Discussion Locked

for the gun nuts among us

0 helpful
46 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Isn't it time to dismantle the metal detectors, send the guards at the doors away and allow Americans to exercise their Second Amendment rights by being free to carry their firearms into the nation's Capitol building?

I've been studying the deep thoughts of senators who regularly express their undying loyalty to the National Rifle Association and have decided that they should practice what they preach. They tell us that the best defense against crime is an armed citizenry and that laws restricting guns do nothing to stop violence.

If they believe that, why don't they live by it?

Why would freedom-loving lawmakers want to hide behind guards and metal detectors? Shouldn't NRA members be outraged that Second Amendment rights mean nothing in the very seat of our democracy?

Congress seems to think that gun restrictions are for wimps. It voted earlier this year to allow people to bring their weapons into national parks, and pro-gun legislators have pushed for the right to carry in taverns, colleges and workplaces. Shouldn't Congress set an example in its own workplace?

So why not let Sen. John Thune, R-S.D., pack the weapon of his choice on the Senate floor? Thune is the author of an amendment that would have allowed gun owners who had valid permits to carry concealed weapons into any state, even states with more restrictive gun laws. The amendment got 58 votes last week, two short of the 60 it needed to pass.

Judging by what Thune said in defense of his amendment, he'd clearly feel safer if everyone in the Capitol could carry a gun.

"Law-abiding individuals have the right to self-defense, especially because the Supreme Court has consistently found that police have no constitutional obligation to protect individuals from other individuals," he said. I guess Thune doesn't think those guards and the Capitol Police have any obligation to protect him.

He went on: "The benefits of conceal and carry extend to more than just the individuals who actually carry the firearms. Since criminals are unable to tell who is and who is not carrying a firearm just by looking at a potential victim, they are less likely to commit a crime when they fear they may come in direct contact with an individual who is armed."

In other words, keeping guns out of the Capitol makes all our elected officials far less safe. If just a few senators had weapons, the criminals wouldn't know which ones were armed, and all senators would be safer, right? Isn't that better than highly intrusive gun control - i.e., keeping people with guns out of the Capitol in the first place?

"Additionally," Thune said helpfully, "research shows that when unrestricted conceal and carry laws are passed, not only does it benefit those who are armed, but it also benefits others around them, such as children."

This is a fantastic opportunity. Arming all our legislators would make it safer for children, so senators could feel much more secure bringing their kids into the Capitol. This would promote family values and might even reduce the number of highly publicized extramarital affairs.

Don't think this column is offered lightly. I want these guys to put up or shut up. If the NRA's servants in Congress don't take their arguments seriously enough to apply them to their own lives, maybe the rest of us should do more to stop them from imposing their nonsense on our country.

To comment, e-mail E.J. Dionne Jr. at ejdionne@washpost.com.

This article appeared on page A - 11 of the San Francisco Chronicle 2009.07.27

46 replies

by santeewelding

Why table etiquette evolved to dictate why the knife is placed edge-in next to the plate.

If the relevance of this escapes you, then I think the deeper relevance of the whole escapes you, and Dionne.

Knives, you see, still appear on tables, except in prisons.

by notsochiguy

...it must have been a slow news day in San Fran yesterday! ;)

While I would agree with one of the high level concepts from this piece (I'm sick of hypocritical politicians myself), I think the manner in which this rant unfolds undermines any credibility the author may hope to bring to the debate; and ultimately leads this off the mark.

For example, the metal detectors aren't just used for guns. They're used for bombs, as well. Walking into the capitol unfettered with 20+ pounds of C4 strapped to the chest is a whackadoodle's wet dream. Each senator could have automatic assault rifles with them on the floor, and they wouldn't be able to deter a terrorist attack of this nature.

Also, on the flip side of this argument are those that advocate strict gun control that are escorted everywhere by armed guards. Chicago has a ban on handguns, yet, there are Emperor Daley II's guards standing next to him at all times, Berettas at the ready. I'm fairly sure that the president doesn't go far without at least a few guns within his immediate vicinity, either.

Just as the pro-gun group would say that there is a legitimate reason for the metal detectors, I'm sure the gun-control group would speak at length for the need to have armed guards. I'd be inclined to agree with them both on these respective points.

If the author was serious about targeting political hypocrisy, he/she would be better off going after those that are proposing higher taxes and/or reducing the salaries of all state/federal employees EXCEPT themselves. That is something people of all political ideologies could identify with in these trying economic times.

by jck

If I remember right, Vidor, TX, is a town that allows open-carry guns.

The incident of armed robbery there (last I read about it) is practically zero.

What robber is going into a convenience store with 1 gun to rob the place when there are 8 others with guns standing around him?

I think the open carry would be more effective.

Robber sees 10 other guns...robber runs like chicken.

Emperor Daley II lol

by notsochiguy

...the effectiveness of having a gun is situational. Vernon Forrest is a good example of this. The hardcore anti-gun group will point to this as an example where having a gun did no good, while the hardcore pro-gun group would say he wasn't exercising prudent usage. The truth is probably somewhere in between.

Either way, that incident has ZERO bearing on how security needs to be carried out at the Capitol building. This is where I felt the columnist went far awry in the piece.

As for His Royal Eminence, Richard Daley II, I wish I could laugh, too. While I moved out of the city (and out of Crook County in general), I still have to work in Chicago. The stuff this guy pulls is unbelievable. If you put together the 10 craziest political stunts you could think of, they'd grossly pale in comparison to what He's managed to get away with so far.

by larryd4

I mean if I'm standing on the corner, with a holstered side arm, and I'm not any type of law officer.

What are the legal ramifications if I decide to shoot a guy running out of a bank, where the alarm is going off and he's carrying a bag???

I mean cops have to verbalize their intent and have to account for all possiblities before they shoot and most are apprehensive about it to begin with.

I believe in our right to bare arms, I own two rifles and a revolver, but I just can see me putting on my holster and walking out the door with a loaded side arm everyday.

I've got enough issues with keeping myself safe and organized, imagine if I had a gun at my side.

by charliespencer

Do you agree or disagree with what you've posted? Posting inflammatory content without expressing an opinion may be mistaken for trolling.

by jdclyde

It is clearly the writings of a mentally disturbed individual.

The explanation for THAT is in my post further down about related links..... :D

by nicknielsen

The NRA called and said they were polling "patriotic Americans".

Their first question was "Do you trust the gun-hating Congress to protect your Second Amendment right to bear arms?" I took great pleasure in pointing out to the individual on the phone that similar logic could also be used to label the NRA as "pro" gun crime. He took offense, I hung up.

While I don't trust Congress where [u]any[/u] of the Amendments in the Bill of Rights is concerned, neither do I trust extremists of any stripe, most of whom have a much different vision of my rights than I do.

by notsochiguy

...but it seems like less of a survey attempt, and more of a way to lead you down the road of donating money to the NRA.

Somehow, I've managed to get my junk e-mail account on the mailing lists of both MoveOn and Young Republicans. If bits and bytes could duke it out, I think that e-mail box would house a PPV worthy tussle---complete with breaks in the action for advertisements for Rogaine and Viagra!

:p

by jdclyde

I have been called many times for things like this, (being an NRA member of long standing) but have never heard them use a term "gun hating congress".

And yes, they are just lead-ins to a donation.

Same thing the activists do of any flavor, political or otherwise.

And no, someone in favor of private ownership is NOT pro gun crime. The NRA has always advocated for stronger enforcement of the existing laws for people that misuse firearms, as well as encouraging education in the proper ownership, usage, and and storing of firearms. Educate yourself on this, because that "logic" would assume car dealers are "pro" drunk driving, which anyone with a clue knows isn't true.

Get beyond "From my cold dead hands" and you will see the NRA is not the dumb toothless hick who will shoot you if you come on their property, that people from the Anti-gun groups like to paint them as. That would be classic misrepresentation.

by santeewelding

You would have already, as they say, researched the literature -- pertinent, standard jury instructions, for example, are a convenient way to do it.

I have only to guess otherwise that you are not serious about keeping yourself "safe and organized", being why you have issues with it.

by larryd4

What does that mean??

I know a lot of my states gun laws and the differences in other states. I work every day in a Superior Courthouse.

I believe in protecting myself and my family and I am comforted in the fact that there are laws in my State that does not allow just anyone to walk around with a handgun in public.

What exactly is your point as to why I was or was not serious?

My point was that I, as an IT analyst, have so many other items to keep track of, I would hate to work in environment where I feel I should be armed to protect myself. A State, County, City, or Town that allows anyone to walk around with a sidearm for no other reason than "Cause I can" is ridiculous. The most obvious problem with that State or town is that the local populous feel, they are in so much danger they have to arm themselves every day.

I just spent two months in an area where everyone is armed all the time. I was extremely uncomfortable as I would keep reaching for a tool on my belt or a net scanner in the pouch and kept having to negotiate around the side arm.

But I know for a fact in NJ a law enforcement officer better have clear cause to draw his weapon.
Their are cases all the time where a thief breaks in to a house gets shot, hit with a bat, or beaten to a pulp by the owner. The thief then turns around and files a lawsuit for use of excessive force.

But it seems from your post that you're looking to antagonize rather than discuss.

So what is it exactly you're trying to say??

by santeewelding

I put mine in the simplest words I know how to write. I paid attention to grammar, too.

As you said: "I've got enough issues". Apparently so; including agony of antagonism.

by notsochiguy

...lest the esposa refuse to go to my high school reunion.com gathering. I'm looking forward to hearing about all the nursing school opportunities these fine ladies experienced online while learning how to surgically regrow hair and snippy snip men without laser or incisions in less then 30 minutes.

I hated the movie overall, but Snake Plissken had it right at the end of Escape from LA!! Unplug it all!!!

:)

by jck

but if people outside hear shots inside...then the robber comes out and gets shot by several people.

I think their law statistics showed that crime was far less than the national average there.

So if you need something that works, letting people deal with miscreants directly seems to be an answer.

by Member 25348569

and I leg it out of the store while the robber is rifling the till and...

Yeah, OK, I think you see the flaw in this.

by jck

Emperor Daley II had lessons from King Buddy Cianci of Rhode Island on how to be a crook. :^0

by notsochiguy

...but face it, these people are more like weeds, all joined at the root!! ;)

King Buddy seemed like a newspaper's dream. Assaulted a guy with a lit cigarette and a log?!?! Hysterical, in a sad-testimony-about-who-we-elect sort of way.

This is a quote from Emperor Richard Daley I, speaking about the DNC riots in '68:
"Gentlemen, get the thing straight once and for all ? the policeman isn't there to create disorder, the policeman is there to preserve disorder."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_J._Daley

How the hell do we end up with people like this serving in government??????

by jck

Usually people look for the "what has he/she done?" in brief, and don't look to the more in-depth things.

As well as I said elsewhere, Americans a lot of the time now are so used to corrupt and tainted people that they shrug it off now rather than ostracizing the ilk, the pompous, and the systemically abusive.

There are good people who run for office, but tend not to be the smiling jack car salesman type who can woo people into casting a vote for them.

Sad really. I really have said for years, I'd rather see housewives and barbers and farmers in the halls of Congress making decisions based on what real people need, and see lobbying ended as a practice.

Then maybe we would see results if hard working regular Americans were making the decisions.

by jck

I've worked about 5 years total in govt.

I work daily with law enforcement, clerk of the circuit court, commissioners, administrators, etc.

I don't get to carry a side arm. I would feel safer if I did. I have been to training, been certified, and even had a federal permit.

I think that if criminals didn't know who had a gun that it's a deterent...definitely.

But when they go somewhere with the intent to rob...say a grocery store...and see 40 others with guns on....they will think twice about the 40 bullets to 1 bullet survival odds they'd have.

Death is the biggest deterent for crime.

People either don't want it...or can't commit anymore crime if they have it.

by Member 25348569

"taverns". Seriously? Alcohol and loaded weapons? I though that bad temper and loaded weapons was bad enough and that mental illness and loaded weapons was about as bad as you can get but I was wrong.

by maecuff

Family reunions and loaded weapons. Never a good idea to let grandma have a gun.

by Member 25348569

She wanted to shoot her next door neighbours dog because it barked all the time. As a Christmas present to Gran, I bought the dog a big bar of chocolate.

I must admit that I wouldn't have trusted the daft old biddy with a loaded gun! She was such a bad loser at cribbage.

by santeewelding

They despair of the norms to which you so desperately cling. She played havoc with them to watch you squirm.

by jdclyde

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/health/article629094.ece
[b]Pollution 'putting millions of children at brain damage risk'[b/]

[b]http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12051555
Air pollution and brain damage.[/b]

My two articles fully explain your article. Or at least the irrational state of mind of the clown the wrote it.

Sorry, but because "E.J's" article is not a serious article, it is not worthy of debate.

by maecuff

Did enough damage with a flyswatter. If someone had given her a gun, I probably wouldn't be here today.

by the scummy one

is to give all old peoples a loaded gun, especially if they are the pissed off kind of old folk.
Hmmm -- no more worries about overpopulation

by notsochiguy

Last night the news was running out all of the people that are looking to fill the soon-to-be-up-for-election positions: various seats in Congress, the Obama-Senate seat, the governorship.

Looked like a veritable Who's-Who for a future wing at a minimum security federal prison.

Truthfully, the frustration is almost enough to get me to consider trying to get enough signatures to get my name on a ballot. But then again, I read Faust---no thanks!

by santeewelding

But I am -- making those decisions and executing them no matter what the yahoos have to say or do.

There will come the day, though, when they get in my way.

by jck

Especially when the yahoos are your friends or people you know or neighbors.

But, you have to try and educate people too. Otherwise, they live in ignorance and indefinitely continue to make your life hell.

by jdclyde

What does it say about you or your posting when you throw it up (regurgitate?) and run?

by john.a.wills

it's not much more than 24 hours since I posted and I'm back. The only posting besides yours that seems to need a response is the one about cutlery, and I think it's from another tradition than mine, in which the knife is placed all by itself on the right of the plate position, or several knives are placed there together.

by jdclyde

hadn't recalled you ever doing a post and dash before, ya know?

I take it that means you weren't impressed with the scientific articles I provided to explain that wild-eyed rant that you had reported on? :(

by notsochiguy

"I'd rather see housewives and barbers and farmers in the halls of Congress making decisions based on what real people need, and see lobbying ended as a practice."

This would bring us much closer to the original intents of the founding fathers, I'd imagine.

Locally, there is one representative that seems to be a 'Regular Joe' type (relatively speaking). Bill Foster (D) defeated Oberweis (R) for the 14th district in Illinois. Foster had no real political experience, and is a research scientist from Fermi lab. So, there is actually one member of Congress that understands real science. ;)

The thing that seemed to work against Oberweis is that he has tried for just about every office out there at some point, and seems overly focused on becoming a politician.

by jck

Too many people now get into politics not to help the country, but to chase the golden goose of having a big pension come retirement age.

Amazing how much a congressman needs to retire on.

by john.a.wills

I thought Dionne's piece was a well-constructed piece of satire, whether or not one agrees with the opinion behind it. Your scientific-article references were not even funny... now if you had satirized the articles...
However, there seem to have been quite a lot of intelligent remarks on both sides responding to Dionne.

This discussion is closed to new replies.