Discussion Locked

Man-Caused Global Warming and/or Climate Change is a Lie

0 helpful
245 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

It always has been, it still is, and it always will be a lie.

I've been consistent in calling it a total lie for ten, twenty, or more years.

http://www.dailyexpress.co.uk/posts/view/196642

http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2010/feb/02/climate-change-pachauri-un-glaciers

When will the [i]Man-Caused Global Warming and/or Climate Change[/i] advocates either be tarred-and-feathered and run outta' town, or better yet, be charged and prosecuted for criminal misconduct?

245 replies

by nexs

Our actions (ie: substances that degrade the atmosphere -- 'Ozone Hole' type of thing) have done damage and in-turn will eventually cause it.

That's not to say humans are the only contributor.

by oz_media

he just likes to take an old debate and make it relevant, or try to anyway.

I think it is fairly common, global knowledge that man did not CAUSE a proven phenomenon that dates back before the existence of human kind.

As for the ozone hole, NASA and Antarctic expeditions have actually found it has begun reducing in size, and began doing so as man has reduced the carbon footprint.

by nexs

Is of a a very strangely shaped foot, I'd imagine.
though, as for being before humankind... Does that mean we get to blame the dinosaurs? Damn them and their carbon emitting rockets and vehicles!

One benefit of less ozone hole is that hot aussie days aren't going to be as dangerous. Woot.

by santeewelding

At first, I thought the links pointed to your consistent and clarion-like alarms in a peer-reviewed journal of twenty or more years ago.

They don't.

I'm in a black mood tonight.

by jaqui

poor santee, got yer panties in a knot? :D

you gotta start eating right to get mean.
I'm a chowing down on Mako shark right now.

by jaqui

citing radical news sources ain't helping your credibility much :p

I would tend to agree with the premise, but the agreement rules that out. :D

by oz_media

He at least admits to parroting a 20+ year old debate, whether relevant and supported by his new found hope or not.

give him a break, there are still people who claim the lunar landings were all faked in Hollywood studios too. You wouldn't call them delusional, nutters...would you?

Face it, you are talking to a guy who lives in Colorado, may as well be describing polar bears to a child in Zimbabwe.

How does someone living in central USA understand climate change, beyond what is blogged or spewed forth by the US government.

Think blindfold and earmuffs, absolutely clueless.

by jackofalltech

They never will be because TPTB are not interested in the truth but in controlling us.

They want to control us, they see that, if true, MMGW will give them control, therefore it IS true no matter what.

Any person with the slightest open mind who does just a little research will find all the information needed to see what a scam this is. Unfortunately, most people are sheep and too lazy to think for themselves.

by ansugisalas

Put the information here.
Just the information, no links.

I'll add it up myself, but I'm not tarnishing my browser with trawling through *that* morass.

by jackofalltech

The fact that you're not interested in doing your own research just proves my point. No matter how much info I GAVE you, you would just filter it through your bias, ignoring what you don't want to see, and come to the same conclusion you already have.

I repeat, if anyone has an open mind they can easily find the truth.

by oz_media

don't know what researc you have done, or how much dust was on the books you read, but MMGW hasn't been a topic of debate for a logn time now. Perhaps US radical news agencies cling onto it, they are full of fear BS anyway, but any so called research would have shown you that MMGW was not a fact. GW/climate change is indeed a fact, man's emissions mirror the conditions found during climate changes traced back hundreds of thousands of years, but that doesn't mean we started it. It is VERY likely that our emissions may contribute to this matural phenomenon, but nothing says we started it, not in the last few decades anyway.

by martyl

Are your shoes too tight, or what?
It isn't my fault that the world is round rather than flat; all I can do is help you find the edge . . .

by oz_media

Not singling out Max though, we can drive off the Area51 clan, the fake lunar landing clan and all the world's religious sects too. Some people will parrot old, irrelevant garbage for decades, if not centuries. Damn, getting rid of the religious crowd would settle the world in a heartbeat!

How can somethign like RELIGION still exist in 2010? It's like th War of the World's people STILL believe that stuff after all these years?

I can understand natives once believing a guy in a canoe delivered the sun and moon into the sky, before we explored space.

I can accept that people though Noah built a big boat and took two of every animal, insect etc. on the planet with him...when the planet was yet to be discovered.

I can accept that Ancient chinese culture believed in Bhudda, or any other culture's supoprt for a deity for that matter.

But this is 2010, let's get with the program and stop this global seperation simply due to this most ignorant, religious 'faith'.

Don't buy into Obama's HOPE, that's not reality, but believe one man created the entire universe.

More stars in the sky than there are grains of sand on the planet, but hey God made it all.

Man, when are people going to wake up and stop believing just for teh sake of believing, whether it's Max's phoney MMGW debate or Islamic terrorism, it's all complete BS without a leg to stand on.

by santeewelding

The rational leg that you stand on?

Or, is it just -- "rationality"? (Don't nobody investigate further)

Your exuberance...whence?

by maxwell edison

[i]Are you disputing global warming in general, or only the question of human actions as wholly responsible?[/i]

The question of human actions as wholly (or even partially) responsible?

by oz_media

You are a man of religious faith, if I remember correctly.

However you don't believe that when scientists find specific atmospheric changes that are present during the natural climate changes, which have occurred for billions of years, that our increase i said atmospheric gases will have ANY adverse effect on the speed of which those changes occur.

We know that water contains hydrogen however, by your claims, if we were to pump pure hydrogen into water for several decades, water's properties would not change and, if they did, it would not be due to the increased hydrogen we added to it.

Never did go to science class huh?
Been to church and prayed to The Almighty though?

It's like listening to someone who believes in fairy tales telling you that wrestling is fake.

You need some credibility to make a point, maybe that's why you have been effortlessly repeating yuorself for 20+ years.

by slayer_

I mean, the world was populated by giant reptiles, dinosaurs, etc.
Then the ice age caused the whole planet to cool down and freeze up. Maybe now it is just going back to the temperature it used to be.
Really, the glaciers have only recently melted away completely, slowly revealing the north pole.

by ansugisalas

Unnatural climate change would mean that it's accomplished by magic or daemonic influence or other such.

If you pump enough inert carbon out of the ground and burn it, the CO2 equilibrium will start shifting. That's natural.

by Member 25348569

but The Guardian is usually better than this.

From the source report's executive summary [b]without[/b] the excision of selected words and phrases.

"The Committee found that the IPCC assessment process has been successful overall. However, the world has changed considerably since the creation of the IPCC, with major advances in climate science, heated controversy on some climate-related issues, and an increased focus of governments on the impacts and potential responses to changing climate. A wide variety of interests have entered the climate discussion, leading to greater overall scrutiny and demands from stakeholders. The IPCC must continue to adapt to these changing conditions in order to continue serving society well in the future. The Committee's key recommendations for improving IPCC's assessment process are given below."

Then you may, if you wish, read the full report, see where the Daily Express cherry-picked their lies, and then walk away quietly.

:)

by jck

[i]Then you may, if you wish, read the full report, see where the Daily Express cherry-picked their lies, and then walk away quietly.[/i]

I've provided numerous research papers as proof, yet they just get dismissed.

Some people live in universe all their own.

BTW, wish I could meet up with you in Italy. :(

by oz_media

The way you gleefully dance around that pole in circles, getting all tangled up in your own ribbons, certainly doesn't make you a messenger.

by Member 25348569

I followed the links in the Guardian article and read the whole report.

Did you?

If you did - and you came to a different conclusion - then by all means feel free to attack my position.

:)

As for "messenger", I would suggest that I have a slightly (British understatement) better knowledge of the integrity of the different segments of the British press.

by jck

Chastise others for what you yourself do not do provide either; absolute proof.

Typical rhetoric.

by maxwell edison

.... that a negative should be proven. Instead, the positive should be proven - not asserted.

The MM-GW/CC advocates have proven NOTHING! Moreover, they've been shown to be WRONG more than not.

Typical jck reply.

by kenone

When? After the peak. But that's not likely for a few thousand years. Now if this interglacial turned out to be much shorter than usual and the peak were to occur soon we could maybe nail some of them to the advancing glaciers, but that's not likely.

by drowningnotwaving

... you really missed on this one.

Oh, by the time the kooks get into it, you'll probably score a three-hundred again.

What is this - the third, fourth or fifth blog of near-identical hyperbole that you've initiated in the last few years?

Your question is pretty fair: I should come up with something of substance.

On this particular blog, the substantial issue is "what really is your point, and what do you really hope to achieve?"

Banging your chest and saying "Look at the Fools that I've Exposed", hey, if that works for you, it's certainly allowed around here.

From afar, the difference between you and those you think you expose becomes somewhat dim.

You've made up your mind, under no circumstrances would you accept compromise or dissent, you scream it loudly in the hope that volume beats value and you jump on the bandwagon of any clown publication that spurts out reports in favour of your point.

So, what exactly is the difference between you and them?

Because surely when two sides are so opposed that neither heed the other, the actual cause or subject becomes somewhat irrelevant, don't you think?

by drowningnotwaving

Why don't you ponder how educated and erudite people on the differing side of the fence on MM Climate Change could ever be in a position to truly peer-review each othe's work?

There are thousands, if not hundreds of thousands, of extremely well educated scientists on either side of the fence.

It would be foolish in the extreme, willfully ignorant in my opinion, to consider every one of those individuals on either side of the fence to be motivated by ill-gotten gain or deception. Some of them on both sides of the fence actually undertook real science and found real outcomes. Differing as those outcomes may be.

Turn your mind to the REAL problem facing us now, not the soap-box soap opera you enjoy visiting every now and then.

by oz_media

Max has been hell bent on getting another post into TR history for length, regardless of relevance or validity.

by maxwell edison

[i]Unnatural climate change[/i] (changes in global climate patterns) has been happening since the beginning of the earth. No [i] magic or daemonic influence[/i] is, or has been, necessary. Mother Nature drives her own vehicle.

Your sarcasm only proves your ignorance - AND your blindness to the lack of real proof regarding the man-caused claims.

There is no proof; there is no evidence; there are only unfounded assertions.

by santeewelding

Aside from [i]whatever[/i] the genius of discussion may be, sling about with abandon "proof" and "evidence" and "assertions" in the presence of some here -- these concepts central to your theme -- and you end up an argumentative corpse.

by maxwell edison

Take a position.

Quit trying to be cute, or profound, or thought-provoking, or whatever the hell it is you try to do, and take a position.

Are you really that unsure of yourself that you can't?

by oz_media

I understand that you are born in a nation that needed thousands of soldiers to die from radiation exposure before agreeing with the scientist's warnings that radiation will remain for decades and can still kill people.

However, climate change is a fact, as you have attested yourself.

Again, if high concentrations of specific gases are present in the atmosphere during climate change, do you REALLY need future generations to find out that emitting those same gases for decades did actually increase the speed that climate change occured.

In order for you to accept science, it must have occurred yesterday, defeating the purpose of scientific exploration. It's the old hindsight is 20/20 safety blanket you hang onto.

Ignorance is not bliss, it is ignorance.

There is no harm in reducing our carbon footprint, there is no foul in becoming more wise in our use of resources. Your fears are entirly political, as always. Someone taxes you a dime and you cry until you are blue in teh face about government corruption, personal liberties, freedoms.

So here's some personal liberty and freedom for you. YOu are allowed to take your own life, you have the liberty to be free of it all. You will save that dime, you will not face the horrific tryanny of the democratic party ever again, even if you pretend it's all about science and not politics.

I KNOW you don't mind being personally reposnsible, I KNOW you dont mind being resourceful and freidnly to nature and the planet, or at least you pretend to be anyway.

So you know what they say, only two things are certain in a persons lifetime, death and taxes; it's your choice to make.

by santeewelding

Soon as you are able to enunciate "life" and "death" and "certainty" without reading by rote what you pulled off a shelf.

by ansugisalas

"Mother nature drives her own vehicle" ... you managed to form that, and still failed to see the point? Or the edge for that matter.

Whatever happens due to forces of [i]nature[/i] (be they matronly or not) is - by the common definition of the formation of "-al" adjectives - natural. What springs of logic is logical. What springs of the chemic is chemical (it's the -stry formation that's uncommon).

So - nyah nyah.

The equilibrium is a fact. Your "mother nature" on the other hand is a straw for which you grasp. Luckily, being what she is, she refuses to help you.

by ansugisalas

While I will not surrender the fact of the equilibrium, I am well aware of there being spin on both sides. Your actual arguments are safe with me - Just don't expect me to eat spin or spam on the matter - my kind prefers a meatier diet.

by charliespencer

"Unnatural climate change (changes in global climate patterns) has been happening since the beginning of the earth. ... Mother Nature drives her own vehicle."

If 'Mother Nature' is making changes, aren't those changes 'natural'? If not, could you provide some examples of 'unnatural climate change', please?

by santeewelding

We need to thrash out, "really".

I'm ready. I don't think you are. Not on your radar. It is central on mine.

Unless, of course, "reality" has nothing to do with what you are saying.

by maxwell edison

Just once. Take a !@#$%^ position.

Quit the !@#$%^& games and take a position.

Or are you incapable?

Are you really no more than a word-game player?

by santeewelding

Say, you were confronted by a respondent -- just barely competent with spelling, word choice, sentence structure, dependence on passing fads, and...worst of all..that which so sweeteningly cloys -- and you have an idea of how I greet you with respect to "position".

Position, as in, "posit". I think you have forgotten, or never learned the meaning, of the word.

I haven't. And, I have. First line of defense. Bridge of Asses.

Don't be an ass.

by oz_media

I read teh articles, and nope, nothing about man-caused global warming mentioned in there. YOU still haven't educated yourself enough to understand the difference?

The articles also don't say that they have proven there is no such thing as global warming, just that many 'predictions' were made falsely or in haste without proper scientific fact to support it.

nobody thinks MAN 'caused' global warming, well nobody relavent anyway. That's an old argument that was dead and done 20 years or more ago ,yet you still parrot it like claiming 'the world isn't flat' makes you sound clever.

Yeah we all know that, thanks for pointing otu the obvious.

However, global warming/climate change is absolute and certainly DOES exist. It has been a proven fact of the Earth's natural progression for millions of years.

The atmospheric changes that occur during a time of warming/cooling, includes atmospheric changes that are shown to include gases that we humans emit in massive quantities. Therefore a natural progression can increase it's efective speed when that atmospheric change is helped along.

The ever famous, though now not so newsworthy ozone hole has actually been PROVEN to be reducing in size. Funny enough, such changes started to occur shortly after man's emissions were reduced.

Unfortunately the polar bears still have a rapidly dwindlign environment and THEY believe in GW all too much.

Your baseless claim, which holds no modern relevance at all, is also not supoprted by your fantastic articles of scientific brilliance. All they say is that many of the predictions related to specific effects of global warming were either made in haste or have since been found unsubstantiated. BRILLIANT MAX! After 20 years you STILL don't have a point and nobody is debating MAN MADE global warming, well they haven't for many years anyway.

I suppose declaring that the Earth really isn't flat is relevant news that makes you right too, in your mind anyway.

No foul though, ive met people from Germany that lived through WWII and STILL claim there were no concentration camps and gas chanmbers were not used to kill millions of Jews.

I've worked with a guy who spent hours each day studying Area51, with his monthly subscriptions and news updates available at a fingers touch. He swears that Aliens are using the US government in Area51 to control mankind. He's a norrmal guy, nice, held a good job, but a little whack too.

Now when you finally come down from your unsupported, groundbreakign news tha man didn't actually create global warming, or if you can find someone else who actually think man DID cause it, you mmay have a reasonable and rational debate, until then you are just parroting old, irrelevant crap that everyone knows anyway, and have admittedly done so for 10, 20 or more years.

Find a real point of debate instead.

You ask:
[i]When will the Man-Caused Global Warming and/or Climate Change advocates either be tarred-and-feathered and run outta' town, or better yet, be charged and prosecuted for criminal misconduct? [/i]

Probably when WMD are found in Iraq or GWB is thrown in jail for war crimes, lies and deceit to teh American people that have cost the many thousands of coalition lives around the world.

I wonder how many people unproven global warming predictions have killed already?

by nexs

That's fairly sexist!
Women are just as likely to damage our environment... Unless, of course, we're going to start up some ripper Sexist Jokes...
;)

by oz_media

Do you actually think he believes that?

What's thought provoking about it? Is it that you think, "WTF is he babbling about now? What a lot of drivel."

If ANYONE here actually found santee's comments to be anythign other than a random string or irrelevant words in a row, I'd be rather shocked.

I don't even know why he bothers posting so much, its all just nothing of any interest to anynone and, if it was, they wouldn't see it anyway.

It's like reding through a discussion and finding posts stating how you can buy Gucci bags and Nike runners cheap, check out a great online business, buy Viagra, shoot the monkey, etc. Have YOU ever paid ANY attention to them? Thought provoking?

by oz_media

Birds, worms "not".

Coming to high tide, not the ebbing of late.

Man's time unfounded amongst children's playgrounds.

Like Max said, just F#$@ off already, wot a twot!

by nexs

How do you all sleep at night with such rage built up inside?

I, however, enjoy watching the to and fro of such conversational war. It brings a tiny spark of a smile to my my face.

by oz_media

I didn't say man caused global warming, thus why would I place blame on dinosaurs or any organism that may have existed billions of years ago.

by nexs

My friend, have a chuckle at an obvious joke, don't take the world so seriously.

Of course the Dinosaurs didn't cause the ozone hole. But what existed before us? That would be dinosaurs....

Jeez, it's not much of a joke if i have to explain it...

by oz_media

Very well, knowing I am safe and far from the foreighn clowns that I experience on TR.

by oz_media

Actually that's true not one shelf at all in my entire condo! not even in the garage!

By Rote? I merely repeated, and acknolwedge it as such, a common saying.

as for you paying attention to me, please don't, just phuque off instead.

by santeewelding

Fact...proof...bias...want...see...things I am not myself capable of discerning.

All laid bare here.

Must be, I was behind the door when all this was passed out, Jack.

by nexs

One of these days. You can't be humourless forever.
I will find the 'Funny Bone', and when I do...
:^0

by santeewelding

He has one.

Only, he keeps it under wraps.

Probably has to do with his self-perception.

Can't let that down, you know.

by ansugisalas

we come in sheeps clothing too.

What I want is the information that sufficed for you.

With my superior googling skills, when I do a search, I can find "information" to support any stance at all.
So, no, I don't feel like doing something so futile.

If you want to brag about your "information" then lay it on me. I'll do my thing with it then, learn something. Maybe just about you though...

by oz_media

not my fault. I didn't say politics had ANYTHING to do with science, you just need to keep up that's all.

by charliespencer

Care to break your point down into single-syllable words for us? I'm also not sure what the legal system has to do with logically or scientifically proving a negative.

by maxwell edison

..... and you retreat.

You are either intellectually dishonest or a coward.

Answer the question or prove yourself to be a fool.

What does being asked to prove a negative have to do with the US justice system and Constitution?

by oz_media

Believe me I am FAR from serious, I don't take much seriously at all, ESPECIALLY when it comes to politics, the US or people in general.

Like I said though, just didn't think it was funny,. Grin and bear it, mayb,e but that's all.

by oz_media

Yeah a real rough, pu$$y town there.

Burnaby's just full of SFU students and old folks homes. Most people that live in Burnaby say they live in East Van or New West just to gain some credibility.

by maxwell edison

..... no more than a pesky fly?

I might swat, but you keep coming back.

You - and/or your questions/comments - mean nothing to me.

by jdclyde

theory of evolution, that we all came from a "big bang" of nothing? Goes directly against the laws of physics. "Matter can neither be created nor destroyed".

Just curious.

by oz_media

If something explodes, there is matter. It doesn't need to be 'created' it already exists and simply changes it's form and properties.

We can see the early stages of the big bang, by sighting planets and stars billions of light years away. Sure they have changed now but what we see today is an image that occurred billions of years ago and took that long to reach us. Some of those planets and stars may not even exist today, I guess well know in another few billion years. Damn, light can seem to travel slow sometimes!

With all these bodies moving at extreme speeds in and outward direction from 'somewhere', they are obviously coming from somwhere. Once we see planets moving in the OTHER direction, away from us, it wil be pretty conclusive that we found the center of the universe we see.

But you're right, a fictional BELIEF that offers no compelling evidence whatsoever is so much more plausible.

What are you asking Santa for this year?

by Member 25348569

Before the Big Bang, there were no laws of physics. The Big Bang created the laws and set the universal constants so that the Universe evolved the way it did.

Nothing curious about it at all.

:)

It's not "Evolution", though. We've had THAT argument before.

by ansugisalas

It ain't over till it's over, and then, so will we be :)

Kind of like how TR is so quiet now.

by oz_media

And that's where you missed the point. If you don't understand that justice works in the opposite manner, then I won't take time to break it down for you.

by oz_media

I think Max just posts in haste too often. I've seen him post articles to support his claims that, when read through, actually dispel them instead.

by oz_media

But when you continue to babble on and on and on when called to task, offering no relevant reply, you simply dismiss the comment as being so stupid it's not worth answering.

I don't know wht you get so upset about being called a hyprcite, hypocrisy shines brightly in almost all of your posts.

I owe you nothing, no matter what I say you will dismiss it anyway. Don't even BEGIN to try your idiotic games with me, I know your style far too well, seemingly better than you see it yourself.

[i]"You do realize, don't you, that I consider you . . . .
..... no more than a pesky fly?

I might swat, but you keep coming back.

You - and/or your questions/comments - mean nothing to me." [/i]

by ansugisalas

You were called upon to deliver, free of taint, the information upon which you increasingly found your position.
And you give links to crap.
Anyone with a preformed opinion can find crap to support it, it's called the internet.
Notice, that I am polite enough not to counter your crap with crap of my own digging.
In this matter am genuinely open to information, but that port is reactively stealthed; you have the privilege of my ear, if you will use it. But know that, in this instance and for all intents and purposes, all your links are belong to crap - by definition. I will not read but your own words on this matter, but if you make a good point I will listen.
I'm allergic to agitprop though.

by mr stumper

Why is it that every single post that vomits forth out of your mind is for purposes of division and not discussion.

Argument instead of true debate.

Why is it so important to you that people choose a side? Regardless of topic.

This need of yours to incite is truly disturbing. It's closer to the behavior of a petty tyrant than a civilized being.

For the record, my "position" is that Climate Change is real. Overall warming of the planet is happening. Human activity has a hand in this. The only question that truly remains is how much of an impact we have. A better question would be what do we have to lose in cleaning up our act. Since reason, maybe's and open minded skepticism have no place in your world.

Also, I'm disappointed...I hoped to see a link to OISM, otherwise known as "The Compound" by the locals, so I could get a good chuckle.