Discussion Locked

NT System files and Boot files on RAID 5

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I have read in several sources that it is not a good idea to load the system files and boot files for the NT operating system on a stripped disk with parity, what are the reasons for this and the possible implications?

5 replies

by ian mclaws

Depends on whether you are talking about hardware RAID, or software.
RAID 5, as provided in the NT o\s, is not only not recommended for the system \ boot files, it won't work at all! NT's software RAID depends on a file calles ftdisk.sys, which is a driver that writes and reads data to\from the stripeset. This file must be loaded before the RAID 5 array can be read, which is impossible if the file (one of the NT files) is on a stripeset itself (what reads and loads it if the stripeset is inaccessible without it?)
With hardware RAID, the stripeset is read by the hardware RAID controller itself, and therefore can be used for the system \ boot files. (A caution, however. If you plan to use hardware RAID, you should ensure that the swap file(pagefile.sys) is NOT on the stripeset, as this causes massive fragmentation and a decrease in performance.)

Good luck,

Ian

by msgtray

Ian has explained hardware and software RAID implementation very well but I disagree on one point. The statement that a pagefile on a RAID5 volume causes massive fragmentation is not quite accurate. Default settings for virtual memory in NT cause massive fragmentation. There is an article posted here in Tech Republic that examined that issue very well.

Ian is partially correct for a different reason. You do not want to place any pagefile on a SOFTWARE implementation of RAID-0 or 5. The reason is simply speed. All data written to a software RAID volume must be processed through the OS before being written to disk (a hardware RAID card has it?s own processor/controller). The pagefile contains information that needs to be swapped directlyto and from RAM. Sending this information to the OS to be redirected to the software stripe set injects a non-linear delay into the CPU processing (Non-linear because processing the pagefile for disk access may generate page faults which would require paging portions of the pagefile, similar to a paradox)

A hardware RAID controller combines the individual drives before the OS loads. There is no difference, from the aspect of the way data is processed, from a hardware RAID set and a single drive of equivalent size, speed, and throughput. A pagefile may reside on a hardware-controlled volume set with the same considerations given to a single drive.

Ray

This discussion is closed to new replies.