Discussion Locked

Intranet or Not...help!

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I need to use a program written for my buisiness that in turn uses SQL7 and Access data bases. I need to be able to install teh program in branches (accross the us about 5 branches) and it only runs when connected to the data base located in the hamoe office. Every branch has access to a DSL line and ISP, that is all set up. I have been attempting VPN using Programmed Routers but with all of the different ISP's and other forces it has become a failed effort. I am looking at creating an Intranetfor this purpose so that i do not have to deal with all of the other crap. I have the hardware but what I need to know is how to set up. I use a combination of WINS, DHCP, IIS. Do I need a dedicated server in each branch or can each node sign onto the network through the Internet? If I do need a dedicated server how do I replicate the WINS server? Does DHCP get replicated? I am open to anything at this point, I have to be connected with in a month! any help is greatly appreciated in every way...Steve (InfosysGuy)

5 replies

by espen

The best solution is to create a full mesh
network, with leased lines between them,
setting up an IP subnet in each branch,
routing between them. ideally, you would
have one server in each branch, serving
DHCP, and DNS. You don't actually have
to use Wins. If you are going to use one
central DHCP server, you need to bridge
the different branches, rather than route
them.

Then you can set up one leased line to
the internet, and use that one for all
branches to connect to the internet.

I would suggest upscaling the access
databases to SQL, as that makes your life
a lot easier. (Access over IP will behave
funny, I think..)

by mpdcsup

If you're going to go to the expense of leased lines and a private WAN (which isn't cost-effective for something driven off MS Access). Not only would you not want to bridge (a flat model just does not bode well on a mixed-speed network), you woulddefinitely want WINS running (or your local offices would see only equipment in the local office). As for DHCP, you can use a single DHCP server on multiple subnets if you know what you're doing.

As for the task at hand, though, I reiterate:

You are mixing apples and oranges here. Virtual Private Networking is a security method and an intranet is an information sharing methodology that assumes security exists in the first place. Tying your offices together over public lines without VPN would open your internal networks to other parties.

You might be able to get by with an Extranet, but without knowing more details about the application and its implementation, I wouldn't even be able to begin making any recommendations.

This discussion is closed to new replies.