Discussion Locked

Hard drive will not format

0 helpful
14 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I realise this hard drive is probable dead but would like to know how this happened. Samsung 30gig. First lost all partitions somehow. Owner says anti virus all up to date. Attached drive as secondary drive on another system. Detected in Bios but not seen in Windows explorer. In device manager, drive was there but not given a drive letter. Put drive as master and booted to Dos, did not read drive properly I think it was 1024mg, not 30gig. Fdisk just said non dos partition, Win98 was on this drive not XP so should have been Fat 32. Did not want to try and delete non dos partition as owner had important data on drive. Tried partition magic and ghost but non would recognise the hard drive parametres. So thought data is gone but might be able to save hard drive. Installed Drive rescue on a Master drive, this read the bad slave drive with no problems,unfortunately could not access any data with drive rescue but it restored the drive with Fat 32, so I then booted to dos again with drive as master, Fdisked and partitioned, took awhile for this to partition but okay. Then restarted and tried to format. Starts off at 0 and just sits there. Tried different boot up formatting discs but same thing. The owner will probably ask how this happened and as this is the first drive that I have not been able to access data, would like to know your opion. Can a boot virus realy do this much damage or is the drive just bad ?? thank you

14 replies

by dmiles

Reads as though the drive went bad,to determine a drive will go bad is any number of things,so I would be hard pressed to explain the mechanics of a bad hard drive.

At some point you mentioned the drive reporting non-dos partition,this coule have been true if the drive was split and a logical partition existed.

See the TechRepublic article 200 ways to revive a hard drive and it may give you some insight on what causes a drive to go bad and how you may have salvaged the dat by trying solutions offered in the article.

by shantie

I bought an Ide to Usb drive converter and it actually managed to read the drive. Showed the true size and although it had win98 was patitioned with NTFS, and partioned into to lots of 14.?? partions.The customer said she only had C and CDrom drives before so who every partioned the drive did not do it correctly, think that has been the whole problem. So there were logical drives but going through Dos it said they were there but would not show or let me delete them. Anyway the Usb converter let me format and repartition the drive. It is now back in the system and working okay. It is a pity I did not have the USb converter befor as might have been able to retrive the data but lady happy to have the drive back. So thanks for the comment.

by otl

A: Win 98

B: Samsung

Enough said normal life cycle for a HD is 5 years ! (that is ALL HD's), answer to owner ,"it lived longer than the manufacturer said it would be happy it lived this long !"

by otl

Will check with my IS dept, she revived all but one directory on my "DEAD" HD, will try to get the name of the PRG for you.

by shantie

Sorry finally managed to format and partition the hard drive with the aid of a USB to Ide convertor, could not retrieve data but hard drive is now okay, defrags and scans with no problem. I have told the lady that it might still not be reliable and to back up everything. Do not know about the five year limit I have 500mg, 1gig hard drives here and still work, just reinstalled win95 on a 480mg and works great. Anyway thanks for comment.

by bwells47

Try fdisk, reboot with boot disk in drive, then type fdisk /mbr at the prompt. Reboot again, then try format. Once you fdisk the mbr, maybe things will straighten out. I've had strange things happen before, and then all of a sudden it will start working. Never know with computers.

by shantie

Fdisk would not work and did try the MBR, but each time booted with boot disk the drive size was wrong, and no point in formatting if size is incorrect anyway fixed the problem with a Ide to Usb convertor which read the drive and was able to see two Ntfs partitions, the owner only had the one C drive so the other partition was not being seen think the person who originally partitoned it done something wrong or used some kind of partioning software. Drive okay now thanks for the comments.

by cglrcng9

Put the Hard Drive into a Ziplock bag, use a straw and suck out as much air from the bag as possible (to keep moisture to a bare minimum inside the bag), zip it up well (I also fold and tape the end over). Put the bag into the freezer for a few hrs., remove & quickly mount the drive. Attempt to start using the appropriate Emergency Boot Disk created on same OS or from www.bootdisk.com When and if the drive spins up, at the A:\> prompt type SYS C: and enter, wait for the files transferred notice, then DIR C: and enter are the directories required there? Then run CHKDSK & SCANDISK C:

Once done attempt to boot w/out the boot disk.

If it still doesn't, go to www.GRC.com, check out Spin Rite and his Boot Sector Virus repair tools.

Good Luck.

by shantie

Nothing the matter with the drive I think the person who originally partioned it did something wrong or used partioning software. Finally managed to read the drive with a Ide to usb convertor, then was able to format and repartition. Thanks for comments.

by moody

I had a similar problem with a 40GB Maxtor HDD given to me by a friend. Tried same utils as you (PQMagic, FDisk etc) with no success. Obtained manufacturer's Disk Management utility & applied a low-level format. Hey Presto! I now have a fully functional HDD.

by shantie

Yes I have heard funny stories about Maxtor and I have a boot disc for maxtor drives but this was a samsun. I think the whole problem was the way the person who originally partitioned the drive did something wrong or used some partioning software. Although the drive had W98 it was partioned into two lots of 14.?? and Ntfs. Anyway used a Ide to usb convertor and read the drive no problems, managed to format and repartition, drive back in system and working okay thanks for comments.

by rmsmith

Simply the best investment I've made is Spinrite, by Gibson Research www.grc.com
At my IT department, 15 drives were marked dead... Spinrite brought 'em all back to life. Some clusters were marked bad, etc., but 95+% of the data was not lost. Spinrite 6 "is able to operate on all Windows XP NTFS formats, all DOS FAT, all Linux file systems, Novell, Macintosh (if temporarily moved into a PC)" - from their website. If/when all else fails (actually, I'd use SR6 before the other methods...)

by shantie

Managed to read the drive with an ide usb drive convertor, although could not retrive data was able to format and repartition. I think the person who originally set the partitions did something wrong or used partitoning software. Will check into Spinrite for future reference so thanks for the advice

This discussion is closed to new replies.