Question Locked

I have a doubt... concerning RAM compatibility and actual use...

0 helpful
25 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I am using a Compaq Mini CQ10-120LA Netbook, Intel ATOM N270 1.60GHz, 160GB SATA-II HDD, 1GB DDR2-800 PC6400 RAM and Windows 7 Ultimate OS. My Q has to do with the type of RAM that I have and why its not operating at advertised clock speed? I have EVEREST Ultimate v5.30 and it displays that my RAM is DDR2-800 in single channel mode so its actually DDR2-400...BUT the benchmark and Chipset results say that its DDR2-533 and the actual clock speed is 266MHz...what is the reason for this?? My supported Memory types are DDR2-400 and DDR2-533 up to 2GB. CPU-Z gives me the same info...why is my RAM not operating as its supposed to as far as clock speed?? Its the factory RAM module and it should be running at 400MHz since its Single channel but its running at 266MHz as if it were DDR2-533... I would appreciate some clarification on this please...

25 replies

by santeewelding

Windows 7 Ultimate on a netbook with an Atom might just have something to do with it, neverminding RAM.

by tobif

I quote:
My supported Memory types are DDR2-400 and DDR2-533 up to 2GB.

Since your memory modules are capable of responding even faster, the system uses it at the maximum speed the system can handle, namely 267 Mhz (corresponding to DDR2-533).

It's quite possible that the ratio between processor speed and memory speed would be different if you had a different type of processor, but I'm not sure. (It's simply not my area of expertise)

by who am i really

required for dual channel mode functionality,

one stick, can't, won't & doesn't do dual channel mode

if you're seeing single channel mode then you don't have the 2 sockets filled, or the modules are mismatched and can't operate in dual channel mode

by cyberghost_1

Ok that explains the Single Channel Mode, the thing is that I only have 1 SO-DIMM Slot with 1 1GB DDR2-800 stick... So if I upgrade to 2GB RAM, what is recommended?? 2GB DDR2-800 or 2GB DDR1-533?? My netbook supports DDR2-400 and DDR2-533 2GB maximum... I am pretty sure that DDR2 RAM is faster than DDR1 eventhough the clock speeds might be the same...

by oh smeg

To the FSB of the CPU. What you need to understand is that the CPU works best in Dual Channel Mode and when set that way with 2 Identical RAM Modules each RAM Module runs at exactly Half of the Rated FSB Speed. So you have 2 Channels of RAM feeding a 533 MHZ which is what the CPU wants not what the RAM is capable of feeding it at.

There are other Limiting Factors involved here little things like the Chip Set of the M'Board are important but as the Atom CPU can only work at 533 it is being feed at 266 MHZ which is the fastest that 1 Module in Single Channel Mode can work at and still keep a stable CPU.

Doesn't matter what the RAM is capable of running at just what the CPU and Chip Set Supports. So if you where using 2 Identical RAM Modules in Dual Channel Mode it would show 533 MHZ but even still each RAM Module would be running at 266 MHZ which when doubled as there are two of them gives you 533 MHZ. ;)

Col

by cyberghost_1

The Chipset supports 2GB DDR2-400/DDR2-533....so if I upgrade to 2GB DDR2-800, like u mentioned, the clock speed will still run at 533(266) since its in single channel mode due to only having 1 SO-DIMM slot...

by oh smeg

To use Dual Channel Mode you need 2 RAM Modules.

If you can not install 2 RAM Modules the unit is restricted to Single Channel Mode unless the makers have done something very tricky with the M'Board Chip Set. While it's possible to use 1 RAM Module in Dual Channel Mode it involves using Double Sided RAM Modules and treating each side of the Module Separately. So if you have 1 Single Sided Module it acts like Single Channel RAM and if you have a Double Sided RAM Module it acts like Dual Channel RAM.

As this is a Expensive Trick for a NetBook it's very unlikely to be involved so the RAM will stay in Single Channel Mode and run at 50% of the FSB of the CPU.

Col

by oh smeg

If the M'Board requires SO DDR11 RAM you can not install SO DDR1 RAM. The layout of the RAM Module is different and DDR1 Modules will not fit into a DDR11 or DDR111 Socket. The same applies in reverse so the different RAM Modules are not interchangeable.

If it's designated to use DDR11 RAM that is what you need to buy.

You can also check out the Corsair Memory Locater here for your System

http://www.corsair.com/

Col

by tobif

It was mentioned before in this thread, but just to make it more clear.

If a computer has a max speed for addressing the memory, then you'll get max performance if your memory meets the same speed. With faster memory, you won't get any further speed boast. The only thing that will happen is that the memory will have stabilized its output for some while when the computer gets around to reading it.
Reasons to buy quicker memory could be availability, price or plans to reuse same memory in future systems with higher speed.
(But always carefully check recommendations, some older systems and memory types could misbehave with too fast ram installed!)

by who am i really

HP/Compaq usually have one slot in the bottom, and the other is under the keyboard

if your system shows it has RAM but there's nothing in the slot in the back then you have one under the keyboard

by cyberghost_1

I have EVEREST Ultimate v.5.30 as well as CPU-Z and both indicate that my Compaq Netbook only has 1 slot. Is it possible that its not showing me that I have 2 slots cuz I?m only using 1 at the moment, the one on the bottom... I guess I should look under the keyboard huh??

by who am i really

skip looking under the keyboard:

your system:
Compaq Mini CQ10-120LA Netbook

according to Kingston's RAM search
the system has only one RAM slot
uses 800MHz RAM

a netbook isn't supposed to be a performance house
intended use of a Netbook, is web surfing, checking email, etc.
and maybe playing a bit of music

so it's no surprise that it's not configured as a dual channel system

http://www.ec.kingston.com/ecom/configurator_new/modelsinfo.asp?id=2&SysID=62687&mfr=HP%2FCompaq&model=Mini+CQ10&search_type=&root=us&LinkBack=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.kingston.com&Sys=62687-HP%2FCompaq-Mini+CQ10-120LA&distributor=0&submit1=Search

by cyberghost_1

I know about double-sided RAM modules for PC?s but not for Netbooks... how expensive is a double-sided RAM module about?? Since my Chipset supports up to 2 GB DDR2 @ 400 and 533 and my FSB is 533MHz, can my system support or even handle a double-sided RAM module and function in dual channel alright??

by cyberghost_1

Would it be possible to install a double-sided 2GB DDR2-800 RAM module for increased performance... could my system handle a double-sided module?? How expensive are double-sided modules??

by who am i really

only means that there are RAM chips on both sides of the module

it doesn't mean there is a separation,

however, if you bump your system from 1GB to 2GB you will get a performance increase regardless

for the record, I've never seen a single sided DIMM or SODIMM that's larger than 64MB

everything 128MB and up has chips on both sides

even the old 30 & 72 pin SIMMs had chips on both sides
only 1MB and smaller 30 Pin and 4MB & smaller 72Pin SIMMs had a single sided layout

I believe the reason they limit the Netbook systems to 2GB RAM in this fashion is because most ship with win7 Starter which has a programmed limitation of 2GB RAM anyway,
and dual channel mode wouldn't help with surfing, checking your email, using media player etc.

by oh smeg

I have just removed several 1 GIG Sodium Modules from a NB that where Single Sided and replaced them with 2 GIG Modules to max out the NB.

There are quite a few 1 GIG Modules out there that are Single Sided but that depends on the maker mostly. I have also several 1 GIG Corsair DDR2 Modules which are single sided so it depends on the capacity and maker as to which way that they come. ;)

Col

by who am i really

they're single sided because they're made of salt

did spell check get you?

SODIMM shows as a spelling error here but I don't let it "correct" the "correct" spelling I typed

by santeewelding

More better.

Besides, Emeritus Smeg gets to spell it any way he wants.

by seanferd

Sodium or Calcium Nodules in Water is more better fun, though.

by santeewelding

I inherited a vial of sodium pellets, once, from a student of my class. They were submerged in kerosene. For years, I would pluck one or two out with tweezers and drop them into a quantity of water. The pellet would propel itself maddeningly all about, generating hydrogen gas as it went.

Finally, despite the kerosene, and after years, the pellets grew a fuzz about them.

Dumpster.

by ansugisalas

and not crucible? :D

You know you can electrolytically make sodium of salt too, right? But since it reacts with water it can't be solute... you have to melt it instead.

by oh smeg

Sodium Filled Valve for me. One of those old Aircraft type that had this soft metal inside them to aid cooling.

I would be very interested to see that thing welded. Provided of course I wasn't in range of it when it goes off. :D

Col

by ansugisalas

I was thinking more about what would happen if one was to take fluorine gas, pressurize it until it turns liquid and then float a ball of an alkali on it... like, say, Lithium...

This discussion is closed to new replies.