Discussion Locked

Is Linux ready for your office? No !

0 helpful
2 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Let me start out by saying, I am not Anti-Linux, or Pro-Windows. I will learn/use anything that works best for a given situation. I have no loyalty for software vendors.

I have been reading many threads on this board where admins are saying thatthey are getting ready to switch over to Linux from Windows (or at least talking about it). Various reasons have been given (many uneducated reasons as well), but I just don't know what they are thinking.

Most of the pro-"Linux in the office" people are extremely technical, and for some reason, expect that average end users are ready for the shocking differences in Linux and Windows. Let's not forget to mention how much more difficult Linux is to use.

I will make this short and sweet. Iwill be damned if I would throw Linux at the users in my office. They grew up on Windows. I can not even begin to imagine the support nightmare, learning curve, and loss of productivity that would ensue.

I don't know about you guys, but this situation would have me in the unemployment line.

Personally, I think Linux is a few years (and a few billion bucks) away from being a solution at home or in the office. Mac OSx has a better shot IMO.

What is your opinion. Flames are welcome.

2 replies

by michael c

No end user should have Linux thrust upon them right now. Not only will it tick them off, but productivity will suffer as well. The one thing to keep in mind is that right now IT admins are generally debating whether or not to switch their backendnetwork servers over to Linux, not the end users' workstations. The end user can continue to use what ever flavor OS they're using now. This issue only concerns network operation. The beauty of a Linux-based network is that it will play nice withWinNT/2000/98 as well as the Mac OSX you mentioned. I believe in a few years the GNU window managers for Linux will be refined enough as to allow current Windows end users to migrate over to them without much trouble, but that is indeed down the road.

by timmitchell

I agree that Linux desktops have not evolved enought to be considered for general deployment to end users. However, Linux certainly has a place in the server market. The Linux kernel is small and secure, and far more stable than Microsoft's offerings. The Apache web server runs circles aroun IIS and iPlanet, and sendmail is more than enough to satisfy the average user's hunger for POP3 email. I work full-time for a school district, and I volunteer as network administrator at my church; bothorganizations have a very limited technology budget, and both have saved thousands by using Linux in the server room.

This discussion is closed to new replies.