Discussion Locked

MAC Address Translation

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Is there a command with NT/2000 (WRK/PRO) to allow MAC Address to IP Translation (Reverse ARP?)

9 replies

by parbo

I doubt there would such a utility. The based on the ip address the resolution takes place. The frames are routed to a specific place. In reverse the would be too much traffic since all known ip addresses on the lan/wan have to respond with their mac address. Can you imagine the broadcast storms this would create?

by parbo

I'm not sure how you will use this but maybe you can create a database with all the ip/mac addresses and go from there. It will be a lot of work though if you are on a big network

by sdogg1m

I know that RARP (reverse ARP) is a supported TCP/IP protocal, however, it seems that it is only something that can be resolved via the gateway router. I am trying to figure out how you would request an RARP from a gateway server (assuming it was set up properly).

Things I know:
+ ping [pcname] returns an IP address
+ nbtstat -a [pcname] or [ipaddress] will return info and the MAC address
+ arp -a [ipaddress] will return a MAC address (seems to only work after a ping, which makes sence)
Could you in theory ping a MAC address? (I tried) I would think that if you can get a MAC address using "ARP" there would be a way to do a "RARP" since they are both supported TCP/IP protocals. I just cannot figure out if there is a command in NT/2000 or maybe a utility floating around that isn't bloated.

Thanks for yout help.

by mc cunningham

No! You can't ping a "MAC" address. If you could explain what your attempting to do, or why you need to be able to check an address by the MAC... maybe someone could suggest an alternative that would meet your needs.

As for RARP, it is reallyonly used by DHCP. As the other person that responded to your request suggested, you can build a script that would ping a range of addresses, the do the "ARP -a" and parse the data from a text file or wrap it in a VB script. Just beware the Arp cache [dynamic entries] is only held for 128/seconds(?), and by default on NT/4 only holds 62 entries, after which the oldest entries will be deleted.

I have done similiar things to aid in "Sniffer" traces where I can associate the MAC to a "Server" name... but I never took the process beyond associating MACs to NT Servers (24 Entries in my Sniffer Config File).

Good Luck,
Matt

by izz

Please read this ID: Q142458 , I am not sure if it will help but it has something about pinging the MAC address.

Have fun

This discussion is closed to new replies.