Discussion Locked

Obama proposes world welfare program at US tax payers expense

0 helpful
259 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

259 replies

by Former member

the deep bayous in the south? Have you seen the swollen bellies from hunger? Have you seen infants dieing from hunger and disease?

This happens right here in our own backyard. Because we are acclaimed to be the most prosperous nation in the world, it is overlooked. Everything you find in Ethiopia and Somalia you will find in our own south - and more.

If you want to take it out of the south, have you ever heard of "Dogtown" in Los Angeles. If you have not, it was, when I lived in L.A. a small area just to the north and east of the University of Southern California. It is named so because the city dog pound is not far away. For the fortunate few a cardboard house was good luck. So that you know, skid row was about three miles away on Main street. Dogtown was so dangerous that the police refused to enter.

Lets spread a little, have you ever been in the hobo camps? Ahh... railroad tramps who needs them?

I stand by my statement, some of the worst poverty in the world. Take care of our own first!

Who is taking care of us?

by nicknielsen

I'm not saying it's right that Americans live in poverty, but to try to compare pockets of poverty in America to the widespread abject poverty elsewhere strikes me as disingenuous.

The statistics I'm finding indicate that about 13% of Americans live below the poverty line, with about 10 million people (only 3 in every 100,000 Americans) going hungry daily. Compare that to [b]billions[/b] of people, about a billion of them children, in the rest of the world.

Half these people are living on less than a dollar a day. Their children are dying before the age of 5, of malnutrition and disease, in annual numbers equal to the populations of larger US states. Their governments don't care about them and they don't have a local food kitchen or shelter. I don't see where it begins to compare.

Links:
http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/poverty/poverty.html
http://www.secondharvest.org/learn_about_hunger/fact_sheet/poverty_stats.html
http://www.globalissues.org/TradeRelated/Facts.asp
http://www.soundvision.com/Info/poor/statistics.asp

Edit: to answer your emotional straw man:
No I've not been in the bayous, but I've been in Kurdish and African refugee camps. Multiply your bayou child or two by dozens or hundreds to get an idea of the difference in scale.

by Former member

As you said, it is a matter of scale:
"A little anecdotal nugget. In January 1996 the exchange rate was 3,000 Saddam dinars to US$1.00."
http://old.krg.org/docs/articles/clarrysf-economic-problems-ik-june03.asp

Wish I was poor because I could not live on $3000 per day.

A few years ago, I did a research report on poverty in the U.S. for an English class. To be polite, it was difficult finding relevant research on U.S. poverty that was not politicized. One thing was certain in this though, that one thing is that the Web is the worlds biggest rumor mill. The information that you present from the census dept. is dated at best and downright wishful at worst (there are three kinds of lies - lies, damned lies, and statistics).

I often use the Web to begin research, but I approach the data with cynicism and pessimism. After I have the basic data, I then begin looking in journals and other research papers. I always look for what the person is trying to spin and ask why.

I think I answered your "Straw Man" argument. There is a huge difference between the refugee camp and the country.

by nicknielsen

My father was in the USAF and was killed (car wreck) when I was six. My mother (and her four sons) moved back to upstate New York to be close to her family. Our only income was survivor's benefits; she never worked full time. Hand-me-down clothes was something [u]everybody[/u] wore. TV? For 10 years, we had a 14" black & white that got 2-1/2 channels (ABC only came in good half the time). We ate casserole for dinner three or four nights a week, and a lot of leftovers. I only remember going out to eat once or twice. Don't remember eating steak at all until after my first summer helping with haying (everybody got paid with a half-cow, cut and wrapped.)

We weren't rich by any stretch of the imagination, but I never thought we were poor. It wasn't until I was in my twenties that I realized I had grown up in "poverty."

Poverty exists in the US. I know it does and those in deep rural areas usually have no way out without assistance. But it irritates the crap out of me to see a segment on poverty shot in an urban neighborhood, with a car (or two!) at the curb, and Dad holding a beer, puffing away on a cigarette. That's not poverty, that's poor spending.

Aside: Most of the developing countries [u]are[/u] primarily rural. The camps are the shining lights that obscure the background.

by mgordon

"We cannot fight the war on terror without also fighting the war on global poverty..."

Wars are fought between opponents. Poverty is not an opponent, it is a word that describes a "lack". You cannot "fight" a lack, therefore there can be no war against a lack.

A fellow by the name of Malthus assures us that we can never win this "war" of which you speak, we can never fill every cup.

Two thoughts:

1. If you feed squirrels, what do you get? More squirrels. You might fill every cup today and you'll be filling ten cups in 20 years for each cup today.

2. Mark Skousen, economist and professor has much to say on this topic.(Google "skousen socialism"). An anecdote attributed to one of the Skousens (might be Cleon Skousen) is a classroom situation. After a test, the class voted to distribute the surplus test scores (those over 80 percent, let's say) to those scoring under 80, and in this manner all can pass. On the next test, most failed; for what happened was that the hardworking students realized they needed only 80 and there was absolutely no reason to push beyond 80. The lazy students were still lazy, and the overall class average dropped substantially. This is the failure of socialism, a misplaced belief that there is "enough to go around" and the only problem is distribution. The failure of every large socialist economy in the world is proof that it does not work. On small scales it will work for a while (Iceland, Sweden) where you have strong social conditioning so that people do not immediately become lazy.

"It's not some hair-brained scheme that Mr. Obama cooked up....the Millenium Development Goals were put together in 2002."

Regardless of who cooked it up, Mr. Obama put this hairbrained scheme before Congress, it has his name on it.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I think a policy of symmetrical tariffs and ending all corporate welfare would have many of the desired effects, and very likely to a greater extent.

by mgordon

"Is it a lost liberty to provide ID to board a plane?"

Yes. Until recently it was not necessary to carry "papers" of any kind especially if you are using public transportation.

If you lose your I.D. while traveling, you could have a serious problem getting home, even if you only went to Indiana.

"Is it a lost liberty to have your bags inspected to board a plane?"

Yes; it seems to violate some concept of search and seizure, some concept of privacy. I don't really care much, but I've had quite a few things stolen during those searches and I don't like my neatly folded clothing to come out all rumpled at the end of the flight.

"Is it a lost liberty to have your call listened to if you are talking to someone outside of the country that is on a terrorist watch list? (remember, it is ONLY calls to and from outside the country that were effected at all..."

The word is "affected" and yes, it is a violation of your privacy.

"How have YOU, directly, ever lost ANY civil liberties?"

See the above. When I joined the Navy, I flew regularly with no identification whatsoever, no inspection. They needed one thing only -- money, coin of the realm.

When inspections and metal detectors first began to be used, one day I left my Botswains knife (pronounced "Bosuns"; big marlinspike on its back edge) in my pocket. The inspector says, "What is this?" Obviously a knife. I said, "It's a Botswains knife and I'm a sailor" (I was in uniform). He said, "Okay" and that was that. If I were to try it today, I would lose the knife and possibly be detained.

More recently I carried my networking tools with me. They are expensive. Some are sharp. I can no longer carry my networking tools onboard aircraft, and I dare not check them into baggage and they don't like the high power X-ray.

"I would really love to hear a thoughtful reply, because I hear people say such things, but have never heard an example of how they were effected."

I was "effected" several decades ago by my parents :-) and as for being affected, I've describe a few of the effects above.

The best people to answer you cannot answer, for they have been detained without civil rights whatsoever.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Trade tariff symmetry would do more to solve both foreign and domestic poverty than any [b]spending[/b] project, and that can be accomplished unilaterally: by sliding our tariffs to exactly equal whatever US-based companies are being charged, to do business ... wherever. I suppose that would inconvenience the ultra-wealthy, but there's fewer o' them than there is of us, so that's still much better than a zero-sum game. It's a major improvement, with only a minor cost, or a side benefit, depending whether you have any ultra-wealthy friends.

by protiusx

I was talking with my nine year old the other day about the ?N? word and why it is a bad word to say. We had a long discussion about racism, civil rights, equal rights and the duplicity of our national culture. This duplicity was displayed in full force by B. Hussein Obama when he referred to his grandma as a ?typical white person?. So what would happen if John McCain would have referred to a black person he knew as a ?typical black person?? His chances of becoming president would have been flushed down the toilet with those unfortunate words.

Why is there a double standard in our country? Why do we allow a group known as the ?National Association for the Advancement of Colored People? to exist when its mere existence is racist? What would happen if we had the ?National Association for the Advancement of White People?? They would be lauded as ?racists? and ?bigots?! So why the double standard? Why do we have ?Miss Black America?? Or ?Black Entertainment Television? The duplicity is astounding!

I have for years espoused a single standard for all. ?Equal rights for all; Special rights for none!? is my battle cry! That is what it is to be an American. What ever happened to Dr. King?s message where he said his dream was a future where each person was judged NOT by the color of their skin but by the content of their character?

B. Hussein Obama has been indoctrinated in this very ideology that throws mud onto the words of Dr. King and raises the history and lamentations of one race over those of any other. He openly supports world communism and will if elected push our country more toward a Marxist government. I for one, pray we never see the day.

by protiusx

Oh and by the way - I saw Canadians there when I was there. So, your country is (or rather was before they ran away from their commitment) fighting the war on terror along side it's southern ally.

by jamesrl

Canada was committed to Afghanistan since day one. In fact we even agreed to change our role from security in Kabul to leading the fight in the much less secure area around Khandahar.

Canada, as a country, NEVER committed to support the US in Iraq. Before the invasion Canada did try to broker a deal that would see once last chance for Saddam to come clean (and a chance to have the whole UN come in) but both the US and France/Germany rejected it without any consideration. Canada at no time joined the coalition in Iraq.

If you are trying to say Canada ran away, how about you PM me your address so I can give it to the buddies of some Canadian soldiers who have died in Afghanistan, I'm sure they'd love to convince you that they never ran away from anything. Of course you could apologise...

If you saw Canadians in Iraq, you saw them there as people working for contractors or NGOs. There was some talk about asking Canadians to train the police (as they have done in Haiti and Afghanistan) but our government never accepted that role.

James

by jdclyde

Establishing a tax and handing it over to the bastaards in the UN is NEVER a good idea or good policy.

by protiusx

I saw them, spoke with them, and interacted with them as part of the MULTI-NATIONAL FORCES in IRAQ. I wasn't hallucinating (while I was surprised to see them there) and their presence was slightly smaller than the contingency sent from MONGOLIA but they WERE there and DID participate in the "Coalition".

Regardless of what you think you know or what you want to believe this is the truth. From what I remember the Canadians played a large role in training the newly hired civilian police officers who daily put their lives on the line (and often times lost them) in an effort to stabilize their own country.

Iraq is the way it is because of external Islamic terrorists from Iran, Syria, Jordan, and Saudi Arabia. Persian Shiites from Iran are delivering ordinance to the Shiite Militia inside Iraq (operated by that murdering sycophant Muqtada El Sadr). Sunni factions are getting weapons and money from their Al Qaeda backers in Syria, Jordan, and Saudi Arabia. There is no vested interest for these countries (who are ruled by oligarchies and fiefdoms) to support a stable Iraq. They pay lip service to the west indicating they want their Muslim brothers to prosper in Iraq but silently plot to destabilize Iraq. Democracy is inherently liberal to the ideologies that the Muslim leaders espouse. It is contrary to their own best interests and so they will not stand by and watch as Iraq prospers under a democratic government. They need to show the Muslim world (the vast majority of which is illiterate) that democracy is a bad idea and that the average Muslim is better served by adhering to the fatwa?s of his Mullah.

by jamesrl

Canada has never been part of the "Coalition of the willing" and no Canadian units have gone to Iraq to participate in war.

Canada naval units did provide escort to the US fleet during the active period of invasion, since they were already in the area for the Afghanistan efforts to ensure arms didn't arrive in the gulf that were destined for the Taliban.

I also understand that some CAF C130s made training runs in Iraq.

When the peacekeepers were kidnapped a few years back some of our special forces (JTF2) came in for the raid on the compound where the kidnappers were.

The RCMP (not a military unit) trained Iraqi cadets in Jordan (not in Iraq proper).

Some Canadian officers participated in training command in Bagdhad - under NATO command.

Of course, since you were there, you would be aware that at any given time, there are hundreds of exchange forces personnel between the US and Canada. And if and when the unit that the exchange soldiers are in goes to Iraq, then of course the Canadians on exchange go along. There were Canadians in the invasion, but they were attached to US units.

If you wanna back up the claims, come up with a unit name.

We did also contribute by increasing our contributions in Afganistan which allowed the US to reallocate units from there to Iraq.

James

by nicknielsen

[i]Iraq is the way it is because of external Islamic terrorists from Iran, Syria, Jordan, and Saudi Arabia.[/i]

I haven't had such a good laugh in weeks.

Iraq is the way it is today because the US invaded. All other "causes" are insignificant in the face of that one.

by jdclyde

The double standards are everywhere.

If you are against affirmative action, you are called racist. how is refusing to discriminate against non-blacks racist?

The very idea of affirmative action in this day says that blacks are NOT as good/smart/qualified to make it based upon their merits and so we need to lower the standards for these substandard people? how can that NOT be insulting to treat people like that based upon the color of their skin?

Anyone here ever met a token black hire? I have, and they are rarely qualified or pleasent to be around. They don't HAVE to try because no one will say "boo" to them for fear of being called a racist over expecting them to do a days work for a days pay.

It was a great day in Michigan when we repealed affirmative action.

by jck

Affirmative Action should be banned. It is, at its very core, discriminatory.

As for what ProtiusX said before you...

I am sure that when Barack Obama called his grandmother a "typical white person" he didn't mean it derrogatorily or in a racist manner. He probably meant it as "average". He wouldn't be the first politician who worded something wrong.

If so, then John McCain should be booted out of congress for calling his wife a "c**t" and being a total a$$hole.

by jdclyde

Maybe his wife IS a c**t. That doesn't make him unelectable.

Maybe he IS and a$$hole. Character doesn't matter, right?

The WAY Obama implied about his grandmother was that TYPICAL white people ARE racist, just like his dear old Grammy that raised his ungrateful a$$. Speaking of Grammy, I don't suppose you noticed at the beginning of his run they had a pic of his Grammy, but while it was the NAME of the Grammy that raised him, it was his BLACK Grammy that didn't raise him. They were afraid of him being "to white" for him to get the black vote.

There isn't a one of the three that is worth two bits, nor would any of the three be representing Us, the average citizen.

Obama will destroy our fragile economy, and is the single worst selection.

The other two will still be horrible. That is why none of THEM will get my vote.

Anyone voting for Obama just hasn't been paying attention and are giving him a free pass because he is black, plain and simple.

by jamesrl

Has gone down a terrible path.

Because there have been major issues with a very high drop out rate with black students, the board was pressured into creating a "Afro Centric" school. It won't be exclusively "Afro Centric" content , and students of other ethnicities will be allowed to attend.

While I think these people are thinking that they are helping, in reality, they are simply trying to focus on one group, to the exclusion of others. In fact there are other groups, including kids from Portugese backgrounds who have a similar drop out rate. Do we build each of these groups a school? How do we avoid ghettoizing them.

Would not the better solution be to look at ALL the issues around early drop out? I don't mind specific actions around specific groups but surely the fastest way to lower the drop out rate is to focus on the issues in common.

This is only one school at the moment, but I don't like the trend. And many of the black community fought against this, arguing with words right out of Doctor Kings mouth. But the loudest and best organized group got their way.

James

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]If you are against affirmative action, you are called racist. how is refusing to discriminate against non-blacks racist?[/i]

No, I give you a hard time about this, because it's so minor in comparison to redistribution of wealth to corporations, and because the group receiving special treatment is still, as a group, less advantaged than average. That's a pragmatic, not a moral argument. I won't bother arguing whether it's "right" to have some quotas, or which ones. Being white myself, I have worked hard enough to inform myself that I know it isn't the blacks, or the Hispanics, or the illegal immigrants who sent 3 million jobs overseas. When whites carry on about the "special preferences" granted to blacks like it's the end of the world, I'm reminded of Don Quixote, tilting windmills.

I don't think Quixote was crazy. It's just easier to win a joust against a windmill.

by jamesrl

While I wouldn't vote for him myself, I can see why alot of people do want to vote for him, beyond the fact that he is black.

He is young - and Hillary is associated with a gang who got elected 16 years ago - and therefore, an old generation who had their chance (and blew it in many eyes).

He is optimistic - he talks about change (without being real specific and letting you decide what that means). Hillary and John are both Washington establishment types. He gives hope for change and presents himself as an outsider. Very JFK of him (both had been senators).

He is trying (with mixed results) to stay away from the mud that his opponent is slinging. That very mud slinging, IMNSHO, is one of the things that alientates young voters and drives them to stay home in droves. Wether he changes when he gets the nomination and faces off against McCain is anybody's guess.

Now those wouldn't attract me cause I'm an old fart, and I'd like to think a wise old fart, and I think leadership is harder than Obama is portraying.

JD you sound like that Manhattanite who got kicked out of the DNC rules committee meeting....

But hey, what do I know....

James

by jck

McCain called his wife that for saying that he was "thinning a little up there" (in reference to his hair. I guess that makes her a real c*nt? Go figure.

I don't think McCain is an a$$hole. I just think he's going senile at this point in life. And, I don't want a puppet in office. I want someone who'll lead. We are finishing having 8 years of a puppet being in office.

And, the day you find ANYONE on capital hill that comes from a common background and who isn't paid and bought...you let me know and I'll be their campaign manager for president.

Obama can't destroy our economy. Bush already did. let over 3M jobs go overseas...has ran the national deficit up to the highest level ever.

I've been paying attention. Obama (of the 3...which is now 2, cause Obama got enough superdelegates now...as of about 15 mins ago) is the least tied to Washington politics.

Oh and btw...Obama about 2 years ago made a speech in front of a black organization...and told them he didn't want them to vote for him because he'd be the black president...but he wanted their vote because he'd be the best president.

How many other blacks in politics have you ever seen do that?

If I had to choose between McCain and Obama, I'd vote Obama.

I'm just as leary of Bob Barr from the Libertarian party. I think he is a wolf in sheep's clothing.

I have to look at some real obscure candidates now and decide.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I'd like to see McCain field questions, so obviously based on racial stereotyping as Obama has taken. I would be very interested in a comparison of his composure and eloquence, under more similar circumstances. And, without some race relations advisor rescuing his ignorant punk @ss like Joe Lieberman did, on who Iran supports, trains or equips.

Update on that, NO Iranian parts found in Iraq. It seems they're not so stupid as to sh*t in their own backyard.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Fifteen others [b]might be[/b] from Iran. Only four can be confirmed. Compare that ratio to this country's own data on weapons confiscated from previously-convicted felons. These findings do not indicate Iranian government support for the Iraqi insurgency. Such a small number of Iranian weapons, so nearby, indicates better control over weapons smuggling than the government of the United States can dream of.

http://www.alternet.org/audits/86280/
[i]Reports by the U.S. command in Iraq over the past 15 months cited only a handful of Iranian weapons out of hundreds counted in caches found in Shiite areas. Nearly 700 mortars and rockets were reported by specific caliber size, along with a handful of RPGs, in nearly two dozen caches. Of that total, only four rockets were reported as being of Iranian origin, and another 15 were listed as possibly being Iranian.[/i]

I also found some links to US military reports of Iranian weapons in Iraq. But if you follow each "report" until the detailed follow-up, you'll find that the links of the Iraqi insurgency to the Iranian government are as tenuous as the previous links of Iraq to Nigeria's yellow cake, or to Al Qaida.

by protiusx

No Iran parts found in Iraq?!?!? What are you smoking? I think it?s illegal (oh wait you probably live in Canada).

http://confederateyankee.mu.nu/archives/233662.php

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,297777,00.html

http://www.worldtribune.com/worldtribune/WTARC/2007/me_iran_10_22.asp

http://in.reuters.com/article/worldNews/idINIndia-33396420080505

It appears as though they will drop their fecal matter anywhere it suits them.

As to your first comments you are avoiding the issue and that is one of racism, and bias.

by $$$$$$$$$$

http://www.alternet.org/audits/86280/?page=2
[i]No 240mm rocket has been reported found in a Mahdi Army weapons cache over the past year, but a single warhead for a 240mm rocket was reported to have been found in Basra Apr. 19. No official claim has been made that it was manufactured in Iran, however.

After a rocket fired at Camp Victory on Sep. 11, 2007 killed one and wounded 11 others, U.S. officials told the news media that the command spokesman, Gen. Bergner, would display fragments of a 240mm rocket -- complete with Iranian markings -- at his next press briefing in order to "show the link between the Iranian weapons and the damage they are doing".

But Bergner admitted to the media that there were no discernible Iranian markings on the fragment, and that a number of countries manufacture 240mm rockets. He was able to assert only that ordnance experts "assess it is of [sic] consistent with the rockets of Iranian origin we have seen used in other attacks."

That was a very weak claim, because Bergner had not provided any evidence to the media that previous attacks had involved Iranian 240mm rockets either.[/i]

The Bush administration, and the couple of million voters that still support it, effed up about Iraq and don't want to admit it. I understand.

http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Middle_East/JE24Ak02.html
[i]When Major General Kevin Bergner was asked that question at a briefing on May 8, he did not answer it directly. Instead, Bergner reverted to a standard US military line that these groups "could not do what they're doing without the support of foreign support [sic]". Then he defined "foreign support" to include training and funding as well as weapons, implicitly conceding that he did not have much of a case based on weapons alone.

Bergner's refusal to address that question reflects a fundamental problem with the US claims about Iranian weapons in Iraq: if there are indeed any Iranian rockets and mortars and RPGs in the arsenal of Muqtada al-Sadr's Mahdi Army's stand-off weapons, they represent an insignificant part of it.[/i]

by Member 25348569

you think that there would NOT be Iranian munitions in Iraq.

The US and its allies have invaded Iraq, an adjacent country with a long land border with Iran. The Iraqis are not grateful - whatever you may think - so the chances of either of us packing up and leaving in the near future is slim.

You have made covert and overt threats against Iran.

It is therefore in their interest to give you the hardest time possible so that you will be tied down to the point that another invasion could not be considered by even the most stupid hawk in your government.

The Iranians are Shi'ite Muslims. A fault or a virtue of the Islamic religion - depending on which end of the gun barrel you are situated - requires them to stick together. Shi'ite in Iran will be aiding their Shi'ite "brothers" in Iraq at all levels. Whether this is with the knowledge or complicity of the top levels of the Iranian government, I don't know and neither do you.

Iranian arms are available all over the World - as are French, Russian, US, etc. Iran is the closest country to Iraq. No arms dealer has a conscience.

I could go on listing reasons why but you probably get the big picture.

THEY DON'T LIKE US.

by Member 25348569

Because, alas, during my lifetime you had places where blacks had to sit at the back of the bus.

It may be that the societal pendulum has swung past the centre but you're just going to have to wait until it finally stops.

Neil :)

I hardly think that the white people have needed an association for [b]their[/b] advancement and I suspect that they don't need one now.

I also reckon that you need to check on what "Marxist" actually means.

by jdclyde

Just as discrimination was wrong a long long long time ago (when you were younger..zing!) does not make reverse discrimination right now.

And yes, we DO need associations for the advancements of whites. If you are a minority, you can get extra funding for college, but if you are white, you are SOL.

When my boys were born, I was making raising a family of four on $6/hour, but because I wasn't black I didn't qualify for any government assistance to help get a start.

Race should not be used as a qualifier for anything.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]And yes, we DO need associations for the advancements of whites. If you are a minority, you can get extra funding for college, but if you are white, you are SOL.[/i]

SOL? Google "merit scholarships" & "financial aid."

by jck

is to stick to the premise of what we're supposed to be about: everyone getting a fair chance to make a better life for themself.

jdclyde is right. it is appauling that someone is given preference in our country (mainly by government-run funding programs) because of the color of their skin.

that, if done by an individual, is called "racism".

that, if done by government, is called "affirmative action".

that, by the name i give it, is hypocrisy.

the first thing i think is...any law in the country...national, state, local...that gives preference, indifference, leniency, or other favorable direction to someone...because of race... gender... religion... sexual orientation... should be removed from the books. everyone who is a citizen here should have equal legal right under law.

there should have never been a law giving "gays" the right to marry anywhere. they should have that right under law already.

legal marriage is [b]NOT[/b] the same as holy matrimony...no matter how much religious conservatives wish it was.

therefore, no religion should dictate that law make legal marriages/unions only between man and woman.

and ya know, it is really sick, jdclyde. there you were with a family...makin $6 and you couldn't get any help. but someone who sits on their butt and doesn't do the best they can for their family...gets all the freebies in the world there are.

i feel for ya man. i'm glad ur in a better place now.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Do you have a problem with that?

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=263533&messageID=2514573
[i]As to your first comments you are avoiding the issue and that is one of racism, and bias.[/i]

I considered everything you said, and picked one part of it to shine back at you, in a different light. If you think I should give more credit to some specific thing you've said, what?

And, what do you say to my claim, that Obama is just getting more questions about his race? He is not more preoccupied with race than the other candidates, they are, the paparazzi asking him are, and judging by the fact that they're still in business, many of us are, too. You can't blame a person for what other people say to him. His answers are not always great, but more often than the other candidates, his answers are very good.

by ic-it

There really is no comparision there;
(for your closing statement, the first part, I have not had a chance to do any in-depth reading, yet).

Your quote "But if you follow each "report" until the detailed follow-up, you'll find that the links of the Iraqi insurgency to the Iranian government are as tenuous as the previous links of Iraq to Nigeria's yellow cake, or to Al Qaida."
That is simply no comparision; your quote 0%, weapondary at least a few percent. ;-)

by $$$$$$$$$$

4 out of 700, or 15 out of 700, it doesn't matter. Either way, that's a quantity that passes across borders [b]despite[/b] the governments' best efforts to prevent it. That is [b]Absolutely not[/b] the result of Iranian sponsorship.

[b]Bush and his military-industrial sponsors are making up an Iranian threat, just like they did about Iraq. Don't be a lemming.[/b]

by jck

societal stereotyping.

just like 60 years ago, blacks were thought to be thought of by some as "lessers"...

today, a white person who goes and starts an organization established to guarantee that whites have equal rights...would be labelled as at least a "troublemaker", if not a "racist" or "radical".

actually, i think i should go make one for German descendants. my ancestors were endentured to work on railroads and abused by anglican taskmasters. and i have cherokee indian on mom's side...damn...i have been left out.

i want my money! and my land!!! and my free commodity cheese!!! (that stuff was awesome for grilled cheese sandwiches lol :D )

by jdclyde

Just curious if it is just the mean ol' US that doesn't recognize a gay marriage to be equal in every way to a traditional marriage?

We know they don't in Iran because their aren't any gays in Iran.... :0

by $$$$$$$$$$

Many immigrant societies exist that are specific to heritage of one European nation. I assume they accept hybrids, provided you can trace your lineage back to at least one member of the nationality of the group.

It is nobody else's fault if those societies we're eligible to join do not offer scholarships to you or me or jdclyde or our offspring, but the membership [b]of those societies[/b].

by jamesrl

Tourism in Toronto has gone down dramatically since 9/11. Whether its the high(er) cost of gas, the need for more ID at the border(not getting into Canada, but getting back to the US) or the rising Canadian dollar (or rather the sinking US dollar) we are hurting.

The one bright spot was gay marriages. US citizens who were gay would come up and get married all nice and legal like and spend money on receptions and dinners etc.

Now I hear it will soon be legal in California, and so our little business will dry up and our tourist operators will be out in the cold again.

Dang Swarteneger.

James

by $$$$$$$$$$

What's the total financial cost of those assistance programs which grant the status of preferred recipient to one or more ethnic groups? How much do those programs pay to whites? A: still a majority of their payroll, merely a slightly smaller majority than you'd prefer. How many jobs has it really cost you in your life?

[i]it is appauling that someone is given preference in our country (mainly by government-run funding programs) because of the color of their skin.[/i]

Slavery was appalling. Affirmative action amounts to chump change -- hell, include all social programs and [b]individual[/b] financial assistance! -- compared to military waste. Where are your priorities?

by jdclyde

All wasteful and improper spending by government should be looked at, not just based upon if you find it worthy or not.

Yea, look at wasteful government spending. End of story.

Slavery? Ancient history. No one alive in the US today was a slave. None of my ancestors were slave owners. Get over it and move on. Descendants of slaves are better off today than many of the people currently living in Africa. It is done, they are free and given equal rights and opportunities based now upon their efforts and abilities.

by jck

[i]We know they don't in Iran because their aren't any gays in Iran....[/i]

Iran is a religious state, where Islam is the state religion and all laws are founded in that religion. That is why mullahs have the power they do there.

America is based on freedom of religion.

As for what countries? Well, if you make that question "modernized countries", then most of them allow it. Even England legally recognized them now.

I just don't see what the big deal is. If your religion/belief/creed/values forbids it, then don't do it. Just dont push your own value set on others.

Equal Justice Under Law: isn't that what it says on the front of the US Supreme Court?

by jdclyde

how many is that? Why would you have to make such an exclusion? Weren't you just telling me how it is morally wrong to impose "our" beliefs on other nations? does that include gay marriage and abortions?

IMO, if the flambers hadn't come out so "in your face" being intentionally repulsive, I don't believe there would still be so much opposition to this. One big non-issue intenionally used to distract from real issues. And yes, abortion is used the same way.

by $$$$$$$$$$

... and put these two subjects into a reasonable context: they're not bothering you.

[i]All wasteful and improper spending by government should be looked at, not just based upon if you find it worthy or not.

Yea, look at wasteful government spending. End of story.

Slavery? Ancient history. No one alive in the US today was a slave. None of my ancestors were slave owners. Get over it and move on.[/i]

You first.

by dr_zinj

The problem with isolationism in the U.S. is that it ignores where our energy, foods, raw strategic materials, and manufactured come from. You can't be an isolationist if you keep buying stuff from foreign countries. And you can't buy stuff from foreign countries without creating and maintaining a world environment condusive to world trade.

If you're an isolationist, I double dog dare you to go through your house and remove EVERYTHING that was made in a foreign country. Every appliance, every thing written by a non-american, everything that contains parts made or written by foreigners. Everything that exists because it was invented by a foreigner. By the time you're through, you're house will be damn near empty, and probably structurally unsound too.

You want to go pure American, you're going to have to create an environment that will make it cost effective for americans to produce all those things we currently take for granted that come from other countries. And the first thing that you're going to have to replace is fossil fuels.

by wmlundine

...is a third term for Bush 43...only then will jd et al be happy. The rest of the world on the other hand...

by $$$$$$$$$$

I was going to try to make a crack about the Surge, working eventually, but it really isn't funny.

Pleased to see you again, at least for the time being.

[I vaguely recall some disagreement, but as long as GWB is the subject, I promise not to say anything very nice. It looks like we can agree on that.]

by wmlundine

...was user-names. That and advanced gray hair. I believe I once confused you with a similar sounding user-name. But, like my late father used to say when he was my age about forgetfulness; "The best thing about it is all the new friends I meet everyday." Sorry.

by cwalrobinson15

The U.S. has cut it's food programs from more than a billion to roughly 300 million while we PAY farmers not to grow food, and spend most of what we do contribute to world hunger on transportation. "President Bush recently requested an additional $770 million in funding for humanitarian food aid, but that money will not be available until October, when the new budget year begins." Why is it okay to have hundreds of private and public food programs but not okay to have one which all countries can and individuals can support? And why is it okay to give the richest percentage in the world tax cuts but not feed those that are starving? AND........I thought this was a TECH site, not a political assassination site!!!

by jdclyde

It is a site for techs as much as it is a site for tech. If you pay attention, you will see the "off-topic" tag.

On to your point.

the only reason you give tax cuts to anyone is because that person/group is already paying more than their share, and if they do not have the money take from them by government to be wasted in the bureaucracy, they will re-invest the money in other ventures or buy themselves goods, either way, giving other people jobs.

Do you think the current progressive taxes are "fair"? Not only are you paying taxes on a larger amount, but you're paying a higher RATE on the larger amount?

Fines are a tax for doing bad.
Taxes are a fine for doing good.

If someone EARNS their money, who are you to vote it away?

People like you then turn around and cry because companies move off shores because of being overly taxed. YOU are chasing jobs from our shores with your mentality of class envy.

As for food banks, if individuals wish to donate, fine. Money taken from US citizens via taxes are meant for one thing, and that is the betterment and running of THIS country. There is nothing in the US Constitution giving our government the right to tax us and give the money to other nations.

by wmlundine

...and only engender resentment inversely proportional to the gratitude you feel for being part of a community. Ask not what tax break the country can give to you...

by jck

confusing nationality with race. they are not one in the same. one is geographic. one is genetic.

if there were a "Miss White America" pageant, there would be protests and law suits and Al Sharpton or Jesse Jackson callin it "keeping the people down" or something. it is thought to be socially and politically incorrect for whites to exclude others of other races from participation in their events and/or organizations.

however, "Miss Black America" is acceptable. They can exclude other races from their pageant. that is accepted by society.

Can you explain that?

by jdclyde

We should stay out of the world affairs of other nations. No more being the worlds police, let the UN/Nato do that.

No more the worlds welfare office, again, give them the number for the UN/Nato/red cross.

only allow trade with countries that are willing to have an even trade agreement. if they overly tax our goods being brought in, then you penalize them in return.

by jdclyde

the ONLY real threat to us is the liberals within our borders that have such a self-hate for doing better than so much of the world has.

Drill our own oil, grow our own food, make our own products. We don't have to be as dependent upon other countries as "we" have allowed ourselves to become.

Besides, I don't believe that either Canada or the UK would allow themselves to be regulated by the corrupt UN. Just look at the savage nations on the "human rights" boards and it is crystal clear what that whole organization is about, top to bottom. Hint, NOT the betterment of humans in general.

by jim

In a word, bullpucky.

There is absolutely nothing in the words of the bill that you quoted that says that the USA will (or even should) pay "a tax to the UN", nor that the USA taxpayer is going to fund a "world welfare program". You sound to me as though you are an extreme right wing ideologue at best.

Make your views clear instead of merely trying to disparage an honorable senator. Come right out and tell us about your isolationist views, about your xenophobia, and about your belief that the USA has no obligations as the worlds "sole remaining superpower" and yet has the right to dictate to every other country how it should behave. And, while you're at it, be sure to tell us why sticking our collective heads in the sand means "We're Number One!" when every bit of evidence suggests that we're far from number one in many (not all!!) aspects of quality of life.

I, for one, strongly support a US foreign policy that treats everyone with respect, that exercises its power wisely, also exercises its responsibility wisely, and is not afraid to use its wealth to help the less fortunate instead of condemning them for being poor. That, IMHO, is a much more dependable road to peace.

But, thanks for raising this subject to my consciousness. I'll be contacting my senators and asking them to vote FOR the bill.

by jdclyde

How many failed wars on poverty do you think we should "fight"?

Yeah, lets send our money over seas to the corrupt leaders that have CAUSED the poverty in the first place, who will KEEP the majority of all aid, like they have been doing all along.

We don't have any poor in this country that could use that money, do we?

by $$$$$$$$$$

Did poverty pose a clear and present danger?

Did Congress vote to declare war?

In Europe, a lot of the motivation for this kind trade sanction against policies that increase poverty originated in authentic guilt for colonialism. Until the unprovoked attack on Iraq, it was very difficult to make the case that North Americans should help pay that debt. Until the US decreases its presence abroad, expect more of this.

by markthshark

You can't fight terrorism by killin' all the Muslims in the world; like George W. Bush would have us try to do. We're spending billions every week just to make more enemies.

We can take care of our own poor -- and -- spread democracy abroad the right way, i.e., distribute aid for food and education.

Like Obama said: It's time to change the mindset of war. But first...

End the freakin' war!

by $$$$$$$$$$

... makes specific knowledge of one's national heritage absolutely impossible, within a generation.

2. Race is based on phenotype, not genotype. Africans can tell neighboring tribes from their own -- also by phenotype, not genotype.

3. "Exclusion" is normally defined in terms of mainstream society, not from sub-cultures. I think the main reason that Miss Black America doesn't offend women who are prevented by their heritage from participating, is that they have no shortage of other beauty contests to compete in. Blacks, on the contrary, have apparently felt that there were shortages in access to mainstream activities. Some of those shortages, at least, have been well-documented. But I'll defer (for now) to your superior knowledge of beauty pageants. They've never been an interest of mine.

by viztor

Long ago, I heard someone describe the way it works. Calls are routed overseas so the Brits can listen to American calls, and vice versa. Many listening stations are located near downlink sites for telecommunications.

http://fly.hiwaay.net/~pspoole/echelon.html

An ex-army person spoke about installing equipment in New York to store information from intercepted calls.

"The terrorists are attacking! Here, put on these chains!"

v.

by law_n_disorder

Those countries will always have corruption. They have had more time to industrialize then we have and have only sat around and reproduced. If you want to help them, teach them birth control and how to feed themselves. Pouring my tax dollars in these breeding grounds helps no one.

by $$$$$$$$$$

"They have had more time to industrialize th[b]e[/b]n we have and have only sat around and reproduced."

... and not a single reference to the content of the statute, either

by markthshark

The American people really need to start looking at what's happening around the world with a radically different perspective. Unfortunately, thinking often cuts into leisure time in front of the boob tube.

You're right, terrorism is caused by poverty and hopelessness. Obama seems to get that.

I remember the first time I really began thinking about voting for him. In a speech, he said he wanted to end the war in Iraq, which was good, exactly what I wanted to hear. But he went further than that. He said that he not only wanted to end the war but also change the mindset in this country that led us into Iraq.

Think about that for a moment...

"... changing the mindset that took us into this needless, illegal and immoral war."

I was stunned. I just turned 50 last month and that was the very first time I've ever heard such a statement from a U.S. politician. It's the very antitheses of the way U.S. foreign policy has been run for decades.

Obama thinks outside the box. He's intellectually curious. He's pragmatic and he's a constitutional scholar -- attributes we sorely need in a leader right now.

Thanks again.

by jdclyde

Marriage has been more than a joining before God. It has been for centuries a way for property rights. It helps hold the welfare party (democrats) from trying to tax money for the fourth time. First, when a company makes the money as profit, second when it is paid as a wage, third when sales tax are charged against the purchases, and the fourth when you die and go to leave your home to your spouse. The leaches of "that" party start circling like the scavengers they are, looking to pick at the body of the dead because they smell money. A spouse doesn't have to pay the inheritance leach tax.

A marriage DOES make for a more stable house hold than people who are just shacked up, in general. Because of that, it has been given benefits. Oh sure, a lot of marriages fail, but I know I have lived with more women than I have married, and the marriage lasted a lot longer, and it is better for children to have both of their parents in their lives on a daily basis.

yes, there are exceptions, just because some people have no business breeding in the first place. Thankfully, many of these people are learning they don't HAVE to have kids and the picket fence.

Look at the stats, and kids that have both parents involved in their lives do better than when one or both have taken off. You FINALLY see people like Bill Cosby standing up and telling black men to stand up and be men for a change and stand beside their children. Why? Can you honestly say that children do NOT do better when the father or mother has taken off?

Damaged kids grow up to be damaged adults, and many end up being less than productive. Having a productive crop of future tax payers is a good thing.

Still waiting for some kind of count, how many countries do vs don't have legal gay marriage. It is dishonest to try to paint the US as the haters of the world because they have voted repeatedly to keep with the traditional meaning of marriage. In many places a civil union HAS been offered to gays, and as long as it has the same legal rights, where is the problem? You want to do something new, give it a new name.

by jdclyde

As I said, why does the existing institutions have to be changed of their meaning all the time?

If a NEW relationship comes out, fine, you make a NEW institution for the new relationship.

But then comes the valid question, if a marriage isn't one man and one woman anymore, then how can it be limited to just a couple? It can't. Do we really want that? If we question that, then how about age limits? Isn't that legislating morality as well? 100 years ago, it was common for a 14 year old to get married. I wouldn't want that to come back.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]But then comes the valid question, if a marriage isn't one man and one woman anymore, then how can it be limited to just a couple? It can't. Do we really want that? If we question that, then how about age limits? Isn't that legislating morality as well? 100 years ago, it was common for a 14 year old to get married. I wouldn't want that to come back.[/i]

Still waiting for the valid question here. The topic was 1 gay man and another gay man; or 1 gay woman and another gay woman. Note the adult words for male & female, and that we're talking about couples, not harems. Those would be separate threads

by tonythetiger

I do not pretend to speak for you and the mouse in your pocket. If [b]I[/b] don't want that, [b]I[/b] won't do that.

[i]If we question that, then how about age limits? Isn't that legislating morality as well?[/i]

No, that's legislating the age of consent. In addition: In most states, some minors may marry ... with parental and/or the court's consent.

http://preview.tinyurl.com/79gzu

by jdclyde

What basis is there for us to determine when WE think people should be allowed to have consensual sex?

If we follow the evolutionists train of thought, it would be as soon as they are physically able to, just like the animals we are suppose to have evolved from?

You look at the different states, some have 16, 17, 18. based on what? I know I don't have that answer.

As for lighting the strawman on fire, pretend that it is not a valid next step, that once you change to include a new definition of marrage as just two humans, who is going to be able to argue only two? What is the basis of that refusal?

Strawman would be if I brought in marrying your sheep or something stupid like that. I am talking just real world practical examples.

by tonythetiger

a judgment by our lawmakers that children are not mature enough to make certain adult decisions. Sex is one. Contracts are another.

[i]As for lighting the strawman on fire, pretend that it is not a valid next step, that once you change to include a new definition of marrage as just two humans, who is going to be able to argue only two? What is the basis of that refusal?[/i]

There is none. That's why I think the government should not be involved. I suggest the terms civil union and marriage should be two different things. Marriage is whatever the people involved believe it to be (usually a religious definition). A civil union is a contract with the government, and requires a license.

by tonythetiger

[i]Until the US decreases its presence abroad, expect more of this.[/i]

I suspect that we'll be there in one form or other for at least several decades, regardless of who is elected president.

by jdclyde

that people are stupid enough to allow such to continue.

The US has to STOP being two things to the world. The world police and the world welfare office.

Get out of other peoples business and take care of our own.

After our own house is in order, THEN and only then should we look outside the borders.

That is NOT isolationist, it is priorities.

by jamesrl

The US intervenes when and if it chooses. There have been many instances where the UN called upon it, and the US turned them down.

As for food aid, its not so simple. Yes, millions of lives have been saved by providing food aid and thats a good thing. Its also helped US farmers make more money -don't overlook that. But it has created dependence. When too much food aid comes in, where is the incentive for the locals to farm - they can't compete with free. So they get out of the business and the farms don't get kept up and bam, there goes the capacity.

James

by oz_media

Just like your politics it is extreme in either direction, there's no middle ground, no grey area etc. Just YES or NO, BLACK or WHITE.

How about, okay here's a stretch, BALANCE?

Balance allows yuo to have a bit of both without focusing solely on one agenda. I know, I know, it's an odd concept; sorry but you'll have to give it time to sink in a bit.

Balance would allow you to offer aide and support those in need, while also taking care of your own and focusing on internal affairs.

Sorry, I didn't mean to screw with everyone's heads, I know it is a bit far fetched for most, that's actually how the rest of teh prosperous world operates.

We all know that all the other countries in the world are ruled by communists and fascists that would let Arabs wipe them out with WMD, while they focus on the complete mind control of their citizens, but they are onto something aren't they? :D

by jdclyde

Now that is a scary thought.

What do these people base their laws upon? Did they go and analyze the average child to determine when they should be allowed to hump like bunnies?

Was it phychological evidence? [i](a field that is a crock. Give them a pill and they will feel better about themselves?)[/i]

Was it medical evidence? [i](physically able)[/i]

Or a MORAL judgement call on when THEY thought it was approprate? [i](I will take what is behind door three, Monty.)[/i]

by jdclyde

we have been sending money and food overseas for decades, and it hasn't done any good.

The money/food/supplies are always taken by the corrupt governments or the "guerrilla fighters", and the people we intend to help are not any better off than before we wasted our money and time.

by tonythetiger

[i]Now that is a scary thought.[/i]

... but we have only ourselves to blame. The trick is going to be doing something about it.

[i]Or a MORAL judgement call on when THEY thought it was approprate?[/i]

One might assume that it is the morals of the people who elected those lawmakers, in theory anyway, but I think it's just another control thing... The bureaucracy's first duty is to the bureaucracy.

by oz_media

When you commented that there are no gay men in Iran (yes I caught the humour, there are no OPENLY gay men in Iran) it reminded me of a movie, the Kite Runner.

Actually an excellent movie, shot in Kabul. Two young boys are friends (a kite flyer and a kit runner) in a kite flying tournament. In short, one guy, now much older, travels from America back to Kabul to compete in this tournament (with the country now under Taliban rule).
Anyhow, the relation was as young kids the kite runner (th eguy who collects the losers kite when teh line gets severed) is tackled by a local bully.

His punishment "Now I'll show you you are not a man. You're gona get it now! I'll show you!" is to getting buggered by the teenage thug. (Quite a shocking 'sidebar' in the movie that they rally didn't need to add I don't think) :)

So now that I have a movie education of the area, I guess there are no GAY men in the Middle East at all, because they are all considered tough guys and bully's for buggering other guys and not called fa@s like they would be here.

by $$$$$$$$$$

anybody not receiving government handouts should be eligible.

[i]Marriage has been more than a joining before God. It has been for centuries a way for property rights. It helps hold the welfare party (democrats)[/i] [which was the "welfare party," "centuries" ago?[i] from trying to tax money for the fourth time. First, when a company makes the money as profit, [/i][common corporate-welfare apologists' model; pretends independent contractors & family businesses don't exist][i] second when it is paid as a wage, third when sales tax are charged against the purchases, and the fourth when you die and go to leave your home to your spouse. The leaches of "that" party start circling like the scavengers they are, looking to pick at the body of the dead because they smell money. A spouse doesn't have to pay the inheritance leach tax.[/i]

So you'd rather give a gay man's inheritance to "the scavengers" than recognize his rights at law. Despicable.

by jdclyde

the maybe (just maybe) the rest of the world that we always hear that HATES the US will see that we HAVE been more of an asset to the world than a hindrance?

I CONSTANTLY hear how you have to explain you are currently a canuk to get accepted.

I feel no obligation to further aid to an ungrateful world that doesn't want our "interference" in their affairs.

You only get kicked so many times before you stop putting yourself in a position to get kicked. Let the world decide if they really want US "interference" or not by removing ALL interference, both good and bad.

And NEVER go back to the policy of "My enemies enemy is my friend".

by oz_media

Take Canada for example, you NEED Canada to make it as a country, you would be SOL without us. On that same note, Canada relies on US money, if your economy tanks, our does in concert until we establish new trading relationships outside of North America.

The UK relies on US money; the US relies on the UK. Germany relies on the US, the US relies on Germany.

Any free democratic nation that has a strong economy or something to offer is a needed ally of the USA, and the USA's money is needed by everyone else, it's a two way street.

So when people in Germany get slammed as useless abusers of America's helping hand, they get rightfully pi$$ed off.

When people in the UK have their sons fighting beside US troops and then hear the USA state how much better they are then the British and how the British owe them so much, THEY rightfully get pi$$ed off.

When all everyone hears from the USA is how the USA is helping out the rest of the world, saving their butts and offering them welfare, the rest of the world gets rightfully pi$$ed off.

If your citizens were taught just how dependant the USA is on the rest of the world, perhaps that arrogance and ignorance would be less visible around the globe.

We HAVE oil, electricity, grains, fish and lumber in Canada, while we would feel the economic hit of losing that trade relationship, it could be reestablish with other commonwealth nations.

If America cuts off such supply, America simply loses out due to the last few hundred years being focused on isolation and independence through assumed supremacy.

If your government actually showed Americans just how much you rely on the rest of the world to stay alive, then perhaps citizens of the USA would have a more humble voice towards the rest of the world. Is it the fault of eth US citizens? Of course not, just as it was not the fault of the German citizen when Hitler dragged Germany's name through the mud, Germans actually believed what they were told, propaganda and all that.

What the world sees is an ungrateful nation with a lot of ignorant citizens who have been told not to trust anyone but America and that America is merely out to help the world rotate, with no self agenda. no wonder people oppose America, your government made it that way.

As for getting kicked, that's exactly how others feel, no matter what you do to help America, America keeps it quiet and simply trumpets what they do for others. THAT is simply kicking your allies in the same way you feel you are being kicked.

Wake up and smell the bacon, the world is no longer a private, isolated place made of individual nations, the internet has opened up a global community, and yet you don't want to play along unless you can be seen as the leader and savior of all.

As you noted, when in other parts of the world, being from America is not a good thing. Having to constantly correct people that I am Canadian is not a good thing either, I would much rather people didn't make such an association and have it mean you are either on the good side or the bad. I don't think America will ever hold the same 'friendly neighbour' status that Canada has with the commonwealth and allied nations; when I was younger, it was not such a BAD thing to be American, people saw Americans as arrogant and undereducated and didn't take them too seriously but not as such an enemy as they do these days.

A little humble pie in the governments face would help, you can still be respected and looked up to, without the constant need to ignore what others do for the USA and focus only on what you do for others.

The loudest, most 'in your face' guy in the club is never the favorite and is always the target of others aggression.

by jdclyde

with welfare projects.

I never said anything about trade, now did I?

Simply let other countries run themselves (no more world police, let the UN do it for a change).

Simply let other countries run themselves (nomore world welfare, let the UN do it for a change).

I don't believe other than trying to give Neil a hard time, that I have ever put down the UK, nor gone on how you "owe us". Everyone knows the brits were tough bastards that took more of a pounding than most, but never backed down.

And yes, Canada needs the US just as much as the US needs Canada.

Neither of them should EVER have a need for oil or food from anyone but the other if things were run properly. Of course, things are not run properly.

by oz_media

[i]"...(just maybe) the rest of the world that we always hear that HATES the US will see that we HAVE been more of an asset to the world than a hindrance?

I CONSTANTLY hear how you have to explain you are currently a canuk to get accepted."[/i]

The above statements fall into the UK/Canada spectrum as well as third world countries.
the problem with being confused with Americans has happened to me in a few places, but was most noticeable ( as I spent more time there)in Egypt and the UK.
It is also big in Brazil, don't let them think you are American you will have a LOT of trouble. In Canada it's not such a big thing, poeple just KNOW Americans right off the bat. When I have a group to speak to and it is mixed Canadian and Americans, you can pick out the Americans in a heartbeat, there's a major difference in how you walk, talk and come across to others.

In the UK, thet just think anything with an accent is American, you get lumped in. Once people in your group know you are Canadian,they then start to stick up for you when they introduce you to others, "
This is .....he's Canadian, not American." (No kidding that's exactly how it goes down and you are instantly accepted for it."

I don't think its a good thing, but it IS a reality. If you don't like that attitude from starving, needy nations, it is the same as you will get from allied trading partners too.

What I think you object to is the needy nations that don't give you any credit in return, but open your eyes and you will see the same go towards all the other nations that help them too. America isn't the only one helping out others with no thanks to be found.

America does hand out the most in gross monetary value, but relatively it is the same hit for one guy in one nation to offer $10 as it is for another with a weaker economy to offer $2.

We all hand out a great deal for very little in return. We are supposed to do it and accept it whether they are ungrateful baystards or not though, that's called being human I guess, we ALL get kicked, not just the USA. This is a key issue that others don't like about teh USA, it is always YOU and never others that are facing these issues.
Others accept it as a way of life when you actually care about others, hearing endless complaints from the states about how you give and never get is another part that makes you look ignorant and arrogant too. Not just you, this is an age old complaint of Americans, "What we do for the world".

In other eyes, everyone does thier share and they don't expect a big hug and thank you for it.

by jdclyde

then keep up and read what has actually been posted, not what you thought you read as you scanned over a few posts.

I said I DO support giving the same rights for this new relationship, but you seem to have missed that.

Despicable.

by jck

we'll never solve all of our own issues/problems/turmoil.

we, as humans, are all chaos machines who try to put some order to a chaotic world so that we feel we have a place.

if we take the stance that everything has to be right here before we can help elsewhere...would make us extremely isolated...as well as rather self-serving.

selflessness is an admirable trait. it's when charity and giving to do good turns into gluttonous expenditure for insignificant return or effect that it becomes a detriment.

kind of like us rebuilding the same buildings and streets and oil facilities in Iraq over and over and over for the past 3 years.

Iraq has enough money from oil. Let them recruit and pay their own army and police and defend themselves now.

Our government raised an army, trained them, and had them battle ready in less than 3 years. Why can't the Iraqis do the same?

I say...give Iraq 6 months. Tell them we're leaving then. Better get your ducks in a row. We're done paying for you, even though you're sitting on trillions of dollars in oil. We've done our good deed. The gravy train stops here. Time to step up or get over-run by Al Qaeda and or the Taliban. Up to you. Good luck.

Then bring that $300B a year back to the USA...feed homeless...build roads...educate kids...and yes...even send some food to desperate nations who *need* help and teach them how to self-sustain.

And if other nations do the same and don't learn to stand on their own...cut them off too.

by jamesrl

Sorry I couldn't help it....

Doctors have to first take care of themselves, cause if they get sick, they can't help others.

Much the same is true with countries. Their first duty is to themselves.

Having said that, I do think that it is in our own enlightened self interest to help others. If we give food to some starving children in Africa, we make some of our own farmers happy and we make the world more stable, which benefits us all.

Of course my preference would be a hand up, not a hand out. I would rather see us help them get their own farms going, so they can build their own wealth, and some day be able to trade with us, than to make them dependant on food aid. But even if we decide thats the right course, we can't go from starving people to self sufficient farmers overnight.

I do think even those on welfare in Canada/US/Europe live better than the poor in Africa. But in some cases, like Zimbabwe, there isn't much we can do given the corrupt dicatorship.

James

by jdclyde

Although you did talk yourself into a circle after that.

If we have a choice, help person X or help person Y, there is nothing selfish about helping person X who is your citizen over person Y who is someone elses citizen. NOTHING.

And yes, GTF out of Iraq and stop [b]wasting[/b] our money on them. The whole world is in agreement that they are not worth it.

by jdclyde

In the case of the "corrupt dicatorships", do we actually make matters worse by sending in aid that is taken by the dictators and never reaches the people in need?

Is it also wrong to stand up and call thse "corrupt dicatorship" EVIL? OR quietly say we shouldn't be imposing our values on other people around the world?

by jck

but you also apply the same mentality to people who have not been given the same opportunities...like it was their fault.

And I agree with James...a hand up...not a hand out. And, we need to do that in our country too. If you're on welfare...and there's a job you're able to do that the government can place you in...and you turn it down...you lose your check. Period.

I can understanding supporting the young and the old/infirmed. But, this letting 20-somethings sit on their but and collect unemployment and welfare and spend it on beer and pot and play Wii all day? That's BS.

by jdclyde

Not talking about welfare in the US, but that is always something to keep an eye on.

If we don't WASTE our money on other nations, we could invest it HERE, making new jobs, and better paying jobs.

Change the import laws to stop making it so attractive to move jobs offshore to save on the insane taxes we put on corporations, that have chased the jobs away.

I was reading today that there are STILL "homeless" from Katrina and they are upset because their payments are on the chopping block that Pelosi is looking at. How long do "we" support these people? When is enough, enough? Because there was shelters setup instead of work programs, we have put MORE people on forced dependency. Give them a shot at a job, and then it is sink or swim, move to the next person and give them a chance to save themselves.

by jck

i understood what you're saying...however...tell me...define "WASTE"?

very ambiguous term. the other day, you thought it was a waste to try to feed people in starving countries just because they haven't moved on from the Kalahari desert.

i just equated that to, when the steel mills closed in PA...everyone should have moved from Pittsburgh...cause if not, they weren't going where they could be more prosperous.

i absolutely agree that we should not waste...and, Iraq is the biggest waste of money this country has ever spent a dime on...well...other than the current welfare system...which pays for people to sit on their butt and not try...and have more and more children that the system has to support.

and i agree about not letting them off-shore jobs. but at the same time...do you know how many $20-40 per hour jobs were off-shored in the last 30 years? If the government would have stuck up for labor (yes...those guys in labor who support leftist wingnut politicians)...this country wouldn't be going to hell in a handbasket.

And actually the person i blame most for letting a corp like Wal-Mart get away with off-shoring?

Bill Clinton.

Someone get jd a heart pill...i think he'll need it after that statement lol