Discussion Locked

Network file permissions dont accumulate

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Am I going crazy. I thought file and directory permissions were additive. If you were in two groups and they had different permissions for the same directory (neither are no access) then the resulting permissions are the sum of the two. Is this affected by trusts. I have a resource server in a resource domain that is in a trust with the login domain. If a person is in two groups their permissions for a directory are the least of the two groups permissions. Set me straight, please.

5 replies

by avachon

Hi, ntfs permissions are cumulative. However, when you have a combination of share and ntfs permissions, the most restrictive applies. What you are seeing then, is the most restrictive set because of the share/ntfs combination. Hope this helps.

by robert.tillotson

share permissions for this share are full control for everyone. the ntfs permissions are the most restrictive in this case: one group the person is a member of is Full Control the other is RX and the RX is what seems to be in effect. When the person is removed form the group with the RX security permissions she then has full control again as intended. Something else must be involved, but I can't see it.

by culizard

You should double check that the files and the directory they're in have the same permissions. ie. If the directory and the files are set differently you could have some strange interactions. I'd suggest initially checking the permissions on the directory, and if its the way you want, check the box to replace permissions on all files and subfolders, and click ok. Then have the user attempt to access it. It could be that there's some rogue permission set that's screwing the whole thing up. Good luck.

This discussion is closed to new replies.