Discussion Locked

How much does the Net's "free and open society" threaten security?

0 helpful
30 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

What do you think about former CIA Director George Tenet's remarks about better securing the Internet, even if it comes at the cost of limiting its "free and open" nature? How do you think society can best govern the Internet? Share your comments about the conflict between Internet security and a "free and open" forum, as discussed in the Dec. 20 Internet Security Focus newsletter.

If you haven't subscribed to our free Internet Security Focus newsletter, sign up today! Click this link to subscribe automatically:
http://nl.com.com/MiniFormHandler?brand=techrepublic&list_id=e044

30 replies

by bfilmfan

After reading his comments, I immediately thought of comments others have made on this subject:

"If we don't believe in freedom of expression for people we despise, we don't believe in it at all."

Noam Chosky

"They that give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty or safety."

Benjamin Franklin

"Security gives way to conspiracy."
William Shakespeare's character Artemidorus, in Julius Caesar, act 2, sc. 3, l. 7-8.

by kodiakbear

"They that give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty or safety."

In the age of "do whatever necessary to keep the bad people away, the "umbrella" of national security has saw fit to exploit the human reaction to fear and profit from a very unfortunate tragedy (09-11-2001). As long as we have a governing body that believes they can be everywhere and control everything, we will see most of the personal liberties that this great country was founded on disappear one by one untill nothing is left. This is all done to make us "feel" better. but the reality remains that 70+% of the cargo containers coming into this country are unchecked, and it is still possible to ship very dangerous items through standard shipping practices. As long and the profitmongers can still make someone uncomfortable with talks of terrorism, they will consume every liberty they see untill american life fits there own twisted image.

Make no mistake. I love this country and everything it stands for, but the people that have managed to manipulate the american psyche into the mindset that they are making us safer are the real danger. while they focus on there own agenda's, they completely miss the real dangers.

by awfernald

I'm just wondering at what level they are talking about security here?

If it is at the physical infrastructure level, that is one thing, however, if you get above the physical level, I'm just wondering what "improvements" are being recommended or even can be made (other than filters).

If they are talking about web-sites, then what impact will the US implementing security have on sites located in Brazil?

by support#netropole.com

i think they are talking about monitoring all internet activity. what sites people visit, your email to your grandmother, every bit and byte.

another thought is total control over what people are allowed to see. blocking information they see as unsafe or unfit for americans to see.

both of these can be done. just takes time, money and the will to screw the people. which we all know politicians think of us as children, that cant think for ourselves.

by hal 9000

The Politicians only think of the general public as children until it comes to election time and then all of a sudden we grow up. With the recent election just being over I guess we can look forward to at least a couple of years of being left to play in the sand pit again.

Col

by mgordon

Here's a scenario. Congress enacts a law that any common carrier transport only IPv8 packets (I've invented it, maybe there is such thing). EVERY packet is digitally signed by a national CA and at every peering point those digital signatures are checked and logged. It will be illegal to operate a server that touches any common carrier without obtaining a server certificate from the national CA. We'll have C2 security in one year; there will be no privacy of course and performance will take a serious hit.

Essentially, it will be similar to SSL right now, but EVERY packet will be signed (whether or not encrypted). Clients already have the option of using X.509 client certificates to identify themselves to the server, Congress need only mandate it as a requirement.

Applications that use other protocols will not work of course until and unless they implement packet signatures.

The internet will probably die; reverting back to the days of ARPANET.

Any of you that are 40's or 50's remember the huge CB radio popularity of the mid 70's -- where is it now? Radios are cheap but the "critical mass" of people that used to be on it, is no longer on it; so there's no point in buying a CB radio. The whole thing is "bi-stable" -- for a time, CB was everywhere, then suddenly nowhere, and it will STAY nowhere probably forever. The moment you no longer can rely on the internet for your information, communication, shopping, entertainment -- it will go away, the huge investment in infrastructure will dry up, the infrastructure will disappear and will never again be regenerated -- why? Because the internet is the residue of the "dot com" boom and bust and THAT won't be repeated.

by hal 9000

It is the very nature of the beast that the Internet is uncontrolled and uncontrollable.

Other than the physical security of actual physical sites the content is uncontrollable. Here in AU there was a law passed that Internet Gambling was not allowed within AU so all the existing sites just relocated offshore and continue unaffected.

While there are possible problems with the INTERNET as it currently stands like the ability to access Kiddy Porn or Bomb Making Items these will never be removed as it is impossible to police this type of thing the best that can be hoped for is to limit the amount available and even then it would be a manpower intensive job that would increase exponentially as time goes by. As for the ability to make bombs the average high school Physics student should be able to tell you the basics of a controlled implosion device {the modern H Bomb} so what good would limiting this be?

While the basics are the easy part it is very hard to obtain the actual materials and even harder to make the thing work. Just ask India and Pakistan as they store their fission devices unassembled because they are so dangerous and have a high degree of a misfire occurring.

If a State is unable to make reliable fission weapons the individual would be hard pressed to replicate the same thing. The best that could be hoped for is to obtain some Radio Active material and use it with conventional explosives {a Dirty Bomb} and you do not need the Internet for this.

Even if it was possible to actually make a working fission weapon there is still the problem of a delivery system it's not like you ring up FedEx and ask them to deliver this large heavy box half way around the world it is a lot harder than that.

Col

by support#netropole.com

its not that hard.

they can put the responsibility on the ISP. if improper information is found on the ISP's servers then they can be shut down or fined. they can also take control of IP addresses by blocking any block they see unfit. oversees internet goes through a pipeline or sat uplink. both of which can be controlled by the government if they wish.

people think the governments cant do this and that. but in reality they have more control then the people know. they take away our feedoms everyday. do we notice,,, no. how many laws out there tell you what you can do compared to what you cant do.

sorry, im just a little pissed the old farts in office take it on them selves to tell us what is right or wrong.

by awfernald

China has constantly tried to censor the internet, however, it seems that the Chinese people have always figured some way to get around the censorship.

The government cannot monitor/censor all satellites/land-lines/radio links that come in to the US, and if they tried, I imagine that we the people would pretty much rise up and kick them in the butt.

As far as monitoring the main routers which lead to the overseas connections, I realize that the government already does monitor them for any type of terrorist information going back and forth, and they also have the capability of bringing this down to the individual ISP area.... however, so far, I'm not too concerned about it.

by hal 9000

Insisted that every ISP report certain types of activity directly to them. It all involved "Kiddy Porn" which on the surface was quite all right.

What the position was that any person who logged onto specific sites had to be reported and then the Federal Police came out heavy handed and paid you a visit to see just what you where up to.

Well in typical Government fashion they neglected to place any safe guards in place for the ISP's they only made it mandatory to report certain activity. The Feds on the other hand where as subtle as an atomic bomb going off 3 inches from your left ear they stormed in stole all of your equipment to see exactly what you had been up to and then if warranted brought a prosecution against those involved in illegal activities.

Well a friend of mine was doing Post Graduate work on Government and was looking for information on different Governments around the world he tried "Whitehouse.com" which at the time was a hard core Kiddy porn site.

When he saw the material that appeared he logged off thought that he had made a mistake on entering the address and tried again with the same results. Two weeks latter he got a visit from the Feds who kicked his door in stole all of his equipment and took him away to help with their inquiries. He was eventually released after 2 weeks of integration but his equipment was not returned as it was required to confirm his story.

Naturally all of his backup material was also required just to make sure that he wasn't covering up anything and he was not allowed to take copies this effectively brought all of his studies to a screaming halt as well as branding him a "Pervert" so he was an outcast at the Uni and anyone who remotely came to his defense was automatically placed under investigation for the same thing.

Now you have to remember that every piece of telephony is monitored in different countries that ranges from simple phone calls to fax transmissions to all data transmissions and if certain strings appear in the data stream it gets flag recorded and eventually handed to a human to have a look at just like the data covering the 9-11 incident eventually got processed.

Everything is done by computers who sole job is to monitor all communications and then the Governments skimping on resources do not have enough people available to actually look at what is collected. It appears that the Bureaucrats & Governments seem to think that the hardware alone will be enough and then skimp on the human element. I believe that was brought forward in investigations subsequent to the 9-11 incident.

Over here this particular guy drooped out of Uni eventually had all of his equipment returned because he had done nothing wrong and was told to sue the ISP for Deformation. Just like a typical incompetent Government decision they want to be allowed access to the data but not have the responsibility when things do go wrong so the ISP in this case while having a Statutory Obligation to report any activity has no protection for doing this and is legally libel for any damage done. But at exactly the same time the Government has in place monitoring equipment that can do all that they require without the need to involve third parties.

When I see Legislation like the above I see it as nothing more than penny pinching by Governments who are unwilling to provide sufficient resources for the investigation side of their business and then legislate for third parties to do what is quite easily done by Government Departments.

The really sad thing on these occasions is the fact that the data is captured by never actually looked at unless it comes under a "High Priority" incident like 9-11 did and even then it was only discovered about 6 months after the event. If sufficient resources where devoted to the Intelligence Gathering Agencies we would not even be having this discussion as the whole thing would and should be a moot point.

Col

by webwatcher

Other countries have tried and succeded, to a degree, to block particular internet traffic.
France blocked "eBay" and "Yahoo!" in relation to distribution of Nazi propoganda and memoribilia.
China's Great Firewall has been in place for quite a while.

This is all fine. Each government is responsilbe for its actions for (or against) its own citizenry.

It is a much different case when one country decides it wants to "secure" the internet for the entire world.
I would hope this is not the scenario that the distinguished Mr. Tenet is proposing when refering to when "he advocated enacting stronger security controls of the Internet to shore up its vulnerabilities to potential terrorist attacks."

This will be interesting to watch as it plays out.

by apotheon

"This is all fine. Each government is responsilbe for its actions for (or against) its own citizenry."

I have to disagree here. This is most certainly [b]not[/b] "all fine". That kind of nannying and oppressive control of the flow of information is wrong. It's an abridgement of the basic human right of self determination, in this case in the form of a right to free speech. One does not make a good person out of someone by preventing him from learning things, even if those lessons you want to "protect" him from consist of information you think is "dangerous".

Human beings are capable of thinking for themselves, and that activity should be encouraged. Not only should Tenet not be allowed to make decisions for the whole world regarding how controlled and secure the Internet is, but various national governments shouldn't be allowed to make those same decisions even for their own citizens. If someone really wants to have an unsecured server connected to the Internet, that's his or her business. Likewise, if someone wants to be able to have private communications across the Internet without being monitored by the CIA, he or she should be able to.

If I want to have a penpal in China, that Chinese citizen shouldn't be prevented based on the fact that I'm a politically vocal US citizen that thinks the Tiananmen Square massacre was an abomination, and that the US shouldn't be encouraging trade with China while discouraging it with other, freer, countries.

by hal 9000

That any Government is supposed to protect its own citizens. That is why we either elect them or tolerate them. Those that do not act in the best interests of the general population tend to get overthrown.

Some in Bloody Coups and others like in Iran by "People Power" where at best the previous leader was not acting in the best interests of the majority of citizens.

Now I see a basic problem here in Iraq there is a military operation in place to bring Democracy to the "People" and in China there is what the West likes to refer to as "Free Trade" that is supposed to achieve the same result in that country.

Neither seem to be working at the moment and all that seems to be happening is that Administrations who should not be there are being propped up by Western Governments.

Then there is also the issue of just how much of a Governments decisions are made by the Elected Officials and how many are made by the unelected Bureaucrats who are the people who actually run the Government as they can and do chose what information to show the elected officials to get the decisions that they want to be enacted by the Elected Officials.

For some unknown reason the people of any country tend to want that country to keep running even though there maybe an election in progress which takes up most if not all the time of the politicians who are supposed to be running that country. Or when there is a change of Government the people expect Government activities to continue unaffected while a transition is taking place. When you look at it that way you can only come to the conclusion that the Politicians are really surperflious to the whole system and are really nothing more than the fall guys for the non elected Bureaucrats who are the real power behind the scenes.

Col

by steven.randolph

Mr. Tenet is a veteran of an administration that has been hostile to free speech since its beginning. It is not surprising, therefore, that Mr. Tenet would see a truly "free and open society" as being a threat to the interests of his powerful centralized government. I believe that the free and open communication provided by the Internet constitutes a last great bastion against the rising tide of oppressive government. God save the Internet!

by apotheon

How can someone that claims to be a defender of the American way of life (as I'm sure Tenet is) possibly look at the words "free and open" and think "Oh, this has to be stopped!"? What kind of broken, backwards, absurdly hypocritical belief system supports that?

by scottsman

The need for security in today's environment is readily apparent. The need for freedom is also readily apparent. The trick is to support both. I feel that we can do this on the Internet. Critical government infrastructure systems should be on dedicated lines that have NO physical or logical connectivity to the Internet. That would solve the National security issue from an Internet perspective. (I understand the cost issue, but if you want to be secure you have to pay for it) I believe that the net must stay free and open. There would be too much political and economic damage from any true restriction of the Internet. I consider myself a white hat and would definitely become at least grey if they try to take my freedom away. Not to mention that the Internet is a great "release valve" for society. You can rant and flame all you want.. it makes you feel better and no one gets hurt. That is win-win to me. Let the net stay as its creators intended; a forum for education and the free exchange of ideas.

by mlanphea

They that give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty or safety. (Benjamin Franklin)

by techierob

This is all to a familiar site depicted by many great films and books in our time. A notion, questionable or not is deemed by a society as "undesirable" and is hense outlawed and enforced by a hipocritical and totalitarian-type government. The result in these situations is almost identical - humans will begin to despise, then revolt and overthrow the forces that be; and will celebrate in their former 'freedom'. Human beings are rebellious by nature - as soon as the lock was invented, lockpicking was developed. I believe that though the idea behind "securing" the internet is a great step forward; it is destined to failure due to these 3 main factors:
1) Who decides what is and what isn't "denied" (who is watching?)
2) Who controls what these people do? (who is watching the watchers?)
3) The pure curious and rebellious nature lurking in each and every one of us. Even if the system is successful, someone will find a way around it.

The internet is a mixed bag of different perspectives and objectives; and to apply a "standard" to such an environment is just ludicrous.

by tecdoc

Splendid analysis and a honourable stance by the
author. Alas, there is nothing to be done about it as long
as the present Washington administration (and others
like it) will persevere in the attitude where the rest of the
planet is a colony where the sacred cow of ?national
security? (anyhow anyone in power decides to define it)
can roam as seen fit on expense of any other nation?s
interests, customs and laws - international or national
(including some of the US laws, just hush about that
one) - being the US the supreme arbiter of all things in
the Universe. Sadly, such a position has currently
gained America the lowest World rating it had since
prior the abolition of slavery and has thus disappointed,
pasivised and alienated all those (they are not few) that
would have liked nothing better than help the US in
making life on Earth better - and resolve some of its
own problems in the process (do not be misled by the
bootlickers that think they might gain something
personally). As the things turned recently, there are
another four years of this blues to come.

by techmail

I too believe in security, I have often lobbied long and hard for more, and was the lone man crying in the wilderness. On the one side the author argues that a country has the right to control the internet within its borders, yet also says that George Tenet is incorrect in saying thatthe US must have greater security. Why can other countries have greater security but it is assumed that the US would dictate to all the World. Could it be that he misread Mr. Tenet's statements. I read them to include or contemplate actions that could be carried out by a single governemtn within it's cyber borders.

On the other side of the coin I find that 911 and the events which followed, particularly the Patriot Act, are a watershed event in US history. A watershed event being one which has changed the direction of history. Thus said, I see an erosion of freedom in the name of security, and of security in the face of political expedience. For those readers who have not yet done so - read 1984 by A. Huxley and then return to this discussion and answer the question - where will increased security or the lack of increased security take US?

by hal 9000

The knee jerk reaction by all Governments post 9-11 was nothing more than an attempt to increase their existing powers which they where not using to the full ability of their then current capacity.

What I find totally distasteful about subsequent Legislation passed since that date is it is nothing more than a blatant attempt to curb personal freedoms without actually affecting Domestic Security.

I actually thought George Orwell wrote 1984 but maybe we are at cross roads here on different books however if not watch out for the "Thought Police" they are in a street near you right now!

Col

by apotheon

Orwell wrote [u]1984[/u], and Huxley wrote [u]Brave New World[/u]. Then, of course, Bush Sr. declared a New World Order.

by jaqui

religous fundamentalists, there are the thought police...
they want to police your thoughts by programming you into their way of thinking from birth.

they don't think about the fact that this will kill inovation..oh, yeah they don't want inovation, they want everything the way it was 200 years ago, when the romans crucified several people at Cavalry, and one was diefied by a few people.

This discussion is closed to new replies.