Discussion Locked

Michael J. Fox, Stem Cell Research and El Rushbo

0 helpful
268 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://www.comcast.net/entertainment/index.jsp?fn=2006/10/25/230710.html&cvqh=itn_fox

The above link is to a Comcast news article detailing Rush's remarks about Fox's scenes on the democrat attack ads for the up coming election.

MJF has always been a likable figure to all Americans especially those generation X ers like me who grew up with his movies in the 80's.

I have the utmost sympathy for Michael as he suffers through this terrible disease. I pray for him and wish him peace as he carries on his day to day life.

I wanted to use this as a spring board to discuss the underlying issue of stem cell research which I, like my conservative counterparts, do not oppose. Adult stem cell research has produces a great many successful remedies for a variety of afflictions and more are being discovered all the time. What we do oppose is embryonic stem cell research. Embryonic stem cell research on the other hand hasn't resulted in any significant remedy. The only reason it is harped upon so zealously is that it is directly tied to the woman?s perceived right to murder her unborn child.
Adult Stem Cell Research link
http://www.21stcenturysciencetech.com/articles/winter01/stem_cell.html

268 replies

by jdclyde

Was the problem that the Ad was dishonest.

It does not state the difference between being against stem cell research and government funded stem cell research.

Typical from that crowd.

by fluxit

Last time I check human beings had the right to life. At least that was what our forefather thought. That is to remark the right TO life - not choose a condition of life or if life will exist at all once concieved.

Furthermore, I think most people will agree that human life is born out of love between a man and a woman. It is not a loving act to conceive life then abort it. It is somewhat selfish and a vulgar means of birth control. For what, recreational sex as opposed to creational sex?

I do not recall anywhere right that allows one human to infringe upon another humans rights.

by maecuff

MrMiami. It's been so boring without you.

As of this date, it is legal to choose to have a child or to terminate a pregnancy. So, you can call it an infringement all you want. If it is, it is a legal infringement.

by nicknielsen

it might have come from the same place where you got the right to butt in to somebody else's life.

Am I in favor of abortion on demand? No, but I do understand that there are circumstances where an abortion is the best possible option. I also understand that I do not have the right to tell anybody else how to live their lives.

My only regret is that abortions cannot be made retroactively...

by fluxit

Last time I check human beings had the right to life. At least that was what our forefather thought. That is to remark the right TO life - not choose a condition of life or if life will exist at all once concieved.

Furthermore, I think most people will agree that human life is born out of love between a man and a woman. It is not a loving act to conceive life then abort it. It is somewhat selfish and a vulgar means of birth control. For what, recreational sex as opposed to creational sex?

I do not recall any right that allows one human to infringe upon another humans rights.

by nicknielsen

[i]I do not recall any right that allows one human to infringe upon another humans rights.[/i]

Yet you wish to infringe upon another human's rights by denying a woman her choice.

How hypocritical.

by tonythetiger

[i]I do not recall any right that allows one human to infringe upon another humans rights.[/i]

the right a woman has to [b]have[/b] a child, and thus force you into several years of servitude :)

by protiusx

Murder? Since when did the woman acquire the right to choose who lived and who died?

by maecuff

of sounding redundant..

It is legal to choose to have a child or to terminate a pregnancy. Not much more to say, is there?

by hal 9000

If that Collection of cells can support life once it's been removed as a Parasite from it's Host.

I thought that you had some sense here and didn't consider all Human Tissue as Alive and having a sacred right to life. Coming from a person who openly admits that they have killed sounds slightly more than a bit Hypocritical to me.

Sould it be mandatory to retain any cancer without the possibility of removing it from your body? After all it's Human and has a [b]Right To Life.[/b]

I suppose that we immediately have to remove all the Worm Treatments off the shelves as well because they are killing a parasite in the Human Body. After all it's the persons choice to eat that undercooked meat so they should live with the consequences shouldn't they?

We must Immediately stop treating any Malaria Case that we find as well because this parasite is living in the Human Body and that person chose to live int hat area so they deserve to catch Malaria don't they?

I could go on and on pointing out various infections that attack the human body and is a parasite on it and in every case any sane person would want them removed.

Not to many are willing to suffer but if you like it can be arranged to implant you with every unwanted embryo and you can carry them to term and then place them up for adoption. All that is required is to place a few cells against your intestinal tract and allow them to grow. Of course any delivery would have to be by C Section but if you are willing I can arrange this to happen. But just remember that once you agree there is no turning back and you will be caring every unwanted foetus till you die and that can be a very long time from now as it's Medically Possible to keep you alive for a very long time.

Col

by tig2

Let me step up and support you in this. We have discussed in the past why this should be and I understand your views and support them.

And will bring out another-

I was recently told by another "God Fearing Christian" that he would not only not help me with a fundraiser - yes, I am walking 60 more miles!- but would oppose my efforts because the Susan G Komen had given grants in the past to Planned Parenthood (to further understanding of breast health). Did not give a moments thought about women who are diagnosed with cancer in pregnancy. Frankly, when questioned, didn't care. His statement to me was, "If God gave that woman a child, it is up to her to raise that child". I pointed out that chemo and radiation would not allow a full term birth, or if it did, the child would be damaged. His response was basically, Tough. God intended it that way.

Really PO'd just now. Hope his dick falls off.

OK I don't. Just really wish he had to try his morals against the judge I went up against- I think his name was Death.

Sheesh!!!

by maecuff

It's okay to hope his dick falls off. It probably won't happen, but if it makes you feel better, hope away!

I know exactly what you mean. I find abortion to be a very sad and tragic thing, but it's ludicrous to suggest that it doesn't serve a purpose. And again (I love this part) as of now..it's legal.

by fluxit

The Bible tells you to test yourself and to reflect upon yourself to determine if you are behaving in a Christ-like manner. Perhaps you should do so.

You should read the Beattitudes: Matthew 5

You should also read C.S. Lewis, A Christian Philosopher who passed in the early 1960's and upon whom many Churches have built their application of Christ teachings.

So from your posting I gather you put yourself before another. That you like worldly life more than death. All true Christians recieve the first death but defeat the second death.

By the way, death is not the judge. Death is the wage of sin.

by av .

Its easy for some men to say that women shouldn't have the right to choose whether they want a baby or not. Men have no idea what a tragic, hard choice it is for a woman to make.

Not all babies are created out of love or have the prospect of being born into a loving home. Some babies are created through rape or incest. They would be born into a life of abuse and suffering. Is that preferable to not being born at all? Where are the men that helped to create those babies? They've moved on.

In cases like that, it is unfair to judge a woman for choosing not to have the child. Maybe men might not relate to that decision, but they should look at it this way; what if the woman that was raped was their 13 year old daughter? What if the rapist had HIV?

What about the women in Darfur? Rape is a weapon there. If they could choose to not have the children that resulted from that rape, does that make them murderers?

Its a sad choice no matter how you look at it, but thankfully most women have a choice. Men will never understand because they don't get left holding the bag. They just move on.

by jdclyde

My boys were not conseived into a "loving home". Certain medication SHE was taking didn't work, and we were the 1%.

Abortion was not an issue, thankfully for either of us.

She looked at addoption, I couldn't do that either.

I offered to take the boys when they were born and free her of responsibility. she hung around for 14 years instead. Now we are divorced and I am back to my original offer, and I DO have both the boys and will fight tooth and nail to keep them. It just took 15 years for the offer to finally work itself out. I do not believe I am the only man that is like that either.

There are as many pathetic humans that are female as there are that are male that abandon their responsibilities.

Rape/Incest/Medical risk are all recognised exceptions to the rule in reasonable people. Most cases it is thrown out there to make this as emotional as possible to prevent any discussion.

Abortion as birthcontrol shows a sad state of society. Many women that go through getting vacumed out deeply regret it later on, and are not properly informed of the trama they will have to endure later on knowing they killed their baby. A hard thing to live with.

by dawgit

The big contraversy is realy about when does she make her choice. It just comes down to a question of timing. I'm personally 100% pro- womens choice, I'm also aware that when she chooses to do the deed, she already made the choice. (if she didn't get to choose to do that, Then there is a problem- & lock him up.) The answer is Education. She should know that.

by fluxit

I read through many postings arguing about rights and life. Our forefathers put into the Cosntitution, Bill of Rights, and the Declaration of Independence specific rights among them, but not limited to, in brevity are:

1. The right to life
2. The right to a secure family
3. The right to a secure home
4. The right to a secure marriage
5. The right of thier God to thier time.
6. The right to a fair trial.

In all the text of the founding documents are no rights to choose between life or death nor is there a right to choose a quality of life. Human rights elevate human dignity and provide meaning to every humans life. I have a difficult time seeing any meaningful benefit to abortion.

Granted that abortion has been around for a long time and has been used for medical reasons and in cases of rape. However, only in the last 30 years has abortion become this 'choice' to use it in a chavalier manner at the whim of peoples indiscretion.

Recently, I wrote a paper comparing a foreign nations infant fatality rate to that of the United States. That country had literally no medical care and marginal energy resources available to the general public, yet they had a higher success rate than the United States. Upon deeper inspection the United States infant fatality rate was 6 times that of this other country due to one event - abortion.

All those people who never came to be could have been genius's, politicians, and others who could have made huge impacts on this world. Instead, we are left with selfish people who choose themselves over another human being.

by tig2

I really try hard to pray for him. i will continue to try.

His dick fell off long ago- right around the time he figured out that he was too holy for sex!

D@mn, I am really PO'd

by jdclyde

That it is legal?

It used to be legal to have black men chained up out back, but that didn't make it right.

It used to be legal to not allow women to vote, but that didn't make it right.

I think you see where I am going with this?

by maecuff

It's not even CLOSE to my best answer.

Where is the outrage for the innocent children and/or pregnant women who get 500 lb bombs dropped on them? Or the outrage over children in THIS country who go without food or shelter?

Years ago, I volunteered at a downtown hospital to rock crack babies. It was one of the most heart breaking things I've ever seen. What hope do these children have? I have said it before and I'll say it again. I find abortion to be tragic. I think late term abortions are horrible. If the fetus is viable outside of the womb, then the abortion decision should no longer be made (and even then, I'd be in favor if the child would be born in severe pain or with insurmountable disabilities or if the mother's life was in danger).

The recurring theme here, is if you play you pay. So, having a child is a punishment? Wow! That's stacking the deck against that kid, isn't it? And it's so easy to kick back and pass that judgement if you're male. It's not something a man will ever have to deal with. I wouldn't go as far to say that EVERY man who is anti-abortion has control issues, but many of them do. They don't WANT a woman to have sex without consequences (the slut), they want to control and judge women for having sex for ANY reason other than procreation. But that argument doesn't go both ways, does it? It's all well and good for a man to get laid whenever possible, but if a woman does, she should be punished. And I think it's beyond tragic to view a child as the punishment she deserves.

But my opinion really doesn't matter one way or another. Because, like I said, it's legal. I fully support your right to vote/protest to get the laws changed, but I'll be right there working to protect the law.

I guess we can't agree on everything, eh? :)

by jdclyde

I have clearly stated over and over my stance on abortion.

It should be legal.
It should be safe.
It should be rare.
It should never be casual, or "just one of those things".

Do you really think that I am someone that is looking to punish women for having sex? (besides the obvious punishment of it being with me?)

Consequences, has that ever been a theme I have advocated? Hardly. I know, you are refering "in general" though. It is as weak of an arguement as justifying something because it is legal?

I would never vote to make abortion illegal, accept for late-term abortions of course.

I would vote to make sure tax dollars NEVER pay for an abortion though.

There are many things in life that are legal, but that doesn't make them right.

Now, do we really disagree so much on this issue after all?

by tig2

Is it right to deny the mother the right to live? Even if it costs her child???

Until YOU have to make that choice, I suggest that you STFU.

There are women dealing with breast cancer and the threat that are making these extremely difficult choices and dealing with issues that "sperm depositors" simply never see.

Look around you. It isn't only your loving family you see. WE ARE WOMEN!

And at the end of the day- you will never understand how hard our choices are.

by tonythetiger

[i]Is it right to deny the mother the right to live? Even if it costs her child???[/i]

... is that first and foremost, one has the absolute right to do anything, even kill, to save one's own life. This has been well established doctrine in world law for centuries. Many countries have extended this doctrine to include preventing serious harm to oneself, and some do not differentiate among emotional/mental/physical harm.

The legal theory is quite sound and I fully accept and even support it. Where there is a lot of wrangling is in determining how serious is serious enough and in determining whether one's stated feeling of impending harm is genuine.

by protiusx

Statistically the vast numbers of abortions are done for woman who simply has had sex, become pregnant and do not wish to have child. The numbers of women who have abortions to save the life of the mother is infinitesimally small in comparison.
In regards to the other part of your argument - are you saying that if I want to discuss pedophiles I need to become one or I should just shut up? I could turn the table on you and say "well if you've not shot and killed a man you can not talk about the war in Iraq". That is an equally silly argument.

by jdclyde

Is while Abortion IS legal, it should never be encouraged.

If people start to rationalize away every whim because they can say it might help someone, we as a society will be in a real pathetic state.

Abortion should never be allowed to become "no biggie" and should be taken seriously every time, and surely never ENCOURAGED.

by tonythetiger

is the seeming unfairness, and it doesn't apply only pre-birth.

In most states a mother can simply take her newborn child to any hospital, church, fire or police station and relinquish her rights (and obligations!) to the child, no questions asked. A new father cannot do this, and not only that, unless he is married to the mother, he has no right to the child unless and until a court grants it (and even if he has or is granted the right, the fact that "no questions were asked" may mean that he may never be able to assert it).

by maecuff

however, in doing this, many newborns will recieve the care they need instead of being left in a dumpster to die.

by jdclyde

you truly don't believe that the unborn baby has any rights to life and is meaningless until the time of birth.

If you DO believe that this means nothing more than clipping your nails or cutting your hair, then the woman would have full right to chose between dead baby and live baby.

If you DON'T believe that the baby is nothing, then the womans "rights" get limited by infringing on the "rights" of the unborn baby.

And of course as there is not a clear definition of when life starts, this will not be resolved anytime soon.

To put this to the test, if a pregnant woman were to get killed by her crazy husband and the body dumped in the bay, should this be ONE murder charge or TWO? The baby has not been born yet, so is not a life and has no value according to the pro-abortionists.

If the baby DOES have value, and there should be TWO murder charges, how can their not be a murder charge against the woman and doctor that performs the abortion? [i] (almost said "mother", but if you kill the baby, you never become a mother)

Obviously, the more clinical you get about the process, the easier it is to justify.

by tonythetiger

the legal theory is that if the mother kills it, it is an act of self-defense, and thus not against the law.

by jdclyde

Taking out of the equation the pregnacies that would threaten the life of the woman (don't say mother, because mothers HAVE babies) and you have removed a very low percentage of the abortions that are done.

Abortions for any other reason could NOT be classified as self-defense by any stretch of the imagination.

Try it again?

by hal 9000

If that is the case and can be made [b]LAW[/b] then every Miscarriage must be [b]Murder![/b]

What happens in the case where a child is wanted but isn't carried to term and dies or is still born if that embryo is a Human Life then the above 2 case must be MURDER!

Then why are the Parents not charged with these Murders? It really wasn't that long ago that no one knew anything about [b]SIDS[/b] Sudden Infant Death Syndrome and in every case where this happened the parents where treated and many times convicted as Murderers when they had not done anything wrong let alone harmed the baby in any way.

Perhaps you would prefer to return to the [b]Good Old Days[/b] and imprison everyone. But surely that will require more in the form of taxes to pay for all those prisoners wouldn't it? But if it was the [b]Norm[/b] and we all grew up under [b]Big Brother in Prison[/b] would we know any better?

Bring on George Orwell's 1984

Col

by jdclyde

If someone dies of "natural causes", there is no crime.

If a baby is still-born because of a crack-cocaine addiction, the mother IS chagered with the death of the child.

There is a big difference between causing a death and a death happening. People die all the time. Not all of the deaths are caused by others.

by jdclyde

We might start to look at the quality of someones life and decide that it is the best possible option.

How about a stroll in the local nursing home? I go there all the time to see my grandparents, and there are people there that are nothing more than bodies with their minds gone, just staring at the walls while they wait to die.

I don't like when people make the decision about what would be the "best possible option" when it comes to terminating someone elses life. Where would it end? People of power and means could say the same about homeless people. It is the best thing for them because of the life they are subject to. Crackheads? How about someone that is just poor and uneducated. Got a few kids and will never do anything with their lives but take drugs and create a future welfare generation. Is it for the best to put the whole family down because they are not in a loving situation?

by oldbag

So the woman is poor. Does that mean she has access to acceptable birth control? Most likely, no. Should she be forced to take a pregancy full-term?

While I prefer proper birth control methods over abortion, no one has the right to say to a woman that you must have this child. What if she was raped or coerced? There are many reasons why a woman may have to make a very tough choice and only she can make that choice.

by jdclyde

They have the right to have any service that they can afford.

Just like all other elective surgeries, if you can pay for it, you can get it.

This poor person has the "right" to purchase this service. She does not have a "right" to ANYTHING she has not earned herself.

If it was from rape, there are lots of womens organizations and charities that help people.

Coerced? From the definition of the word, it is a rape. Why say it twice?

She isn't "forced" to carry anything. If she can afford to get vacumed, then clean house. If she can't, she can look for an organization that will help.

Tax dollars should never be spent on elective surgeries. Odds are, your health insurance would not cover this either, so why should anyone else?

She also has a "right" to get a job so she can afford all the abortions she wants.

by tonythetiger

So the man is poor. Does that mean he has access to acceptable birth control? Most likely, no. Should the woman be allowed to force him into years of servitude by taking a pregancy full-term?

What if he was raped (13 yr old boy by female teacher)? I guarantee you that if the woman has the child, he is going to start paying child support as soon as he turns 18. It's already happenned several times.

by protiusx

They are giving away birth control free in our high schools. This notion of the "poor woman as a victim" is utter nonsense. I am not saying that rape doesn't happen. It is unfortunate and it does happen and women are the victims here for sure. I knew a woman who was the product of rape. Her mother was raped in their own home and her mother "chose" to carry the baby to term and had intended to give her up for adoption (there are a lot of people who want to adopt)but when she and her husband saw the little baby they chose to keep her.
Men are not always the "villain" here. What about their rights?

by hal 9000

In every ICU and Palliative Care Unit World Wide.

I've worked in these places and seen it happen and more importantly I've also seen a Hopeless case cost the life of a person quite likely to recover from their injuries because Critical Life Support Machinery was in use on a patient with No Chance while those with a chance simply died through not having the necessary equipment/staff available.

When Medical Intervention is required it should be looked at very hard before being used so that that machinery & Staff are available to more deserving cases if they where to come along. Why should a Brain Dead person be kept alive in the Legal Definition while a severely injured person with every likelihood to survive be allowed to die?

In the real world we don't have unlimited resources so we must make the best use of what is available to us to use. Unless of course if you are willing to pay 200% Tax on your income to have all the possible medical equipment in place [b]Just In Case.[/b]

Col

by jdclyde

Because then we will hear from the men that are "punished" with a baby they don't want by these selfish women that keep the baby that resulted from casual sex.

We get in the arguement of if the GUY does not want this baby, what RIGHTS does he have? He can't MAKE a woman have an abortion. If the woman decides to have the child anyways, HE is punished by having to pay for this unwanted child.

Isn't that one of the same arguements reversed about how a woman should be "punished" if she has sex? If she should NOT be punished, then why should a guy by punished?

Oh yeah, I forget. That is different, somehow?

by maecuff

I really wasn't singling you out, but you DID ask if I had a better argument. :)

I guess the difference is the condemnations and judgement that goes along with making such a difficult decision. I will not put myself in a position to judge someone's decision. I have not lived their life, so how can I judge? And please, don't bring obvious crimes into the picture, you KNOW what I mean.

I have personally known a number of women who have made this decision, and I can say, without reservation, that they made the best decision given their circumstances. I have someone who is very close to me whose first sexual experience was rape that resulted in pregnancy. She terminated the pregnancy. Her subsequent actions were self destructive and life altering. In turn, she had another abortion and is no longer capable of having children. This is best. I dearly love this person, but she should not be a mother. I'm not excusing her actions, she is an adult and responsible for herself, but given her situation, they are understandable.

I'm sure that some women make this decision lightly and it is no more to them than ordering lunch at a restaraunt, but, at least from my experience, these women are few and far between. And as long as it's an option, how can we police the reasons? We can't. People can be self-serving, selfish and callous, there is no doubt about that. But I still do not believe that most abortions are used as a form of birth control. Who would choose such an expensive and invasive form of birth control? It just doesn't make sense.

by maecuff

While I am in total agreement with AV's post, I will concede that it is unfair to assume that ALL men will walk away from the situation or take a callous attitude regarding an unwanted pregnancy. The level of understanding will be different between men and women, because, well, you know. Men can't have babies. In many cases, however, men can (and do) just walk away. A pregnant woman doesn't have that option.

by maxwell edison

Between you and me, I hate these kinds of discussions.

(So why did I let myself get sucked in?

Okay, back to global warming......

by maecuff

I know. And it doesn't really matter if it's abortion or global warming, no one will change their minds. We can throw opinions, studies, statistics, or whatever we want and will make not a bit of difference. But I still can't help myself.

Now please excuse me while I go defend myself against being accused of condoning infantcide.

by oldbag

Rape, incest, poverty, coersion, ignorance are all causes of unwanted pregancy. So women don't have the right to choice in these cases. Abortion should not be used instead of proper birth control but there are cases where that is not possible.

by Former member

reading through these posts an am just wondering how we went from a post on Stem Cell research to rants on abortion. I'm a Libertarian, so leaving out a lot of religious/moral thoughts. It's the womens right, and they have to live with the choice not matter which they choose.

Now about stem cell research. I'm all for it, anything that has the potential to cure a disease should be pursued. If the Federal Government doesn't feel comfortable funding it, so be it, but that shouldn't make it illegal. i assume there are plenty of people out there with money willing to help fund it just to have something named after them.

by jdclyde

No one was talking about making the research illegal.

It all came down to the Republican that was getting the hatchet job done on him had voted against the GOVERNMENT paying for it. He had not voted to make it illegal.

I do not know if Fox was just mislead, or intentionally lied.

by hal 9000

On Embryonic Stem Cell Research. Personally from the reports that I've seen here about Fox and those adds he seems to me to be pushing the idea to remove the current legal restraints that are allowed on Embryonic Stem Cell Research not telling a Lie.

Isn't that his right just like the previous face of the US Debate on Stem Cell Research Christopher Reed to follow his beliefs and attempt to force the existing Government of his country into changing it's existing Laws?

Sorry JD but I thought that was what Democracy was all about. :D

Col

by techexec2

The abortion discussion was triggered by the last sentence of the original post:

[i]"...woman?s perceived right to murder her unborn child..."[/i]

by jdclyde

"Temporarily legal process of using a vacume to become unpregnant", maybe none of this conversation would have started? ;\

And of course, looking back it was me and only me that actually discussed the MJ Fox ad. Why is that?

by protiusx

I did want to discuss the issue of stem cell research. You would be interested to know that private companies do not do research with embryonic stem cell research because it has never been shown to be curative while adult stem cell research has already provided medical benefits that have been used in patients today.

by Former member

any sites that back this up. not that i don't want proof or don't believe you but would be interested in reading them.

by hal 9000

The main reason why Private Companies don't do any Embryonic Stem Cell Research is because of the Legal Hurdles placed in their way by the current Government.

They Mandate what can & Can Not be done to these cells and then insist that these private companies throw open their doors to random inspections with no guarantee that any [b]Secrets[/b] will not be passed onto a opposition company and allow them to reach a Patented Cure first. Or worse still some face;less Bureaucrat making an arbitrary decision on the spot that something is illegal and closing the place down while an investigation is undertaken.

Under those conditions there is no Sane Company on the Face of this Planet who would willing follow Embryonic Stem Cell Research in that country. Because of these stupid laws we will see some Scientist in an Unregulated third World Country make the break through that we are preventing ourselves from making and then we will be paying that Scientist either directly or through the Company that he worked for Millions of $ for the cure that he/she has come up with whatever that may be.

A great way to send the Developed world broke Bin Laden should have been developing Embryonic Stem Cell Research and when his Scientists came up with a cure he could have charged an [b]Arm & a Leg to the Infidels[/b] while giving it away free to his [b]True Believers.[/b]

That would be an act of self inflicted Terrorism on ourselves and we through our own Governments would be the ones to blame.

Besides there is one major breakthrough that has arisen because of [b]Embryonic Stem Cell Research and that is that Adult Stem Cells have Been Discovered Previously it was believed by the Medical & Scientific Communities that the didn't Exist.[/b]

Col

by tonythetiger

As I said to TT, it is the stretch of the "self defense rule" to also cover threat of serious emoptional/mental/physical harm that allows abortions to be legal (forcing a woman to have a child she doesn't want is considered to be harmful). Of course, in other cases of 'self-defense', the threat must be [b]proven[/b] to have been perceived, and be proven to have been perceived as being imminent, and in this case I wouldn't know how you'd go about doing that, nor do I understand why a man being forced to support a child he doesn't want would not be considered equally harmful.

by jdclyde

[i]"So I guess men are in charge of procreation then?
Rape, incest, poverty, coersion, ignorance are all causes of unwanted pregancy. So women don't have the right to choice in these cases. Abortion should not be used instead of proper birth control but there are cases where that is not possible."[/i]

Poverty and ignorance ARE things a woman has a choice about.
[b]Coersion IS rape,[/b] but must make you think there is more justification if you can keep saying the same thing using different words?

So, what does any of that have to do with there [b]NOT being a VALID "SELF-DEFENSE"[/b] argument for anything you have stated?

Or did you post in the wrong spot, intending to reply to something else?

by oldbag

An aquantance of mine suffered brain damage due to a tumour. She was a single mother to a young daughter. Guess what? Daddy split. Is it her fault that she was poor and could not hold a job, let alone find one?

The US and Canada both have large numbers of 'working poor'. Do these people not have rights or are they less worthly than us because they do not have the means to make a better living and those who enjoy a better standard of living do not want to pay them more because it may cause inflation?

What about the refugee who is attempting to make a better life for themself but is finding prejudice is blocking their advancement?

In hard financial times, large numbers find themselves without jobs because of layoffs. Do they not have rights?

In any of these cases, an unplanned pregnancy can occur. I advocate proper birth control over abortion but sometimes putting food on the table is the priority.

Do not tell me that they shouldn't 'do it' because I now go back to my list: rape, coersion (how about the teenage 'If you love me you will'), incest and so on.

by tonythetiger

Maybe devastating! (I had a girlfriend have an abortion without my knowledge of the pregnancy, and I can assure you that when I found out, I was! (Oh, but I'm a man... I can take it, right?))

I am, of course, only speaking in theory, but if a man can be forced into obligation, why should he not be allowed to assert his right? Or are you suggesting that he only has the right if he knows about it?

by maecuff

I've never said anywhere that a man should be able to take the pain of losing a child better than a woman. I truly am sorry that you had to suffer that, it must have been devestating.

And I am not suggesting that a man should have no rights concerning his offspring. I don't know the right answer here. I'm only saying that I believe that there are compelling reasons to keep abortion legal.

And as far as the hospital drop off stations go, I would not suggest that there wouldn't be pain and suffering to a mother or a father in making the decision to give up your child, however, if it saves children from being stuffed in a garbage can, then it is well worth it.

by tonythetiger

and I don't know the right answer either. I was just noting that men's 'pain and sufferring' seems to be treated less importantly in our society. One might wonder what might eventually become justifiable were this trend to continue.

by jdclyde

The suggestion is that "it isn't your body, you have no say in the matter".

Of course because of leftover discrimination against men, you will have to foot the bill if the woman decideds to keep the child against your will.

Of course because of leftover discrimination against men, you will have no say so of stopping the abortion if you WANT the child.

Of course because of leftover discrimination against men, she can have this child and then put it up for adoption, with you not having a right to get the child.

You are a wallet, nothing more, nothing less, so open up, sit down, and shut up.

by protiusx

Abortion is infanticide and Mae's argument is that the child would be better off dead than stuck as a child of a crack mother. Since when is dead better than anything? Since when did the mother get to "choose" whether a child deserves to live or die? The Germans did it in the 1930's where they killed retarded children. They stepped up to killing Jewish children in the late 1930's and early 1940's (a whole lot of them). There are a great many cultures who discard babies when times were tough. The Norsemen would take a newborn out into a snow storm and leave it for the wolves when times were tough or they didn't believe the child was strong enough to make it. Have we reverted to this place again in our culture where human like is so cheap?
I am a male and I am not a control freak as Mae alleges. I do believe in baring the consequences of our own actions though. We are each responsible for the things we do. It is the mother and fathers fault equally when a child is conceived. They may not have intended for it to be so but in today's day and age where birth control is so prevalent there should be no excuse.
I believe in truisms. A life is a life and deserves equal treatment under the law. An unborn child has the same rights to 'life' and 'liberty' as his or her parents do.

by protiusx

The issue is that removing the tissue from the fetus causes the fetus to become non-viable. Additionally, the only reason this has become an issue is that no private entity would fund research that has been proven to have no curative worth. So certain labs who see their only source of revenue (government grants) drying up cry fowl at the "religious fundamentalists.

by hal 9000

A question with a question but here I'm sorry but I can't help it. Do you know what happens to those Unused Stem Cells? They get flushed down a sink into a sewer so they are not Human Life as the Pro Lifers would like to see things they are treated as the garbage that they are. These are created by IVF Programs and those not used are mandated by Law to be disposed of after a certain time has elapsed.

While they are technically owned by Law by both parties involved in their creation they [b]Can Not[/b] be used if one party disagrees with their use so it's more than likely and quite often the case that these don't get used because of a Mans Right to deny their use. They will use arguments like I divorced her 5 years ago so why should I be paying Maintenance for a child that wasn't born before we separated?

Or in a recent case here where an extremely wealthy couple where undergoing IVF where killed and the estate tried to push it through the courts that the unused Embryos where the Legal Beneficiary's of the Estate there was not one Judge in any court that would agree with them and they where thrown down a sink as garbage.

Personally I don't have a desire either way but if something is going to be thrown out as Garbage shouldn't we have the right or the responsibility to recycle these items just like we do empty Beer Cans?

I actually get a good laugh when I hear people complain about Therapeutic Cloning as they get all carried away but they are the first who insist on using Cloned Skin on burn Victims particularly if they are their immediate family.

Currently you are correct there have been no major medical break through in Embryonic Stem Cell Research but there have been precious few with Adult Stem Cell Research either and even those that have been found have only come about through a Happy Mistake that isn't allowed to be used on Embryonic Stem Cells.

Col

by oldbag

Your example of the 13 year old boy is a little off the mark. Did he not eventually marry the mother of the child? It is my understanding that this couple does not even have custody of the children. But I digress.

If the boy could prove statuatory rape then, no, I do not believe that child support should forced upon him.

The decision to have a child should involve both parties. If one of the parties does not want to have a child then they should take appropriate action. While I feel that this should be discussed before it is a 'fact', errors occur.

'Years of servitude' can be applied to either the mother or the father. The child is blameless and should not be used as a pawn in a relationship battle. Unfortunately, this is not the case at times.

Abstinance is free and a child will never result. Unfortunately, men get more of a choice in that area than women do.

by jdclyde

does NOT mean that you have some RIGHT to recieve ANYTHING.

It is legal for me to buy a set of glasses, but I do NOT have a right to free glasses.

It is legal for me to get lasic surgery, but I do NOT have a right to free surgery.

I have a RIGHT to purchase any of these products that I can afford.

The poor poor have the same right to have anything that is LEGAL that they can AFFORD.

Sounds like your "friend" should file for disability which many states offer. There is a big difference between a disorder and someone that is just poor. If you are disabled, you get assistance from the government if you are unable to provide for yourself.

Quit going back to the minority of what is the root of the abortions out there to justify each and every abortion.

Rape has no place in the same discussion as someone that got knocked up, and you know it.

by maecuff

advocating infantcide. An infant and a fetus are two different things. An infant is not the same as a mass of cells. We can argue the differences from now until the end of time and we will not see this is the same way. But I can say, without a doubt, that I am in no way advocating infantcide, that is so misleading. I will have my first grandchild any day now and heaven help a person if they try to do her harm.

And I most certainly did NOT alledge that you are a control freak. I said that I believe that to be true for some men, but not all men. If YOU chose to put yourself in the 'control' category, that's your business. I know nothing about you, other than we disagree on many subjects, but I wouldn't claim to know enough about you to suggest you are a controlling person who hates and objectifies women.

I also believe equating abortion to the atrocities committed during WWII minimizes the pain and suffering that those people went through.

by tonythetiger

[i]If the boy could prove statuatory rape then, no, I do not believe that child support should forced upon him.[/i]

There have been several of these, the first two of which received major press. There was also at least one case where a man was slipped a mickey and his sperm extracted, and the court said that wasn't the child's fault, and he has to pay, and another where a nursing aid "raped" an elderly patient and ended up with a good chunk of his remaining assets. Those "shouldn't be" either, but are... because they are male.

And what of the Kentucky man who was imprisoned for rape, 12 years later proved innocent, released, then promptly re-arrested for not paying child-support for those 12 years, or the man in Virginia who was arrested for the same thing after being rescued from the American Embassy in Iran in 1978?

[i]'Years of servitude' can be applied to either the mother or the father.[/i]

But it can only be [b]forced[/b] onto the father! The woman can abort, or she can drop the newborn off at a "no questions asked" station.

Not that it's women's fault alone... men are just as much to blame... Take domestic violence for example. If a woman shows up at work with a black eye, everyone, male and female alike, hovers over them and cares for them... if a man does though, you hear whispers and snickering.

by protiusx

One question, since you said that you will have a granddaughter any day that would mean that she hasn't been born yet. According to your argument she isn't a person but a mere glob of cells that could be done away with and you wouldn't care one bit? Please.
If infanticide applies only to a child that has been born then what was that whole Mark Peterson mess in California about a few years back? Oh, I get it. He was a ?man? and therefore had no "choice". Had his wife aborted the little glob of flesh nothing would have been said. He was tried and convicted (rightly so) of the murder of his UNBORN son. What is that called? Fetuside?

by hal 9000

Unfortunately I bet you've never seen the other side.

Last time I was in the Philippines a predominately Catholic place I was at a hospital who diagnosed a Bust appendix on a 20 year old woman and then threw her out the door to die preferably not on their steps because her family didn't have the necessary funds for the operation to save her life.

In this place you are apparently condemned if you practise Birth Control but are allowed to die in agony if you don't have the money for the medical procedures to keep you alive.

Sorry but I don't see things quite the same way as you mainly because a foetus isn't alive in any sense of the word until it can survive independent of it's mother where it is effectively a Parasite on it's host.

And even if it survives who takes care of it when it's not wanted the [b]Tax Payer! That's Who![/b]

Col

by protiusx

The US government has in no way curtailed the private sector with respect to embryonic stem cells. They have (rightly so) put stipulations on embryonic stem cell research on agencies conducting said research while also receiving Federal subsidies.
Your comments are a bit paranoid. I don't know what's going on down there in clean green New Zealand but it's not happening here.

by maecuff

read my previous posts, you would know that I would never support late term abortions, with exceptions that would include extreme pain and suffering of the child or if the mother's life was in danger. My granddaughter is due any day now, she is not a mass of cells. Early in the pregnancy, that's what the fetus is, a mass of cells.

You have misquoted a couple of things I've posted. Why do you feel the need to do that? I would think your beliefs are strong enough to stand on their own without having to twist the words of others.

by protiusx

Even if this constitutes "very few" it is more than "none".
This was taken from:
http://www.21stcenturysciencetech.com/articles/winter01/stem_cell.html

" Moreover, very promising treatments of serious diseases with adult stem cells have already been tried. The special advantage is that there are no rejection reactions, because the cells are from the same body.

Of longer standing is treatment with bone marrow stem cells. The treatment comes into play when, for example, a patient has lost his or her blood-forming tissue through radiation or high-dose chemotherapy. Previously removed bone marrow stem cells are then retransplanted, and are able to resume the formation of blood cells.

In 2001, however, a team of doctors at the Duesseldorf University Clinic carried out a treatment of very far-reaching consequences. For the first time, they treated a cardiac infarct patient with stem cells from his own body. The cardiologist, Prof. Bodo Eckehard Strauer, is sure that the stem cells from the patient?s bone marrow, after injection into the infarct zone, autonomously converted to heart muscle. The functioning of the severely damaged heart clearly improved within a few weeks.

Four days after the infarction, the doctors took bone marrow from the patient?s pelvis using local anesthesia. The stem cells in the marrow were concentrated outside of the body and implanted in the infarct area the next day with a special technique via a coronary artery. However, the doctors could not yet take cardiac tissue to prove definitively that the implanted blood stem cells had converted to heart muscle cells. But, according to Strauer, there is no other way to explain the marked improvement in the patient?s condition. After this first successful operation, six more patients have already been treated with their own stem cells, with similarly positive results.

There are also reports of successful treatments with adult stem cells in cases of Crohn?s disease (a chronic infection of the gut), thalassemia (a blood disease), and a rare skin disease. And?despite the fact that basic research with adult stem cells is in its earliest beginnings and is in no way being promoted with urgency?there have been a growing number of reports lately of experiments with animals, from which it emerges that adult stem cells can successfully transform themselves into differentiated cells of organs of many kinds.

In contrast, reports of successful conversions of embryonic stem cells are very infrequent and cautious. Thus, we find in Science of Dec. 1, 2000 (Vol. 290, pp. 1672-1674): "In contrast, the human embryonic stem cells and fetal germ cells that made headlines in November 1998 because they can, in theory, develop into any cell type have so far produced relatively modest results. Only a few papers and meeting reports have emerged from the handful of labs that work with human pluripotent cells. . . . The work suggests that it will not be simple to produce the pure populations of certain cell types that would be required for safe and reliable cell therapies. . . ."

by hal 9000

They where doing Bone Marrow Transplants not Bone Marrow Stem Cells Transplants as the Bone Marrow was removed prior to the treatment that was going to destroy it.

As for Embryonic Stem Cell Research the actual Stem Cells have the nucleus removed and replaced with the recipients DNA so they effectively remain the [b]Same Tissue[/b] without the possibility of rejection. There are many problems involved here not the least of which is that this is a form of Cloning that many people feel threatened by as it drags up false images of some Mad Scientist producing several of the same person.

1 GWB is scary enough for me I don't even want to consider 20 of them wandering around but this is what many people think of when the word [b]Cloning[/b] is used. I saw exactly the same thing up North at an installation where some radar equipment was being developed as there where [b]Danger Electromagnetic Radiation[/b] signs all over the fence so the people of the town immediately got terrified and thought that they where all being Nuked by Nuclear Radiation and didn't understand that Electromagnetic Radiation is different to Nuclear Radiation.

When you deal with the [b]Average Person[/b] you have to allow for the lowest common dominator as that is bound to be the one that rises to the surface and causes panic.

From my knowledge most Adult Stem Cells are extracted from the Nasal Cavity as this is the richest source of Adult Stem Cells. [i]I do work for a guy that is into this and he's promised to make at least 5 clones of me to keep me around.[/i] SO I have a slight advantage over the majority here in knowing what is currently underway in the Research. If you think that Embryonic Stem Cell Research is in it's infancy Adult Stem Cell Research is even younger and while they can in the Lab get these cells from both lines to reproduce they as yet have not found the necessary switches that make them form different tissue or organs. Currently there is a lot of work on both the Heart & Liver as these are necessary organs that are impossible to live without and any Human Trials by reputable Scientists are a very long way off as yet.

While I'm not sure of the quoted article I would hazard a guess of lets [b]Suck it & See what Happens[/b] as we can't do any more harm. But I'll ask about it today and see what answer I get back though I know that from the people that I deal with everyone of them is saying that any Human Trials are a long way off yet.

That doesn't mean that you will not get some rich wacko who is desperate and willing to try anything untested that may or may not work occurring.

Col

by hal 9000

It's the Mothers responsibility to look after that baby. Hence the Drug Abuse causing the termination of the Foetus is considered as Murder not Death.

So in every case where the Foetus Dies at the very least shouldn't there be a enquiry into that death? Something like a Coroners Inquest but with the female undergoing extreme Medical testing to see if they have done anything wrong.

Even driving without a seat belt not worn and in an ensuring collision that causes the foetus to die can be constricted as Murder actually for that case the wearing of a Seat Belt could be constricted as attempted Murder as it places the Foetus [b]At Risk.[/b]

Sorry mate but this is just way to slippery slope to even consider starting down, the pitfalls are way to great and with our current level of medical understanding impossible to reach a reasonable outcome that is fair to all parties involved.

Col

by jdclyde

Anything can be excused these days if it is a woman doing it to a man.

If you are gay, there are also people that will stand up for you. (unless you are a republican senator)

Straight men don't have a chance unless you are rich enough to buy justice.

by jdclyde

and the statement Fox made about the Republican trying to make it illegal are false, thus a lie.

The vote was to NOT provide governmental funding for the research, not to BAN the research.

So no, you heard wrong.

by techexec2

I checked it out. The Michael J. Fox ad did not lie about Senator Talent. It said:

[i]"Senator Talent even wanted to criminalize the science that gives us a chance for hope"[/i]

Michael J. Fox ad
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a9WB_PXjTBo

-----

[i]"Since joining the Senate in 2002, Talent had supported federal legislation that would ban embryonic stem cell research. This included co-sponsoring a bill (S.658) [20] sponsored by Senator Sam Brownback which would ban all forms of human cloning including embryonic therapeutic cloning techniques that are seen as crucial to stem cell research."[/i]

Jim Talent and his opposition to stem cell research
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Talent#Stem_Cell_Research

-----

Senate bill 658
Prohibits human cloning (essential part of embryonic stem cell research)
Sponsor: Sam Brownback, KS (R)
http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/bdquery/z?d109:s.00658:

Senate bill 658 cosponsors (31 Republicans, 1 Democrat)
Talent cosponsored 3/17/2005
Talent withdrew 2/10/2006
http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/bdquery/z?d109:SN00658:@@@P

edit: correction to cosponsor count

by jdclyde

I was NOT advocating that this be classified as murder.

This came from the statement that abortion was self-defense in the cases that the womans life were placed in danger by the pregnacy.

I only pointed out how flawed THAT is, because the majority of abortions are NOT performed because of anything life threatening, unless you consider SOCIAL-life dying an issue. Hard to be a bar tramp with a litter of kids at home. Really cuts into the beer money.

by jdclyde

or are you directing this only at the US government?

Is it really only the US government that has restrictions and monitoring of fetal stem cell research?

by hal 9000

SO I would imagine that they are fairly similar.

This I do defiantly know any place doing Embryonic Stem Cell Research has to open their research to both he Ethics Board and the Government. They are subject to Random Inspection by people who read their directions out of Hand Books and generally speaking have no training or understanding of what is happening if it Ain't in the book its wrong. Period and the place is shut down which effectively means any work is destroyed until a full investigation can be performed. For this reason there is no Cutting Edge Research happening here and they can only work with several established lines of Embryonic Stem Cells. New lines [b]Can Not be added.[/b]

When this Law was drawn up here it was almost a direct copy word for word of the then US Legislation and as things have been altered over the years amendments have been made to our Laws here. Generally speaking we follow the US Legislation quite closely and if it can't be done here it certainly can't be done there.

Col

by tonythetiger

The various states that comprise the US have many different, and sometimes conflicting laws. Scott Peterson, for example, who was convicted of two counts of murder for killing his pregnant wife, would have been guilty of only one count had the crime occurred in, say, Massachusetts.

by protiusx

Firstly, when have I ever admitted to killing?

Secondly, what utter nonsense. Have I ever suggested that life consists of biologic mass? No, I have not. Your argument is not only illogical but nonsensical as well. While a fetus' relationship to the mother can be compared to that of a parasite the two are not the same. Do parasites become the progeny of their hosts? Does cancerous tissue form into a living entity? Does it develop a brain, heart, lungs and eventually separate from the person and live autonomously? Quite being ridiculous.

by hal 9000

As there are only 2 women that I personally know of that have had Surgical Terminations and both where affected by cancer which was being told would literally explode thought their bodies if the pregnancy was to run it's course with the most likely outcome of the female dieing before the foetus even came close to term.

Apparently Female Hormones in Pregnancy and Cancer are not a good mix. Both after their treatments have gone on to have perfectly healthy children.

There is also one case where the Placenta started acting like a cancer that I know of and at the birth the woman had to undergo a Radical Hysterectomy to remain alive as the placenta was spreading through her body and not remaining on the inner wall of the uterus. All of these where things that I had to be in Theatre for when I was dong Medical Work and the last one was a messy business.

Actually JD I did read some of the above but as they are stupid I tried to keep away, there where just a couple of interesting ones that I jumped in on when they seemed wrong to my way of reading things but I've read everything above.

Now just to throw a spanner in the works here. ]:)

If the Foetus is alive what is the Placenta and Umbilical Cord? And if this is Human Tissue why should it be removed?

Col

by maecuff

So Lorena Bobbit was aquitted. That sword cuts both ways. I mean, a wealthy former athlete can cut off his ex-wife's head and still be found on the golf course, right?

by jdclyde

the individual you are refering to DID have the money to buy himself justice. Store-bought justice is not the same as what is common mortals recieve.

And a bit of a difference in the case, because there was never a question in court about the Bobitt case on if she did it or not, and she never denied it. This changes the example just a little bit, would you not say?

OJ had a sloppy prosecutor.

by onbliss

Based on the article, looks like Rush acknowledged he was incorrect and apologized to Fox.

Did Rush not do his research properly? Is'nt it going to hurt his side little bit now that he has managed to bring attention to this advt. to many who would not viewed it or given more thoughts to it, especially if Rush was proved wrong?

I do not know much about the disease; was Fox playing up his affiliction for dramatic effect?

by protiusx

Fox is using his infirmity to further his political ideology. That's just wrong. I have compassion for the man but I think it was bad form for him to use his illness to further the political aspirations of others.

by onbliss

Looking at both the parties; each seem to be using points that could get it elected. Democrats used the Foley case; and some Republicans have said Democrats are just using it for political gains. Republicans have talked about terror; and some Democrats have said it is a political ploy to get votes.

In essence each side seems to be blaming the other when the other seems to have successfully utilized an opportunity to highlight something.

When both parties are going to each other, how is something decided to be a bad form?

disclaimer: I am a fan of M.J.Fox. Don't pelt me with stones, but I liked the "Back to the Future" series movies :-) I can still watch those movies.

by protiusx

I think we own a few. Deep down inside I think that Michael J Fox is a pretty nice guy.
Your right that there is a lot of mud slinging going on and its unfortunate. As a conservative I will and have always called a spade a spade. Foley is a sleaze bag who is attempting to play the victim. I am sure there is a lot more going on there than what we are hearing about. These are our elected representatives and they get to DC and run amok. During the recent three way debates here in Washington State the candidates were asked about their position on drug legalization. The libertarian was all for it (go figure) the Democrat was not. When they got to the Republican he said that not only did he disagree with legalization of drugs but he advocated mandatory drug testing for all welfare recipients. The libertarian fired back that he advocated mandatory drug and alcohol testing for all members of congress. You know what? That?s not a bad idea.

by maecuff

that God will judge. Apparently, he's passed that torch to you? What a good Christian you are.