & 2004 "contenders" for President, yet wanted to take the President at his word, even though we'd consider a night in the Lincoln bedroom a punishment, hear what he says and see the expression on his face as he says it (5:30), and we know that "rejecting those ideas...leaving before the job is done" without ever defining "[b]the job[/b]" since his WMD's were proven to be fictitious -- we know that that man is not to be trusted, ever.

by puppybreath

Calm down, will you? I can tell you're worked up by the number of typos.

The point I was trying to make was that we hear a lot from people that complain that we have too much dependence on foreign oil but the government refuses to allow ways to reduce it. We can't build refineries, can't explore or drill (on our property, not yours) for more oil, can't build nuclear plants, won't work to develop alternative fuels, won't use wind farms, etc. etc.

I agree that we should curb comsumption. I agree that we need alternatives. But in the short term, if we want to reduce our dependence, we have to get the oil from somewhere else. The smartest thing, IMHO, is to use our own available resources rather than trying to work with foreign powers.

When you have someone saying that you're restricted from drilling off the coast because of the dangers to the environment and then allow other countries to do it, it doesn't make much sense.

But I agree that the long term solution is to come up with another fuel source.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]I can tell you're worked up by the number of typos.[/i]

Never mind, I get it; you can tell, by the number of typos, that he's worked up.

[i]The point I was trying to make was that we hear a lot from people that complain that we have too much dependence on foreign oil but the government refuses to allow ways to reduce it.[/i]

I would be interested in a thorough [not necessarily complete, but thorough would be good] study of who in Congress has voted against which energy plants, when, and who has donated to their campaigns, bought them lunch, taken them golfing etc.

by puppybreath

But the best thing for America would be to require term limits and then throw out everyone currently in office.

Most, if not all, have proven to be unworthy so we'd be better off starting with a clean slate rather than letting them finish out their terms so they can get those last few retirement "donations".

by $$$$$$$$$$

Only individuals may donate; no corporations, PACs, PIRGs, churches, no exceptions. Simply put, collectives are too difficult to hold to account for corruption. Individuals can be so held quite easily, [b]except[/b] when their corruption occurs as member of a collective.

Kenneth Lay
I rest my case.

by puppybreath

and let's not forget line item veto to cut back on the enormous amount of pork that these jokers throw into every bill.

by $$$$$$$$$$

1. The President has the option, without the line-item veto, of stating which lines are the reason for his plain-old veto.

2. Use of the line-item veto tends to reduce attention to the particular scum-bags getting line-item vetoed, and their corporate sponsors.

3. A decent database front-end is not very difficult, nor expensive [relative to the $10^12/year sums at stake] to create, nor keep current with the latest days' spending items. Members of Congress already have a fair number of assistants. Keeping records of each members' votes could be made a mandatory duty of one or more existing staffers, or possibly competition to be the most forthcoming would make new legislation unnecessary, if private interested parties first create such a tool and prove it useful to citizens eager to be well-informed, without spending half of each day doing so. The latter case would also make a powerful statement about the need for new legislation, to address what basically are structural problems.

by puppybreath

As I understand it, the line veto would allow the President to still sign a bill into law after removing the pork or portions that he considers to be unnecessary.

So, if he signs it and doesn't remove the pork or eliminates important sections, you hold him totally accountable for his actions. If he removes the pork and Congress complains, you force them to explain why adding millions of dollars to a bill for a bridge that goes nowhere is really necessary.

If he eliminates important pieces of the legislation that would directly affect the public, Comgress still has the opportunity to override the veto after publicizing it so that the public can get involved.

As it is now, we hear about the pork once in a while on slow news days. To really get a good understanding though, you have to dig to find out exactly who is trying to add pork and which bill they are using to do it.

by locrian_lyric

Anyone can despise a cowardly attack.

That does not mean that we had world support or anything other than a 'gee, that's awful' sentiment.

IF you recall, we already encountered opposition when we went into Afghanistan.

Memories fade over time when they don't directly affect you. The truth is, the world doesn't give a damn about the USA. Never has, never will.

Do a google search on Gordon Sinclair. Almost four decades later, those words still ring true.

We lost France's goodwill the moment the last Nazi was removed from their soil.

Anti-americanism did not begin, nor will it end with GWB.

Look at how Europe thought of America in the early 19th century. European papers even published such nonsense that everything degraded in America to the point where dogs ceased to bark.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[b]Politician: My opponent believes that higher taxes are the only way to pay for needed improvements. She never met a tax she didn't like. But I have a better idea: let's cut waste in government first.

Why are politicians always so willing to tell you what the other side thinks? One reason is that, in explaining someone else's views, we have a chance to oversimplify and even falsify them. In the example above, is it really likely that the opponent prefers raising taxes to cutting waste in government? Probably, her position is much more complex than that, and makes better sense.[/b]
http://www.sjsu.edu/depts/itl/graphics/adhom/straw.html

[i]Anyone can despise a cowardly attack.[/i]

To do so implies only [u]sympathy[/u] for the victim of a cowardly attack, not your caricature:

[i]That does not mean that we had [u]world support[/u] or anything other than a 'gee, that's awful' sentiment.[/i]

"Gee, that's awful" is a basically accurate, though childishly unsophisticated substitute for the word "sympathy," which is the exact word I chose, for good reason. Your straw man argument falsely asserts that I said we had [b]more[/b] "than a 'gee, that's awful' sentiment;" that we had [b]more[/b] than the world's sympathy. But I did not say that. Your rebuttal depends on the [u]perception[/u] that I did. The facts are, in fact, on my side.

We did [b]not have enough[/b] sympathy to randomly or whimsically attack countries that don't and didn't threaten us. We [b]did[/b] have enough sympathy to be supported in overthrowing a sovereign government in Afghanistan which was known to support our attackers; that was widely considered a defensive action on our part, and acceptable or at least debatable under various secular and religious definitions of "just war," including those common to Judaism, Christianity and Islam. We [b]did[/b] have enough sympathy to wield our soft power effectively, but our Nincumpoop-in-Chief lacks either the smarts to do so or the courage to stand up to Cheney, or both. Since he's initiated this war in Iraq, and engaged in such embarrassing, unsubstantiated, prolonged saber-rattling with Iran, I really wonder whether we'd have any support, in the case of another attack, say by one of the many groups in South America, which tend to use similar tactics, terrorism.

[i]IF you recall, we already encountered opposition when we went into Afghanistan.[/i]

I recall a healthy period of debates about invading an impoverished, sovereign nation, in which our CIA had already fought a proxy war with the USSR for 10 years, among other things. The [u]official[/u], willing support of the Taliban government for the group that said they attacked us, Al Qaida, is what ended those debates in favor of our invasion of Afghanistan, as I recall. I also recall a bit of a coalition, which is my point. We certainly enjoyed more assistance there than we've had in Iraq, since it has become glaringly obvious that the WMDs were not an honest error, but a deliberate falsification for the sake of a policy that had already been decided on the basis of Cheney and other neo-cons' Project for a New American Century agenda.

[i]Memories fade over time when they don't directly affect you. The truth is, the world doesn't give a damn about the USA. Never has, never will.[/i]

Do you expect the world to give a damn about you? I'm satisfied to be left alone, except possibly for a bit of international trade. That is the relationship with other countries provided for by our Constitution, not 700 military bases scattered over 130 countries.

[i]Do a google search on Gordon Sinclair. Almost four decades later, those words still ring true.

We lost France's goodwill the moment the last Nazi was removed from their soil.[/i]

Incorrect, hyperbole. We "lost" the bond of a common, extremely repugnant enemy. Do a Google search on Machiavelli, and read up on the various methods and motivations for forming alliances. We don't have to be bestest best pals to not go to war. It's strategically foolish to go to war when diplomacy can avoid it.

[i]Anti-americanism did not begin, nor will it end with GWB.

Look at how Europe thought of America in the early 19th century. European papers even published such nonsense that everything degraded in America to the point where dogs ceased to bark.[/i]

That only tells me that the popular press was at that time already well on its way to becoming the utter crap that it is now. Public opinion is not a monolith, much as the collectivist swine who are attracted to being "media moguls" [Rupert Murdoch, and William Randolph Hearst before him] always wish that it would be.

by $$$$$$$$$$

That would not be the tie-breaker issue for me, unless I'm faced with some remarkably unremarkable candidates. And, it could be interesting to see how it fares.

Personally, I think our biggest problem might not even be structural; the cultural aversion to exercising the [b]Constitutional[/b] option to impeach has allowed Bush, Jr. and Cheney to keep a lot of facts to themselves, which at the very least the Congress who voted to authorize military action, has the right to know. They seem uncertain of that right, and reluctant to assert it.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]As members of congress, don't you think
they already have access to all the
information?[/i]

The Senate Foreign Intelligence Committee
had access to Secret or higher clearance
information, which clearly contradicted the
conclusions that Saddam (1) had WMDs or was
anywhere close to a nuclear program since
losing Kuwait (2) had ever had ties to Al
Qaida. The members of that committee were
prohibited by law from exposing
Bush/Cheney's lies, and unfortunately did
not risk prison to save soldiers' lives.

by ontheropes

I now have many things figured out to my satisfaction and can say that I feel no need to convince anyone else to believe 'things' to be the same way as I see them. That's not important. What IS important, to me, is that other people who kick or rebel against the status quo do speak up. I need to hear it. I don't have everything figured out yet but I'm working on it. This go along to get along crap is just that, crap. I learn very little from it.

I hope you continue to speak up!

by $$$$$$$$$$

I clearly remember the propaganda leading up to the Iraq war, and that being a bit contrary to my impression that, for the most part, the UN sanctions and inspections of Iraq had achieved their objectives. Looking back, I was suspicious, and didn't have enough information to be any more than suspicious. [b]Now[/b] I have enough information to be absolutely certain that Bush, Rumsfeld and Cheney are bald-faced liars, which means only that. It doesn't mean that any of us are or were stupid.

"I hope you continue to speak up!"

I plan to let up when they're all tried for war crimes.

by protiusx

Okay here we go again with the inane leftist dribble "Bush lied! Kids died!" or "it?s an oil war!"... I wonder seriously if you or your kind have ever had an original thought. Is there any way you could possibly offer any substance to your argument other than the leftist propaganda slogans you've already spewed out.
I could argue that he had the same intelligence as everyone else in the world at that time and that many of your Leftist peers (Hillary Clinton, Howard Dean, and John Kerry to name a few) were saying the same thing the president was at the time. I won't argue with you though as it would be as throwing pearls before swine.

by jdclyde

Bush TRICKED them. He is a criminal mastermind that was able to fool them all.

Oh wait, he is an idiot and of below average intellegence?

But he TRICKED them, so they must be even dumber than he is?

Which is it, criminal mastermind that tricked everyone or idiot?

I don't expect a rational response from the people that have been saying both sides at the same time.

by $$$$$$$$$$

He didn't "trick" anybody. He dealt from a fixed deck, and has been caught. Check out the evidence.

Recently, in a discussion of a very different topic, deepsand made a very pertinent remark on the responsibility for ignorance. I did not agree with him, by the way, on blaming teachers for students' ignorance. But teachers are merely paid to assist in learning. They do not, as a rule, have the power to withhold access to any information that their students take the trouble to seek in a library, or other useful source of information.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=261584&messageID=2485025

[i]I don't expect a rational response from the people that have been saying both sides at the same time.[/i]

And who, pray tell, is that?

by nicknielsen

But he's not the only one involved. There was a Rummy involved, and there's still a Dicky that, in addition to being a megalomaniac, is as sharp as a tack.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Ask, and ye shall receive.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HyWsyqLDYjE
(the meat begins about 0:50 into the montage)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W-6ibicKl50

Feith, under-qualified to be even a PR guy, essentially was put in charge of policy decisions.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zn3tGD6M-50

"We're coming up on 3500 servicemen killed, more than 25,000 service members seriously wounded. The Iraqis themselves lose that amount in a month. They've suffered more then 100,000 casualties. As the Iraq Study Group said, this will cost $1 Trillion to $2 Trillion before all is said and done. Remember Larry Lindsay was fired for saying it would cost $200 Billion. So at the end of this, not only have we not succeeded -- have we not achieved our objectives, but as the President acknowledged this week in his speech at the Coast Guard Academy we actually now face a much more foreboding threat, largely of our own making."
( PJ Crowley )

by nicknielsen

Didn't Rush Limbaugh trademark the phrase "inane leftist dribble?" Or was that Sean Hannity?

Think for yourself, man. Don't parrot somebody else's words. The truth is the truth, no matter who pointed it out. If you can't deal with that, you're not equipped to vote responsibly.

by jardinier

It was only ever about oil. It just took some people longer than others to wake up to the fact.

A secondary motive with the "shock and awe" tactic was to bomb the sh1t out of Iraq so that American contractors -- and especially Bush's buddies -- could make a mint out of rebuilding the place.

You can be assured that America will always maintain a strong presence in Iraq in the form of military bases and its fortress-like embassy.

Meanwhile in other parts of the Middle East, Mr "born again" Bush has just delivered the heartening news that the Palestinians can be assured of a state of their own in a mere 60 years from now.

[b][News.com.au, May 16, 2008][/b]

President George W Bush told Israelis today they were a "chosen people" who can forever count on American support against enemies like Hamas and Iran.

On a day when Palestinians remembered homes and land lost as Israel was created in 1948, Mr Bush made only fleeting reference to their aspirations for a state of their own in a speech marking Israel's 60th anniversary that was laced with references to God.

Basking in ovations on the second day of a farewell visit to a country where his presidency is hailed as a golden age, Mr Bush again said little of the talks he has sponsored in recent months between Israel and the Palestinians, which he hopes can bring a deal on a Palestinian state before he leaves office in January.

Speaking of the "promise of God" for a "homeland for the chosen people" in Israel, Mr Bush told the Israeli parliament after a visit to the Roman-era Jewish fortress at Masada: "Masada shall never fall again, and America will always stand with you."

He predicted the defeat of Islamist enemies Hamas, Hezbollah and al-Qaeda in a "battle of good and evil".

Letting Iran have nuclear weapons would be an "unforgivable betrayal of future generations", he said.

By comparing talking with such foes to appeasement of Hitler, he sparked a debate at home among those campaigning to succeed him as president.

Mr Bush described the "bonds of the Book" - faith in the Bible shared by Christians like himself and Jews - as bolstering an "unbreakable" alliance between Israel and the United States.

[b]Of the Palestinians, half of whom were pushed into exile to make way for the Jewish state, Bush said that,[u] looking ahead another 60 years in the future,[/u] "the Palestinian people will have the homeland they have long dreamed of and deserved".[/b]

The President's language in Israel has dismayed Palestinians looking for the US superpower to mediate in their negotiations with Israel.

Islamist Hamas, which spurns such talks, said Mr Bush sounded "like a priest or a rabbi" and had delivered a "slap in the face" to those Palestinians who placed their hopes in him.

Mr Bush said: "Some people suggest that if the United States would just break ties with Israel, all our problems in the Middle East would go away ... America utterly rejects it."

Calling Mr Bush "the leader of evil in the world", Hamas official Sami Abu Zuhri said the group would never grow weak.

Mr Bush and his wife Laura will today wind up their visit to Jerusalem and fly on to Saudi Arabia before weekend talks in Egypt with Abbas and other Arab leaders.

by $$$$$$$$$$

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tW1-_JmXQt0&NR=1

They are not the innocent angels, under unjust attack based only on envy, that they portray themselves to be. The mainstream media address only one side's offenses in a conflict that is at least two-sided. Britain also bears enormous moral responsibility for its ham-fisted approach to creation and early support of Israel, which takes us back to petrol.

by tony hopkinson

since you left.

As always the truth is somewhere in the extremes, and any one who doesn't remeber all politicians have personal motives for what they disclose, when and how, and in some cases who they get to do it for them, has left the path of reason.

You are big on pointing out what factors were definitely not important, which ones do you think were, wit the benefit of 20/20 hindsight.

I'll listen, after all you aren't always wrong even though you are the archetypal right wing christian. :D

by braggeroni

In general response:

It was the U.S. Government that funded, trained and/or endorsed "freedom fighters" to rebel against organizations that we didn't 'approve of', including Osama Bin Laden, Fidel Castro and Saddam Hussein.

Ultimately, while the information used to achieve "consent" to invade Iraq isn't entirely honest, to say there would be less bloodshed is whole-heartedly wrong. Remember that it was our government that funded and put Saddam in power. By that regard, we as a country and as human beings have a responsibility and blame for every atrocity and murder committed by those individuals (and our embargos against Cuba are just as responsible for poor conditions on the island as the leadership we supported when Castro was only the leader of a small rebellion.

The U.S. may not be as conservative in international influence as we used to be, but the attack on Pearl Harbor is attributed as being the final days of American isolationism, and for good reason.

Our first and foremost responsibility is to protect ourselves as a nation; but we cannot use that as an excuse to watch attrocities from a distance and not act.

"We all must fear evil, but the evil we must fear the most is the indifference of good men"

In response to NickNielsen:

I try to avoid calling the middle east stable at any time, although kudos for the strategic placement of "relatively."

Ultimately there has been, and will be bloodshed in the middle east for millenia. What concerns me is that as a general rule, far western and eastern countries have silently stood by, lest we become part of the wars. These are not idealogical wars, they are tribal and cultural, as if a microcosm of civil unrest in purpetual bloodfeasting. It has taken the deaths of over 4000 of my brothers and sisters for the American public to become as vocal and angry as they are now... but why can't we be as concerned and proactive when it isn't Americans that are dying?

by jardinier

And in case you have forgotten, Australia was the only country besides America and Britain which participated in the initial invasion.

While you have your head up your American a$$ I might also tell you that Australian SAS troops were the FIRST to engage with Iraqi troops.

Australian troops are STILL THERE.

Fu$king Yankee wanker.

by santeewelding

You declare to kill, become stone in this matter, not to mention worrisome other and far greater superintending matters.

Decide them on the basis of absolute 5.56 or 7.62 and I don't let up either.

by $$$$$$$$$$

In either case, what is the containing directory? Or, might they be numbers chosen at random, intended to convey nothing, but only appear to have ever been information, now obfuscated?

by $$$$$$$$$$

And, which "worrisome other and far greater superintending matters"?

What are they, and why do you prefer "not to mention" them, even as you mention them, publicly?

by $$$$$$$$$$

Or, you want further curtailment of Amendment 2 to the United States Constitution.

http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/systems/ground/m16-variants.htm

Or, possibly, your "expressed" opinion is opposite one or both of the above, or something completely unrelated. Maybe, your memory
of your own opinions fails you, so you concern yourself primarily with those of others, rarely stating your own clearly.

Like I've said previously, before a short-lived improvement in the quality your messages led me to misguided generosity, you're nothing to me but a waste of time. I won't again make the mistake of granting you benefit of doubt you have replaced with certainty of your wish to communicate only defacement, like illegible code spray-painted on others' property. I do not believe we are in "lock & load alignment" with nearly as much as the abstract noun "politics" implies, if with anything at all.

And until you describe your own alignment, in your own words, I have no cause to make any assumptions. Weighing the paltry evidence you offer, your primary motive is to obfuscate, and your secondary motive is to comment on the person, not the premise. Any value you might have, which we might have in common, you have provided insufficient evidence to believe.

by santeewelding

You do just fine until you get to that witness mark, the Constitution, and then you stop.

That's what it is: a witness mark.

As steeped as you are, you know they of the Convention went farther afield. They struck the mark close so most could see, yet struck far and away farther than any mark of the kind before.

Stopped and preoccupied, you are, on the following side of the mark.

Of course I kick you in the pants. You are stooped as though to a stone that marks the end of a line.

Come. There is further afield. Go light. Leave the Powerpoint behind. A disciplined post is all. Even the Declaration fits easily on a refrigerator door.

You may even strike the crux of a Convention to come.

Does this help? Be sure if it is to authorize a thumb.

by ontheropes

I'll go with my being ignorant. Seeing as how God didn't tell me what to do I was out of the loop.

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/bush-god-told-me-to-invade-iraq-509925.html

I'm sick and tired of hearing about 'religious beliefs' that some leaders hold that war is somehow a good idea sanctioned by some invisible, high in the sky, freaking holy and powerful overlord. Organized religions that support war can bite me.

Since I've somewhat cured my ignorant condition I try to remember one thing; it's all about money. Someone else here at TR at one time wanted to add that it's all about money AND power but I'm sticking with just money because enough money can and does buy and subvert power.

by $$$$$$$$$$

If so, what was the motive of the Congress, which authorized him to use force, first against Afghanistan, then against the United States, then against Iraq, then against the United States again?

The "Patriot Act" and the "Protect America Act" are authorizations of un-Constitutional uses of force against US citizens. Refusal to prosecute for torture also allows use of force, and surveillance without legal warrant.

by ontheropes

Some people find it useful to use 'God' to justify their past actions when there is no good justification or they fabricate a good story when pandering to various groups. I believe President Bush to be a liar so no I don't think that was his motive but I do think his God statements reveal much about the character of the man.

All of a sudden a nameless voice in the crowd says, "that's dangerous talk boy!" :|

What war crimes committed by Bush and Co. were you talking about specifically? Do you think that members of Congress helped to commit any war crimes?

by tony hopkinson

after 9/11. Otherwise the political opposition would have proposed some highly visble action and made them look bad in the poll / media.

Afghanistan from a political point of view, was a perfectly understandable knee-jerk reaction to 9/11. As soon as the afghan goverment taliban types told you no you aren't having Bin Laden, (for which they should get a stupidity award), somebody from airborn, was going to respond airborn.

Iraq, well that's beyond me, I don't get it, the only people who have benefitted are military REMFs, extremists and fat cats, and they don't get a say in a democracy do they? :p

by $$$$$$$$$$

... for starters. Financial relations with Blackwater, Halliburton, and KBR also deserve the closest scrutiny.

[i]Do you think that members of Congress helped to commit any war crimes?[/i]

Yes, each one who continues to vote in support of the fallacies that FISA needed to be weakened, to tap terrorists' phones, and that simulated drowning is necessary to obtain intelligence.

by ontheropes

There's more. I'm sure of it.

War profiteering really grinds on me too especially in light of the way this Administration cares for our troops and veterans.

A short clip. 4:42 long - http://www.brasschecktv.com/page/319.html

For various reasons I meant to stay away from this whole thread but I had to go and open my big mouth after I saw what you're posting here.

I believe that there is little to no chance of any prosecutions beginning, much less succeeding, against anyone you've mentioned. I wish that was just a feeling but it is my belief. I think it'll never happen. I really don't want to and won't get into any or all of the reasons I believe that. It does not mean that I think you're way out of line. I don't. I do think that, practically speaking, you're not going to get too much of anywhere. I'd love to be proven wrong.

So, what do I do even though I may see things the same as you see them? Simple, I just take care of my own business as I see fit. I don't have a lot of money and/or influence to help change things for the better but that doesn't mean that I have to believe in lies. I don't. I'm probably known by some of my acquaintances and friends as that crazy conspiracy theorist. I care.

I'll just say this, for anyone to have more than just the barest inkling of what I believe to be true would require that they sit down with me for a few days and go over quite a bit of material. That's not going to happen. I don't even have enough time to explain everything to my wife.

I do like people who have a mind and think for themselves. I'm waiting on a blog too even though the last time I encouraged someone to write a blog it didn't work out too well. :^0 Sorry about that obscure reference but that's all I'm going to say about that here.

Peace.

Oscar

by santeewelding

Write a Declaration, then do the Constitution.

In the one write why, and in the other how.

Write for all you are worth.

Write for all who are.

by $$$$$$$$$$

No invitation is required. Therefore, the invitation is irrelevant.

I have given you more than ample opportunity to carry your own conversational weight. You have refused at close enough to every entreaty, that this is final: You have nothing to say to me.

This discussion is closed to new replies.