Question Locked

Hard drive with bad block

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a 3 month old seagate hard drive which failed (BSD) almost immediately after installing a failing drive from my daughters computer into my computer for testing. I now have that seagate drive in another computer I bought just for testing hardware and software so I never screw up my main computer again while trying to fix another one.
I don't really want to send the drive back under warranty because it has all my data on it. I would prefer to re-format that bad block and be able to re-use it my replacement fails. Is that possible / advisable and what software would I need to do that?

Dave

6 replies

by thumbsup2

SCANDISK and tell it to repair bad sectors. However, once a drive starts to fail, there's no telling how long it will last. You're better off getting your data off the drive and sending it back for replacement under warranty.

To answer your question, no you can't format just one bad block. SCANDISK will attempt to recover data stored in that block and then mark it as bad so it's not used again. Even if you formatted the whole drive, it would simply mark the bad sector as being bad and remove it from the usable space on the drive. Once a sector is bad, it's bad forever.

by oh smeg

Into another system. You should fit it to a USB Adapter and then plug in the USB Connection to a computer to test.

Now if the Drive actually does have a Bad Block there is nothing you can do about it short of replacing the drive. But in this case it may be a False Positive reporting the Bad Block so a Low Level Format should be run as well as Sea Tools which is available here

http://www.seagate.com/www/en-us/support/downloads/seatools/

Though first you'll need to copy your Data & Settings off this Drive and save them to a safe place while you make any required changes tot he Drive.

Unfortunately there is no way to attack just 1 or even several Blocks on any Magnetic Storage Device.

Col

by dgolfnut

I installed the drive as a slave on the ide cable - not as the primary drive. Is that a bad thing to do?

by oh smeg

You should never add a Suspect item inside any computer no matter what it is.

But in the case if a HDD or for that matter any Drive they should always be used in a USB Enclosure or USB Adapter so if the worst happens the Computer itself is not damaged, If you do a lot of HDD Recovery you should buy yourself one of these a USB to HDD Adapter

http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/SearchTools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=2329300&CatId=3770

Though if you plan to use a HDD a lot you should get a USB Enclosure and preferably a Actively Cooled one.

That way if the HDD is shorting out it just damages a $20-30 item not a M'Board. ;)

Col

by balge

hi
just a point - you could do a DOD wipe on the drive before you send it back, something like Dariks -

http://www.dban.org/about

- if you're worried about data security (and who isn't) then you will get a new replacement. If the drive is failing you shouldn't put it back in a PC.
hth
cheers!

This discussion is closed to new replies.