Discussion Locked

Global Warming - The zealots are getting desperate

0 helpful
265 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

265 replies

by Member 25348569

The people with nuclear weapons are the ones who [b]aren't[/b] doing anything to reduce carbon emissions. (That's YOU, by the way). I don't think that many of we "rabid radicals" actually have access to any of the US's weapons so I don't know who you think is actually going to start it.

Nuclear winter doesn't last more than a few years, anyway, so it's not an option worth considering. Nuking the oil fields? Now [b]that[/b] is worth considering. Sorts out most of the Islamofasists in Saudi Arabia AND reduces oil consumption. Got to be cheaper than keeping troops in Iraq as well. Win-win-win for an Islamophobe Greenie Get-the-troops-out like me.

by Member 25348569

Is more laws to stop people using the laws that you already have...

Seems like the US needs to investigate the feasibility of lawyer-burning power stations as an option. Given that they are a renewable resource and you have so many of them, they're at least as eco-friendly as biodiesel.

by Member 25348569

asking you to use low-energy light bulbs and appliances and, maybe, not driving such a big, new auto and so on is environmental-whack-ism.

Leave it to the market? It's the market that's driven us down the road of rampant consumerism that's caused all of this crap.

I don't know about converting you against your will but I think we're trying to convert you against your irresponsibility.

by sn53

Neilb said, "So, you think asking you to use low-energy light bulbs and appliances and, maybe, not driving such a big, new auto and so on is environmental-whack-ism."

Asking? No. Asking is fine. Convincing me is fine. Raising my taxes and forcing me is not fine. Forcing me to take an action that makes you feel better is slavery.

neilb said, "Leave it to the market? It's the market that's driven us down the road of rampant consumerism that's caused all of this crap."

I respectfully disagree. The dirty places of the world are the former socialist and communist countries. The cleanest are the western, capitalist countries like the US. There will always be exceptions, of course, but on the whole market-driven economies tend to be clean economies.

neilb said, "I don't know about converting you against your will but I think we're trying to convert you against your irresponsibility."

Do you see a difference? You make my point that your preference is to subjugate me for your pleasure. That is slavery.

by drowningnotwaving

... then surely I have every right to:

a) Argue the point, and

b) (if I argue well and hard enough and get enough people to see it the same way), in a democratic society, make changes/laws to limit the areas of your free will to areas that, in itself, doesn't limit my own freedom.

E.G. you have no right to throw your shit over my fence. Keep it in your own backyard and take responsibility for dealing with it.

Similarly with your rampant use of pollutant-causing power.

Argue all you will. The tide is against you. You will be forced to pay an exhorbitantly high price to exercise your free will. Your additional payments will be your fee/payment for someone else to actually fix up the problem that you are participating in and contributing to, of your own free will of course.

You argue it hasn't been proven. I argue that no longer matters in reality. You're gonna pay for all those years of consuming and generating pollution. Oh, by the way, so am I. We're all in it.

You could of course f'ck off and buy a house in Russia to avoid the issue. That would also be your free will.

And thus the cycle returns and repeats.

* Big Business - Free will = no responsibility.

* Causes some huge f'ck-up. See Enron, See Standard Oil, see Arthur Anderson, see Union Carbide, see any number of thousands of wonderful examples at your local town, city, state, national or international level.

* In hindsight, laws put in place to cease future f'ck-up and repair damage.

* "Free Will" people scream blue-murder that their free-will and beautifully self-managing moral society is being pushed under the water.

It never was 'self managing'. It never was morally incorrupt. That's the fundamental downfall with the dream.

by tonythetiger

One, Since you chastised Max for not having all of the facts before rendering an opinion, and I see you rendering opinions quite often, you must either think you have all the facts, or you hold Max to a different standard than you hold yourself. And since surely you wouldn't be doing the latter, I assumed you were claiming the former.

Two, I didn't "decline" anything. I responded as soon as I saw it.

Three, I am honored that you wait with such bated breath for my postings.

by deepsand

3) I'm flattered that you feel honored.

2) If it is the case that you saw my post which appears later in the thread at an earlier time than you did that which appears earlier in the thread, then I stand corrected.

1) Implicit in my usage, as well as that of others, of the word "all" is "necessary, by virtue of being material." In this case, max & jd have taken issue with a report which they have apparently not deigned to read. Within this context, then, my use of the word "all" is correct.

by karmashock

I laid out a clear logical argument and challenged people like yourself to find logical fault with it. My thesis is that "1" that model applies to global warming and especially to Kyoto and secondly that the environmental moment is neither informed nor logical enough to bother truly examining the validity of their statements.

If you believe that my statement is in error then please demonstrate so logically. You mistake my conclusion for my reasoning. There is a profound difference. Were I using my conclusion for my reasoning as ironically I am arguing the environmental movement is doing then of course it would be no logical merit. However, if you read my statement it is very clear that I base my conclusion upon a logical argument that can be tested, examined, proven, and disproven.

Disagree with me? Cite your reasons.

by maxwell edison

[b][i]Global warming sees polar bears stranded on melting ice: [/b]They cling precariously to the top of what is left of the ice floe, their fragile grip the perfect symbol of the tragedy of global warming.... Captured on film by Canadian environmentalists, the pair of polar bears look stranded on chunks of broken ice. [/i]

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/news.html?in_article_id=433170&in_page_id=1770

I claimed it was a BOGUS and/or misleading story. And I was right!

http://www.riehlworldview.com/carnivorous_conservative/2007/02/the_polar_bear_.html

http://news.search.yahoo.com/news/search?p=polar+bears&c=news_photos

[i]Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper once called the Kyoto accord a "socialist scheme" designed to suck money out of rich countries, according to a letter leaked Tuesday by the Liberals.[/i]

http://www.cbc.ca/canada/story/2007/01/30/harper-kyoto.html

[b][i]NUREMBERG-STYLE TRIALS PROPOSED FOR GLOBAL WARMING SKEPTICS [/b][/i]

http://epw.senate.gov/fact.cfm?party=rep&id=264568

[i][b]Climatologist Calls Global Warming Fears 'Greatest Deception in the History of Science'...[/i][/b]

http://www.cgfi.org/cgficommentary/two-new-books-confirm-global-warming-is-natural-moderate

[i][b]Scientists Counter UN Report - Claim Global Warming Due to Solar Activity, Not Man....[/i][/b]

http://www.canadafreepress.com/2007/global-warming020507.htm

No, MOST DO NOT believe such a thing!

http://epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=PressRoom.Blogs&ContentRecord_id=3a9bc8a4-802a-23ad-4065-7dc37ec39adf

by tonythetiger

there's no way for any of us to know it, unless we were eye-witnesses. And since I know I [b]have[/b] been witness to things that were not reported that should have been, I can reasonably assume that others have too.

Most people (not pointing fingers at anyone here) are too stupid to investigate anything on their own, content to go with whatever they read in the paper or hear on television. Then the media compounds the problem by polling many of these same stupid people, and uses the results of these polls to recruit even more stupid people. What you end up with is an equation:

world opinion times stupid squared equals policy

and that's not good.

by deepsand

My point was that, knowing that I am not the only one to do independent research, I cannot assume that you do not do likewise.

While I do concur that your point is generally true of the majority, I would not, absent supporting evidence, state it to be so of any particular person.

by tonythetiger

is that the few who [b]do[/b] do the independent research aren't the ones whose opinions drive policy. The majority, whether they are right or wrong, are who it seems want to drive policy, and anyone who goes against the majority, even when they are right and the majority is wrong, are ostracized.

by tonythetiger

I guess it sucks to be you :)

[added: Whomever has the biggest weapons isn't necessarily going to be the ones to start it, but they will probably be the ones to finish it.]

by absolutely

And, we are not in agreement as to the objectivity of this list:

"Think objectively here... Judge a given solution with these known properties:
1: Solution will be [b]extremely expensive[/b].
2: Solution might not actually fix the problem or might do so little as to be [b]insignificant[/b].
3: Solution puts your assets/country's economy under the control of some other group that you'll have [b]limited to no control[/b] over.
4: Problem that solution is designed to fix [b]has not in fact manifested[/b] and might well never manifest ever.
5: If problem is real it might be [b]impossible[/b] to stop or even [b]significantly[/b] slow."

The items [b]emphasized[/b] above are unsupported assertions which you have described as part of "the objective list". Sorry, toots, calling it "objective" doesn't make it objective. In fact, numerous problems of global warming have manifested, rendering your assertion #4 totally false. The rest are merely emotive opinions of yours, which you have provided no evidence to support.

"Please engage the objective list... if you think any element of the list is wrong or something should be added then let me know. We can both be rational about this."

I know I can. Now it's your turn.

by karmashock

I asked you to cite problems with it for debate. As you seem to be doing that, lets just get on with it.

Stop. Lets go through the list slowly.

1. Do you refute that kyoto and other assorted global warming measures proposed thus far would not be extremely expensive?

2. Do you refute that kyoto and other assorted global warming measure proposed thus far would be insufficient to solve the problem? I have never seen a single solution that promised to be able to make so much as a double digit dent in the issue if projections are accurate... and as they change rather irradically I don't think they can be trusted.

3. Do you refute that the US and other signing nations would have limited to no control over the oversight committees and boards?

4. What specifically has manifested that could be be termed as a "serious climate problem that is a threat to human civilization"? Because that's the argument for all this global warming stuff... that it will threaten human civilization... mass starvation... cities covered in water... where is the evidence of anything threating to humanity?

5. This is a tie into section 2 in that it seems to be a consensus so far as I can tell that the problem can only be limited and not stopped. What's more the percentage difference isn't even in double digits which I personally didn't consider to be that significant. Do you dispute this?

Lastly I would like to point out that you're proving me right with your needless hostility. There is no reason for you to insult me or otherwise act in a rude and disrespectful manner. You are showing exactly what I think the environmental movement is based upon... mindless ignorant hostility.

Do you disagree? Then disagree in a manner that does not contradict your assertions. You must operate in a clear, logical, and respectful manner or your very protest becomes an affirmation of my point.

In short, slow down, calm down, and run the numbers.

by drowningnotwaving

There is a huge difference.

Let's go through a couple of things ...

Despite the highlighting of a few (certainly a massive minority of) scientists that argue against global climate change and acceleration thereof due to human activity, the overwhelming majority of world scientific opinion is in favour of both continued research and taking immediate and sensible action to reduce the accelerated impact.

You may recall, when it comes to scientiests arguing facts, it was only as far ago as the 60's and 70's that most US-based geographic and earth-based scientists refused and refuted the entire science behind tectonic plates and their role in shaping the world on a continual basis.

Further, look at the arguments and the 30-year crusade to remove the horrendous impacts lead from our environment.

Professors Emeritus argued on behalf of the oil companies, paint companies and the like.

And in the meantime people died.

The funny thing is that the environmental movement (which is NOT without it's bunch of loonies, what group is?) has been building up this science and momentum for 50 years.

It's only recently that a swell of anti-science has come to the fore. Historically this reeks of corporate sponsored greed at worst, or 'favouring the status-quo' at best.

But I am not here to force change on you, per se. However YOU have to take responsibility for your own actions - as do I and as does every other person in this new environment we find ourselves in.

So you want to drive a V8? Fine. Pay three times as much for your gas.

You want an air-conditioner in every bedroom? Fine. The price of electricity has to go up to reflect the costs of cleaning up the source processes and also to pay for the economically-innefficient new sources (like Nuclear!). And it needs to go up on an inverse sliding scale - the more you use, the MORE you pay per unit. That recognises the people that are striving hard to reduce their use. So pay accordingly.

Wanna buy stuff from companies that are energy inefficient? You guessed it. You can. No problem. Just expect their costs to be suitably increased becuase of the increased costs of the use of energy by those companies.

So you will still have your choice. It will just require you to take responsbility for your choice.

And guess what? My enviro-fascism isn't going to be limited to what we call the global warming stuff, either.

There is a whole stack of other things that have or are ruining the world for my kids, their kids and their kids.

Here's an example.

Sydney Harbour. Our beautiful Sydney Harbour. Globally acknowledged as (one of) the most beautiful harbour in the world.

Know what? You can't fish in the entire harbour and river / creek system anymore.

Well, strictly speaking you can (despite the warning signs every 50 metres on the entire foreshore) - you just cannot eat the fish

Know why?

Because a whole series of factories of every single really bad thing you can think of, from batteries to paints to industrial and domestic chemical plants to petro-chemical refineries have dumped their shit in the harbour for over 100 years.

As a result the dioxin, lead and mercury levels of the underlying soil are through the stratosphere. And of course dioxin, lead and mercury ALL accumulate in fish. They don't stabilise. They don't reduce over time. They get worse.

Now you tell me.

Do you need a Bachelor of Science degree in environment, chemistry or climatology to realise that pouring sh't into the harbour is a stupid and bad thing????

Maybe the dying fish and vegetation would have been a giveaway?

Now, the factories and companies that did all these things are gone (many of the companies still actually exist but statutes of limitations and the practicalities of the legel system would say that they will never be brought to pay for their destruction).

So, in order for my children and grandchildren to enjoy the basic quality of life like fishing in the harbour, the entire soil substrata must be removed, burned in super-high-temp facilities where the chemicals are split out and collected, and then returned to the harbour.

Just one section - 800 metres by 500 metres - is costing nearly $100 million to recycle.

So guess what - I demand that my kids have a basic access to their harbour and if that means me and every other schmo who is a part of this state have to pay then so be it.

And there are hundreds and thousands more, where willful destruction of the environment has a direct and detrimental effect on me and my children etc etc.

Is it acceptible that we could get in the car, drive 60 miles and fish somewhere eles?

No, f'ck off. Why should we? Why can't we have our natural environment exactly as it should be?

In another post on the Budget, Maxwell quite rightly points out that the deficit is the responsibility of each and every person to repair and restore. He is absolutely right.

The environment in which we live is similarly the responsibility of each and every person. Where we can find the 'culprit' and bring justice to bear then we must do so - and not with fines in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, but fines to repair the entire scope of damage. Where, through willful actions (invariably based upon the good old political "donations" system) or plain stupid ignorance, these things have happened to destroy our environment, then we have to contribute to the reparations. Does this have to be the single highest priority we have as a society? No of course not but it has to start now. Could companies use their donations of time or resources or product to the cleaning activities to offset their carbon emissions? F'cking brilliant idea - I'm off to patent it as we speak.

{ Personally I would recommend death duties to take back from the older generation that made their money on the back of enviro-vandalism and make them pay at LAST for their crimes.

But our pollies don't have the guts. Why, they'd have to face their own mums and dads!! }

edit sum speeling mistakes probly not awl

by absolutely

I will not argue against your stereotype of environmentalists any more than I will argue my intellect against your emotions.

by karmashock

People that refuse to defend their positions while joining public discussions are so tiring... you come here and make your statements and then absolutely refuse to defend them.

Be in the discussion or don't join it.

by sn53

Yes. Place a moratorium on anti-nuclear lawsuits for the next hundred years. But only if you are serious about "solving" global warming.

by drowningnotwaving

Nuclear power, hydro-electric power, wave turbines, whatever ...

Are you seriously suggesting we give 'carte blanche' to whoever builds and operates them, to [b]not[/b] take responsibility for doing so properly?

Given the last 200 years of experience with 'responsible and community-spirited companies'?????

Just 'cos your US lawsuit society is somewhat of a standing joke worldwide, that does not in itself excuse whatsoever the demands, responsibilities and commensurate penalties upon every single decision maker and performer in the planning, construction and operation of any new technology.

If we have learnt NOTHING else in the last 200 years, surely we have learnt this???

by sn53

So much for nuclear power. How many of the environmental-whackos on this board regret that the leftists in Hollywood made the movie, The China Syndrome? Think of how much colder we could be if we had more nuclear power and less global warming!

uh-huh.

by karmashock

Question: What would you accept as proof? I'm sorry but I find often that in internet discussions people tend to accept nothing as proof while demanding it the loudest. Please give me a hypothetical example of what you would personally accept as valid proof of my point.

After all I could be convinced that the world is flat or that gravity is just a conspiracy... but certain conditions would have to be met as I have a lifetime of experience that would call such assertions into suspicion.

What are you conditions? Again... calm down and be logical. I will not be moved by animal emotionalism.

by deepsand

You will find that I am exceedingly logical, to the point of greatly exasperating those here who insist on having opinions stand as facts. You will also find that I do not lightly suffer fools; those who persist in ignoring facts, those who selectively winnow the facts so as to cull those that fail to support their cause, those who fail to understand and distinguish between fact and faith, those who cannot maintain a civil disposition, and those who engage in sophistry will quickly earn my wrath and condemnation.

As for your question re. acceptable "proof," let us re-examine your premises:

1) Those who reject the notion of global warming's existence, or of man's role in such, are rational; while,
2) Those who accept such are irrational.

In order to prevail, you must demonstrate that those falling in the 1st category are [b]not [i]irrational[/i][/b], while those in the 2nd are [b]not [i]rational[/i][/b]. As one cannot prove a negative, you cannot directly prove your premises.

The best you can do is to attempt to definitively settle the issue being here debated, and then poll a sufficiently large sample to find out their position on the issue both before and after its having been settled, along with their reasons for both their before and after positions.

Within the context of this discussion, the best you can do is to obtain a qualitative measure of the participants based on the extent to which their statements are based on matters of Science, Policy based on Science, or Policy alone.

If you examine not only this discussionb, but similar earlier ones here at TR, you will in fact that those accepting the existence of global warming and man's ability to have an effect on climate tend to be those who offer up more Science, while their opponents tend to rely heavily on matters of Policy, offering up only those facts which seem to support them, and as isolated variables rather than within the context of the system as a whole.

by drowningnotwaving

Here is how I have interpreted what you have said in your last couple of notes on this topic:

(this is my paraphrasing of your discussions)...

"If we want Nuclear Power, we must be enable the companies to do it without any legal ramifications upon how they build it, how they maintain it, how they operate it and how they inform the community of possible safety issues or breaches".

And from the second note:

"If that isn't possible then Nuclear Power is not possible".

Do I have this right? Have I interpreted your electronic sighs correctly? Or have I oversimplified the scenario?

Please inform me exactly what you mean before I respond.

by deepsand

"[i]Place a moratorium on anti-nuclear lawsuits for the next hundred years.[/i]

The use of nuclear power and the concept of of being liable for the harm that one causes another are [b]not[/b] mutually exclusive, as you would apparently have it be.

by sn53

CanI said, "The tide is against you. You will be forced to pay an exorbitantly high price to exercise your free will. Your additional payments will be your fee/payment for someone else to actually fix up the problem that you are participating in and contributing to, of your own free will of course.

Islam is a religion of submission. The Islamofascists will force us to submit or be killed. CanI shows that he/she is of like mind. He/she would force me to submit to his will for the sake of his/her religion.

CanI said, "You argue it hasn't been proven. I argue that no longer matters in reality. You're gonna pay..."

See what I mean. The truth, reality, they don't matter. This is an article of faith with the environmental-wackos with their own brand of a religion of submission -- environmentalism and the creed of Global Warming.

These are the tools the enviro-fascists use to subject the masses to their religion. Just wait until they set up their Caliphate.

by sn53

You said, "Please confirm your overall message for no misinterpretation
Here is how I have interpreted what you have said in your last couple of notes on this topic:

(this is my paraphrasing of your discussions)...

"If we want Nuclear Power, we must be enable the companies to do it without any legal ramifications upon how they build it, how they maintain it, how they operate it and how they inform the community of possible safety issues or breaches".

Yep. That is it exactly. Anti-nuclear lawsuits have prevented nuclear facilities from being built in the US. They are a tactic only. So if you are serious about global warming then pass the law that eliminates the anti-nuclear lawsuits.

No harassing lawsuits.

You said, "And from the second note:

"If that isn't possible then Nuclear Power is not possible".

Do I have this right? Have I interpreted your electronic sighs correctly? Or have I oversimplified the scenario?

How can you put in quotes words I never said?

The fact that we do not have any new nuclear power generating facilities is evidence of the power of the harassing lawsuit's ability to prevent new construction.

by tonythetiger

[i]2) If it is the case that you saw my post which appears later in the thread at an earlier time than you did that which appears earlier in the thread, then I stand corrected.[/i]

though honestly I don't recall. Sometimes one subthread catches my eye before another.

by sn53

deep said, "The use of nuclear power and the concept of of being liable for the harm that one causes another are not mutually exclusive, as you would apparently have it be."

Antinuclear harassing lawsuits were never about being liable for harm. They were always about preventing any new construction of nuclear power facilities. They worked too. So maybe we ought to blame global warming on the leftist enviro-fascist wackos.

What do you think?

by maxwell edison

Best (or worst) case scenario (depending on your perspective and/or "desired end conclusion"):

There are JUST AS MANY reputable "scientists" and/or "climatologists" who agree with the notion of man-caused global warming as those who don't.

Do you consider that statement true or false? (And agree or disagree, please provide some support.)

by jdclyde

is to first determine what makes someone qualified to be an "expert" on global warming.
(which is a fact, as the ice age is over, so the globe has naturally warmed)

Now, we need to have a way of counting accurately the number of qualified "experts".

From there, we then need to have them take a vote, and see what the actual count is.

Or we can keep going like we have, and claim that only the people that are unable to get employment in the private sector are qualified, so we can run around saying "everyone KNOWS" blah blah blah.

If these nutcases would spend more time focusing on cleaning up toxins that are poisoning the world and less time flying planes around the globe to tell people to stop polluting, we might get somewhere. Instead of sounding like raving lunitics, screaming that the world is going to end (in a few thousand more years and 2 degrees later), conserve energy and pollute less to keep from poisoning us NOW.

They might actually accomplish something if they did.

by drowningnotwaving

The reason that I understand (in my press-borne ignorance) that Nuclear facilities have not flooded the world, is that they are not economically viable in the long term.

Except, of course, when you add all the hidden costs of what we are doing to the environment and you turn them into economic costs in terms of higher power prices, carbon emission schemes etc etc.

Then the overall economics changes.

Your 'pre-go-ahead' law-suit would appear to be a particularly US-centric problem.

But can I [b]confirm[/b] that your fear is limited to the planning and approval process?

Do you agree that builders / operators / maintainers (once a plant is 'going ahead') should continue to be held to rigorous and extreme measures of quality in every aspect of their operation?

by drowningnotwaving

.
Or is it fair that you actually have to take responsibility NOT to adversely affect me?

Tell me, can you point to a time in history when any society actually acted in the manner that you dream of / subscribe to?

by sn53

You said, "That's a US-centric problem."

Yes. It is. France (a country whose people I loathe) provides about 80% of its energy needs with nuclear power.

You said, "The reason that I understand (in my press-borne ignorance) that Nuclear facilities have not flooded the world, is that they are not economically viable in the long term."

They are not viable because the left uses lawsuits to prevent them from being built. From memory the last one Pacific Gas and Electric spent billions and worked to fight the swarms of lawsuits for more than 25 years before they threw in the towel.

You said, "Except, of course, when you add all the hidden costs of what we are doing to the environment and you turn them into economic costs in terms of higher power prices, carbon emission schemes etc etc."

Free market capitalist countries do quite will in cleaning their environments. It is the anti-capitalist nations who do poorly.

...

You said, "Your 'pre-go-ahead' law-suit would appear to be a particularly US-centric problem."

Yes. It is.

You said, "But can I confirm that your fear is limited to the planning and approval process?"

No. We need to eliminate the harassment lawsuits entirely. We need to narrowly define what harm is.

You said, "Do you agree that builders / operators / maintainers (once a plant is 'going ahead') should continue to be held to rigorous and extreme measures of quality in every aspect of their operation?"

Sure. But no harassing lawsuits.

by sn53

You said, "Or is it fair that you actually have to take responsibility NOT to adversely affect me?"

Huh?

You should have to prove that I have harmed you. It should not be enough for you to feel that I might have harmed you or that if I continue to do things you do not approve for another hundred years there is a chance that my actions might harm you.

You should have to prove your case against me.

You said, "Tell me, can you point to a time in history when any society actually acted in the manner that you dream of / subscribe to?"

Are you asking if there has ever been a time when people have behaved honorably toward one another? If there has never been such a time does that mean I should not consider it a thing to be striven for?

by drowningnotwaving

Nuclear power is seen by even many fervent environmentalists as an option that must be considered. The flip-side is that no one, not even including the pollies who look for simple answers, see it as the [b]only[/b] answer whatsoever.

One major component of "why" it is coming back in favour is an underlying assumption that the overall quality of build, of operation, of transferring fuel rods into and out of a reactor, of controlling and maintaining the entire mechanics, are so much better than 10, 20 or 50 years ago when they first came into play.

Another is that the economic benefits are becoming more realistic in relation to just about every other power generation method because (as I discussed in another post) the costs of those other methods will soon be (correctly) forced to include the environmental impact as an economic cost.

But if you do not enforce stringent standards on the operation of a Nuclear plant, both the real and perceived costs will blow it out of the water as a viable alternative.

And what benefit is this to anyone ????

And you can make snide little jokes about the movies and lefties all you want. No-one on the planet should feel embarrassed about forcing the nuclear barons to justify, singularly without exception, their safety processes and mechanisms.

If they can't or wont, you gonna have one in your backyard?

by deepsand

And, it seems that those who deny the Science are doing so based on Policy preferences.

by deepsand

As I said, I'll take your word for that; and, owe you a drink.

I've lost count; who owes who what at this point?

by deepsand

Your "my religion's better than your's" and "my rights end where I say they do" mantra speaks of but one thing - [b]blind, arrogant selfishness[/b].

by deepsand

Is this why the U.S. government stopped funding of our nascent fast breeder reactor program?

by karmashock

You are not addressing my point you are instead pretending that my point is something else and then attacking that.

My support and logic of my argument is not that those pushing the GW frenzy are illogial. For the last time that is the CONCLUSION. There is a distinction you are ignoring between an argument and the conclusion of an argument.

You are it seems intentionally misrepresenting my stand point and it's ultimately self defeating. The only people here whom this point matters to is you me. We're the only ones in this sub thread. So blatantly misrepresenting my argument does NOTHING to prove your point. It only shows yourself to be petty and cheap.

Now please... I am happy to forgive this... Forums often get heated and people forget themselves. But acting like a child merely shames you.

by sn53

You said, "But if you do not enforce stringent standards on the operation of a Nuclear plant, both the real and perceived costs will blow it out of the water as a viable alternative."

Harassing lawsuits have nothing to do with the quality of the operation. They are a form of the same strategy that I propose against Islamofascists. The left will give no sanctuary to nuclear power plant operators. They hunt them down and force them to defend against harassing lawsuits until they are exhausted. It works. It works so well the left is trying to do the same thing to eliminate the Second Amendment to the US Bill of Rights using the same technique.

You said, "And what benefit is this to anyone?"

Indeed. The lawsuits have nothing to do with the quality of the operation. Their only benefit is to force the would-be nuclear plant operator to "sue for peace" by changing to coal.

You said, "And you can make snide little jokes about the movies and lefties all you want. No-one on the planet should feel embarrassed about forcing the nuclear barons to justify, singularly without exception, their safety processes and mechanisms."

That was never their intent. Their goal was to stop the nuclear industry from expanding. The China Syndrome was just one more shot across the bow and it worked in turning back nuclear power in the US. The left should be held accountable for that. Of course they will not be.

You said, "If they can't or wont, you gonna have one in your backyard?"

Sure. I think every city and large town ought to have their very own. This is a real use of eminent domain.

by tonythetiger

and ALWAYS about agendas. And one would be a fool not to take that into account.

Science couldn't care less. If they cared, they wouldn't stand for having their data misrepresented.

by tonythetiger

So, if they're not credible, and they're now on the bandwagon, does that mean we should now doubt what those on the bandwagon are saying?

:)

by macumazahn

There are accounts of ships sighting and capturing 'the great white bears", for the Coliseum in Rome, they were noted for their ferocity and size and entertainment value to the games, many had drifted on flows within reach of the Roman ships, but maybe the Romans were causing global warming too.

by planemech

The fact is the Lib-nut left has purposely used this photo in a fraudulent fallacy known as an appeal to emotion.
They have shopped this photo around with various misleading captions, designed to appeal to emotion over reason in the absence of fact.
Which pretty much sums up the entire augment on the Left for all their nutty religious beliefs and misguided causes. Global Warming is a Religion, not fact.

You can tell when the Left is lying. In absence of any hard fact to support what they ?feel? to be true; they revert to trying to build ?consensus? and then try to pass off the sheer numbers of their ranks of the gullible, as the learned opinion of the majority and as such, irrefutable fact.

Check out the truth and facts behind that photo here.
http://newsbusters.org/node/10601

The guys who actually took the photo back in 2004 were carrying guns for protection, because there were so many stinking polar bears about. They were there to drill ice in order to plant equip. in the ice, but almost had to give up do to the fact that the ice was much thicker than expected.

by mhbowman

I think the whole arguement about whether or not Globabl Warming exists is a ridiculous waste of time. The fact that can't be disputed is that approximately 85% of the world's pollution has occured in the last 50 years.

Changing course at this point demand a world-wide effort in order to make a difference. Ending the use of fossil fuels, and even more ridiculous sources like nuclear energy that result in radioactive waste, to the removal of harmful products from the market, waste management, resource management, not to mention clean up efforts will have to take place.

The effects are obvious. The world's oceans, rivers, and streams that used to be full of life are dying from being used like a garbage dump. The world's forests are being clear cut and not replaced.

Does global warming exist? Most likely, yes, but even if it doesn't the cause is the same. The result: if we don't change what we're doing soon, we're all going to die anyway.

by planemech

I think the only false argument here is the one you make. Projecting your own traits, labels, and accusing the other party of engaging in false debate tactics, is an old trick the Liberal Left which they use when they are out of valid ammunition in the form of facts, bankrupt of original ideas, and can no longer effectively contribute to the debate.

When your position is in doubt, punt. Then resort to calling names

by planemech

Global Warming is not due to human contribution of Carbon Dioxide

Global Warming: The Cold, Hard Facts?

By Timothy Ball
Monday, February 5, 2007

Dr. Tim Ball, Chairman of the Natural Resources Stewardship Project (www.nrsp.com), is a Victoria-based environmental consultant and former climatology professor at the University of Winnipeg. He can be reached at letters@canadafreepress.com

http://www.canadafreepress.com/2007/global-warming020507.htm

by planemech

'Scientist' Group's Funding Comes with Liberal 'Strings Attached'
By Kevin Mooney
CNSNews.com Staff Writer
January 23, 2007

(CNSNews.com) - At a time when the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS) is censuring free market organizations for accepting donations from ExxonMobil, critics have turned the spotlight back onto the UCS, its left-wing positions, and its own funding practices.

http://www.cnsnews.com/ViewNation.asp?Page=/Nation/archive/200701/NAT20070123a.html

by planemech

Gore to Testify on Climate Change

By: Ryan Grim
February 3, 2007 10:17 AM EST

Former Vice President Al Gore has accepted an invitation to testify next month in a congressional hearing on the highly controversial issue of climate change.
Gore will appear at a joint hearing on Wednesday, March 21. He will be the only witness to appear before the Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Energy and Air Quality and the Science and Technology Subcommittee on Energy and Environment. Gore served on both committees during his House tenure representing a Tennessee district.

http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0207/2596.html

by spacewarp

I have SERIOUS doubts about man-made "global warming". I've been reading this whole thread. You convienently dismiss facts presented by the other side, Deepsand, as irrelevant, irrational or just outright lies.

Someone presents a rational discussion about solar cycles and you ridicule them and state that they need to read a U.N. report.

You say over and over that "90%" amount with regards to scientists. Maybe, if you look at http://oism.org/pproject/s33p37.htm you'll see that there are not only a lot of folks who disagree with your faulty premise, but there are a portion of them willing to put their names on the line.

Now, I have some serious questions for you. I'd like some actual answers instead of dismissals and snarky comments.

1) With the increased solar activity, what makes you think that the sun is not partially responsible?

2) When a volcano erupts, it emits on average more emmissions of "greenhouse gasses" and other polutants than the combined output of all of man's annual output. If we're having just one eruption a year, is it not possible that the earth is responsible for some of the warming?

3) Since we've taken samples of Antartic ice showing there was once some vegatative life there, as well other samples are showing that we've had plant life in other areas where currently there is ice, is it rational to conclude that we've got some sort of previous levels where the temperature was higher?

4)What about the previous warm periods?

5)What about the 2006 hurricane season, which climatologists said was going to be worse than 2005, but later had to be revised at least 4 times for a calmer season?

6)When observed, the claims by "Global Warming" believers resembles that of relgious ferver where that which refutes it or possibly cracks the faith are referred to as blaspheme and treated as such. Does the latest rounds of refusing to allow public debate at all not give an indication that there is something wrong with your argument?

7)Why is it the publicly funded institutes and the U.N. funded institutes are finding "evidence" of global warming, but the independant organizations, or those privately funded are finding it's not there?

Follow the money. You'll see there are big dollars to be had in Global Warming faith.

When you look at things and wondering why there are non-believers, think about personal freedom, financial responsibility and those pesky little facts that those of us see that disturb us.

Deepsand, I can picture you in robes, wandering around the streets of L.A. or somewhere similar, chanting about the church of Global Warming.

Good luck.

Paul

by deepsand

[i]This[/i] thread was not intended as a substitute of such; rather, it was maxwell's reaction to a thread that I started several hours before this one.

Accordingly, it is neither my intent nor desire to here argue the merits of my side, but to simply rebut max and his ilk.

If you should like to participate in a formal debate, you'll need to find those willing and able to stand for you side.

I will, however, briefly respond to some of your points.

You state "[i]You say over and over that "90%" amount with regards to scientists[/i]."

Please show where I have ever said such.

You state "[i]Someone presents a rational discussion about solar cycles and you ridicule them[/i]."

My response was not that the gross influx of Solar radiation was of no import, but that the relevant measure is the [i]net[/i] influx. As long as the amount reflected and/or re-radiated is [b]less than the gross influx[/b], there will be a [b]net gain[/b] in thermal energy.

You state "[i]When a volcano erupts ... is it not possible that the earth is responsible for some of the warming?[/i]"

Again, one can not look merely to the gross effect of a single variable. The particulates so released [i]also[/i] serve to [b]diminish the gross influx of solar radiation[/b].

If you truly desire to debate this subject, do try to round up your team

by deepsand

Moreover, if you read the [b]content[/b] of the article that max posted, it counters his position.

by spacewarp

"Argue all you will. The tide is against you. You will be forced to pay an exhorbitantly high price to exercise your free will. Your additional payments will be your fee/payment for someone else to actually fix up the problem that you are participating in and contributing to, of your own free will of course."

Now, please go read that again. You've just let the liberal argument out of the bag. "We're going to make you pay, and pay big to exercise your free will."

I have my home. I have a certain amount of trash I take out regularly to the dumpster. I keep my home heated in the winter and cooled in the summer. Yes, I generate some pollution when I live. I also pay money for the right to dump my trash in the dumpster, get clean water, heat and cool my home. These are basics. You want to control me. And everyone else around me. How do you accomplish it? Make me pay, and pay big to live.

You wonder why we don't go for your junk "science". It's because it's a religion, not science. The "experts" can't predict next month, nevertheless next year, but you're going to tell me they can predict with tools that are not designed for prediction, but modelling, (in other words, if this, this, this and this happen, what happens) what is going to happen in 100 years? They are making a lot of assumptions. And you know what happens with an assumption. It makes an ass out of you and umption.

by deepsand

If you hold your assumption to be a Conclusion, rather than a Premise, then what is/are you Premise(s)?

And, [i]what[/i] was it about my post to you that was [i]not[/i] well measured? That I suggested that observations of extant post on TR did not exactly support your position?

In any case, you've set an exceedingly difficult task for yourself, owing to the [i]qaulitative[/i] nature of such. To expect that your opponent should assist you is specious indeed.

by spacewarp

It is estimated that the materials, labor and associated costs directly related to that of building a nuclear reactor is approximately $135 million. With the legal ramifications, application fees, court costs and the other things that are brought about by the "environmentally friendly" crowd, the cost soars to approximately $3 billion.

Let's look at Nuclear.
1) Clean
2) Low accidents.
3) Effenciency returns now at or above levels of coal burning power plants.
4) Less deaths in the last 40 years than any major power source. (Windmills don't count, not major.)
5) Not built due to fear, hysteria and general misunderstanding in the US. In France, over 80% of the energy is nuclear generated.

We should end the over-regulation and eliminate the harrassment suits that spike the legal costs to allow them to be built and operate. We also need to ensure that failure to comply with safety regulations will be met with swift and severe criminal prosecutions and liability issues. Nuclear is safe because we've had safeguards in place. It's not safe because we've had legal hurdles like crazy.

Paul

by tonythetiger

I neither accept nor reject, because there's not enough evidence to either accept or reject it (though I'm closer to accepting global warming than not, I am far less so with regards to its cause)

Let's just say that irrational people are far more likely to accept it, because it is being played by the media as fact when it's no such thing.

Off topic, but If I were king, the press would be treated exactly like witnesses in court. If you get caught in a lie, you get imprisoned! Due to their additional freedoms, they should have additional responsibilities.

by jdclyde

MAN-MADE Global Warming is what you were referring to.

The fact that there has been more than one ice age clearly shows the earth warms and cools without the influence of man.

by spacewarp

I don't need a team.

Unfortunately, I find two flawed premises that most global warmers seem to have.

1) That the global warming is a man-made phenomenom.

2) That the natural warming and cooling cycles of the planet Earth are not in effect.

Again, you addressed the question with regards to a volcano (which brings another question regarding your answer, but I'll save that for later), and the question about solar radiation (which I'm not sure you have truly addressed, but we can discuss that in length later). You've completely glossed over the previous warming evidence and the rest of the questions asked. I'm curious, given the items presented, do you want to start a new topic of discussion, so we can rationally discuss the topic, you from a pro-global warming and me from a cyclical standpoint? I'm not going to debate the fact that the temerature on average has risen slightly in the last 25 or so years. I will give you that point.

Paul

by deepsand

Are you sure that you're prepared to singlehandedly mount a [b]formal[/b] and rigourously scientific debate?

As for your present post, you stated:

"[i]Unfortunately, I find two flawed premises that most global warmers seem to have.

1) That the global warming is a man-made phenomenom.

2) That the natural warming and cooling cycles of the planet Earth are not in effect.[/i]"

Item 1 is a Conclusion, not a Premise; and, it does [i]not[/i] accurately state suc. To be more precise, it should be "Mankind's action gave contibuted to global warming."

Item 2 is neither a Premise [i]nor[/i] Conclusion of so-calles "global warmers."

This precisely the sort of misunderstanding & misrepresentation that "global warmers" are constantly bombarded with.

by deepsand

Neither side lacks for want those who are less than wholly rational.

But, it must be borne in mind that such is part of the human condition. After all, we did not [i]choose[/i] to have emotions; they just come with the package.

PS - Did you find the drink count yet?

by drowningnotwaving

... it is the problem with the law !!!!

Give me any example of how the left has done "this" and I am sure within about 30 seconds I can give you another of how the right have done "that". QUick example - how many Union Carbide officials have faced deportation to India and criminal charges relating to the deaths of over 20,000 people?

Sort out your law. Sort out the concept of personal liability and responsibility. Sort out the concept of matching lawsuits and fines with the actual costs incurred by the victim (e.g. get wiplash? Here is your hospital fees paid. NOT "oh and by the way here is another $50 million for your trauma".) Sort yourselves out!! F'ck your entrepreneurial lawyers off!!

I take your point, though. Really I do.

So I would agree. Work a way that the fundamental process of planning and development is made smooth.

But the concept of freeing the designer / builder / operator from their responsiblity to build an extraordinarily high quality product must surely remain, and hang over their head like the Sword of Damacles in every sense.

by drowningnotwaving

I can understand your reaction 'cos I did write it like that and fair enough too.

I was being beligerent and argumentative. Not sure that this is a rare commodity around here but it has enabled your fair interpretation ...

I don't want your money, per se. I don't want to stop you doing anything you want to do.

As long as you take full and complete responsibility for those actions and choices.

And (obviously) as long as those choices don't have an immediate and dangerous impact on me and mine.

The weight of scientific evidence does support taking action to curb greenhouse gas emissions. What is reasonably irrelevant is the correctness. [b]You feel[/b] there is doubt. That is your right.

As a result you think these are impositions and encroachments on your freedom. Okay. Feel that way.

I also have the right to feel that the enviro-fascist-murdering-leftie-commie scientists, measuring and analysing this stuff for well over 50 years now, [b]have it right[/b].

The political pendulum is now on my side.

Therefore in a democratic society, I do have an inalienable right to demand that action is taken to protect me and mine from the frivolous or illegal actions of people continuing either to pollute or (through their consumption choices) contribute to that pollution and problem.

I have to take responsibility. You have to as well. It is no longer an option. It needs to be enforced. The politicians agree because there are overwhelming scientific evidence and publicity thereof has generated the groundswell.

And it's done so AGAINST the background of corporations spending millions and millions of lobbying, advertising, pseudo-science and education to the contrary!

I respect your right to think this is a huge leftie plot. I think, if you think that is the case, you have rocks in your head.

I think I am protecting me and mine and demanding that we all take responsibility for a) stopping the mess and b) cleaning it up.

I feel, and certainly it would appear at the present that a majority of others feel, that I have every right to demand my government to take proactive action to make that all happen. In exactly the same manner that I demand the government to make laws against petty and felonous criminals.

I respect your right to think you are being hard-done-by.