Discussion Locked

IT Admin "Was Fired" But... Was it a GOOD idea?

0 helpful
266 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

There was an IT Administrator who had been fired from his Company, do to deliberate mismanagement of the companies network systems in order to acquire new products and software for which they proposed - was the best solution in order to fix the problem, however, A.S.A.V.M operates an internal investigation department... one which no employee had been aware of.

They found in there investigation, that this IT Admin, deliberately mismanaged the net work to obtain software and hardware for both personal use and for personal private transactions.

Now there is a new IT Admin running the show, which just became a circus... The old IT Admin, apparently created personal encrypted passwords which have locked in all essential files, and has been unsuccessfully decoded... now the company has become paralyzed by and Admin who no longer is with them.

The first question is... If you were this new IT Admin, what course of action would you take?

And the second question is... Do the companies you work for have back up plans for the unexpected... what ever the unexpected may be?

266 replies

by tony hopkinson

beore they obtained access to their own kit and a secured it from him ?
I'd want to leave and go work for someone with a brain cell.
You've only three options, rebuild the entire system, get the passwords off the ex-admin, or hire some people who can break in. The middle option is still the easiest.

by neil higgins

if someone had done something no doubt totally against company policy,I'd expect them to be hauled up before the "top dogs",and ordered to unincrypt the system,even if they'd been fired.Other than that,the "idiot" who'd set this chain of events in motion,so that the company ended up in this mess,should also be fired.Me,I'd be off to work for a more sensible bunch.

by john

Either use hacking software to pull the passwords from the registry or run brute force software on the passwords and get them that way. You can even take the discs to a data recovery firm and have them obtain the data. Document everything and give those docs to the legal team. This is probably a federal offense.

Inviting him back in to unlock the files is asking for trouble, no telling what he will do while he's there! He could steal, corrupt or just break your systems, or commit any number of malicious activities.

by duct_tape101

Before Canning him did they give talk to him giving a warning to stop this type of activity? I agree that there needs to be a backup system. This should be the First thing when seting up any system Back-up. Maybe they Did the man a favor by canning him. Like Tony said go work for some with a brain Cell or 1/2 half one

by 2manycerts

"Hey could you not mismanage our network and steal from us? That would be nice. Um, oh and by the way, can you decrypt everything and give us your passwords? Thanks"

RIGHT...

by jdmercha

Who in their right mind has only one person in the company with admin access. Never mind being fired, what if he/she got hit by a bus on the way to wowrk? You'd still have the same problem.

The admins boss should have the same level access. Even if the boss is not an IT person, they can at least hire a consultant to do the work with the boss's account.

by jeremiah2911

jdmercha u'r right, president,evp should have same level access even if he/she is not an IT person, anything can happen to those gurus... maybe hit by an ambulance! ... : )

by davidvangelder

In my position I keep a spreadsheet of all my vendor contacts complete with account numbers and passwords, all the software CD keys, and every single thing that reuires a logon name/password. I also keep my Administrator password here, and my personal password as a Domain Admin in it. About every month I give a copy to our Business Administrator 'just in case'. I owe them this as part of my responsibility to be the caretaker of the network and their data.

by ozi eagle

If he was the Guru of IT at the company, the rest probably didn't have a clue to what danger they were in. I mean if one truck driver "dies" you just hire another, don't you.
They obviously have no appreciation of IT and its traps.

by tony hopkinson

we have no experience with in IT.
All my colleagues agree with me.
Mr Spanner, Mr Driver and even Miss Hammer.

Sounds like a classic case of no management let him get on with it followed by an executive extremity and then what's known in technical circles as a cluster****.

by wayne m.

I can't really tell from the description whether firing was justified or not. The issue people should take away from this, though, is the risk associated with relying on a single individual.

One rule I enforce on every project I run is to have at least two people involved in every task. In addition to redundancy, this provides some side benefits. This is an excellent way to train someone in a new technology or task; the expert can serve as a mentor. This also allows the expert to work on his leadership and communication skills. Lastly, because the work is shared, the expert now has time to learn a new skill in a different aspect of the project.

This is not an IT issue or reflect a lack of knowledge of IT. Every position in the company from CEO to worker on the loading dock needs to have someone who can step and fulfil his responsibilities. Yes, I really mean all the way down, because I have seen major projects and proposals nearly come unhinged because no one knew how to send an overnight package. Duplicate all job roles.

by sheiba

The company must have checked the admin out before he was hired. Obviously he was OK. Did they sack him for being inefficient, incapable or was he doing something illegal? If the latter call the police, you may get the passwords that way. If he was sacked for other reasons then have a good look at your hiring policy!

by holdupmaster

This scenario should never have occured.
Good system administrators keep documentation on design / configuration / and builds. These are active documents that managament also have access to. They are invaluable in Disaster Recovery scenarios and in environments where there are multiple admins and also so that workload can be transferred, for holidays / people leaving.

All sysadmins should have proper documentation of there system. In my opinion not doing this is not doing the job properly. Dont whinge about doing it, as it will save your skin in the future, and also enable you to bring juniors into the team more easily... You can just give them documentation to read, a build / config doc etc etc.

Password documentation, or password management software should be in place and the information stored securely. If he hadnt been documenting his system I'd have sacked him long ago.

by mscidba

If that were the criteria for firing administrators, there would be a HUGE amount of "forced turnover".

As a consultant, the companies I've entered where that information WAS documented is definately in the minority. And, oddly, it seems to have nothing to do with company size (i.e. I used to think larger companies would be more structured).

Lucky for me, that's often one of the first recommendations I make and get paid to complete.

by gkchege

IT has been for a long time left without clear reporting functions. Employers MUST insist on more than one person doing the data security. Most have an admin who doubles up as manager and maybe even support person - 'the IT guy'. In such cases, only one person has relevant/crucial passwords. It is then easy to be held hostage. Still, if the damage is done, the best option is to pay the former admin handsomely and get the system up, then do it right with the new admin.

My advice for the new admin, either recommend the best option or get ready to rebuild the systems. Worst case scenarios, go underground and find hack specialists!

by givemejava

Somehow I doubt that this guy will be all that helpful if you call and ask for the passwords. You should try, but I expect he'll just laugh in your face or attempt to charge you $1000 per hour in consulting fees.

Where was the management? Why were they not insisting on thier own seperate authentication for these files? These boobs deserve the punishment they are getting for thier own stupidity.

by jackuvalltrades

Tony and Neil have hit the nail square; There is really not much other recourse. I also agree that jumping ship is probably a wise idea in the long run. Fix it up, be the hero, get the gold star on your resume and get out, quick. It sounds like this company is going to be looking for a bunch of fall guys to shield themselves from their obvious screwups.

by aaron

I have read most of this discussion, and see a lot of my own company in this. We are not very large, and at present time have no need for more than a single Admin/Engineer etc. Right now, I am all of these roles. Whenever I deploy anything, I keep hard copy notes of everything I have built, and generally print the "how to's" or at least install directions for every open source and other application I compile and setup. I have a hard copy in a filing cabinet of every important .conf or similar file. I have detailed network diagrams of everything piece of my network. Most of which didn't exist when I took over from an external consulting agency that was previously fulfilling my duties. Everytime I change an admin password I document it, and make sure my boss (the CTO) has it stored securely. This is just as much for my own protection as this company's. It is plain and simple, this is the difference between a "paper cert." and real world experience. I insist on at least one other person knowing nearly everything I'm doing or not doing on a weekly basis. Again, mostly for my own protection. I find absurd that management didn't require this of that particular employee, however previous to my coming on board my company had been in a very similar situation with another consulting agency. Clearly this particular individual deserved to lose his position, however there is no excuse for management's conduct either. Hopefully they have learned (a very costly) lesson.

by prwexler29

Bad grammar! "...do to deliberate..." "...net work to obtain..." "...paralyzed by and admin..."

Sorry to sound like a schmuck, but, oh my God, forget about firing someone for fraud when you should fire them for being "dyseducated!"

by i.t.services

OMFG! You don?t just sound like one, you are a schmuck! Or maybe, yet another displaced, out-of-pocket, better-than-thou English major, so convinced of their own sense of superiority that they can't even follow a simple topic without interjecting their own "righteous" values upon everyone else.
So the grammar was bad, could you follow the intent? Or are you so wrapped-up in sentence structure that you fail to see the worth of any statements not sent through spell check?

To answer the question, I have to somewhat agree with Tony Hopkinson; but I only see two options as opposed to three: 1) rebuild, 2) get the passwords off the ex-admin. I do not see hiring people who can break in as a valid option because of all the new security problems that would create.

by tony hopkinson

a domino and a bag marked swag.
They break in, reset the passwords, get opaid an go home.

As for the poster on Fraud, might not have worded it better, but this balls up could end up costing the business much more than than they were beoing defrauded. I just don't get how they let this guy out of the door with out reseting the passwords, and for that they'd need his.
If he's not being prosecuted , he must be laughing his ass off at these idiots.

by wayne m.

Please note that there are legitimate services that do provide password cracking services. These have saved many a company by unlocking laptops, etc.

The suggestion is to use a legitimate service, not find a high school or college student to break into the network. Start with the providers of your servers and see if they can provide any recommendations. Passwords become lost for a variety of reasons, and having some crack a lost password should always be considered as an option.

by oz_media

Where does typing skill in a public forum correlate with IT management for your company?

Take a pill.

by rapell

atitued gai who tnihks we sue englis to srot pobrems. For all we kwno the dude mite be german and he juts wasnt to participate and share with su at TR. Lest start gramar thread fo him. yes Oz is rithg, wrhere is engliski teh language if IT??

by chip_langowski

The quality of a person's writing is often a direct reflection of the quality of their work. Learning from past mistakes, I no longer hire people with poor spelling and grammar skills...

by arm

Belt up, speed kills! (A slogan, not a sentence.)

If you really were interesting i would wax lyrical. Instead i'll pick the melted wax from candles, which is infinitely more engaging.

;-)

Chin up old fellow, i'm sure someone out there likes you!!

by zlitocook

I was a contractor to a small bank and hired after contract ran out. A office manager was the Administrator for all the servers, he used a consulting group to do all the administration of servers, security and other functions. When I got real administrator access to the servers I found and patched three back doors and access to all servers to more then five people. The consulting group complained that they needed access from remote computers. When I asked them why I never received a good answer. If you have one administrator you need to have him/her give all thier passwords. And let them let you log in as them to see what they have access to. And it is a good idea to have a contract that will say that if they leave they have to provide all access and passwords.

by mjd420nova

that persons boss should be out the door too.
To fire him and not get access passwords is
inexcusable. Sorry to say buy you are going to have to rebuild, and the two new hires that control and build the new system will have to be watched over by a knowledgable third manager.
Unless this is done , you may have an even bigger problem down the line. I hope that this
will open the eyes of those of us out here who
dread this type of situation and may now take
steps to prevent it from happening to them.
I know, I've seen it before, but was able to
do a restore from before that idiot was hired.
We lost some data but was able to replicate it from the individual machines on which it was
created.

by brotherj

I work for an organization that is just completing going through a similar agony. The only saving grace is that prior to firing the individual I made it policy that all admins, network engineers, etc. had to register their passwords in an encrypted database that I, the CTO and the Network Security analyst had access to. The individual terminated still had numerous private passwords on the devices he accessed regularly, but we were able to get into the devices and clean up the private passwords, backdoors, etc.

by don'tquityourdayjob

I would question how good of an investigation they applied to the situation in the first place.

I don't think it would be unusual for an admin to password protect files, especially those deemed essential to network opps.

Some admins argue that doing this makes it more difficult for "malicious" progams to change these files.

Some companies have a policy against this but I am uncertain your's has such a policy.

It was not a GOOD idea to fire this person, especially if this was the only IT admin.

by jcritch

So let me ask the question, what would this company have done if this person was run over by a bus? Where was their D/R plan, which should have included the fact this guy could be dead?

This truly is a case were litigation is possible, but hey the guy could come down with a case of amnesia, then what? I bet you will see some sort of judgement placed on him by the courts.

by oz_media

Besides a published policy, what control does a company have over it's staff in that it would be watching all the IT staff's passwords?

Yes a DRP would be a better idea, but if an employee changes passwords there's nothing you can do at the time unless you know about it. The only way to know about it is via micromanagement, and we've all seen what a negative, company crushing disaster micromanagement is.

by oz_media

If your company, ASAVM, has an internal investigation department (though I am thinking it's probably just a post employment investigation and not an IT specific one), they most likely have a policy in place that all passwords are company property. Check into the policies first.

Regardless of policy though, the admin MUST make his passwords available to the company, it is illegal not to. They own the hardware, they own the network, they MUST have access to it, the admin can face some serious theft charges if he has locked the company out of their own hardware. It's NO different than changing the locks on the front door and leaving with the key in your pocket.

I would suggest having someone call him, if not yourself, and ask for/demand ALL passwords, he is NOT legally able to lock your company out of their system, policy or not. If he refuses to offer the information or come and unlock all passwords, then take legal action.

by jmgarvin

Explain that this was a malicious act and if he doesn't cough up the passwords, you will sue him.

Also, I doubt he will be getting a good reference from that company....so make sure he KNOWS that.

by calson

I seem to recall a similar case years ago where a guy was charged with theft for encrypting everything. I think it might have been where he broke into someone's computer and encrypted their files, but the premise is the same.

by oz_media

You have taken company property and made it in accessible to those who own it. You have stolen access to their own products from them.

by gprinsloo

I think the company should go all out to punish the individual.

Use the law to force cooperation and liberation of the locked data.

Ruin his/her career in the media as it will greatly benefit the honest admins who institute sound policies.

All companies must assure that they never place all their eggs in one basket.

A DISHONEST admin is a CRIMINAL and should be treated as such. What is the difference between destroying, stealing, hiding (encrypting, mislaying) or falsifying company property/data, all are CRIMINAL acts. which are aggrivated if commited by "responsible and trusted" persons.

by avid

a good acceptable use policy should should be able to show, in court, that the passwords actually belong to the company. refusing to give them to the company could land him in jail if he gets a hard nosed judge.

by jwschull9

This happens all the time. I know of one specific case where the result was a lost contract, the company closed it's doors and everyone lost their jobs. Shame on the company management for not handling the employee with a bit more common sense and respect. Forget the backup. Those files are probably encrypted also.

You assume that the person who started the employee's termination had the common sense to insure that this could not happen. Bad assumption == Bad management.

by oz_media

THat an employee stole access to their network?

If you leave your front door unlocked i am welcome to come in and help myself?

No, it may be your negligence that allowed me to enter but I'm still a theif, as is the employee who has broken the law in this case.

by jwschull9

I'm not trying to justify this particular employees deeds. The statement was that he mismanaged ... in order to acquire. In other words he got the company to buy stuff they really didn't need. They didn't say he stole anything. If he stole something ... shouldn't they have arrested him? Charged him with theft?

The company overreacted. They should have talked to him first. And they should have recommended a second admin, a backup, LONG before any termination took place. Upper managements knee-jerk reaction may cause the whole company to suffer.

by sirbyteme

I cannot agree with you more.
Understand that I am no English major, but I am so tired of techno-geeks thinking that their tech skills make them so almighty as to be able to ignore all other aspects of their existence.
"Forget about spelling, grammar, grooming, personal hygiene, fashion, manners, etc.....I don't need them....I'm a GURU!"

All of the pieces make up the whole.
Others are out there with the same or better skills who are actually in touch with the rest of society to the point that they inherantly understand that every little bit counts.

Part of my hiring process includes a writing test.
If I ask for a report/proposal/documentation/etc. from them, they damn well better produce something that is legible and does not need to be translated from pig latin!

by tony hopkinson

or did you pick it up as part of your language skills.

Pig latin ?

Unfortunately I would be disbarred on account of my poor handwriting from being employed by your good self, there again that might be a good thing, because you sound like a walking talking personality conflict. You seem to be guilty of the same disrespect and unwarranted generalisations as those you rail against.

by oz_media

Sorry, but those companies can have their staff, not interested.

I couldn't imagine working with a company that was so blind to real talent and simply based it's choices on academic criteria, even demanding certs is a way of employing people while wearing bliders. Any dummy can hire a certified employee, how about finding the right fit for your company instead, it's more work but the employees are generally better too.

by itengineerguy

As far as the Admin that got fired, he should have offered the company all passwords when he was terminated. Always leave in good faith whether firing is justified or not. IT people should always have the highest respect for the IT field and remember there is someone taking your place.

by gsg

Sorry, but "paralyzed" is how it's spelled in the US, so, would be acceptable in this case. Yes, the spelling and grammar do make the document marginally difficult to understand, however, get a grip, people.

by oz_media

" is often a direct reflection of the quality of their work."

And OFTEN it isn't, so to use it as a blanket to deterine who's best for th ejob is pathetic.

Yu can't get through certs and testing without a good understanding of English, typing skills are important for a programer but not most admin work.

Again though, this is just a public chat room, not exactly a place where English skills need to be demonstrated. I too just don't care if punctuation and spelling is correct here, you want accurate copy you can pay me for accurate copy.

And what's with an American claiming he speaks proper English anyway? Perhaps a proper version of the bastardized English spoken in North America, but it sure as hell isn't proper English.

by bhalley1

If a techie doesnt see the need to communicate using correct grammar and spelling, what would make a hiring manager think they are going to be any more accurate with their technical duties?

by oz_media

This is BARELY one step above text messagin on a cell phone. NOw people are expected to live up to YOUR understandin gof proper English? Get a life and find somewhere relevant to focus your energies.

This isn't a job interview, it's a discussion forum.

One thing that really sticks out to an employer is never to hire a self rightous know-it-all who thinks his s**t doesn't stink. You wouldn't have a snowballs chance in hell of getting hired by a real company.

by tony hopkinson

For I := 0 To 9 Do
Begin
MyList.Add(Pointer((I+1));
MyList[I] := Pointer(Integer(MyList[I]) * ((I + 5) * 10))
End;

Which details, when and why are as important.

by freemarkets

That was poor management, period. It had nothing to do with the employee. They should call the employee back, beg forgiveness and offer money to makes things right again. Maybe next time they will learn how to manage people.

The new admin should leave unless mgmt. is willing to admit it was 100% in the wrong and is willing to right its actions.

by jamesrl

and trash the place, you should forgive me and hire me to do the cleanup?

Yes management made mistakes in not ensuring through a proper disaster recovery plan and testing of the plan that they could not survive without the admin without a negative impact. A good analysis would show that there was a significant risk. What ifs abound in this case - what if the admin was incapacitated, on disability, snowed in etc.

But in no way does that let the bad admin off the hook. If, as the OP suggests, the admin was guilty of misusing corporate network for personal gain including illegal software, then they deserve to be fired. A smart exec might not execute that right away before thinking about the impact, and taking some steps to lower it if possible.

James

by 2manycerts

He use company resources to acquire hardware and software for PERSONAL use? That has nothing to do with the employee?

The devil made me do it.

It amazes me how many people are defending the actions of a THIEF

by jmgarvin

What are you talking about? I've worked with many VERY bright people who cannot spell or write a document to save their lives.

Using blanket statements like this not only reflects poorly on IT, but on IT managers as well.

Can you spot the spelling error?

service --status-all | grep smb

How about grammatical errors?

./configure && make && make install && make clean && echo DONE

Jeez...

by wayne m.

This may be somewhat off-topic, but the scenario described above reminds me of the basic subplot in Jurasic Park!

by wayne m.

It is perfectly acceptable to set standards for writing ability as well as for any other aspect of the job. Do you provide training to allow your employees to meet your expectations?

It is quite easy to state one has high standards. It is quite another to take action to ensure that the standards are met. There is a vast pool of potential employees out there and each has his own strong points and flaws. Whoever is hired will have at least one flaw.

It is a management decision about whether to overlook shortcomings and allow standards to decay over time or to work with individuals and bring them up to standard. Sadly, most companies take the former approach and the purported standards become a joke for the workforce. Put one money where one's mouth is and teach and train your workforce.

by marc h.

Hell yes, he should be fired! Firing is almost to good for him.

I have a sealed envelope that sits in the CFO's office. That envelope has a list of the passwords for the network. Every month, we check the seal on the envelope. Should the entire team be hit by a bus, the corporation will be fine. The information is secure, there's a backup plan, and its ethical.

As for this admin, the simple threat of litigation and criminal proscution should be sufficeint to secure the needed passwords. In most states, I believe it would qualify as felony theft in most states here in the US.

Just my $.02.

by hectorjleslie

Why don't they just give him a call and ask for the passwords. If He refuses then they can proceed with any legal alternative they may have.

by db8abl

If the company walked him out the door without simply asking for his passwords they were very myopic. If they did ask and he didn't tell then they can take legal recourse. It is normal for very few (usually less then an handfull) admins to have the all the keys. If you take the high road and assume that he was not asked, just walked out, then bring him in as a contractor (1099) for a few days, pay him a decent hourly wage, get your information, and call it a day. Everyone wins.

by bwohl

Wow...that budget must be awesome - 2 people where only 1 is required?

You work at GM or Microsoft?

(Can I bring my friend...you need two?)

by teajay9001

A good manager seeks end results. If I put all of my eggs in one basket and drop the basket I'm through. This guy who got fired, suppose he got hit by a car, got sick or even died. The company is in the exact position. I tell you what, you bring your friend and I'll fire you BOTH.

by wayne m.

The cost of having two people able to do any task is not double, and the planned costs for training the second person needs to be compared to the unplanned costs incurred when a single source is not available.

When training the second resource, there is a short-term duplication of effort, but once trained, duties can be split. The split does not need to be 50-50, but the backup should have enough work to maintain familiarity. This frees up the primary to be trained and serve as a backup.

Even in a one-man IT shop, it is valuable to train one or more non-IT personnel on IT duties. I guess, though, there are some people who prefer to get paged on a day off when a tape backup fails or some other glitch occurs.

Duplication does require some extra costs, but these can be planned for. I prefer this approach to hoping that a predictable disaster (e.g., someone being absent for a day or indefinitely) will not occur.

by oz_media

You are right, you can't tell from the description nor would anyone [b]really[/b]know why unless directly involved.

I find in most similar situatios, it's not the final action that created the decision. It's often for other reasons and they were just looking for SOMETHING to justify their want to fire him to begin with.

It does sound like the guy had a few irons in the fire, was interested in other things and was a bit sketchy, trust wise. But him, just like anyone else in the world, won't curl up in thefetal position and wait to die, he'll just move on to bigger better things, the company will grow bugger and better and life goes on.

He is a thieving ba*tard though, I'd nail him to the wall for it.

Then again, due to the company's own inaction, hey may not even realize they are locked out. A quick phone call, now he's probably cooled a bit, is likely to result in his happily offering all passwords.

by teajay9001

Actually managment should have took a hit on this one. To entrust a single admin with you entire network/business infastructure is a piss poor manangment/security practice. ALL passwords should be documented and locked in a safe with dual control access. A company policy with full manangement involvement should be developed and carried out to the tee. I agree with Tony the company should lick thier wounds and hire his ass back. Then develope and administer the policy have him sign it then give him a permanent layoff.
(just keepin it legal).

by 2manycerts

"Sorry we fired you for STEALING. Gosh, can you come back and decrypt everything? And give us your passwords? Thanks"

Seriously? The guy is a THIEF. Do you think he would ever do this?

"Um...why do we need it decrypted? Uhhhh... special reasons... No, we would NEVER fire you. Oh yeah. Okay, we would never fire you AGAIN"

by 2manycerts

"...deliberately mismanaged the net work to obtain software and hardware for both PERSONAL USE and for PERSONAL PRIVATE TRANSACTIONS." [caps added]

WHAT DO YOU FIRE PEOPLE FOR, IF NOT STEALING????

SHESH

by thesnowfamily

I think the only way they will get the passwords is for the new IT guy to call. "Hey dude, listen I don't know you and had nothing to do with your getting fired. I realize your probably pissed at ABC Company but my life is crap right now because they are breathing down my butt to get these files open. Can you please help a guy out of a mess?"

Might not work but I think has a better chance then the guy who fired him calling. I also find it hard to believe the files cannot be hax0red. Sounds like the company is just too cheap to pay the right amount.

by 2manycerts

Why that's INSANE, requiring an employee to be able to spell and compose a complete sentence! What's next? The ability to count?

You should purely hire anyone based solely on...um... eye color... no, no, no... um, a dice roll.

by lsmith1989

I think it has already been mentioned,

Find a lawyer and pursue all legal avenues and prosecute him to the fullest extent of the law and make him pay for the company's legal bill. Software piracy is illegal and he can get heavily fined for each instance or even face jailtime if there is enough proof.

If this guy is a professional, then this corporate sabotage bit was just a cover up to another real heist (Jewels, Artifacts, Company's Ultra Secret recipe?) and the thief is already out of the country. Anyone seen the Italian Job?

Unless this company is the Mickey Mouse club,
it should be able to afford a somewhat decent lawyer and it should have been normal hiring procedure/practice to have this person sign a note about policies on company property, software property, and consequenses of stealing from the company and bieng prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law, etc. Most places I've worked at have something like this in place so that they can pursue legal action easier.

Just my opinion.

by jlspencer

Get with the times ...he passed on ...not receiving phone calls... I agree on the documentation aspect. More often then not when the IT admin is let go certain steps should be followed to protect the company.
1. Admin passwords held by two or company execs.
2. Make sure you have full access prior to escorting IT Admin to the door
3. While he is in the exit interview CHANGE ALL ACCESS passwords.
4. Disable all unknown accounts.
5. any others ?

by vijayaraghavan_g

Businesses using computers extensively are very vulnerable to both equipment and human failures. In a company where I was working as the equivalent of a CIO, I used two administrators each with their specific roles but with the knowledge of the other's area of work. I used to switch their roles now and then. (After all they can and do go on leave or vacation occassionally, isn't it?) In addition, I had all important administrator passwords with me also and used to try them at random to be sure that they work correctly.

Administrators do have access to a lot of business critical information and their selection and periodic evaluation to ensure that they stay on the straight and narrow path is also a must.

by jabamonte

First off I would pay for password decryption. There are companies that specialize in this area.
As for my company, all that I do has been written down in detail (read click by click). I am the sole IT person. I don't believe the company fears losing me, I just want to make sure that if I fall off the face of the planet, that whomever follows me does not have to start with a blank slate.

by meauxmoney

"A.S.A.V.M operates an internal investigation department... one which no employee had been aware of."
"They found in there investigation?"

If they are smart enough to hire an investigative team that can login and find all of this out (without anyone knowing mind you), they should have been smart enough to prevent this.

by theohkm

What if no one can know who (the geniue) have accessed the system with supervisor privilege when something goes wrong ? The question is who takes the responsibility.

It is completely reasonable to have keep new admin unknown of critical password, esp. before probation period.

While the company already has more than one people who know the password, and changes to part of the system has been found to be modified by more than one person. It is important for admin to *protect* himself rather than anything.

If the files cannot be decrypted by any second person, it is a seriuos problem that must be solved.

Not to let in password and access to sensitive resources are natural to experienced admins, especially when the environment is complex.

by adminofone

Ok, so we have a company that doesn't understand the basics that it's bad for a single person to have the keys to the kingdom, much less some basic disaster recovery planning, but they have some ultra-elite internal investigative group that has the capability to determine what is and isn't the appropriate way to manage the network.

Now, if I was the new IT Admin I'd start working up a plan to rebuild the lost infrastructure from scratch. Sure you could try and take the guy out for a beer and get the passwords, but you plan for the worst, not the best.

If you can't get the passwords, proceed with the rebuild. It will cost the company some money, but as far as I'm concerned they deserve it for their negligence, and hopefully this time the lessen will be learned.

And yes, my company has backup plans for the unexpected.

by b.swank

I agree with AdminOfOne, the lesson has been tought, the first thing would be to get an Admin with some experience one who takes their Job and the responsibility of being an Admin seriously.
get an understanding of the network and its function and infrastructor layout and rebuild resetting the switches, routers, etc... is time consuming but well worth it in this case, why? you ask. if this admin was doing these things and encrypted, and locked everything down so bad what else is out there? how many back doors were built-in? I believe as an admin we should be held to the same standards as Doctors and Lawers! documentation!!!!!!! and review boards for cases like this.

by g_tilghman

Those passwords, whomever created them, was part of the corporate intellectual property. I would have warrants served on the guy and tell him we will prosecute to the fullest extent of the law, including fines and jailtime if he didn't produce those encryption keys and passwords IMMEDIATELY WITHOUT FAILURE.

It would not be an empty threat....

by justlj

Would that be a violation of any of the Federal statues regarding electronic commerce, or even under one of the SOX provisions? Maybe an FBI office can be of assistance.
If the business has a Federal contract, then most definitively call FBI.

I believe some states have specific laws regarding that occurrence, so maybe a simple call to the sheriff would get the ball rolling.

And yes, the business was silly for not being sure they could get into things - maybe making a severance contingent on verifying ample access to systems; however, they didn't "deserve it" because the admin was fired.

by john.bruette

The original post reminded me immediately of a story I heard about thirty years ago.

A tape librarian had been belittled for incompetence for quit some time. The librarian?s responsibilities included sending mainframe database backup tapes off site for storage. Management finally issued the pink slip. Instead of escorting the librarian to the door, a two week notice was given.

A month after the librarians last day, the company found itself in need of database backup tapes from the off site storage facility. The tapes were retrieved and a restore was attempted. But? the backup tapes were blank.

The company sued the librarian. The librarian?s defense ? you told me I was incompetent, I guess you were right. The company lost.

Moral of both stories, get your ducks in a row before canning someone who holds the keys to the kingdom.

by issinho

You know, I agree with this whole "Rule of Two". Sure, the ideal (and cheapest) way to go would be to only have One admin. Lord knows we all want to be The ONE! C'mon, how realistic is it to only have one person in control of everything?
The company I work for has an entire team devoted to network and system administration. That way, in the case someone leaves the company (on good terms or not) you still have others with the "Power" to administer the system. Sure, the other members of the team are probably not paid the same as the team Lead, but they still have all the same rights and privileges that he has. It is very feasable and doesn't require a huge budget to have an additional admin. Simply start them out a little lower and with a different title. Then, make your current Admin. the Lead admin. Is that so hard?

by reinhardt

Somehow I got the obviously erroneous idea that IT was about working - not spending time in chat rooms debating the pros and cons of good grammar. Silly, silly me.

Since I'm here though, tell me - just why is the IT field so loaded with individuals who have all the answers, are never wrong and more frequently than not are completely unwilling to come to grips with the idea that all people deserve respect and consideration? I'm guessing that in this crowd there are a lot of future consultants.

by larry

I can promise you that the number one attribute of a successful consultant is the ability to communicate in away that non-technical users can understand becuase being a consultant is first about being a good saleperson.

I work with extremely non-technical people all of the time and have a tremendous relationship with my clients simply because I take the attitude that my primary job is to help them run their business. I.T. resources are just tools.

I find it amusing that I.T. people think they are somehow more "special" than the marketing guy who has no computer skills outside of the application he uses to sell products for he company.

Or I.T. people who have contempt for company management that is computer illiterate becuase they are in the concrete business but need systems to manage their multi-million dollar enterprise.

To these people that bunch of equipment in the server room is no different than the concrete trucks in the parking lot: Just part of the infrastructure to run a business. I doubt these management people are any more savvy about diesel truck engines than they are about network servers.

If you are an I.T. person who is not smart enough to figure that the food chain in any company is always like this:

Revenue Generators (Sales, Marketing, Operations)
Finance
Management
Infratructure Maintainers (I.T., Facility Maintenance, Training Staff)

Then you will not be a successful consultant.

It is critical to understand that your technical skills are assumed if you have the job. Your people skills and communication skills will be the deciding factor in your overall success in any oganization.

So here's some free advice from a successful consultant: Integrating yourself into your client's business is the key sucess factor. Your technical skills, which most clients cannot measure or understand, are a far second.

by issinho

From what I have seen, the only real reason to have certs is to get past the gate guards-Human Resources. They are the ones that really use certs as a way to weed out the thousands of Applications and/or resumes and get the ten or even the hundred interviews. The interviewer decides whether or not the person is the right fit for the job.
Don't get me wrong, I agree with you. Talent and knowledge is much more valuable than a piece of paper. Hell, anyone can study and memorize a test. What does that person do when the Sh*t really hits the fan? More often than not, he goes running to a co-worker asking for help. Someone with experience in said circumstance would figure out the right solution.

by just watching now

Heartily agree with the rule of two, but it's a minimum. Back (in ought eight) when times were flush, management tried to keep all skills in the hands of three people.

In today's world, one deep suffices. So this one admin was a 24/7/365 one-man show? May have been a little bitter, too.

Do a simple cost benefit on all three proposed fixes above. The hacking company won't come cheap. Rebuilding the system won't result in the same system. I'll bet the old admin would give you the passwords for a few thousand bucks.

Take it out of the education budget.

by jforan

You do NOT want anyone having any more access than is absolutely needed. If you have the staff, you shouldn't even have more than a pair of "enterprise admins" (for lack of a better term, not necessarily the MS group name) per region. It's a bad idea to give the right to accidentally destroy any and all systems to a guy who may be great with numbers, great with "closing the deal", and great with managing people, but clueless about the ramifications of trying out the latest tip from his high-school-age kid.

The best executives I've worked with understood their roles, and they understood that this most often means they don't need admin level acces. Why would you risk it, especially if you have compliance issues to worry about?

by kenneth.cottrell

If I were the new network admin, I'd call the guy and ask him - just one tech slave to another - for the passwords and tell him 1.) if encoding files made him feel like he was securing his job, that obviously didn't work, 2.) if he has a beef, it's with the company, not me (just let me get in here and do the job that you threw away), and 3.) the potential reprocussions of his actions (legal and with regards to himself in the job market).

If that doesn't produce results, I'd go after him with a focus like a laser beam. He's messing with the company's assets (even though the company took no measures to protect them - what fools!). I would even look into the possibility of nailing him for lost time and revenue.

by just watching now

Yes, but how much time do we have to rebuild the system to keep the company going down the road? In most IT situations, you need the systems to do business.

You could sue him, or file criminal charges, and in two or three years you will get your passwords or he will owe you a lot of (uncollectable) money.

Mismanagement will out, in the end.

by avid

and pray that they cover all their bases when they hired him. admin passwords should be covered as intellectual property, and therefore they belong to the company.

by fdinel

Yes take him to court but first

Play it dumb call the guy offer some money... remember your dealing with a thief...
Small offer i.e. let say 2k.

Record all phone calls pay whatever you can...
Sign whatever he asks...

Get your systems working again.

Then prosecute the guy to it's full extent make sure he remembers this to his grave.

by larry

There are many companies that do what I do for a living: Computer Forensics, incident response and password recovery. Not sure where you are located, but there should be one nearby. Hiring someone who is not in the business of password recovery opens up a whole new can of security worms. You would basically be handing over your network to someone you have no idea about unless you use a company with a good reputation to do that kind of work.

For instance I can reset your server passwords, crack your cisco router passwords, and almost any kind of document password. If the files are password protected at the file encryption level, I have software that will extract the files bypassing the encryption. That is a prime issue in computer forensics work. Getting to files people don't want you to get into.

So, my recommendation if you cannot access systems or files that are critical, i.e. worth the expense to recover, then you should hire a pro who does that kind of work.

by lee.p.scott

Contact each software corporation and request a patch that will return the password to the software install password. An alternate is requesting on-site help from each software company.

The best plan to cover for the unexpected is only as good as out of the box planning.

by john

When I started with my company, it was a one-man IT shop before me. I spent the first year wrangling with management and the admin to get a full set of passwords for everything, and the admin guy made it real difficult. It took pressure from the top, but as soon as I got them I made up a spreadsheet and gave a copy to each of the owners of the company. I told them that these passwords are your property, along with the data and systems that they protect. I feel lucky that I was able to do this before any real need for it surfaced.