Discussion Locked

Is it worth it to get a bachelors in IT?

0 helpful
25 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I recently got an AA in network administration, and was thinking about getting my bachelors in IT and maybe a masters, but I'm getting discouraged and I'm not so sure if I should go that route. I've been trying to get job for a while now, but it's very hard to land an interview now a days. I was thinking maybe I should go for Computer Science/Engineering. Any advice would be appreciated.
Thank you.

25 replies

by hal 9000

Been there done that and the PHD isn't worth the paper it's printed on but what's worse is once some potential employer see that they imediatly think {That's more I've got to pay him/her} and it is a draw back in most instances unless you are looking at Government Work.

Anything else it is a draw back as most employers prefer to train you themselves to what they want not what they think you will deliver. The hard part is getting your foot in the door{which I'm sure you've already noticed} But with perserverience you'll eventually get there and it won't hurt in the mean time to do some "Volinter" work for some school or the like where they require to keep old equiptment running so some form of charity or something like that is a good place to start. You'll find it easier getting a job once you already have one even if you're not getting paid.

I hope this is of some assistance to you.

by m.i.t

I definitely would like to continue going to school, but if that is not going to help me, than what would you consider it would a good career path?

by hal 9000

Any undergrad bit of paper willmake you employable {well sought of depending on whoever is employing at the time.}

All Post Grad bits of paper are great but they do mean that you do comand more money even if you know nothing and this can work against your best interests.

If you want some income right now there was something on TR's front page about CV's and how to improve them it might be worth a look as it just might point you in the right direction. But no mater what you decide to undertake you must first have the knolledge that any education "ONLY GIVES YOU THE RIGHT TO GO OUT AND START TO LEARN YOUR TRADE" no matter what it is and with this firmly in mind you can't go wrong. But and here is the BIG but most Post Grads have the belief that as they have the piece of paper the "KNOW IT ALL" which is clearly stupid but worse still is the fact that they believe that they should be earning "Top Dollar" as well and so do most potential employers.

So first take a leaf out of TR's book and improve your CV and then after you've thought about what you want to do set about doing it but as from my memory you wanted a job now and not some time latter down the path in a few years time you will have to help yourself here.

Don't worry to much about what Maxwell has to say as he constantly derides me for having 3 PHD's all of which have proved useless in my eyes but are a very healthy thing to have when after any Government work as these places are the only places where paper is rewarded rather than actual knolledge. There is no subistute for hands on experience ths is something that just can't be learned from a book but that by no means means that I don't approve of book learning but you just have to keep things in presepctive.

by maxwell edison

...at least not at this point in time.

You must admit that your assertion that I am "constantly deriding" you for that is a bit of an exaggeration. I haven't mentioned that in quite some time, and have since backed off quite a bit. That was back in the days when you and I were engaged in those constant "sparring sessions", challenging almost everything the other said. (But on the good side, I did learn a lot about Pin Gap, didn't I? Before that, I didn't even know it existed.)

If it's any consolation, I'll take back anything derogatory I said in that regard, and apologize if I offended you.

(I don't even have one PhD, but I wish I did. Is it too late for a guy pushing 50?)

by jimhm

From my 30 years in this business - the almighty sheep skin is the power to remove those career walls - the Master's is even more powerful.

If you want to get above certain levels - and into any management - and even bigger dollars. You need that paper..

Take the gold road - or get ready to hit a wall in your career ...

by oz_media

It seems that if you are based in the USA you will definitely get further ahead with the paper under your belt.

From working with a few Us based companies, i'ev seen the management levels and expertise they expect and paper is where it seems to be at.

Unfortunately, this doesn't guarantee a company that you have are competent but does assure them you have a certain skill set.

It seems the majority of people in this forum have had problems moving ahead in their goals due to a lack of eexperience or the fact that common certs are just that, too common to distinguish people from one another.

IT is going nowhere, even with call center outsourcing and support jobs moving overseas, godd IT staff is ALWAYS required in house by larger companies. Thise larger companies will also have a massive roster to choose from due to the lack of IT jobs in America (so I told). To stay ahead of these people, you must have more than mere certs. Puch for your bachelors and then go on to your masters degree and you should NEVER have problems moving forward with your career or beating others to the job.

Good luck

by maxwell edison

Some people may say that having a (4 year) degree doesn't matter. And while I generally agree with that sentiment when it comes to advancing one's own career as a self-motivated and self-employed professional, not everyone sees it that way, especially when it comes to an employee-employer relationship.

Will some hiring managers overlook you because you don't have a degree? Yes, some will pass you over for that reason alone.

Will some hiring managers overlook you because you do have a degree? Nope, not usually.

Whether or not that degree "makes you smarter", per se, is a matter of opinion. But will it make you more "employable"? Absolutely.

Go for it. In fact, go for the masters.

by hal 9000

And you where the person who only called them "Bits of Papaer" I'm glad that all thta education didn't go to waste after all.

Col

by maxwell edison

It may not necessarily advance one's career, but it certainly helps in making a person a little more well-rounded and expands one's thought process.

by m.i.t

Then again I feel like maybe Net. Admins will no longer be needed, just for the simple fact that everything is becoming automated and the need for a person to administrate may be no longer there.

by rabbit_runner

I will whole-heartedly agree with Max and Jim. If you do NOT have the Bachelor's degree, it could negatively influence some HR's to pass you over. I have seen this and known of friends who were skipped because of no degree. Here is my take... To be successful as an Systems Admin / Developer-Programmer / DBA / Network Admin, then you would want to get your Bachelors degree. When you start to look at Mid-Management, then go for your Masters. If you have your cap set on executive positions in IT, then consider the PHD. These recommendations are just that, recommendations. Each situation, each person, and each company will differ. But by-and-large education helps a bunch. So Go For It. I have never seen where education will hold someone back. Education will help to advance.

Best of Luck

by hal 9000

He has his "Masters" in Civil Engineering and works as a garbage collector because it pays better than the job that he couldn't get in Civil Engineering and he was top of his class not some one in the middle to bottom of the class.

Having that bit of paper can be a real hindrance but as you've quite rightly said it all depends on each person and each company they are all different.

by jimhm

Col

I can do the same - I know chemical engineers that are doing systems design in computers. I know PHD's that are teaching in grade school. I know Master's degrees that are Cobol programmers.

But - and it's a big Butt... I don't - I will Repeat - I don't know any CEO's - CFO's - CTO's - CIOs - Directors - that have only their A+, MSP or a certification. Na-da - Zippo - Zero - None - Big Freaking Goose Egg..

At one time in the world a person could climb the corporate ladder to success without a sheep skin. One of the best CEO's I ever worked for didn't have a degree but that was back in 1976 (he retired in 1978).. Black shoe officers where the best - before the college boys... But you don't see that anymore ...

I will intro you to guys and gals - I know that couldn't find a good paying job with their A+ or MSP certs ... and are now in college working on the BS. They listen to the MS hype about how they should earn $35 to $65K a year - and found out that the salaries were more in the $20 to $25K a year... They wasted years and big dollars getting that cert..

It is a better career move to get the BS / BA than not ... your salary cap moves up each degree in most companies..

by dnvrtechgrrl

Even though I've been in the industry for a little over 7 years, I'm just now finishing my AA. I only started the two year degree on the advice that with my 7 plus years in networking, a general programming degree would offer a well rounded person to future employers. This coming from my current employer mind you. =)

I've noticed a trend in the last three IT departments I've worked in. They are not as concerned with the degree as they are with the practical experience. There isn't a school or a certificate in the world that can prepare you to walk into an "in-house" operation. Sure, you'll have the basics behind you, though it won't matter when most of what you are working with is created around a specific company or need.

My advice is to look hard at the jobs you are applying for. If the systems and software they use require "general" knowledge, take your education as far as you want to.

If you are looking at more specialized areas of IT, don't worry about the paper behind you. What most employers are looking for now a days is the ability to learn, learn quickly, and apply that knowlege in a manner that will provide positive/forward moving feedback.

by tomsal

I am of the opinion that there simply shouldn't be any doubt in anyone's mind that the more formal education and training the better. What's more is the field really matter (unless you are talking low end skill jobs like trash collector or pizza delivery boy).

I think its utterly ridiculous to assume that having more formal training from accredited universities, colleges, training centers, etc. in your desired field of occupation can possibly hurt you.

Anyone who settles for just the "minimum" to land the job will never truly be successful in their career unless they blackmail the CEO, are related to an executive, etc. (or are born rich). ;)

And even that doesn't really mean you are successful it just means you got handed a high paying high prestige position -- you could right well screw it up.

Get all the training you can. Eat up knowledge as fast and furiously as you can, never stop learning as new technologies emerge. The world economy doesn't get easier to compete in each year, it gets harder - makeself as attractive to an employer as humanly possible.

But for god's sake get HANDS ON experience, don't just read the labs in your books -- DO THEM. Buy cheap stuff and make a home network, etc.

by hal 9000

There is a limit of diminishing returns as after you reach a certain level of Academic Qualifications you can very quickly become unemployable but again that depends on just where you want to work and how big a company is or isn't and if you are after a Government Job. If you want to work for the big end of town then the more the merrier and if you want a Government Job they just love those pieces of paper but then again I'm reminded of what actually happened to all the "Rocket Engineers" when NASA cut back on their Space Program in the 70's they just couldn't get work for love nor money. It has also probably contributed to the mess NASA is in now as they lost so many of their experienced staff and eventually replaced them with people with little to no practical experience.

by oz_media

Reading back on my post, I must apologize for my spelling mistakes. I can't type worth a crap so I fumble along, I'm sure you'll still see my point though.

sorry bout dat.

by jellimonsta

I personally hate school!.... I have 4 years of Tech school from the UK. I now reside in the US and I have my MCSE and CCNA and almost 4 years of Net Admin experience. I am also enrolled in multiple 'on-line' training programs right now with the possibility of other certs in mind.
This all taken in mind, I am still looking at going back to school to get my BA or possibly eventually masters. I may simply look at General Business Admin or Management though. If I am employed in the field and gaining experience and certifications, I do not feel that the Bachelors or Masters field is too pertinent.

by jimhm

I agree - I was the same way. I spent 4 years in the USN - blew 3 years stationed in DC with freebees to Unv. Of Maryland. I know better, that degree is bs.

Well - went I got into the real world - The sun shown on my mistake - and started night school - 8 years latter got it. While I was going it helped my career just because I was attending.

But since you are employed - check with your HR department about what the skills and education they are looking for in the Senior positions. Sr Network Admin - Manager - Director - VP ...

Most of them will have - BS/MS degree required..

It's BS - because your degree can be in Sand-Box design or anything, what they are looking for is the ability to do it and the "Well Rounded" employe that comes out.

by jellimonsta

I agree with you Jim. I am probably going to go for my Masters (I am just not at all excited about all those years of school again. Not to mention I doubt any of my schooling carries over from the UK). I am most likely going to choose general business as I do not want to 'niche' myself into a corner being 'totally tech'.
Regardless I do not think I should pass up the opportunity of my employer paying 90% reimbursement. :)

by hal 9000

This is the best way to further your job by getting what is required rather than what you think as necessary.

As someone who now employees others I look at their practical experience rather than their paper experience as it means very little to me but then again I'm not normal so I might be a bit biased in my opinions.

The only real problem now days in getting what your employer wants is the fact that you are no longer guaranteed a job for life if you are good enough as most CEO's, CIO's and the like are looking at the bottom line and will dispose of an "expensive" staff member in favor of a cheaper person doing the same job if possible and then all that education becomes a hindrance in your attempt at getting another job.

But on the other hand if you go out looking for a job while you are currently working you'll find it far easier to get another job that may be more to your liking or better money or whatever turns you on.

On my final Thesis for Applied Physics I submitted a design for a U235 Reactor and unless you where to work in the Atomic Energy Field is nothing more than a waste of paper for any thing else but I do have a PHD in Physics {though what good that will ever do me I'm not at all sure} but I did require it for the job I was doing at the time.

by hal 9000

I was just interested to see so many people say that "the bit of paper" was so important particularly when I have to agree with you that most of those Uni students couldn't tell if their arse pointed to the ground or sky {but I'm not the average person either} as I hate being called "Doctor" and especially having everyone e think "I know it all" particularly when I'm the first to admit that I sure as hell certainly don't know a lot at the best of times and am still learning as I go.

If you really want that piece of paper you could get it here at least as an External Student or Adult Student I don't know if they have something similar there in the US but as our society is so heavily geared to-wards the American Model I'm assuming that you would.

But honestly at somewhere around 50 you could probably teach far more than what you would ever learn at these places. I'm the first to admit that I learned far more about Mechanical Engining after I left Uni than what ever I learned there and at that stag I was part f a company who worked closely with the Qld Uni to give some piratical training to the students that they would never have got out of books.

Actually Maxwell if you really want a PHD you can have mine as I find then counter productive whenever I approach any company for work they only become useful if there is Government work involved and in those places they reward stupidity by advancement and the really good workers get held back so that the job gets done. Or when I have to give evidence in a court so fool holds me up as an "Expert Wittiness" the best that I'll say is that I've had a bit more practice than some.

by hal 9000

But I can't say that it gives me any sasifcation in saying that as you so rightly pointed out the best boss that you ever had didn't have all that paper but actually knew what they where doing.

Do you think that there is some form of conspiricy working here to keep the education instutitions in business turning out less than perfect products while the workers get screwed a bit more?

Recently over here we had an add running for an education instutition where some girl claimed that after attending thsi school {for want of a better word that will be understood over there} they landed the "Ideal Job" writing code for M$. Now that isn't something that I would bost about but then again I suspose most people who arn't in the trade think that M$ is wonderful and can do no wrong and it is the computer's fault when things go wrong.

This discussion is closed to new replies.