If you don't just buy for the latest and greatest the decision should be made on your needs.
I started with a Palm V, moved to a Tungsten T and a Bluetooth phone. Next to a Tungsten T3 for the larger screen on to a T5 boat anchor and then Treo 600 and now Treo650 for bluetooth and G3. The converged device answered all of my needs.
We train corp. tech support staffs on troubleshooting and repairing devices so have seen lots of uses.
As a traveler the Treo 650 has everything that I need. Email, web, PIM. I do still use my T5 for my GPS because of bluetooth and the larger screen.
Stand alone is a bit of a misnomer on the new devices since they have bluetooth and WiFi.
The problem that I see is tha most people don't understand what they can do with it. If the manufacturers develop education programs for users then the stand alone device will flourish.