Question Locked

New at this - How to set policy to prevent files from deletion...

0 helpful
14 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
A slight problem at work has prompted my boss to ask me to make sure that none of our users (about 7 of them, some using Windows ME and others using XP) can delete files stored on their hard drives. I'm sure this is a fairly simple policy to put into effect, I'm just not sure where to start. Someone directed me to TechRepublic and here I am! This seems to be a really informative website. Thank you all for any help you can provide for me.

14 replies

by sgt_shultz

you'll need some third party software for this. ME can't be member of a domain so you can't control with group policy.
so first step is: upgrade to XP

by jbltmua

No, I'm not joking. I appreciate your quick reply. We do have a domain with ME computers connected. I'm not asking to have them controlled by group policy. Is there a way to prevent files from being deleted on each physical computer? Like I said, I'm new at this and not ME proficient. I am not able to upgrade to XP at this time, so that is out of the question.

by sgt_shultz

i do not know of a way to do this in ME. I can't remember that far back anymore. seems to me you'd need to format the file systems as ntfs then maybe you'd have control by assigning permissions, or rather unassigning delete permissions.
how about write protecting the files you want to protect against deletion.
maybe others can help.
or maybe you could let us know what you are trying to accomplish (disaster recovery?) and we could propose other solutions.
why is deleting files a problem?

by jbltmua

My boss has recently found a few issues with sensitive files being deleted by users. She asked me to make it impossible for any files to be deleted from the users' hard drives. We have a very small facility and no definitive IT department. I've been the "Techie" since my employment because I knew more than anyone else about computers. But, as you said, ME is just terrible, and I'm not sure how to do much with that operating system. I just need to be able to "secure" each individual hard drive so nothing can be deleted. I still think the users should have the ability to modify files, just not delete them permanently, as some are sensitive and need to be retained. I'm really at a standstill with the project. I'm just not sure where to start. I need to keep the data protected and the users working, but not suspicious of my actions, because we don't need any additional files being deleted in the mean time. I really appreciate your concern and help. Thanks so much!

by sgt_shultz

usually when i open by big mouth, plenty of others jump in to correct me. so hang on, others may have better input. but i think you are beginning to suspect a couple things:
1) bosses never say what they want accomplished, they always say 'how' they want you to do stuff. So be ready to reform their requirement for them (So, boss, you want me to secure the pc's so that no files can be permanently lost, yes?) and 2) you can't write protect an entire hard drive and still boot the thing.
here are a couple ideas:
1) put the files in a folder and write protect the folder.
2) run backups every 5 minutes through the day to a network location.
3) buy some 'undelete' software (recommended)

by jbltmua

My boss is cool, but she's not hip to "tech speak" as she calls it. She just asked me to find a way to make it impossible to delete files, and I had no idea how to do it, so I said I'd look into it.

I have to actually sit down at the computers in question and try out some of your suggestions. Unfortunately, I have to stay past work hours to do so, but I think I can arrange it this afternoon. I've never really used ME for anything other than the internet, so I'm drawing a blank until I actually sit at the computer. I use XP at work, but we still have a few users on ME, and they just so happen to be the computers the boss wants "fixed" so they can't delete files.

We do a nightly tape backup on the server, but not of individual hard drives. We have a shared drive on our server that everyone uses to access shared files. It seems that some users are saving files locally, and thus these files cannot be backed up by our server.

I just got a copy of System Mechanic 6 Pro from a friend and I'm going to try it out tonight on a dummy hard drive to see if that will recover past deleted files.

I appreciate your concern and help. Thank you so much.

by locolobo

If you right click on a file or folder do you get a security tab? If so explore the permissions. I'm not sure how to allow them to modify the files without being able to delete them. Maybe somebody else will clarify that.

Another idea would be to back them up every night. If your already doing that, sorry. It might be a workaround.

by jbltmua

I don't know much about ME, either. I'm hoping there will be room in the next budget year for some XP upgrades! But for now, ME is what I have to work with.

I haven't sat down at the ME computers just yet, so I cannot answer your question. I assume there will be a security tab. I'm hoping this afternoon when I have the ability to mess around with these computers I will be able to figure it out.

It wouldn't be possible for me to back them up every night. Not at this point, anyway. I leave at the same time as the users, and everyone turns off their computer at the end of the day. If I can't find anything out tonight by sitting at the computers, I'll have to take the next step and see if I can change my hours or something, so I can stay here longer than everyone else and back up the computers every day. I hope it doesn't come to that. Ugh.

Thank you for your insight. I appreciate your help!

by rob miners

If your users do not use shift + del there is a good chance that the files are in the Recycle Bin. You could try setting a Policy with your Users not to delete Read Only Files. If you use the Attrib Function in a Batch File to make the files Read Only. EG: Attrib + r c:\data\*.doc and run it on a schedule every hour or so.
If your Users right mouse click on a File to Delete it a dialogue box appears "Confirm File Delete"
The file Test.txt is a read-only file. Are you sure you want to move it to the Recycle Bin? You have two options. Yes or No.
It should't take them too long to get the idea.

by jbltmua

...isn't something done well by my users, unfortunately. haha

I'll have to try out your suggestions this evening when I gain access to the computers.

Thank you very much for your help!

by cmiller5400

Win ME machines do not support NTFS, so therefore your options are limited as to how to stop users from deleting files. There may be a third party program that can do this, but I would check out software such as Executive Software's Undelete. You can set it up to capture deleted files and hold them in a recovery bin.

Win NT, 2000, and XP machines can utilize NTFS which you can set to deny on the delete right. One caveat is that some programs when you save the file actually write the file to a temp file and then delete the file you are saving to and then rename the temp file to the filename that you saved it to.
Also be aware that if you do not know what you are doing in the security tab, you can lock yourself out of the files with no easy way to recover them. Read up on NTFS permissions before you go touching them. Remember, Deny permissions ALWAYS take priority over allow.

by jbltmua

I'm going to look into the Undelete program. Executive Software's Diskeeper is an excellent program, so I can imagine Undelete is good as well. I wasn't aware that ME did not support NTFS.

I really appreciate your insight. Thank you so much for helping me!

by jbltmua

I'm looking into Executive Software's Undelete program now. I can't seem to find if it works on Windows ME machines. I'm continuing my search, but if you read this and happen to know the answer, please let me know!

Also, have you (or anyone else reading) ever used Undelete?

Thanks!

This discussion is closed to new replies.