Discussion Locked

Is the PDA dead? ... Or has its death been greatly exaggerated?

0 helpful
24 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The stand-alone PDA appears to going the way of the ZIP drive and the Commodore 64. Smartphones appear to be taking over where the PDA left off.

Do you still use a stand-alone Palm or PocketPC, or have you migrated to smartphone? Why or why not? What do you view as the pros and cons of a stand-alone PDA vs. a smartphone?

24 replies

by debuggist

I used to use a Palm V. Then I decided that I didn't want my life so complicated that I needed a PDA.

I used to use a Blackberry, too. But I was changing batteries on it more than I was using it, and that just seemed stupid to continue doing.

I have a regular cellphone. If I need to communicate with someone ASAP, I just call them or they call me. It's much more efficient than punching out txt messages.

I can see where frequent travelers would need easy access to email, but I'm not one of those. As for PDAs, they don't make my life simpler.

If a electronic device doesn't improve my life, then I don't need it.

by neil higgins

I use my Sony ClIE PEG-TG50/E,and find it very useful.It might not be the latest all singing,all dancing variety,but it displays in colour,syncs with MS Office,stores news data off the web,plays mp3's,quantity dependant on the memory stick size,a few low tech games,and has a an e-book reader.Would I feel lost without it?Maybe.It's that look of cool that I like.Will I upgrade anytime soon.No.I like it because I know how to use it.Maybe I'm just lazy,or settled on my choice of gadget.

by kirk, really!

For 2 years I used a Compaq iPAQ. I would leave it on my desk to synchronize. When I did remember to unplug and take it with me the batteries would run down. Then it was useless.

My DayRunner hasn't run out of power yet and now going on three years. Need to replace the hard storage yearly at $25-$30, but much cheaper than the 3 to 6 hundred dollars for a new PDA. I did spill coffe on it once, but it wasn't riuned.

The one problem I have had with the pencil & paper solution is scheduling 5 or more years out. ;-)

by lhatcher

I personally use a Treo. I love the integration of the phone and PDA, one less device to carry around, and i dont lose any functionality of either the phone or PDA. I would be lost without it.

by boitsfort

I have been using a PDQ (Pocket PC) for quite a long time. I started with the Compaq Aero 21xx series then I moved to Toshiba e570. Both were disconnected devices. On the Toshiba, I had bluetooth so I could connect using my mobile phone in dial-up and GPRS.
When my company gave me the opportunity to switch to QTek PocketPC with built in phone, I had to choose between that device and a small very pocketable Nokia 6100 phone (w/o bluetooth). Well, considering the size and benefits of the PocketPC, I opted for the standard Nokia phone and since then I don't have a PocketPC anymore.
I revitalized my old Psion Siena just to store my contacts and calendar (no email, nor web surfing), and I found it still very useful.
Now, if I had to choose again, I'd rather go for a BlackBerry...

by peteloo

I've not bought my PDA, although I'm in the market for one.
At the moment, I've a Sony-Ericsson K700i. It's not one of those smart phones, but it provides what I need to stay in touch.
Why didn't I upgrade to a smart phone? Well, I saw a colleague try to answer a call when he was using a PDA feature of the smartphone. It wasn't easy.
I think it would be better to get a PDA for reading MS documents, viewing MPEG movies, or as a mini notebook. I would not compromise on the battery life of my phone just for these activities.
I hope I'm right going the direction of the PDA.

by sseifert

I have both a cell phone and a PDA. I am constantly kidding other folks when they brag about what their phone can do, with the response "Yeah, and I can talk to other people on my phone"! Phones are for talking to people, and PDA's handle all the other stuff. You can't cram too much into one device without making it terribly inefficient. I've had a PDA since the Apple Newton days, and they are great - but I sure hope I never receive a call on mine!

by phantom56

I was tasked to install some PalmPilots a while back and to train the users. I liked what they could do and acquired the Tungsten E. As a highly mobile Search and Rescue director (in my spare time), I have come to depend on having the database and map software within easy reach. I could not pass up on the chance to upgrade to the new Tungsten T5 with WiFi, Bluetooth, IR, a 256 MB USB drive mode and rotatable screen! On a recent trip, I used the WiFi capability to stay up-to-date on my e-mail as Hurricane Katrina approached the Gulf Coast (where I live). My Nokia (non-smart) phone shares calendar and contact information with the Tungsten via bluetooth any where. I carry my own data backup and if one device is lost or damaged, I still have the other. The Nokia 6255i stays with me, the T5 is close by, ready for more advanced requirements. Blackberrys and smart phones are nice, but too clunky for a day-to-day cell phone.

by hagstrom

I'm with you, so far at least, I think it's better to keep the phone and PDA separate.
I just got a regular cellphone and my iPaq 5555.
Could not be without PDA, which I use daily, keeping track of a bunch of contacts, notes and documents, Excel sheets, etc. to name a few...
Don't want to use a clumpsy PDA as a cellphone, and don't want a tiny cell to try to be a PDA...

The PDA is not dead! It's staying with me for a long time ahead.

by steve-nyeoka

I had a Palm since the IIIxe. Loved the way it sync'd with Outlook. Use a time-study program at work. Download and read test files and make shopping lists.

Bought a Zire 71 (still use it). Takes quick snap shots, plays MP3s. Used the installed SD card to transfer files back and forth to work and home.

Plays decent solitare.

Use the phone to call people. It's small and I like it that way. Have like 10 numbers in my speed dial (a pizza place is one of them). Anyone else I need is in my Palm. No bluetooth, but then again, my fingers ain't busted...

by bc planner

Much like a TREO the Kyocera 7135 is a Palm enabled phone -with one huge difference. It has analogue as well as digital phone capability. Some folks say they need to use the PDA while on the phone thus the need for 2 devices. Solution - use a headset - talk and check the calendar or calculate similtaneously. Carry just one device.

by robroynj

I love my Treo. I travel a fair amount and having everything in one device is great. Also, my old PDA (an early blackberry) had no access to the web in general. While slow and not something I'd do all the time, there have been many instances where this feature has really saved me time. The trick is to buy some extra member. I have iGB.

The person that said that too many things in one device is an issue is wrong. A poorly designed device can present problems sure but we are close to having the functionality of a PC in our palms.

by desizemo

I have been using a PDA for over 4 years now, and I would not go back to a paper based daytimer for any reason, as I used to use a 3-ring binder "System" that cost more than my Tungsten E. I will migrate to a combo Smartphone/PDA when I can reasonably afford it, and when the transmission and reception quality improves.

More importantly, I want the technology to be light, klutz resistant, and transparent to my capability requirements, i.e. WiFi capable without to much hassle, and plug and play Bluetooth connectivity to my laptop and workstation.

by annmarie.cross

I have friends who have all in ones and like them, and others who hate them. a paper solution cannot remind me what time it is so that i make that meeting, or easily push tasks forward to another date. an all in one has the drawback of not being able to enter/read data easily while on the phone...

I like my aging Palm, and I like my aging LG phone. When both need replacement, I'll think, again, about an all in one, and then i'll very likely buy one of each again.

by jmgarvin

Your uses will leave bluetooth on on their smartphones or they will allow IR access at any time.

While this is a problem with the PDA, it is usually mitigated by the PDA either not having bluetooth or it is hidden away so IR can't see it.

While I quite like smart phones, I'm not ready to drop my PDA yet. Give the smart phones a few years to mature and have more FAR functionality than a PDA.

by stoweboy

I have a PDA a Compaq 3635 which I love and can sync with outlook and keep my information in it. Maybe it is not top of the line but it does what I need it to. I checked into Blackberrys but the cost is way to high. I think smartphones have to come down in price before I give up my pocket pc

by jim wyse

I currently have responsibility for 20 PDAs, and they are excellent. They are Orange M2000s and as well as the usual email and web browsing, we use them for an electronic invoicing facility for our field guys, such that invoices are logged at the server within moments of them being created at the customer's site. We also run Tomtom Navigator on 10 of these, cutting down on non-productive time as the field-techs try to find their customers' locations.
This pairing of applications saves us so much time, and therefore money, that we plan to roll-out the system to over 130 field-techs.
The alternative solution, a notebook PC for each field-tech, is so much more expensive, both to implement and support, that the PDA solution will be with us for a long time to come, especially as we intend to develop more applications for it, to maximise its potential.

by willpd13

I could not live without my PDA (I even have a spare just in case). It is invaluable in my day to day work not just because of email but also as a network tool with various utilities for testing wireless network connections and even using terminal services to connect to our servers while I am away from my desk. It has and does save me a lot of time and running around. I think that PDA's in one form or another will be around for a while yet and there will always be people like myself that want a phone to be a phone and a PDA to be a PDA and not something that tries to do the job of both but not as well as either.

by ldb4554

I use a Nokia 3650 (PDA integrated in a smartphone) and have downloaded applications for it. It works well for me, and can be synched with Outlook.

by bodendavidson

most PDAs come wireless enabled now... even further blurring the line. look at how we shop - the PDAs are displayed with the smartphones. i would assume that marketers are blowing up smartphones which are not nearly as customizable as PDAs... yet.

by sobrmike

I've been using some sort of PDA for over 12 years. I currently use Palm's Tungsten E. It carries all my contacts, word and excel files,maintains my daily expenses, and memos. Not to mention I down load and send emails, family photos, mp3s,has an Adobe Reader for my downloaded ebooks all this and it interfaces with my current phone. I guess you know what I favor. I can't live without my PDA.

by tecdoc

No true PDA can be substituted by a cellphone, no
matter how sophisticated; if You are satisfied by the
phone features You actually do not need a PDA and
devices like the iPaque and similar do not count for they
are cross-breeds. The features of a PDA outshine a
cellphone and, seriously, who wants to lose ones
eyesight on characters or images the size of fleas
running over a thumbsize screen - a 4 in. one is the
bare minimum.
I have a Handspring visor with all kinds of modules
including a phone one that I use for emergency
interneting and e-mailing in spite of the fact my
cellphone is Internet enabled, but that one I use only for
old-fashioned talk and occasional SMSing.
Although the two species may be overlapping in some
instances, do not expect one finishing off the other. I
hope to see soon a PDA with integrated GSM (GPRS or
UMTS even better) phone and browsing features, GPS,
camera (with video snippets), a score of applications
that will enable You to survive comfortably away from
Your desk (yes, working on a true computer with a big
screen is still the best and most healthy solution) plus
radio, TV, MP3 and maybe some other intelligent (or
just cute) hardware & software additions to be tailored
to specific professional needs; in addition to that a
bluetooth wristwatch (so one would not drop, lose or
forget it) cellphone for simple fussless talking.

by drafferty

If you don't just buy for the latest and greatest the decision should be made on your needs.

I started with a Palm V, moved to a Tungsten T and a Bluetooth phone. Next to a Tungsten T3 for the larger screen on to a T5 boat anchor and then Treo 600 and now Treo650 for bluetooth and G3. The converged device answered all of my needs.

We train corp. tech support staffs on troubleshooting and repairing devices so have seen lots of uses.

As a traveler the Treo 650 has everything that I need. Email, web, PIM. I do still use my T5 for my GPS because of bluetooth and the larger screen.

Stand alone is a bit of a misnomer on the new devices since they have bluetooth and WiFi.

The problem that I see is tha most people don't understand what they can do with it. If the manufacturers develop education programs for users then the stand alone device will flourish.

by bryonyc

Can't live without it. My full calendar and contacts, sync'd with my home PC. Docs and spreadsheets are doable. Also great for books (ereader, mobi and adobe) - the large screen makes them easier to read than on my partner's Treo, without having to fork out for a specific ebook reader.

This discussion is closed to new replies.