Discussion Locked

Hackers and hacking: what is your opinion?

0 helpful
125 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

First lets define what is hacking and who is the hacker

Hacker
A person who enjoys exploring the details of computers and how to stretch their capabilities. A malicious or inquisitive meddler who tries to discover information by poking around. A person who enjoys learning the details of programming systems and how to stretch their capabilities, as opposed to most users who prefer to learn on the minimum necessary.

Hacking
Unauthorized use, or attempts to circumvent or bypass the security mechanisms of an information system or network

Well lets look at the hacker side, what is the motive for him? Does he try to prove to others how clever is he? Okay after he cracks a program or a site or what ever isn?t that a useful alerting tool to programs and applications programmers and designers to improve the weak points in their projects?

In your opinion shall those people treated as criminals because the breaks systems or applications security or Geniuses because they discover the black holes and bugs that wakes up programmers to recover?

What do you think?

Regards.

** Note : The defenetions are from this glossary
http://www.tsl.state.tx.us/ld/pubs/compsecurity/glossary.html

125 replies

by apotheon

A hacker is not "[i]A malicious or inquisitive meddler who tries to discover information by poking around.[/i]" Hacking is not "[i]Unauthorized use, or attempts to circumvent or bypass the security mechanisms of an information system or network[/i]". The terms you're looking for are [i]cracker[/i] and [i]cracking[/i], unless you're a member of the willfully ignorant mainstream media or the woefully uninformed public.

I recommend you check out the definitions for "hacker" and "cracker" in RFC1392 (the Internet users' glossary), the Jargon File glossary, and FOLDOC (Free OnLine Dictionary Of Computing). I'm sure you can find all three on Google easily enough. These are the three most authoritative references on computer-related jargon available. If, after reading their definitions of "hacker", you still don't get it -- well, then there's no hope for you at all.

Try to avoid comparing those of us who have been called "hacker" in a positive manner by colleagues we respect to those subhuman invertebrate nitwits who think it's fun to vandalize others' systems and violate others' privacy.

by lcm man

Apotheon actually answered the question. However, you could have considered this a moment to educate the public about the differences between hackers and crackers. Instead you choose to put down the "woefully uninformed public" and try to put yourself on a pedestal (just because you work for rocket scientists does not make you one).

The purpose of Tech Republic (as I have interpreted it) is for fellow colleagues in the IT community to provide tips, tricks advise and a little education were needed and requested. We all have our area of expertise and have become members of this site to lend part of that to anyone who asks.

by creative8008

I dont know but mybe there is misunderstand from your side about my point in this discution ..

first of all i have got the defenetions from this glossary
http://www.tsl.state.tx.us/ld/pubs/compsecurity/glossary.html

second thing that im tring to know what is other opinion in this issue not to put my self on a " pedestal" or to put down the "woefully uninformed public" its a discussion that any one can propose and if you and Apo. think that i did a wrong thing by posting this discussion its your opinion and i respected.

""The purpose of Tech Republic (as I have interpreted it) is for fellow colleagues in the IT community to provide tips, tricks advise and a little education were needed and requested. We all have our area of expertise and have become members of this site to lend part of that to anyone who asks"" also there is lots of discussions not only mine that discussing other issues not only provide or get technical assestant as what i know ..

Thanks all
Best Regards.

by apotheon

I don't see how referring to the "woefully uninformed public" is putting someone down, but you go with that if it makes you feel more warm and fuzzy inside.

I didn't put myself on a pedestal. I didn't mention working [with] rocket scientists in that post. What's your issue?

by absolutely

Repeating a lie until it is accepted as truth by the "woefully uninformed public" is a far more malicious and harmful discourtesy than a stern reprimand. Yes, malicious: when you treat facts as so irrelevant that you omit the minimal effort and [b]common courtesy[/b] of being correct, you [b]never know how important[/b] the results of your willful ignorance will be, because you have not checked the nature of reality.

by salty c

Apotheon did provide "links" to definitions that illuminated differences between hackers and crackers, ie. he did consider it a moment to educate... probably more usefully than spouting his view of the differences which might have been considered putting himself on a pedestal.
It would have been inappropriate to duplicate all the relevant info in the links on this thread. It would have been good use of hyperlinking as originally conceived if he had provided full HTML links. As the original poster started with definitions and asked opinions I found Apotheons post more relevant and useful than your unneccessarily critical entry.

by ditchmonk

well i like to test myself to see how far i can go..and have been doing it since the 70's i have been known to leave a note showing the hole on a desktop or send a email but there is large headed folks out there that do get the benifit of my exploits and i do share info to ppl that show respect anyway all haxors are not bad now ones after storage space diff story B/W cost and he is not paying

by dawgit

just to let you know, that is illegal now. yes, it used to be cute, a courtisy, but times have changed. DON'T DO THAT anymore, you might find yourself in serious do-do.

by d.h. cesare

I can't think of any reason to hack if it isn't malicious. I think that malicious hackers should be executed.

by dawgit

that is the real Question. Should it be as slow and painfull as our loss, and hopefully, recovery is? The problem though, is catching someone. As long as people still think it's ok or kool to damage someone else's sys. we'll be fighting an uphill battle to Hang 'em.
I'm talking about 'Hackers' only in the Texas vernackular, people that damage, not what we consider 'Hackers' in the computing community.

by too old for it

... virus / torjan horse / spyware writers / script-kiddies should be hauled bodily out of their parent's basement by some hooded ninja-clad "furies", then and there to have their arms lopped off at the shoulder out in front of Glub and everyone.

But some say I am too easygoing ...

(This could not be that expensive for a billionaire who [b]really[/b] cared about preventing virus activity.)

by pedrorepublic

Hacking doesn't need to be malicious.
Curiosity about new things can be the drive behind it.
Once you hide something whilst leaving it accessible you are attracting curiosity of others.
So if you don't like others hacking, you have two choices.
Segregation (nobody gets in), or openness, anybody can get in.
The issue is the Internet Protocol was designed to be open by a bunch of University researchers.
Because of its openness, it became the standard universal protocol.
Now people want to use it to exchange protected information.
That comes at a cost?
Credit card companies continue to use X25.
So if you want to exchange private information get out of the WWW and use your own network. You can then fire the employees who hack/misuse the corporate network...

by tisha

I couldn't agree with you more D.H , and in saying so let us start atthe top of the foodchain with Mr.Gates and his whole army of software writers at Microsoft.

by michael_orton9

Nearly every IT system has design faults and isn't "fit for the purpose" so it gets "hacked" which usually involves "unauthorised" batch files, often compiled with "illegal" software like bat2com, to get the virtually unworkable system to do what is needed. This is legal, ethical hacking. As MS runs com before exe I use this method a lot myself.
Cracking is outsiders breaking into the IT system for malicious purposes.
As so many systems are so easy to break into, its only the malicious ones that are a problem.
Last Month I went to the Welsh eCrime Summit in Llangollen.
I was shocked at the general impression given by the speakers, including a senior MS man.
Their Internet and IT security was a lawful, well controlled, secure system.
I see a free4all, wild-west system, with virii, worms , trojans and phishing attempts rampant.
As most attacks come from dodgy states who don't care, or support it, its laughable to expect police action.
On the BBC radio last Monday there was a typical comment.. Some "expert" even claimed that their firm "got new anti-virus updates EACH MONTH!!!!"
I often get 2 each day from Frisk.
ISPs can offer some protection form malicious attacks, but IMHO it is futile to rely on them or "The Law".
Every IT admin needs to be a vigilante, a "Ex-KGB Goon", (or a judge, jury, executioner) and of course undertaker!
Hackers make systems,
Crackers break them.

by kron

Until we know everything ;\ - I think that the world wants to be hacked - I mean that?s how we learn and make things better. Now cracking should land you in jail but hacking now... hack away my friend and learn.

by maelorin

You have lifted the jouranlist's definition from a website for librarians.

Perhaps spending a few more minutes researching might help you form your own opinion?

Several people who have cracked network and system security have written about their experiences - including their motivations.

Testing software and hardware is (and certainly should be) a standard part of building and maintaining systems. That may include testing security and stability.

As for how to respond to people who do such things without permission? Much depends upon the consequences and their motivations.

by d.h. cesare

there is no such thing as a-little-bit. Hacking/cracking is wrong, as is stealing, and should be punished severely.

by absolutely

Victims of identity theft don't care that our data was taken by people pursuing "innocent curiosity". Hacking on one's own property is laudable. Performing the same exploits on someone else's property without permission is illegal, whatever you choose to call it, and is theft and intrusion as surely as if you broke down my front door.

by james speed

There is absolutely no difference between a hacker getting into a private network or prying open my front door and walking in my house. None whatsoever. My network may be exposed to the internet, but its for my convienience and access which does not give them license to intrude.

Hackers believe if it lives on a computer they should have to right to see it. This is the height of arrogance, stupidity and absense of any moral values. Its simple, its "Breaking and Entering" no matter how you look at it.... my data is NOT open public knowledge nor is the closet in my house. One of these days the laws will be toughened to prosecute those caught breaking into systems. Hopefully the technology will progress to the point that ISP's could track down an intruder and alert police... I know.. Pipe Dream... but I hope they start REALLY hitting these clowns harder when they do catch them.

by rascal1981

And provide useless information with oh so witty commentary.... You know the biggest problem with the IT field is elitist (and those that are sensitive to such subjects as hacking and cracking and react aggressively) such as yourself who seem to have an inability to dispense information without criticism and sarcasms and its becoming more and more frequent on this board. If you are going to dispense information, how about doing it in a constructive form instead of wasting the rest of our time with insults and abusive sounding language. Finally please do not play na?ve; anyone can go back and read what you read and gather the same tone and context from your message.

Regarding the overall topic of this conversation; I would say that the difference, REGARDLESS of mainstream definition (or what Google and the news media say) is the use of the knowledge as applied to the application. In other words, if you are committing a crime, it?s a crime and there is no way around that and no way to justify it.

by absolutely

Rascal1981: "You know the biggest problem with the IT field is elitist (and those that are sensitive to such subjects as hacking and cracking and react aggressively) such as yourself who seem to have an inability to dispense information without criticism and sarcasms and its becoming more and more frequent on this board."

You're completely wrong. The biggest problem with every field is the assumption that ignorance should [b]not[/b] be answered with insult; that intelligence is [b]not[/b] superior to stupidity; and that deference should be shown by elites to our intellectual inferiors; that those who know the correct answer are utilities or appliances whose only purpose and function are to "dispense information" to mindless trash who haven't the discipline and integrity to [b]get it right[/b]. Knowledge is gained by effort, and [b]is[/b] just cause for pride. Knowing more than almost everybody else [b]is[/b] just cause for elitism.

Creative8008 is posting about IT on pages for IT pros. Knowing that, the individual using the name Creative8008 should [b]expect[/b] that if he is incorrect [b]about IT[/b] and its specialized vocabulary, professionals who take our ability and effort seriously will insult him appropriately for pretending to be something he is [b]not[/b].

by rascal1981

So the higher I climb, the more I can step on the people below? Wow and I thought that the purpose of education was to inform and not use as a whipping stick for those that are uninformed. Do you verbally insult your children for their mistakes as well? Do you degrade your fellow employees when they ask a question that may seem obvious to you when at one point you might (who knows you could be a genius) have not known? My point being that education does not have to be a painful process as self proclaimed elitest seem to think it needs to be. Perhaps if the self proclaimed elitest took more time to explain and educate the lesser informed on how to acquire the answer rather then produce machine like responses with insults then their would eventually be an established pattern rather then the knowledge that a person can get an answer from the "utilities or appliances" that dish them out with an insult. Hey if all they have to bear is an insult for an answer then I am not so sure that people will be detoured that way.....

by sleepin'dawg

Once upon a time the terms "hack"; "hacker";
"hacking" was only applicable to chopping wood or something to do with horses. It was also a derisive term for a journalist. This was pretty much the way it was until the advent of the Apple II and the PC. The word was then applied as a "cute" word for those who would go online and try to gain entry to supposedly closed secure systems. It could also be applied to those who tried to increase or bypass hardware limitations. It was another word for a geek, one who would break into systems to share information with all and sundry. The general population didn't take it too seriously at first and there were stories making the rounds that when companies, especially financial agencies discovered they had been hacked, they would hire the hacker and put him in charge of computer security rather than prosecute him in court. It was felt that too much information about these proprietary systems would be exposed in court laying the systems open to further attacks.

This was where the origins of hack, hacker and hacking derived from and the general public persisted in thinking of the activity as somewhat "cute" and not to be taken too seriously. After all many of their children were "playing" with computers and unbeknownst to a lot of parents they had no idea of just how serious the activities were until the Secret Service, the FBI or the RCMP arrived on the doorstep with warrants to seize computer equipment. After a few parents had to shell out several thousand dollars to keep their little darlings out of the slammer, the activity began to be taken more seriously.

A few years ago somebody in Moscow, hardly a center of cutting edge technology, posted the names, account numbers and social security numbers of about 12,000 credit card holders on the internet. He made no demands but suggested he could provide information on 500,000 card holders. The story ran for maybe two days and then strangely the incident disappered into the mists of time. However, it is rumoured that the credit card company got the individual a green card, moved him into a house somewhere nice and warm and paid him several million to show how he did it, to keep his technique confidential and to never do it again. Did it happen??? Was it just some fairy tale of the press??? Did the guy get paid off or did he get a late night visit from some of the "boys"??? Who knows??? I remember hearing the original story and figured it was probably just another urban legend but I did read the story in a newspaper and heard it mentioned on the news; after that, nothing.

Then there was some baker in New York who had the account numbers and social security numbers of some wealthy people and he was supposedly wire transferring various amounts out of their accounts. He wasn't caught until he exceeded the $5000 reporting limit and some clerk phoned Donald Trump, or someone in that league, to gather further details for reporting the information to the IRS. I would imagine the Donald not being too pleased.

Still, by and large, the general public only heard the stories as rumours and weren't too alarmed until somebody announced they had unleashed a virus that would shut down all computer systems. I can't remember precisely but I think it was the Michaelangelo Virus that was supposed to crash all systems on the anniversary of the artist's birth. That sort of put the fox amongst the chickens and there was much handwringing, protesting and complaining about how this could happen and yet many believed not only that it could happen but that it would happen. Some MIS managers spent a few sleepless nights worrying about that one. (Remember when it was MIS before it became IT???)

Anyway the perception of computer pranks came to be taken more seriously and that is about the time the words "crack", "cracker" and "cracking" came into vogue as it more closely related to criminal activities, such as safe cracking, etc.

All I know is that whether it's called hacking or cracking, it is now definitely illegal,and unless it is court ordered, it is annoying and defending against it can be costly. If my systems come under attack, for whatever reason, and we can trace the origins of the attack, we will prosecute to the fullest extent of the law and I won't be hiring any of the little dipshits afterwards. If legal procedures fail to give satisfaction, I might consider putting out a contract with some of the "boys" to go and amputate a few fingers. Life can be damn inconvenient when one is lacking an opposable thumb or two, especially when you collect the index fingers as well.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by apotheon

Are you making this up as you go along?

The term "hacker" as applied to computers did [b]not[/b] start with security crackers in the age of the Apple II, and did not in fact have anything in particular to do with computer security in particular at all. The term's use arose from a model railroad club at MIT in the 1960s, when a computer that could fit on a desk wasn't even a faint glimmer in its inventor's eye and computer network security was mostly theoretical because it wasn't yet needed. The reason the term migrated from a model railroad club to MIT's AI lab is imply that the two environments were mostly populated by the same bunch of intelligent, inquisitive, geekish geniuses.

When one abuses the term "hacker" as the mainstream press and legions of Microsoft drones do, it is first and foremost those brilliant and venerable scions of the early computing culture at MIT that are being maligned. It shows ignorance and, worse, disrespect to misuse the term that way.

The period where you insist that the term was first applied to computers was actually the period when idiot journalists who had no clue what they were talking about started misusing the term "hacker" as you've misused it.

by w2ktechman

The definitions are more like cracking than hacking. Part of them describe hacking, except the malicious part. Hacking can involve any type of change to the system or program. Example like hacking the registry to fix a problem with the system or setup. If you alter the code on a program, again hacking.
But, if you write code for malicious purposes it is not really hacking, but cracking! The term Hackers was an earlier term, in the industry. And the term did hit mainstream, but since then, for many years, the malicious part was changed to cracking. But it never caught on in the movie industry, and never went mainstream.
But to the point of your post, hacking, I do myself. I write batch files, edit the registry, and find solutions to problems with a computer, even a remote system.
Cracking, is a needed portion of society. Without it, programs would lack the security needed. Crackers bring out the problems of securityy in not only the OS, but in many applications as well. However, I do not condone their acts, and I believe they should be punished harshly. I wish that they would put their activities to better use, like informing the companies of the risk(s), but if all of them did, the companies wouldnt change anything, would they.
Without the constant attacks on our systems, most companies would still be writing crappy code with the most basic of security. But because of these attacks, companies are FORCED to use better security, better code writing, or go the way of the dinosaur.

by the admiral

First off, you are so far off base that it is sick.

A hacker by definition is:

One who is proficient at using or programming a computer; a computer buff.
One who enthusiastically pursues a game or sport: a weekend tennis hacker.

Hacking is defined as:

To cut or chop with repeated and irregular blows: hacked down the saplings.
To break up the surface of (soil).
Informal. To alter (a computer program): hacked her text editor to read HTML.

So where did you get the idea that hacking is 100% illegal. If we went by those definitions or by the definitions of those from the media, we would all be hackers and all be convicted.

The fact of the manner is that you are avoiding the appropriate terms for illegal activity.

Cracking, phreaking, pirating.

by d.h. cesare

You know what we're talking about; don't be a prick. Any and all malichious hacking/cracking.
K.I.S.S.

by apotheon

Ignore accuracy. Let's all just misapply terms all the time and excuse it by saying "Well, I don't care if it's wrong, you're a prick for pointing out that I'm using the wrong word." Let's use the word "locksmith" to mean "burglar", and use the term "soldier" to mean "murderer", and use the term "mechanic" to mean "saboteur". We could use the term "lawyer" to mean "traitor", too. After all, locksmiths know a lot about the things that keep burglars out of houses, soldiers know a lot about killing, mechanics know a lot about the internal workings of things that might be sabotaged, and lawyers know a lot about the legal workings of local government.

Ridiculous. When you misuse words the way you seem to think it's okay to misuse them, you end up paying some very respectable people a great deal of disrespect. Prick.

by highlander718

Than we'll say that all the other law-brakers are some sort of geniuses that are prompting the "system" to discover it's weaknesses ?
Thiefs are geniuses that know how to break into the most sofisticated safes right ?

by rbdevore

If someone knows how to break into a safe, they may not be a genius, but they are definitely smarter than most of us. At this point they are not a criminal.

If someone knows how to break into a safe and does it and takes the contents without the permission of the owner, then that person is a criminal.

If you know how to get into a computer system and you use that information to improve the system, you are a hacker.

If you know how to get into a computer system and you use that information to gain access to information that you should not have access to or to damage the system, then you are a cracker.

by michael_orton9

rbdj,
You wrote;"If someone knows how to break into a safe, they may not be a genius, but they are definitely smarter than most of us."

Do a Google for "Matt Blaze" + Safecracking
and you will find a .PDF from Professor Matt Blaze on how 2 do it.
He is an IT security expert and he is just showing that Safes are not as safe as we thought them to be, just like IT security!
Yes you can learn how2 open the office safe in a day, he claims 20 minutes with practice.

http://WWW.CRYPTO.COM/PAPERS/SAFELOCKS.PDF

This is his excellent tutorial on the subject.
Yet I still find that people lock up sensitive material in such safes without intrusion alarms, or other physical security devices.
Like any PC, if an intruder can spend the night with it, he should be able to break in.
The only difference is that with a PC nothing is actually missing.
MI5 ran "Party Piece" on BCP, and had to run up a huge overtime bill to copy the spoils.
A USB HD caddy or USB keyring leaves no traces and doesn't occur a huge overtime bill! (From Peter Wright's Spycatcher book.)

IMHO Security, whether IT or Physical, is often more illusionary than real.
Matt Blaze's work on the subject is worth reading.

by x-marcap

He must have confused lowly you with Glorious me.

I am the rocket scientist, and, Dang, I work on a raised computer room floor. At NASA and at my full time job. I guess that is a pedestal.

Apotheon was just being too kind. He said "woefully uninformed public" not idiot jac**** and their butt kissing sycophants. I'm sorry I have to correct him. He is still to PC.

by jkaras

Yes it is the new grafitti of the milenimum. Everyone wants to be bad or walk the dark line more than once in their life. Some people are about trying to profit from it, some trying to test how clever they are by displaying their prowess, and other believe that they are sticking it to the man.

Regardless of their intentions there are many benefits. First off guaranteed employment. If this issue didnt scare any company or person then people wouldnt pay top dollar for our field or it would be a very small vocation. Think about all the money generated from it, virus protection, upgraded software to promote more security, future evolution towards better security. Lets face it if there wasnt a threat then we wouldnt profit much of this field and it would be more of a hobby. Second how to build a better mouse trap. This stimulates better programming, and a true commitment to protecting the user/client. It also pushes for better laws and moral debate concerning etiquette across the net. Has the internet facilitated more pediphiles? Yes but it also has generated more arrests and prevention to rid society from these predators before they abduct children using highly documentitive evidence to convict these people.(ok so its a side product of the original question, but the result is evident through better programming)

As pointed out earlier, increased awareness to protect yourself, family, or business.

DO I think hacking, cracking, or whatever definition you prefer is good? No, but it brings about a lot of good things as a result. If you remove every bad thing in life it cannot improve. "Without obsticles there can be no progress" Life and everything in between has balance.

by stargazerr

that you might want to look up what the difference between [b]hacker[/b] and [b]cracker[/b] is ...

A hacker hacks to help secure systems and find bugs and security holes. A cracker cracks to cause havoc and to steal. You are using the terms as non-techs use them. That is not the correct use of the word Hacker. The word has been dragged down un-necessarily.

I see that many others have replied to this thread (I havent read any yet) .. so I might be repeating what someone has already said ...

]:)

by sanoranmadman

Research has shown that individuals with antisocial personality disorder are indifferent to the possibility of physical pain or many punishments, and show no indications that they experience fear when so threatened; this may explain their apparent disregard for the consequences of their actions, and their lack of empathy with the suffering of others.

by t-cally

If you are hired to do the job, you are legal. If your aren't your illegal, case close. Does a person robbing a bank get to say I was just seeing if it could be done? We've gotten so intelligent that we've become stupid, is that what is meant by "full circle"?

by lcm man

I agree with Apotheon. There is a distinctive term to be used based on the activity taking place. When Microsoft user of Windows 3 first experienced Windows 95, there was ALOT of hacking going on. Everyone was exploring a new(er) landscape in computing. The geniuses that created BackOrifice were using it to illegally crack into your PC.

One reply in this post states that if you are paid to do it it is not illegal. WRONG. If I paid someone to get access to the bank or financial institution holding your money and alter whatever software they are using to keep your account secure, and instruct them to place code in the software to transfer your funds to my account, which part of that is legal?

I think this post shows some of the reasons the legal community is having issues with this subject. Even in the IT world we cannot agree on what to call it.

by akalinowski

hacking is just an action, to break into a bank is not the same as to break into a system to see if you could, there are some ethical questions, should i break into something that doesnt belong to me, no, should i break into my own stuff to see if i can, or work as a samurai, yes

its like shooting a riffle, if i shoot it at a deer during deer hunting season, and i have a permit, perfectly legal, if i shoot it at a person for no god reason, different story, should all guns be illigal because of it, no

by wayne m.

I think Too Old For IT got the definition right. Hacking: "their arms lopped off at the shoulder".

by white4350

Hackers are usually computer nerds with grey, empty, little lives, who imagine themselves as evil geniuses and cyber-heros. Their only claim to fame, is successfully intruding into the activities of other people doing worthwhile things and causing maximum inconvenience, often of a destructive nature.
The thrill in these envious attacks, is in believing onself to be the "victor" in breaching others' defenses and the delusion, that they are now in control. Though undoubtedly the activity requires an advanced knowledge of computers and a modicum of raw intelligence, they do not have sufficient ethical or moral sense of purpose, to use these gifts for anything constructive.
In effect, they are no better than brain dead grafitti "artists", making a mess and creating a public nuisance for their own shabby amusement.

by rashby1

Reading this string has entertained me the last two days. I have to ask a question though. Where are all the crackers in this?

One of the things that got me into computers in the first place was the want to counter attack those who kept "booting" me off of the Internet.
I actually became a menial script kiddie in the process using tools others made, reading, "how to" guides, even the infamous "Guide to mostly...." I was pretty lame. But as the years gone by, my desire to learn "for real" out grew my destructive nature. I went to college (ECPI) and did much research and finally landed an IT job. I find myself tinkering with computers at home (I have six). I don?t have the desire (most of the time) to load Trojans or root kits like I used to do. I actually "tinker" now to either better understand or improve that system (usually it is my system).
I believe this is the true nature of hacking. I used to be a cracker (just annoying, no formatting or stealing). I know that the readers of this can?t be all good-natured users / admins, or self-proclaimed hackers. I know some of you crack, like I used to. Speak up. Tell us your motivation like I did so we can better understand the differences and similarities if any.

by d.h. cesare

You argue for the sake of argument. Hacking/cracking is wrong and that's what we're talking about. You want to concentrate on nit-pickin', have at it.

by apotheon

Sticking your fingers in your ears and shouting "lalalalalalalalalalalalala" all the time so you never have to hear someone tell you how exactly you're wrong doesn't make you right. I'm not arguing to argue: I'm arguing [b]because you're wrong[/b]. Here, read up on the definition and history of the term "hacker", and stop being a willfully ignorant, disrespectful, ungracious, offensive, immature git:

http://www.catb.org/jargon/html/H/hacker.html

Educate yourself.

by absolutely

An oversimplification, but it explains the essential distinction between the definitions of the terms "hacker" and "cracker" as used (correctly) in IT. This also should clarify to honest, but not fully informed observers, why experienced IT folks care passionately about the use of the term "hacker" to describe somebody who modifies programs honorably to improve their function, distinct from the word "cracker" which means somebody that uses whatever IT skills they have to gain unauthorized access to systems they do not own nor have any permission to use.

Apotheon's argument is [b]much[/b] more important than a dispute for the sake of argument. Hacking is not wrong, when that term is used in its correct sense, as originally defined by the programmers who coined it. Cracking is what is always wrong, because it is, by definition, the illegal application of the same skills and techniques as hacking. You're welcome.

by the admiral

Then you should turn yourself in because when you type in a password, you are indeed hacking.

When you change the firewall settings for websites, you are hacking.

When you accept a cookie, you are hacking.

So let us know the court date of your trial, so we can watch.

by ni70

[b]hack[/b]
Last modified: Monday, October 21, 2002

(v) 1. To write program code.

2. To modify a program, often in an unauthorized manner, by changing the code itself.

(n) 1. Code that is written to provide extra functionality to an existing program.

2. An inelegant and usually temporary solution to a problem.

Also see hacker.
http://www.webopedia.com/TERM/h/hack.html

[b]hacker[/b]
Last modified: Monday, August 25, 2003

A slang term for a computer enthusiast, i.e., a person who enjoys learning programming languages and computer systems and can often be considered an expert on the subject(s). Among professional programmers, depending on how it used, the term can be either complimentary or derogatory, although it is developing an increasingly derogatory connotation. The pejorative sense of hacker is becoming more prominent largely because the popular press has coopted the term to refer to individuals who gain unauthorized access to computer systems for the purpose of stealing and corrupting data. Hackers, themselves, maintain that the proper term for such individuals is cracker.
http://www.webopedia.com/TERM/h/hacker.html

[b]crack[/b]
Last modified: Monday, October 21, 2002

(1) To break into a computer system. The term was coined in the mid-80s by hackers who wanted to differentiate themselves from individuals whose sole purpose is to sneak through security systems. Whereas [b][i]crackers[/i][/b] sole aim is to break into secure systems, hackers are more interested in gaining knowledge about computer systems and possibly using this knowledge for playful pranks. Although hackers still argue that there's a big difference between what they do and what crackers do, [b]the mass media has failed to understand the distinction[/b], so the two terms -- hack and crack -- are often used interchangeably.

(2) To copy commercial software illegally by breaking (cracking) the various copy-protection and registration techniques being used.
http://www.webopedia.com/TERM/c/crack.html

I agree with Apotheon.

by ntrewartha_germany

..anybody can write an entry to webopedia.
?
Hacking is illegal.
Like I wrote else where , why don't Hackers use their energies to rid Internet of the really unpleasant elementa -Spammers,Phischers and Virus spreaders. Funny that no hacker seems to be doing anything about that.

by pedrorepublic

When I was programming and maintaining, sometimes we needed to do "acrobatic" interventions.
These often involved penetrating computers in order to replace an executable, or repair a database.
It was pure hacking...
You could say it was illegal, but the costumers were happy, the company was happy and we learned something...
Hackers are doing a lot to repair and get the internet rid of the "unpleasant elementa".
Maybe you're just not aware of it...

by apotheon

You're obviously not very good at reading available information and assimilating it. Try checking out FOLDOC, the Jargon File, and RFC 1392 for more official definitions of "hacking" and "hacker" that can't be edited by "anyone". You might also pay attention to the fact that large-scale wiki projects like Wikipedia are self-policing so that articles like definitions for terms like "hacker" don't let just any old crap slip in, as you seem to be inferring must happen if something is publicly editable. Clearly, you lack some sociological understanding.

by zlitocook

I was a hacker in the 70's and 80's. I had to learn how to get into main frames and then to use them. But I did not install or do any thing, I just wanted to look around and see what the computers did or could do.
I even set my self up as a user so I could talk with the programmers and sysops. They did not get mad unless you started using computer time for some one that needed it. So I was on after midnight and left by six am.
At that time a hacker just wanted to learn and maybe help another hacker too.
Now all hackers do is bother people or worse take over thier computers. I am in favor of jailing people who hack, make malware, virus makers and spammers!
Using a computer should be fun, a learning experience and not be a worry about what you have done on the Internet that day!
Sorry but this is going to be a short rant.
Why should I worry about opening any email? Why should I worry about any website I go to? Why do I need to check my system every day? Because of the stupid people who think it is fun to destroy or take over a computer. They have let the people who feed on others, the criminal part of our society take over.
Mabie the hacker is making up for some short coming that he has, like the person who has to have the biggest car.
I hate hackers, virus makers and spammers!

by absolutely

to ignorant "journalists". I was born in the mid-1970's, and I've done enough of my homework to know the difference between a hack and a crack.

by capn_crispy

I was born in the mid-1970's - That makes you a JUNIOR Player, son.

started using pay phones for free w/ a tone box back in the late 60's while yr parents were protesting the war & smokin' dope.

Get yr facts straight...

by jrbarve

As compared to the development of technology, the development of our laws has been lagging far behind. And the redefinition of morals and ethics farther still.

With Hackers and Hacking two things are involved:

1. Action
2. Intent

When a judgement is passed, the principle to be followed is "Not only must justice be done, but it must seemed to have been done". In a similar vein, the action of hacking is wrong and punishable when there is an intent to cause harm. The problem however is that it is difficult to establish intent and so conclusions are made on the basis of what can be established.

by absolutely

(1) Don't call me son.

(2) My parents did not smoke dope.

(3) You're an imbecile to tell me "Get yr facts straight" without contradicting a single statement that I made.

by rascal1981

Through verbal abuse you educate? I think a dicatorship once ran like that but last I checked the Nazi's failed......

by apotheon

Well, you've just proved Godwin's Law — and, by convention, that indicates you lose the argument. Thanks for playing.

by rascal1981

way to go on finding a way to end the arguement with no good conclusion; I envy your ability to tuck and run. Since the point can't be made to you and your little buddy "Absolutely" I will drop the subject and move on but I truly thank you for taking the time to reinforce your one sided, elitest values on the rest of the community. You and "Absolutely" are fine pillars of the community and thank God, for without you two, we know the rest of us would still be crawling around in the dirt.......yeah.......

by absolutely

Whoever gave you the impression that my purpose is to educate, lied to you. I have better things to do than to interact with those who have not educated [b]themselves[/b].

by apotheon

If you can't make substantive arguments, perhaps you should keep quiet so you don't further decrease the signal-to-noise ratio.

by jaqui

wrong forum to use media definitions of Hacker and Hacking.

true meaning of Hacker, is someone who pokes around trying to find out how things work, at worst a nuisance to the sysops / company, no damage done to the system.

Hacking is tossing together something to accomplish a specific task, be it a black box or a regex.

What the meadia uses is better known as Cracker and Cracking.

A Cracker is ssomeone who malisously breaches the system, with intent to cause damae.

Cracking is the process of finding bugs / exploits in order to create viruses / break in and steal data.

crackers should be put on a chain gang and put to work doing manual labour , paid minimum wage and made to pay back double the amount of damages they caused, then executed.

by absolutely

Nor am I the most elite, which would be correct. But I may, in some cases, be "elitist". I believe that achievement is worthy of respect and that lack of achievement is not. You decide whether that makes me "elitist". Meanwhile, I will decide for myself what achievements of mine define me as "elite".

by zlitocook

A blue box or mabie a white box? Sorry it's been awhile but I still have the plans for four of the box's.
I just thought about my war dialer, a program that I used in the 80's to find systems that were open to phone dialers;)
Wait I did not do any of these things. I am a good person, like every one. But look at every one, you can not expect every one to be a good person. Look at the news and protect your selfs!
If I can get into computers on the internet and access stuff about you, just for fun. What can hackers get into?

by capn_crispy

I appologize to everyone for the ALL CAPS thing. I wasn't paying attention; inventory system only recognizes CAPS; Anyone heard of MANFACT ? UGH !

& NO, no leaisure suits. Ran out of oil one day & burned them in the furnace. Ever see doulbe knit plastic go up ? Wheeee !

*&* I've still got a few years on 1957, but at this point in my life, that is pretty immaterial. Just more timeline for better stories of things I shouldnta donee, I guess !

I think my box was in an empty BUD can. Great conversation piece. Maybe I'll send it to the Smithsonian Museum of American History. Tee Hee.

Didn't mean to offend anyone - & I'll pay closer attention to my KB lights from now on. (and proof my posts as well !)

The Cap'n
SSSSSSSSS

END$

by absolutely

Capn_Crispy: "I wasn't paying attention; inventory system only recognizes CAPS"

You lazy piece of trash. PAY ATTENTION! Your company doesn't pay you to put errors into their inventory system.

by rbdevore

Hacker
1) A person who enjoys exploring the details of computers and how to stretch their capabilities.
2) A malicious or inquisitive meddler who tries to discover information by poking around.
3) A person who enjoys learning the details of programming systems and how to stretch their capabilities, as opposed to most users who prefer to learn on the minimum necessary.

The second sentence in your hacker definition, contradicts the other two.

by apotheon

When someone starts spuriously comparing opponents in a debate to Nazis, it's not only offensive -- it's also an excellent indicator that the schmuck in question is an unreasonable troll with whom not common accord can likely be reached. Thus, you lose.

Get outta my face, troll.

(and learn to spell "elitist" while you're at it)

by zlitocook

Geem in your mothers eye, I was put into this world in 1958 so you should call me you could call me old fart or Mr. old fart;). The 70's do you still have a leisure suit?
And yes I still have all the old programs for the box's. But it was me and friends who were logging on and changing things. And yes we were smoking things, and yes we loved doing it!

by absolutely

I am not yet apotheon's "buddy". I have admired his dispassionate style for some time, but we are just getting acquainted. I am not yet sure how many points of disagreement we will find, but on his interpretation of Godwin's law, I agree, Absolutely!

Furthermore, it is not offensive only because neither of us has murdered one, let alone 6 million, individuals. It is offensive that you use the word Nazi in a discussion having nothing to do with any of the National Socialist party's agenda, and without specifying what similarity you assert. Respect for life and the memories of the real people really murdered by the Nazi party demands that if you [b]really[/b] see that type of behavior, you specify and substantiate your assertion. Otherwise, apologize for your disrespect to the memory of those who were really murdered by Nazis.

by scendales1

Anybody in IT don't have a college degree should stay out of IT. Keep the industry clean of wannabees! Make an effort for crying out loud.

by apotheon

I both agree with you and disagree with you.

1. Grammar and spelling are important, particularly for formal communications.

2. These aren't exactly formal communications, so a certain amount of leeway is appropriate. Still, some of the posts here are pretty awful, in terms of grammar and spelling.

3. Your grammar sucks.

4. Was your college education that crappy, or did you just not pay attention? More than one exclamation point is inappropriate for formal communications, and more than three is incorrect for even informal communications.

5. While I have had some college (and graduated two computer related trade schools), I don't actually have a college degree. Despite that, I don't think many would call me a "wannabe", and I'm pretty sure I know more about what I'm doing than you do. Would you like to rethink your nattering on about college degrees?

6. I have more respect for a successful autodidact than some pink-faced college grad without much real-world experience. Not too many colleges teach such useful concepts as how to implement non-vendor-specific solutions, hetergeneous systems integration, and pragmatic tech industry trends analysis.

by rashby1

Are you insane? My very first computer related job was as the lead technician at Circuit City. I left them to work as the Com OP for Information Systems at Spectrum Laboratory Network. I got a diploma from ECPI, and am learning still. I was chosen over people who had four-year degrees... Why? Your post implies to me that you are insecure about your college given abilities. Are you being made to look like a newbie everyday by some "wannabee" coworker? Now that you have your degree, are you finished learning? Are you better than those without degrees, or even certs?
If you think you are, your not.

by old guy

It's really funny that you jumped someone for grammar. If you're going to do that then make sure your rant/comments is correct. Your first sentence is incorrect and the other two are incomplete: "Anybody in IT don't have a college degree should stay out of IT." You left the who, or which, out.

by apotheon

That would be "who", not "which". Which would be inappropriate. (S)he/it also used "don't" where "doesn't" would have been correct.

You're absolutely right: scendales1 has no clue what (s)he/it is doing when it comes to grammar. The irony is amazing.

by alonzokissel

... after reading the "hacker/cracker" exchanges. I felt an IQ drop of at least ten points and only read the last three days of comments (I have no intention of finishing).

I've learned nothing about "hackers", less about "crackers" and witnessed some of the worst spelling and grammar since grade school. That, coupled up with the lack of communication skills (with people), it is no wonder why technical support is being farmed out to other countries.

Note to the "rocket scientists": If your attitude at your paying job is similar to what is exhibited here then it won't be long before you regress from "rockets" to "paper airplanes".

by rmccloud

I think that RFC1392 is, hmm, just a little bit more authoritative a source for computing definitions than, say, a texas library archive.

Call me crazy, or an elitist. Or maybe I'm just woefully uninformed...

Ric

by ntrewartha_germany

Frankly I think Hackers are a kind of Criminal. How else can you explain their behaviour.
Unfortunately, the Media insists on glamourising Hackers.
If they really want to help the IT communinty why don't use their skill to localise Spammers , Phishers and lowest kind of life: the Virus
speaders.
So far a waiting for Hacker to discover weakness in Software..This should be dealt with the QA Sofware Test dept!!

by tisha

This is not by any means a black and white issue!
When you think of all that hackers have achieved in the past all the exploits in software that they have exposed.
Where would be without Hackers?
The way I see it they are a necessary evil, that keep multibillion software companies on their toes.
In a way they are doing us a service.
IMHO all Network security administrators need to learn Ethical Hacking.
Patching up your system is all well and fine , as well as very time consuming , looking at your system through the eyes of a hacker and finding the backdoors, the weak spots that can be and will be exploited is far more efficient.
That's my 2 cents worth on this subject.

by pedrorepublic

Going back to my previous post.
Rules and regulations or official definitions appeared after the internet was invented by people who wanted it and created it to be open.
Some people are now trying to make it their turf.
Good luck!
You?d better invent your own protocol for that.
Only glitch is, no one will use it?

by absolutely

Rascal1981: "So the higher I climb, the more I can step on the people below?"

Nobody stepped on anybody else. False claims were made smugly and arrogantly. A courteous response would have been inappropriate.

Rascal1981: "Wow and I thought that the purpose of education was to inform and not use as a whipping stick for those that are uninformed."

One of many valid uses of information is to impart it on the uninformed. When uninformed parties proclaim their misconceptions as fact, the appropriate response is to abruptly correct the untrue statements they make, not to praise them for their failure to verify their assumptions.

Rascal1981: "Do you verbally insult your children for their mistakes as well?"

Are you a child? Adults frequently, and rationally, hold higher expectations of other adults than we hold for our children. Get used to it.

Rascal1981: "Do you degrade your fellow employees when they ask a question that may seem obvious to you when at one point you might (who knows you could be a genius) have not known?"

I would insult even the president of my company for making a false statement about his own business or profession.

Rascal1981: "My point being that education does not have to be a painful process as self proclaimed elitest seem to think it needs to be. Perhaps if the self proclaimed elitest took more time to explain and educate the lesser informed on how to acquire the answer rather then produce machine like responses with insults then their would eventually be an established pattern rather then the knowledge that a person can get an answer from the "utilities or appliances" that dish them out with an insult."

What "self proclaimed elitest" do you mean? I don't see any statement posted on this thread that is elitist, or that identifies the poster as elitist. I think you have an inferiority complex.

Rascal1981: "Hey if all they have to bear is an insult for an answer then I am not so sure that people will be detoured that way....."

Ignorance & stupidity should be penalized more harshly.

by absolutely

One can become known as a "hacker" by honest & admirable work; self-directed inquiry into the operation of a labor-saving device. Computer hackers are not all evil.

Safes, on the other hand, have exactly one purpose, and learning how to circumvent that purpose, for any reason other than legitimate criminal investigation, is inherently evil.

Not contradicting any of the points made above, just interested in how in some respects the safe-cracking analogy applies to IT, and how in other respects it definitely doesn't.

by tisha

Finally some common sense!
Well at least three of us agree on a few pointers.
So you do you agree or not, with how you view your system?
Ethical Hacking is and always will be a must, know your enemy!
Know their weapons!
See what they see, not what you have been trained to see, look through. Their eyes.
Find the exploits before they do and lock them down.
Only way to win this failing war, is to beat them at their own game.
Hack your system on a regular basis, using their weapons and then you might stand a chance.

As for crackers not touching on that one at all.

by jaqui

...is to beat them at thier own game"

true.
but using their tools and practices to find the holes is cracking your system. using you knowledge afterwards to seal those holes is hacking it.

by bvg_1

hi all,
hacking is not a silly thing.
hackers do really hard work to find out the loop holes of the system.
infact each company should have a hacking team like a Quality assurance, which can try all the ways to break the system.
once this team assures the code free of loopholes, then system can be released.
regards,
venu

by lcm man

Code free of loopholes?!? LMAO. Never happen. The bigger the program (like MS Office etc.) the more inherent it is to loopholes (flaws) in the code.

Hackers = Good
Crackers = Bad (except with soup)

by ntrewartha_germany

If you made the effort to actually read the header where a definition of Hacker was offered as the discussions staring point
God know what tormented logic you used to come up with "you lack some sociological understanding."
But there again you seem to make a lot of such sweeping remarks to other people in this discussion.

by apotheon

By sociological understanding, I refer to your understanding of how high-traffic wikis with a strong user community work. I guess I shouldn't expect you to get that, though, judging by the other hints of your lack of understanding.

by fernando_fcbs

I would like to start of in saying these are opinions:

someone in the reply mentioned about why IT has issues? if you all read everything which was posted, and i did for the most part, you would notice that mostly everyone argues, instead of working together for a solution or an answer. Nothing wrong with that at all, if you like technology to stay put, but i thought IT was about sharing knowledge.
Now a days most "old school", key word most, amdins horde knowledge like it will save their lives instead of sharing it or passing it on.
If you look at the history of IT alone, it has many a humble begining, one of which there was only one one definition for "hacker", and one for "phreaker" (for those of you who remember such things). Hackers were known as people who "hack at it" with a problem, till they found a solution. These beginings started by people sitting in their garage and making clubs witch spoke about new technologies and knowledge was "shared"(there was actually a computer group which started this way, sorry forget the name), not given by driplets to those who would want the knowledge, but just shared and discussed ways to improve it. IT today is basically multiple partnerships, be it by corporatrions or just IT professinals collaborating with each other. This is how IT was developed from, collaboration.

To those who think that they know all about computing, congrtulations, you have proven you know nothing. By that comment i don't mean to take away from anyone's accomplishments, but to try to make someone realize there's always something new out there which they may not have heard of. Personally i know there's always more to learn, the day i stop learning, is the day i won't know the technology being used.

The arguments about hackers and creackers?
well, to be technically honest, crackers would be more of the people dealing with cracking of software or encryptions, but may not know anything about networking, and the same can be said about a "hacker", which may know about networking but nothing about cracking. It depends on the skill level of the individual. The definitions used by most of these organizations were introduced mostly by people who didn't take part in it. As for the hacker, i believe there's different hats for them: white hatter, black hatter, grey hatter.

each of them dealing with different characteristics. one ethical, one malicious, and one in the middle, which has the knowledge of the "darkside", but works for good or vice versa.

Finally, to answer the post, i would not consider someone "hacking" into a network a crime if there was consent to do so. Best way i can explain it: would you want someone trying to lockpick your bedroom door without you knowing it?
I think it's more of a invasion of privacy, and sometimes confidentiality of businesses.

Apotheon, as for the aforementioned quote "hackers make systems, crackers break them"... so you're telling me taht a hacker would make a network but not test it by trying to hack into it themselves(pen testing)? that's like putting all your valuables in a tent zipped up in middle of central park. well hope yall have a great day.. off to the trenches for me .. again :(

by bschmidt

...and I'm bored and there are 8 minutes left in the day.

The definitive definition of definite words:

HACKER: someone with an incessant cough, probably a smoker. Not malicious with their hacking in the fact that they cannot help it, but usually very irritating in theaters, airplanes, etc.

CRACKER: thin, baked piece of dough. Mostly associated with soup/chili. Usually salty, but not always. Sometimes assume the shapes of animals.

by absolutely

Your example dialogue shows why the society responsible for the most lawyers per capita on Earth and the most death sentences of any industrialized nation does not deserve IT pros.

At all.

by bschmidt

HACKER:
Hello, I was examining your network architecture and found vulnerabilities in XXX and YYY areas of your network. This could potentially lead to someone breaking into your systems and, ultimately, the theft of very sensitive data. You should have someone address these vulnerabilities immediately.

FIRST BANK OF TECHREPUBLIC:
Oh, why thank you for the information. We'll get someone on this immediately.
*** In the background: Get the FBI on the phone, this guy just told us he broke into our system so we're sending his sorry butt to prison. By the way, send an email to IT Security about it. ***

There's a hacker situation. Probably still get reamed, but his intentions were good. Nobody got hurt (except him of course when he meets his cell mate in Block D). Now on the other hand...

CRACKER:
*** Busy spending all the money in your account on EBay, selling your social, address and phone numbers on the black market. Not available for comment. ***